Minister Narendra Modi successfully balance India’s longstanding relationship with Russia with courting closer ties with Western powers?
India's current foreign policy towards China is a combination of collaboration and cutthroat competition with strategic hedging from it. Ties between the two countries have been strained, especially after a border standoff in 2020. While such initiatives have aimed to thaw ties, disagreements over sRead more
India’s current foreign policy towards China is a combination of collaboration and cutthroat competition with strategic hedging from it. Ties between the two countries have been strained, especially after a border standoff in 2020. While such initiatives have aimed to thaw ties, disagreements over substantial issues like territorial disputes—China is sending out some heavy artillery in South Asia as well —and India’s strategic partnerships with the US ensure that problems will endure.
India has adopted a composite strategy that combines diplomacy and force in dealing with China. On the other, multilateral forums like the SCO and BRICS where it is involved with China on several issues. On the other side, India has bolstered its border defenses and stepped up strategic alignments with China wary like USA and Japan.
The Russia-Ukraine war has brought a new dimension and problem to India’s foreign policy. India, however, has struck a cautious note by refraining from naming Russia and instead called for dialogue & respect of sovereignty besides maintaining strategic neutrality. This policy shift has its roots in India’s traditional closeness to Russia, notably in defence and energy. Of course, India could not afford to go out against Western powers particularly the United States which has left a great influence on their neutrality.
India is of course more broadly influenced by its strategic calculus concerning China as well, within the dynamics of the Russia-Ukraine war. India aims to maintain a stable relationship with China – not only is it engaged in the Quad that seeks to balance an overbearing Chinese influence in the Indo-Pacific region, but India also concedes that escalation will be detrimental.
The pragmatic nature of India’s foreign policy is evident in the manner it navigates through the complexity inherent in part due to its security interests and strategic interests. Its stance on the (Russia-Ukraine war and Chinese ties are guided by its strategy to preserve autonomy in a multipolar world.
See less
Prime Minister Narendra Modi deals with the dilemma of keeping India's traditional alliance with Russia and its desire to tighten it with Western powers in balance. Here are some key factors to consider: 1. **Historical Relationship with Russia**: India and Russia are old friends as they have a relaRead more
Prime Minister Narendra Modi deals with the dilemma of keeping India’s traditional alliance with Russia and its desire to tighten it with Western powers in balance. Here are some key factors to consider:
1. **Historical Relationship with Russia**: India and Russia are old friends as they have a relationship that goes back to the time of the Cold War. It is through these ties that they have been cooperating in defense, involved in economic relations, and also shared their views on global issues with other. This affiliation has always been a defense-based one that needed an economic link and a soft power alignment in global policies.
2. **Evolving Geopolitical Dynamics**: The international scenario is not the same as it was during the time of the Cold War, and India is looking to relate to other countries as well. Among others, the efforts of India to strengthen its ties with Western powers like the United States, the European Union, and the United Kingdom should be noted as well.
3. **Strategic Autonomy**: India prides itself with its strategic autonomy and has always been unofficially non-aligned in the foreign policy department. This position also gives India the upper hand in communicating with different nations and they could do so without being dependent on any single country.
4. **Defense and Technology Collaboration**: Russia has remained one of the firm standpoints of India in terms of their defense equipment and the transfer of technology. Through lean diversification of their defense importing strategy, India still heavily depends on Russian military hardware.
5. **Economic Considerations**: In comparison to defense and strategic cooperation, the financial links between India and Russia have been less developed. Both the countries have shown interest in broadening the front of economic cooperation and the most suggested areas in this sector are energy and technology.
6. **Global Diplomacy**: Strengthening ties with the West by working on the Indo-Pacific strategy, involving in the Quad (India, US, Japan, Australia), and joining international forums and partnerships that serve as India’s strategic interests have all been combined by Modi.
7. **Challenges and Balancing Acts**: These international relationships need smart diplomacy to balance them out. As the government under Modi has appreciated the scope of Russian influence in China and Ukraine developments, it has also been successful in sustaining India’s involvement in multilaterals like BRICS.
Wrapping up, on the one hand, the principal goals of Prime Minister Modi when moving in the direction of reinforcing these links are technology, investment, and strategic alignment with the West; On the other hand, the importance of the relationship with Russia for historical reasons, defense, and global interests shared by both of them still remains. Thoroughly dealing with these relationships needs a well-thought-out approach and the skill to ensure India’s national interests are safeguarded while also harnessing broader global cooperation.
See less