Sign Up

Have an account?

Sign In

Don't have account,

Forgot Password

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.


Have an account?

Sorry, you do not have permission to ask a question, You must login to ask a question.

Need An Account,

Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.

Search
Ask A Question
Home/upsc: important international institutions/Page 4

Mains Answer Writing Latest Questions

Puja Singh
  • 0
Puja SinghBegginer
Asked: July 17, 2024In:
  • 0

Talk about India’s involvement in the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) and its initiatives to fortify the international framework prohibiting the use of chemical weapons, as well as its stance on the chemical strikes in Syria.

upsc: important international institutions
  1. Agni Rao
    Agni Rao Begginer

    India has been an active participant in the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) and has contributed to the global efforts to strengthen the regime against the use of chemical weapons. Here are some key aspects of India's engagement with the OPCW: **Membership:** India joinedRead more

    India has been an active participant in the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) and has contributed to the global efforts to strengthen the regime against the use of chemical weapons. Here are some key aspects of India’s engagement with the OPCW:

    **Membership:** India joined the OPCW in 1997 and is a signatory to the Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC).

    **Contributions:** India has made significant contributions to the OPCW, including:

    1. **Technical assistance:** India has provided technical assistance to developing countries for the destruction of chemical weapons and their precursors.
    2. **Capacity-building:** India has organized training programs for OPCW inspectors and national authorities on topics such as chemical weapons destruction, sampling, and analysis.
    3. **Research and development:** India has contributed to research and development projects related to chemical weapons detection, monitoring, and verification.

    **Position on Syrian chemical attacks:** India has consistently condemned the use of chemical weapons in Syria and has called for a thorough investigation into such incidents. India has also supported the OPCW’s efforts to investigate and verify allegations of chemical weapon use.

    **Key positions:**

    1. **Non-proliferation:** India emphasizes the importance of non-proliferation of chemical weapons and supports efforts to prevent the spread of chemical weapons technology.
    2. **Verification:** India has stressed the importance of effective verification mechanisms to ensure compliance with the CWC and prevent cheating.
    3. **Destruction of chemical weapons:** India has supported international efforts to destroy declared stockpiles of chemical weapons and has contributed to the destruction of its own stockpile.
    4. **Assistance to victims:** India has provided medical assistance to victims of chemical weapon attacks, including those affected by the Syrian civil war.

    **Challenges:**

    1. **Limited resources:** India’s limited resources have constrained its ability to make more significant contributions to the OPCW’s work.
    2. **Regional concerns:** India’s involvement in regional issues, such as its disputed border with China, may divert attention from its engagement with the OPCW.
    3. **Prioritization:** India’s priorities may shift depending on domestic and regional concerns, which could affect its focus on chemical weapon issues.

    **Opportunities:**

    1. **Increased cooperation:** India can explore increased cooperation with other countries, including regional partners, to strengthen the global regime against chemical weapons.
    2. **Capacity-building:** India can continue to provide technical assistance and capacity-building programs for developing countries, enhancing their ability to comply with the CWC.
    3. **Research and development:** India can leverage its scientific expertise to develop new technologies for detecting, monitoring, and verifying chemical weapons use.

    In conclusion, India’s engagement with the OPCW reflects its commitment to preventing the proliferation and use of chemical weapons. While there are challenges and limitations, India can build on its strengths in areas like technical assistance, capacity-building, and research and development to strengthen the global regime against chemical weapons.

    See less
Puja Singh
  • 0
Puja SinghBegginer
Asked: July 17, 2024In:
  • 0

Examine India’s participation in and contributions to UN peacekeeping operations, taking into account the difficulties it has experienced as well as the strategic advantages it has enjoyed in terms of its stature in the world and its ability to influence ...

upsc: important international institutions
  1. vikas singh
    vikas singh Begginer

    India has been an active participant in the United Nations Peacekeeping missions since its inception in 1948. As one of the largest troop contributors to UN peacekeeping operations, India has played a significant role in maintaining international peace and security. Here's an analysis of India's rolRead more

    India has been an active participant in the United Nations Peacekeeping missions since its inception in 1948. As one of the largest troop contributors to UN peacekeeping operations, India has played a significant role in maintaining international peace and security. Here’s an analysis of India’s role and contributions to UN peacekeeping missions:

    **Contributions:**

    1. **Troop contributions:** India has contributed troops to over 40 UN peacekeeping missions, including the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL), the United Nations Mission in the Democratic Republic of Congo (MONUSCO), and the United Nations Mission in South Sudan (UNMISS).
    2. **Financial contributions:** India is among the top five contributors to the UN regular budget, and has also contributed to the UN peacekeeping budget.
    3. **Capacity building:** India has shared its expertise with other countries through capacity-building programs, such as training for peacekeepers, and has provided equipment and infrastructure support.

