Examine the potential of nuclear energy in India’s energy mix, taking into account the government’s emphasis on increasing the nation’s nuclear power generation capacity. Talk about the related technological, financial, and safety challenges as well as the approaches to allay ...
Installation of new generating capacity for renewable energy in India has outpaced that of fossil fuels in recent years, making the country home to the fifth-largest supply of renewable energy in the world. In this context, India has set the ambitious target of generating 450 GW of renewable energyRead more
Installation of new generating capacity for renewable energy in India has outpaced that of fossil fuels in recent years, making the country home to the fifth-largest supply of renewable energy in the world. In this context, India has set the ambitious target of generating 450 GW of renewable energy by 2030.
However, there remain several unaddressed issues, especially related to renewable energy (RE) generation, that need to be resolved. These include
- Procurement Issues: Solar and wind energy developers sign a contract with a power purchaser — mostly distribution companies (discoms) — for a prescribed period (typically 25 years) at a particular tariff rate per unit. The tariff is based on the capital cost, land costs as well as other operations and maintenance (O&M) costs for the supply of all the generated power. There have been instances when enticement of discoms to procure cheaper power from newer, large-scale solar and wind projects has left many old projects in a difficult situation. Cases of renegotiation have also been witnessed, leaving renewable energy projects vulnerable to damage, forced curtailment and payment delays.
- Deployment issues: Renewable energy deployment remains highly concentrated in a few resource-rich states. The share of solar and wind energy generation in renewable-rich states like Karnataka (29%), Rajasthan (20%), Tamil Nadu (18%) etc. is significantly higher than the national average of 8.2%. Further, some states do not meet their renewable purchase obligations (RPOs). Thus, the extent and adoption of renewable energy is not uniform in the country.
- Intermittency in generation: Fossil fuels like coal, which currently account for a majority of India’s power generating capacity, produce a stable and predictable stream of on-demand power. In contrast, power generation from solar and wind energy is more variable and unpredictable. As a result, grid operators may not be able to fully rely on these forms of variable energy as a means of sustenance. These challenges increase costs in the short-term and slow the build-out of renewable energy in the long-term.
- Issues related to governance: According to MNRE’s SARAL index, India is lagging in achieving its rooftop solar (RTS) power generation goal of 40 GW installation by 2022. This is because of administrative inconsistencies, inadequate financing, complexity of institutional frameworks, etc.
- Financial constraints of discoms: In December 2021, power discoms owed Rs. 101,436 crores to power generation firms according to the PRAAPTI (Payment Ratification And Analysis in Power procurement for bringing Transparency in Invoicing of generators) portal. The discoms have a precarious financial position due to massive Aggregate Technical and Commercial (AT&C) loss during transmission, absence of competition, unsustainable cross-subsidies, inefficient tariff-setting processes etc.
- Lack of trained professionals: There is a lack of skilled professionals to design, build, operate and maintain renewable energy plants in states. Further, there are not enough standards, procedures and guidelines in renewable energy in terms of durability, reliability, performance etc.
In this regard, power distribution companies and electrical grids must adopt the following reforms to mitigate their issues
- Regional interconnection and balancing: There should be increased coordination and trading between regions/states to increase the efficiency of energy flow across the network, improve economic efficiency of power procurement, and enable better integration of variable renewable generators. Further, the mechanism of tradable renewable energy certificates should be utilised.
- Advanced re-forecasting and skilling: More accurate renewable energy forecasts improve grid reliability and stability while allowing for a more cost-optimum economic dispatch of other generators in the fleet. Further, there should be skill training and capacity building of personnel.
- Decentralisation and grid modernisation:
- Rooftop solar: Long-term integrated resource plans that identify specific deployment goals for RTS that can benefit with transmission and distribution (T&D) loss reduction, peak-load management and power-procurement optimisation.
- Mini grids: Mini-grids are a sustainable and potentially cost-effective (lower T&D losses) solution, especially for remote rural areas.
- Energy storage: Energy storage can play a major role in firming up the grid and enabling high penetration of renewable energy generation.
- Harnessing potential renewable energy: Renewable energy projects in areas with potential (such as harnessing hydropower energy in North-East India) should be implemented after conducting proper impact assessment and detailed studies on possible geological issues that might arise. Further, private players should be involved in order to raise capital for the projects.
The renewable energy sector can continue to grow significantly and play a key role in India’s ambition of tackling climate change. However, if not managed well, greater penetration of renewable energy can impact the technical and financial functioning of discoms. Thus, adequate measures should be taken to enable the power distribution companies and electrical grids to successfully transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy.
