Roadmap for Answer Writing Introduction Contextual Background: Introduce the historical role of India as a leader of oppressed and marginalized nations, particularly during the Cold War. Thesis Statement: State that India’s evolving foreign policy and new role in the global order have diminished ...
Model Answer Introduction The judicial systems of India and the United Kingdom share a historical connection, with India's legal framework significantly influenced by British colonial rule. Over time, both systems have evolved, reflecting their unique societal and political contexts. This evolutionRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The judicial systems of India and the United Kingdom share a historical connection, with India’s legal framework significantly influenced by British colonial rule. Over time, both systems have evolved, reflecting their unique societal and political contexts. This evolution has led to both convergence and divergence in their judicial practices.
Body
Points of Convergence
- Common Law Tradition:
- Both India and the UK operate under a common law system, relying on judicial precedents and the principle of stare decisis, which emphasizes the importance of previous judicial decisions (Gonzalez, 2021).
- Rule of Law:
- Both countries uphold the rule of law, ensuring that laws are applied fairly and that the judiciary maintains independence from the executive and legislative branches (Choudhury, 2022).
- Judicial Activism:
- There has been a rise in judicial activism in both nations, with courts taking an active role in interpreting laws to address social, economic, and environmental issues (Sundaram, 2021).
- Protection of Fundamental Rights:
- Both systems prioritize the protection of fundamental rights. The UK’s Human Rights Act 1998 incorporates the European Convention on Human Rights, while India’s Constitution enshrines a comprehensive set of fundamental rights (Human Rights Watch, 2022).
Points of Divergence
- Constitutional Framework:
- India has a written constitution as the supreme law, whereas the UK operates under an unwritten constitution based on statutes, common law, and conventions (Morris, 2022).
- Judicial Review:
- Judicial review in India is broader, allowing courts to strike down laws that violate the Constitution, while the UK judiciary’s review is limited to compatibility with the Human Rights Act (Patel, 2023).
- Court Structure:
- India has a unitary three-tier structure: the Supreme Court, High Courts, and subordinate courts. The UK features a complex structure with separate systems for England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland (Smith, 2021).
- Appointment of Judges:
- India’s collegium system for appointing judges is more opaque, involving senior judges, while the UK’s Judicial Appointments Commission provides a more transparent, merit-based selection process (Johnson, 2022).
Conclusion
As India and the UK continue to adapt to contemporary challenges, their judicial systems are likely to evolve further, potentially leading to new areas of convergence or divergence that reflect the dynamic legal landscapes of both nations.
See less
Model Answer Introduction India’s foreign policy has evolved significantly, moving away from its historical image as a champion for oppressed and marginalized nations. This shift reflects a new role in the emerging global order, where national interests now take precedence over collective interestsRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
India’s foreign policy has evolved significantly, moving away from its historical image as a champion for oppressed and marginalized nations. This shift reflects a new role in the emerging global order, where national interests now take precedence over collective interests of developing countries.
Body
1. Historical Leadership and Idealism
India’s leadership credentials were robust during the Cold War, characterized by its advocacy for smaller economies and vulnerable nations. For instance:
2. Shift in Foreign Policy Perspective
In recent years, India has prioritized economic development and national interests:
3. Regional Dynamics and Global Strategy
India’s approach to regional forums and its strategic foreign policy have also evolved:
4. Criticism and Allegations
India faces scrutiny for its changing role:
Conclusion
India’s transition from a leader of the oppressed to a major global player marks a significant transformation in its foreign policy. This shift towards Realpolitik indicates its growing ambitions and the importance of contributing to a rules-based international order, shaping the future of global relations.
See less