    **Challenges:**

    1. **Security risks:** Indian peacekeepers have faced security risks, including attacks and injuries, in various conflict zones.
    2. **Logistical challenges:** India faces logistical challenges in maintaining its troop presence in remote or hostile environments.
    3. **Cultural and linguistic differences:** India’s diverse cultural and linguistic backgrounds can create communication barriers and cultural misunderstandings with other troop-contributing countries.

    **Strategic benefits:**

    1. **Global standing:** India’s participation in UN peacekeeping missions enhances its global standing as a responsible and committed international citizen.
    2. **Regional influence:** India’s involvement in regional conflicts helps maintain its influence in the region and demonstrates its commitment to regional stability.
    3. **Economic benefits:** Peacekeeping operations can generate economic benefits for India through infrastructure development, local purchases, and employment opportunities.
    4. **Humanitarian assistance:** India’s participation in humanitarian efforts demonstrates its commitment to humanitarian values and provides opportunities for humanitarian assistance.
    5. **Diplomatic leverage:** India’s contributions to UN peacekeeping operations can be used as diplomatic leverage to negotiate with other countries and promote Indian interests.

    **Recent developments:**

    1. **Increased involvement:** India has increased its involvement in UN peacekeeping operations, with a focus on African missions.
    2. **Capacity building:** India is focusing on capacity building for peacekeepers, including training programs for African nations.
    3. **Enhanced coordination:** India is working to enhance coordination between different UN agencies, governments, and civil society organizations to improve the effectiveness of peacekeeping operations.

    In conclusion, India’s contributions to UN peacekeeping missions have been significant, and it has derived strategic benefits from its involvement. While challenges are inevitable, India’s commitment to international peace and security remains unwavering. As a responsible global citizen, India will continue to play a vital role in maintaining international peace and security, while also promoting its own interests and influence on the global stage.

    See less
Avni Singh
  • 0
Avni Singh
Asked: July 16, 2024In:
  • 0

Analyze how the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have influenced India’s macroeconomic policies and the country’s economic growth. Talk about the critiques and changes that India and other developing nations have suggested for these institutions.

upsc: important international institutions
  1. vikas singh
    vikas singh Begginer

    The International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank have had a significant impact on India's economic development, particularly in the post-liberalization era. Their influence has been multifaceted, and their role in shaping India's macroeconomic policies has been both positive and negative. PoRead more

    The International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank have had a significant impact on India’s economic development, particularly in the post-liberalization era. Their influence has been multifaceted, and their role in shaping India’s macroeconomic policies has been both positive and negative.

    Positive impact:

    1. **Economic reforms:** The IMF and the World Bank have played a crucial role in promoting economic reforms in India. They have encouraged India to adopt policies such as liberalization, privatization, and globalization, which have contributed to rapid economic growth.
    2. **Macroeconomic stability:** The IMF has provided financial assistance to India during times of economic crisis, helping to maintain macroeconomic stability and preventing currency devaluations.
    3. **Technical assistance:** The World Bank has provided technical assistance to India in areas such as infrastructure development, human resource development, and public health.

    Negative impact:

    1. **Conditionality:** The IMF’s conditionality requirements have often been criticized for being overly restrictive and biased towards austerity measures, which can exacerbate income inequality and undermine social welfare programs.
    2. **Neo-liberal ideology:** The IMF and the World Bank have been accused of promoting a neo-liberal ideology that prioritizes market-driven growth over social welfare and labor rights.
    3. **Debt trap:** India’s heavy reliance on foreign debt to finance its economic development has created a debt trap, making it vulnerable to debt servicing and refinancing risks.

    Criticism from India:

    1. **Conditionality:** India has criticized the IMF’s conditionality requirements for being overly rigid and not taking into account the country’s specific circumstances.
    2. **Lack of policy space:** India has argued that the IMF’s conditionality requirements limit its policy space, making it difficult for the government to implement policies that benefit the poor and vulnerable.
    3. **Biased decision-making:** India has accused the IMF and the World Bank of having biased decision-making processes that favor Western countries and multinational corporations.

    Reforms proposed by India:

    1. **Increased policy space:** India has called for increased policy space to enable governments to implement policies that benefit their citizens.
    2. **More flexible conditionality:** India has advocated for more flexible conditionality requirements that take into account the country’s specific circumstances.
    3. **Alternative institutions:** India has proposed alternative institutions, such as the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) and the New Development Bank (NDB), which are seen as more responsive to the needs of developing countries.

    Reforms proposed by other developing countries:

    1. **More representative governance:** Developing countries have called for more representative governance structures within the IMF and the World Bank, with a greater voice for developing countries.
    2. **More flexible lending arrangements:** Developing countries have advocated for more flexible lending arrangements that allow for more sustainable debt management.
    3. **Alternative financial architectures:** Developing countries have proposed alternative financial architectures that prioritize debt forgiveness, debt cancellation, and more equitable burden sharing.