See less
Potential of Nuclear Energy in the Indian Energy Mix Nuclear energy has been a key component of India’s strategy to diversify its energy mix and ensure a stable, low-carbon power supply. The Indian government is focusing on expanding nuclear power generation capacity to meet the country’s growing enRead more
Potential of Nuclear Energy in the Indian Energy Mix
Nuclear energy has been a key component of India’s strategy to diversify its energy mix and ensure a stable, low-carbon power supply. The Indian government is focusing on expanding nuclear power generation capacity to meet the country’s growing energy demands and environmental goals. Here’s an analysis of the potential of nuclear energy, along with the associated technological, economic, and safety challenges, and the strategies to address these concerns.
Potential of Nuclear Energy
Contribution to Energy Security: Nuclear energy offers a reliable and consistent source of power that can complement intermittent renewable energy sources like solar and wind. With the country’s growing energy demands, nuclear power can play a crucial role in ensuring energy security.
Recent Example: India’s nuclear power generation capacity is set to increase with the construction of new reactors. The Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant (KNPP), a joint venture with Russia, is expanding its capacity with Units 3 and 4 expected to be operational soon, adding significant megawatts to the grid.
Low Carbon Emissions: Nuclear power is a low-carbon energy source that can help India meet its climate goals under the Paris Agreement. It significantly reduces greenhouse gas emissions compared to coal-fired power plants.
Recent Example: The Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) and Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) have set ambitious targets to increase the share of nuclear power in the total energy mix to 25% by 2050.
Technological Challenges
Development of Indigenous Technology: India’s nuclear program relies heavily on indigenous technology, including the Pressurized Heavy Water Reactors (PHWRs) and the Fast Breeder Reactors (FBRs). Developing and scaling up these technologies poses significant technical challenges.
Recent Example: The Fast Breeder Test Reactor (FBTR) at Kalpakkam, a prototype for the future FBRs, has faced delays and technical issues, highlighting the complexity of advancing nuclear technology.
Infrastructure and Maintenance: Building and maintaining nuclear power plants requires advanced infrastructure and technical expertise. Ensuring the long-term operational efficiency of these plants is critical.
Recent Example: The Narora Atomic Power Station in Uttar Pradesh faced maintenance challenges that affected its operational performance, underscoring the need for robust infrastructure and skilled personnel.
Economic Challenges
High Initial Costs: Nuclear power plants involve high capital costs for construction and safety compliance. The long lead time for plant construction and the high costs of nuclear fuel and waste management add to the economic burden.
Recent Example: The construction of the Jaitapur Nuclear Power Plant, which will be one of the largest in the world, has faced delays and cost overruns, impacting the project’s financial viability.
Funding and Investment: Securing funding and investment for nuclear projects can be challenging, particularly in a competitive energy market where renewable sources are also vying for investment.
Recent Example: The India-US Civil Nuclear Cooperation Agreement has been instrumental in facilitating technology transfers and investment in the Indian nuclear sector, though challenges remain in fully realizing the potential of such agreements.
Safety Challenges
Risk of Accidents: Nuclear power plants carry the risk of accidents, which can have severe environmental and human health consequences. Ensuring stringent safety protocols is essential to mitigate these risks.
Recent Example: The Fukushima disaster (2011) in Japan has heightened global concerns about nuclear safety, prompting India to review and strengthen its safety regulations and emergency response protocols.
Waste Management: Managing nuclear waste and ensuring its safe disposal is a major challenge. Long-term storage solutions must be developed to handle radioactive waste securely.
Recent Example: The Nuclear Fuel Complex (NFC) in Hyderabad is working on advanced technologies for waste management and reprocessing to address the long-term challenges of radioactive waste disposal.
Strategies to Address Public Concerns and Enhance Sustainability
Transparency and Public Engagement: Increasing transparency and engaging with the public on nuclear safety and benefits can help address concerns and build trust.
Recent Example: The Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) has launched various outreach programs to educate the public about nuclear energy and its safety measures.
Strengthening Safety Regulations: Implementing and enforcing stringent safety standards and regulations to ensure the highest safety levels at nuclear power plants.
Recent Example: India has adopted international safety standards and practices from organizations like the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) to enhance safety protocols and emergency preparedness.
Promoting Research and Development: Investing in R&D to develop advanced nuclear technologies, such as small modular reactors (SMRs) and advanced fuel cycles, to improve efficiency and safety.
Recent Example: The Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC) is actively involved in developing next-generation reactors and advanced fuel technologies to support sustainable nuclear energy.
Conclusion
Nuclear energy holds significant potential for India’s energy mix, offering a stable and low-carbon power source to meet growing energy demands. However, the sector faces substantial technological, economic, and safety challenges. The Indian government’s strategies to address these challenges include enhancing transparency, strengthening safety regulations, investing in R&D, and engaging with the public. These efforts are crucial for ensuring that nuclear energy can contribute effectively to India’s energy security and sustainability goals.
See less