    In conclusion, while the IMF and the World Bank have played a significant role in shaping India’s macroeconomic policies, their impact has been controversial. India and other developing countries have criticized their conditionality requirements, lack of policy space, and biased decision-making processes. To address these concerns, reforms are needed to increase policy space, make conditionality more flexible, and promote more representative governance structures within these institutions.

    See less
Ananya Patel
  • 0
Ananya Patel
Asked: July 16, 2024In:
  • 0

Examine how the United Nations (UN) is changing the landscape of global governance, especially in light of India’s bid for a permanent seat on the UN Security Council (UNSC). Talk about the prospects and problems facing the UN reform process.

upsc: important international institutions
  1. Sidharth Mohan
    Sidharth Mohan Begginer

    Analyze the emergence and evolution of caste-based associations, such as the Dalit movements and the Jat Reservation Agitation, in the Indian political system. Discuss their influence on identity politics, social justice, and the demand for affirmative action. ChatGPT The emergence and evolution ofRead more

    Analyze the emergence and evolution of caste-based associations, such as the Dalit movements and the Jat Reservation Agitation, in the Indian political system. Discuss their influence on identity politics, social justice, and the demand for affirmative action.
    ChatGPT
    The emergence and evolution of caste-based associations in India, such as the Dalit movements and the Jat Reservation Agitation, have played a significant role in shaping the Indian political landscape. These movements have influenced identity politics, social justice, and the demand for affirmative action in various ways.

    Dalit Movements
    1. Historical Context:

    Colonial Era: The Dalit movements can be traced back to the colonial era when British administrators documented the deep-rooted caste inequalities in Indian society. Reformers like Jyotirao Phule and B.R. Ambedkar began challenging these inequalities.
    Post-Independence: After independence in 1947, the Indian Constitution, drafted under Ambedkar’s leadership, abolished untouchability and aimed to promote social justice.
    2. Key Movements and Figures:

    Ambedkarite Movement: B.R. Ambedkar, a key figure in Dalit politics, advocated for the rights of Dalits and worked towards their upliftment. His efforts led to the formation of the Scheduled Castes Federation and later the Republican Party of India.
    Contemporary Movements: In recent decades, organizations like the Dalit Panthers and various NGOs have continued to fight for Dalit rights, focusing on issues such as caste-based violence, discrimination, and socio-economic upliftment.
    3. Influence on Identity Politics:

    The Dalit movement has been instrumental in fostering a sense of identity among Dalits, highlighting the intersection of caste and social justice.
    It has challenged mainstream narratives and policies, pushing for greater representation and recognition of Dalit issues in political discourse.
    4. Influence on Social Justice and Affirmative Action:

    The movement has led to the implementation of affirmative action policies, including reservations in education, employment, and political representation.
    Despite these measures, challenges remain, including disparities in educational attainment and economic status.
    Jat Reservation Agitation
    1. Historical Context:

    Socio-Economic Changes: The Jat community, traditionally an agrarian group, sought reservation benefits to improve their socio-economic status amidst growing economic and educational disparities.
    2. Key Agitations:

    2016 Jat Reservation Agitation: One of the most notable agitations occurred in Haryana in 2016, where Jat leaders demanded inclusion in the Other Backward Classes (OBC) category for reservation in government jobs and educational institutions.
    Violence and Protests: The agitation led to widespread violence, property damage, and significant disruption in the state, highlighting the intense demand for affirmative action among different caste groups.
    3. Influence on Identity Politics:

    The Jat Reservation Agitation reflects the complexity of identity politics in India, where even relatively privileged communities seek affirmative action based on perceived socio-economic disadvantages.
    It underscores the fluidity of caste-based identities and the shifting nature of political demands.
    4. Influence on Social Justice and Affirmative Action:

    The agitation intensified debates on the criteria for affirmative action and the need for a more nuanced approach to reservation policies.
    It also demonstrated the growing demand for reservation among various groups, prompting discussions on balancing social justice with merit-based considerations.
    Conclusion
    Caste-based associations and movements in India have significantly impacted identity politics and social justice. They have pushed the boundaries of affirmative action, highlighting the need for ongoing dialogue and reform. While they have succeeded in bringing caste issues to the forefront of political discourse, the challenges of ensuring equitable implementation and addressing evolving socio-economic needs continue to shape the Indian political landscape.

    Evaluate the objectives and methods of civil society organizations, such as the Aam Aadmi Party and the India Against Corruption movement, in their efforts to promote transparency, accountability, and good governance. Discuss the challenges faced by these organizations in influencing the political decision-making process.
    ChatGPT
    Civil society organizations (CSOs) such as the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) and the India Against Corruption (IAC) movement have played pivotal roles in advocating for transparency, accountability, and good governance in India. Each has approached these objectives through distinct methods and faced unique challenges in influencing the political decision-making process.

    India Against Corruption (IAC) Movement
    Objectives:

    Anti-Corruption: The primary aim of IAC was to combat corruption within the Indian political and bureaucratic systems. It sought to bring about systemic changes to reduce corruption and increase transparency.
    Accountability: IAC aimed to hold public officials accountable and demand stricter enforcement of anti-corruption laws.
    Good Governance: The movement advocated for stronger governance structures, emphasizing the need for transparency and accountability in both public and private sectors.
    Methods:

    Public Protests and Mobilization: IAC used large-scale public demonstrations, most notably the 2011 anti-corruption protests led by Anna Hazare, to rally popular support and apply pressure on the government.
    Media Campaigns: The movement effectively utilized media, including social media, to spread its message, garner public support, and bring attention to corruption scandals.
    Petitions and Legislative Proposals: IAC advocated for the passage of key legislation such as the Lokpal Bill, which aimed to establish an anti-corruption ombudsman.
    Challenges:

    Political Resistance: The movement faced strong resistance from entrenched political interests and bureaucratic systems, which were often resistant to the proposed reforms.
    Fragmentation: The movement struggled with internal disagreements and fragmentation, particularly as it transitioned into the political arena with the formation of the Aam Aadmi Party.
    Skepticism and Criticism: There were criticisms of the movement’s effectiveness and its potential to engage in political opportunism, which affected its credibility.
    Aam Aadmi Party (AAP)
    Objectives:

    Anti-Corruption and Transparency: AAP’s primary objective is to fight corruption and promote transparency in governance. It advocates for clean politics and a corruption-free administrative system.
    Decentralization of Power: The party supports decentralization of power, emphasizing the importance of local governance and grassroots democracy.
    Social Welfare: AAP aims to improve social welfare by focusing on issues like education, healthcare, and public services.
    Methods:

    Electoral Politics: Unlike IAC, AAP entered the political arena formally by contesting elections, starting with the Delhi Legislative Assembly elections in 2013.
    Public Engagement: The party has employed grassroots mobilization and public engagement to build support and influence policy changes. It focuses on direct interaction with citizens and community-level issues.
    Policy Implementation: Once in power, AAP has worked on implementing its agenda through policy measures and governance reforms, including initiatives in education, healthcare, and anti-corruption.
    Challenges:

    Governance and Administration: AAP has faced challenges in governance, including the constraints of coalition politics and limited administrative powers, especially in a federal structure where states have significant autonomy.
    Political Opposition: The party encounters opposition from established political parties, which often undermines or obstructs its initiatives.
    Public Expectations: Managing high public expectations and delivering on campaign promises in a complex political environment has been a significant challenge for AAP.
    Conclusion
    Both the India Against Corruption movement and the Aam Aadmi Party have made substantial contributions to promoting transparency, accountability, and good governance in India. However, their paths diverge in methods and challenges:

    IAC used grassroots mobilization and media campaigns to push for anti-corruption reforms but faced issues with internal fragmentation and political resistance.
    AAP transitioned from a movement to a political party, employing electoral politics and governance reforms to address corruption and promote transparency. It faces challenges related to governance, political opposition, and managing public expectations.
    Their efforts highlight the complexities of influencing political decision-making and the need for continued advocacy, reform, and engagement to achieve lasting improvements in governance.

    Evaluate the role and influence of think tanks, such as the Observer Research Foundation and the Centre for Policy Research, in providing policy recommendations, conducting research, and shaping the public discourse on various issues of national importance.
    ChatGPT
    Think tanks play a crucial role in shaping public policy and national discourse by providing research-based recommendations, engaging in policy analysis, and influencing public opinion. In India, organizations like the Observer Research Foundation (ORF) and the Centre for Policy Research (CPR) are prominent examples of such think tanks. Here’s an evaluation of their roles and influences:

    Observer Research Foundation (ORF)
    Role and Objectives:

    Policy Research: ORF conducts extensive research on a range of topics, including foreign policy, national security, economic development, and technology. Its objective is to offer data-driven insights and policy recommendations.
    Public Engagement: The foundation organizes conferences, seminars, and workshops to discuss pressing issues, engaging policymakers, academics, and the public in dialogues that influence policy discussions.
    Publications and Media: ORF produces reports, policy briefs, and articles that contribute to public discourse and provide evidence-based recommendations to stakeholders.
    Influence:

    Policy Recommendations: ORF’s research has informed policy decisions on various fronts, including international relations and economic strategies. Its expertise is often sought by government officials and policymakers.
    Shaping Discourse: By organizing high-profile events and publishing research, ORF influences public debate and helps shape the narrative around key national and international issues.
    Networking and Collaboration: ORF collaborates with international think tanks and research organizations, enhancing its impact on global policy discussions and fostering cross-border exchanges of ideas.
    Challenges:

    Resource Dependency: Like many think tanks, ORF’s ability to influence policy can be limited by its funding sources and the need to balance independence with financial sustainability.
    Political Neutrality: Ensuring political neutrality while engaging with various stakeholders can be challenging, as think tanks are often perceived to have particular ideological leanings.
    Centre for Policy Research (CPR)
    Role and Objectives:

    Research and Analysis: CPR focuses on in-depth research and analysis on issues such as governance, urban development, and social policy. It aims to provide evidence-based recommendations to improve public policy and governance.
    Policy Advocacy: CPR engages in advocacy efforts by highlighting research findings and working with government bodies, civil society, and other stakeholders to drive policy changes.
    Educational Contributions: The center contributes to academic discourse by publishing research papers, books, and policy briefs, and organizing seminars and lectures.
    Influence:

    Policy Impact: CPR’s research has influenced a range of policy areas, including urban planning, social welfare, and public administration. Its recommendations are often incorporated into policy frameworks and government strategies.
    Public Discourse: CPR helps shape public discourse through its publications and public engagement activities, providing a platform for informed debate on critical issues.
    Academic Contributions: By contributing to the academic field, CPR influences the broader intellectual and policy-making community, fostering a deeper understanding of complex issues.
    Challenges:

    Visibility and Reach: While CPR’s research is highly regarded, its impact can be limited by challenges in reaching broader audiences and translating research findings into actionable policy.
    Political Dynamics: Navigating the political landscape and maintaining credibility in the face of political pressures can be a challenge, particularly when dealing with contentious or sensitive issues.
    Conclusion
    Both ORF and CPR play significant roles in providing policy recommendations, conducting research, and shaping public discourse:

    ORF is known for its wide-ranging research and public engagement efforts, influencing both national and international policy discussions.
    CPR excels in in-depth research and advocacy, contributing to academic and policy debates on governance and social issues.
    Their effectiveness in shaping policy and discourse is closely tied to their ability to produce high-quality research, engage with diverse stakeholders, and maintain credibility in a complex political environment. Challenges related to resource dependency, political neutrality, and visibility are ongoing, but both organizations continue to make meaningful contributions to the public policy landscape in India.

    Analyze the role and influence of youth organizations, such as the Indian Youth Congress and the Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha, in mobilizing young voters, engaging in political activism, and shaping the political discourse on issues of concern to the younger generation.
    ChatGPT
    Youth organizations in India, such as the Indian Youth Congress (IYC) and the Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha (BJYM), play a crucial role in mobilizing young voters, engaging in political activism, and shaping political discourse. These organizations serve as platforms for political engagement, advocacy, and leadership development among the younger generation. Here’s an analysis of their roles and influences:

    Indian Youth Congress (IYC)
    Role and Objectives:

    Mobilizing Young Voters: The IYC aims to mobilize young voters for the Indian National Congress (INC) by promoting voter registration, participation in elections, and political awareness among youth.
    Political Activism: The organization engages in various forms of activism, including protests, campaigns, and advocacy on issues like education, employment, and social justice.
    Leadership Development: IYC focuses on training and developing future leaders within the INC, providing young members with opportunities for leadership and involvement in political processes.
    Influence:

    Election Impact: The IYC’s efforts to mobilize young voters can influence election outcomes, particularly in terms of voter turnout and support for the INC. Its campaigns often focus on youth-centric issues, aiming to resonate with younger demographics.
    Policy Advocacy: Through activism and campaigns, IYC advocates for policies that address youth concerns, such as job creation, affordable education, and social equality. This advocacy can impact the party’s policy positions and public discourse.
    Shaping Discourse: The IYC contributes to shaping the political discourse by highlighting issues relevant to young people and pushing for reforms that align with their interests and needs.
    Challenges:

    Perception and Credibility: The IYC sometimes faces challenges related to its perceived effectiveness and the overall credibility of the INC among younger voters, especially when compared to newer political organizations.
    Internal Dynamics: Like many political organizations, the IYC may struggle with internal conflicts and leadership challenges, which can affect its organizational cohesion and effectiveness.
    Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha (BJYM)
    Role and Objectives:

    Mobilizing Young Support: The BJYM works to mobilize young voters for the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), focusing on building a strong base of youth support for the party through outreach and engagement.
    Political Activism: The organization is involved in political activism, including campaigns, rallies, and social media outreach. It addresses issues such as nationalism, economic development, and youth empowerment.
    Leadership Development: The BJYM provides training and leadership opportunities for young members, helping to develop future leaders within the BJP and prepare them for political roles.
    Influence:

    Election Influence: The BJYM plays a key role in the BJP’s electoral strategies, helping to energize and mobilize young voters. Its campaigns often focus on nationalistic themes and economic growth, which can sway voter sentiment.
    Policy Focus: The BJYM’s advocacy often reflects the BJP’s policy priorities, such as economic development, national security, and cultural issues. Its activities can influence the party’s policy agenda and public messaging.
    Public Discourse: The BJYM shapes public discourse by promoting issues important to the BJP’s platform and engaging in debates on national and local issues. Its active presence in social media also contributes to shaping online discourse.
    Challenges:

    Ideological Polarization: The BJYM, with its strong alignment with the BJP’s ideological positions, can face challenges related to ideological polarization and opposition from youth with differing viewpoints.
    Perception of Authenticity: There can be concerns about the authenticity of the BJYM’s engagement with youth issues, particularly if the organization is perceived as primarily a political tool rather than a genuine advocate for youth concerns.
    Conclusion
    Both the Indian Youth Congress and the Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha play significant roles in engaging young voters and shaping political discourse:

    IYC focuses on mobilizing youth for the Indian National Congress and advocating for policies relevant to young people, though it faces challenges related to its perceived effectiveness and internal dynamics.
    BJYM works to build support for the BJP, emphasizing nationalism and economic development, but must navigate challenges related to ideological polarization and perceptions of authenticity.
    Their influence on political activism and discourse is substantial, as they contribute to shaping the political landscape by addressing youth concerns, mobilizing support, and advocating for specific policy agendas.

    Analyze India’s evolving strategic relationships with its immediate neighbors, such as Pakistan, China, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka. Discuss how historical baggage, territorial disputes, and geopolitical considerations have shaped these relationships in the past decade.
    ChatGPT
    India’s strategic relationships with its immediate neighbors—Pakistan, China, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka—are shaped by a complex interplay of historical baggage, territorial disputes, and geopolitical considerations. The past decade has seen significant shifts in these relationships, influenced by both domestic and international factors. Here’s an analysis of these evolving dynamics:

    1. Pakistan
    Historical Baggage and Territorial Disputes:

    Historical Conflicts: The relationship between India and Pakistan has been marred by a history of conflict, including three wars and ongoing tensions over the Kashmir region.
    Territorial Disputes: The dispute over Kashmir remains a central issue, with both countries claiming the region in its entirety. The Line of Control (LoC) often witnesses skirmishes and ceasefire violations.
    Recent Developments:

    2016 Uri Attack and Surgical Strikes: Tensions escalated after the 2016 Uri attack, leading to India’s surgical strikes against militant camps in Pakistan-administered Kashmir. This event highlighted the fragile nature of bilateral relations.
    2019 Pulwama Attack and Balakot Airstrike: The 2019 Pulwama attack led to India’s Balakot airstrike, further straining relations and internationalizing the Kashmir issue.
    Diplomatic Engagement: Despite these tensions, there have been periodic attempts at dialogue, though they have often stalled due to renewed violence or diplomatic disputes.
    Geopolitical Considerations:

    Counterterrorism: India has sought international support to isolate Pakistan diplomatically, particularly concerning its alleged support for terrorism. The FATF (Financial Action Task Force) has been a forum where India has raised concerns about Pakistan’s counter-terrorism efforts.
    2. China
    Historical Baggage and Territorial Disputes:

    Border Disputes: The unresolved border dispute, particularly in Arunachal Pradesh and Aksai Chin, has been a major point of contention. The 1962 Sino-Indian War left lasting scars.
    Strategic Rivalry: The rise of China as a global power and its strategic partnerships with countries like Pakistan have added complexity to the India-China relationship.
    Recent Developments:

    Doklam Standoff (2017): The Doklam standoff was a significant episode where India and China came close to a military confrontation over a disputed area in Bhutan.
    Galwan Valley Clash (2020): The clash in the Galwan Valley in 2020 resulted in casualties on both sides and underscored the volatile nature of the border situation.
    Economic and Strategic Engagement: Despite border tensions, India and China have engaged in economic cooperation, though strategic competition persists, particularly in the Indo-Pacific region.
    Geopolitical Considerations:

    Strategic Partnerships: India has strengthened its strategic partnerships with countries like the U.S., Japan, and Australia as a counterbalance to China’s influence in the region.
    3. Nepal
    Historical Baggage and Territorial Disputes:

    Historical Ties: India and Nepal share deep historical, cultural, and familial ties, but these have sometimes been strained by issues related to sovereignty and border disputes.
    Territorial Dispute: The dispute over the Kalapani-Limpiyadhura-Limpiyadhura area has led to diplomatic friction, with both countries presenting competing maps.
    Recent Developments:

    Blockade (2015-16): The blockade of Nepal by India during the 2015 earthquake recovery period strained relations, leading to accusations of Indian interference in Nepal’s internal affairs.
    Recent Diplomatic Engagement: Efforts have been made to repair ties, with high-level visits and dialogues aimed at resolving disputes and enhancing cooperation.
    Geopolitical Considerations:

    Influence of China: Nepal’s increasing engagement with China has added a layer of complexity, with India closely watching Nepal’s growing economic and strategic relationship with Beijing.
    4. Bhutan
    Historical Ties and Strategic Importance:

    Close Relations: India and Bhutan have traditionally enjoyed a close relationship, with India being Bhutan’s largest trade partner and ally in security matters.
    Strategic Interests: Bhutan’s strategic location between India and China makes it important for India’s security and regional stability.
    Recent Developments:

    Doklam Standoff: During the Doklam standoff, Bhutan’s support for India was crucial, highlighting the strategic nature of their relationship.
    Continued Cooperation: The relationship remains strong, with continued cooperation on economic, security, and developmental fronts.
    Geopolitical Considerations:

    China’s Engagement: Bhutan’s cautious approach to China’s growing influence in the region is closely monitored by India, given the strategic implications.
    5. Bangladesh
    Historical Baggage and Strategic Importance:

    Historical Context: India played a crucial role in the creation of Bangladesh in 1971. The relationship has been generally positive but has had issues related to border management and water sharing.
    Strategic Importance: Bangladesh’s location and its growing economic potential make it an important partner for India.
    Recent Developments:

    Border Issues: Efforts have been made to address border issues, including the exchange of enclaves and improving border security.
    Economic and Strategic Cooperation: The two countries have strengthened economic ties, with India providing trade benefits and investment in infrastructure projects.
    Geopolitical Considerations:

    Countering Extremism: India collaborates with Bangladesh on counter-terrorism and security issues, given concerns about extremist activities and cross-border smuggling.
    6. Sri Lanka
    Historical Baggage and Strategic Importance:

    Ethnic Tensions: India’s involvement in Sri Lanka’s ethnic conflict, particularly during the 1980s, has left a legacy of mixed feelings. The Tamil issue has been a significant point of contention.
    Strategic Importance: Sri Lanka’s strategic location in the Indian Ocean makes it important for India’s maritime security and regional influence.
    Recent Developments:

    Economic Cooperation: India has been involved in several development projects in Sri Lanka, including infrastructure and housing projects.
    Diplomatic Challenges: There have been occasional strains related to issues like the treatment of Tamil minorities and geopolitical competition with China.
    Geopolitical Considerations:

    Chinese Influence: Sri Lanka’s increasing engagement with China, including infrastructure projects under the Belt and Road Initiative, is a point of concern for India, which seeks to maintain its influence in the region.
    Conclusion
    India’s relationships with its neighbors are shaped by a combination of historical legacies, territorial disputes, and strategic interests:

    Pakistan: Relations are marred by historical conflicts and territorial disputes, with recent years seeing heightened tensions.
    China: The strategic rivalry is underscored by border disputes and geopolitical competition, with ongoing efforts to manage conflicts while engaging economically.
    Nepal: While historical ties are strong, recent disputes and Nepal’s increasing engagement with China have introduced new challenges.
    Bhutan: Relations remain strong, with cooperation and strategic alignment being key factors.
    Bangladesh: Cooperation has strengthened, focusing on economic ties and border management, though challenges remain.
    Sri Lanka: Strategic and economic relations are crucial, with recent concerns about China’s influence affecting bilateral dynamics.
    These relationships continue to evolve, influenced by domestic policies, regional developments, and global geopolitical shifts.

    Analyze the evolving role of the United Nations (UN) in global governance, particularly in the context of India’s efforts to secure a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council (UNSC). Discuss the challenges and opportunities in the UN reform process.
    ChatGPT
    The role of the United Nations (UN) in global governance has been evolving in response to shifting geopolitical dynamics, emerging global challenges, and calls for reform. India’s pursuit of a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) reflects broader debates about the effectiveness and representativeness of the UN’s structure. Here’s an analysis of the evolving role of the UN, the challenges and opportunities in the reform process, and India’s efforts in this context:

    Evolving Role of the UN in Global Governance
    1. Global Peace and Security:

    Traditional Role: The UN has historically played a crucial role in maintaining international peace and security through peacekeeping missions, conflict resolution, and diplomatic efforts.
    Modern Challenges: The UN faces new challenges, including complex conflicts involving non-state actors, cyber threats, and transnational issues like terrorism and climate change. The effectiveness of the UN’s peacekeeping and conflict resolution mechanisms is often debated in light of these evolving threats.
    2. Development and Humanitarian Assistance:

    Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): The UN has spearheaded global efforts to address poverty, inequality, and sustainable development through initiatives like the SDGs.
    Humanitarian Efforts: The UN provides humanitarian assistance in crises, including natural disasters and conflicts, with agencies such as the UNHCR, UNICEF, and the World Food Programme playing key roles.
    3. Human Rights and International Law:

    Human Rights Advocacy: The UN promotes human rights through instruments like the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and various treaties and conventions.
    International Law: The UN also upholds international law through its International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the International Criminal Court (ICC), addressing issues of war crimes and international disputes.
    India’s Efforts to Secure a Permanent UNSC Seat
    1. India’s Aspirations:

    Historical Context: India has been advocating for a permanent seat on the UNSC for several decades. The argument is that the current UNSC membership does not reflect the contemporary geopolitical realities and the increasing role of emerging powers like India.
    Rationale: India argues that as one of the world’s largest democracies and a significant regional power, it deserves a permanent seat to better represent the interests of developing countries and contribute to global decision-making.
    2. Support and Opposition:

    Support: India has garnered support from various countries and regional blocs, including many developing nations and members of the G4 (Brazil, Germany, Japan, and India), who advocate for UNSC expansion and reform.
    Opposition: Some countries are skeptical of India’s bid due to concerns about increasing the number of permanent members, the potential for further complicating decision-making, or geopolitical rivalries. China, for instance, has been cautious about supporting India’s bid due to broader geopolitical considerations.
    3. Reform Process Challenges:

    Consensus and Negotiation: Achieving consensus on UNSC reform is challenging due to differing national interests and priorities. The reform process requires the agreement of the current permanent members, who may be resistant to changing the status quo.
    Regional Representation: There is debate over how to ensure equitable regional representation. Questions about the inclusion of new permanent members and the distribution of veto power remain contentious.
    Political and Geopolitical Dynamics: The global political landscape is complex, with shifting alliances and emerging powers influencing the debate. The strategic interests of current permanent members and major powers play a significant role in the reform discussions.
    4. Opportunities:

    Increased Support: Growing global recognition of India’s economic and strategic importance provides an opportunity to garner more support for its UNSC bid. India’s role in peacekeeping, economic development, and climate action is increasingly acknowledged.
    Global Governance Trends: There is a broader trend towards reforming international institutions to better reflect current global realities. This trend may create a conducive environment for advancing discussions on UNSC reform.
    Diplomatic Engagement: India’s diplomatic efforts, including strategic partnerships and active participation in global forums, can enhance its position and influence in the reform process.
    Conclusion
    The role of the UN in global governance is evolving as it adapts to contemporary challenges and opportunities. The debate over UNSC reform, including India’s pursuit of a permanent seat, highlights the need for a more representative and effective global governance structure.

    Key Points:

    Challenges: The reform process faces hurdles such as achieving consensus, addressing regional representation, and navigating geopolitical dynamics.
    Opportunities: India’s growing global influence and the broader trend towards reform present opportunities for advancing the debate on UNSC expansion.
    India’s ongoing efforts to secure a permanent UNSC seat reflect its aspirations to play a more prominent role in global governance and contribute to shaping a more inclusive and effective international system.

    See less
Pranay Chopra
  • 0
Pranay ChopraBegginer
Asked: July 16, 2024In:
  • 0

Examine how the International Court of Justice (ICJ) has assisted India in settling maritime and territorial issues with its neighbors, including the Pakistani case of Kulbhushan Jadhav. Describe how India’s foreign policy is impacted by international legal systems.

upsc: important international institutions
  1. Shree Shree Singh
    Shree Shree Singh Begginer

    The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has played a crucial role in resolving India's territorial and maritime disputes with its neighbors. One notable example is the Kulbhushan Jadhav case with Pakistan. **Kulbhushan Jadhav case:** 1. **Background:** Kulbhushan Jadhav, an Indian naval officer, waRead more

    The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has played a crucial role in resolving India’s territorial and maritime disputes with its neighbors. One notable example is the Kulbhushan Jadhav case with Pakistan.

    **Kulbhushan Jadhav case:**

    1. **Background:** Kulbhushan Jadhav, an Indian naval officer, was arrested by Pakistan in 2016 and sentenced to death for espionage and terrorism. India contested the detention, claiming it was arbitrary and violating international law.
    2. **ICJ intervention:** India approached the ICJ, requesting a stay on Jadhav’s execution and seeking his release. The ICJ issued an interim order, staying the execution and asking Pakistan to maintain Jadhav’s status quo until the court made a final decision.
    3. **Final decision:** In 2017, the ICJ ruled that Pakistan had violated the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations by not informing India about Jadhav’s detention and denying him consular access. The court ordered Pakistan to release Jadhav or provide adequate guarantees for his safety and well-being.

    **Significance of international legal frameworks in India’s foreign policy:**

    1. **Compliance with international law:** India recognizes the importance of adhering to international law in resolving disputes with its neighbors. The ICJ’s decision in the Jadhav case underscores India’s commitment to upholding international law and promoting peaceful dispute resolution.
    2. **Deterrence and deterrence diplomacy:** By approaching the ICJ, India demonstrated its willingness to use international legal frameworks to deter Pakistan from taking actions that violate international law. This approach sends a message to other countries that India will vigorously defend its interests and nationals through legal means.
    3. **Enhancing diplomatic leverage:** The ICJ’s involvement in the Jadhav case helped India to gain diplomatic leverage over Pakistan, as the court’s ruling put pressure on Pakistan to comply with its obligations under international law.
    4. **Promoting regional stability:** By pursuing legal remedies through the ICJ, India can help promote regional stability by reducing tensions and avoiding military escalation in conflicts with neighboring countries.

    **Other cases:**

    1. **Indus Waters Treaty:** India has been locked in a dispute with Pakistan over the Indus Waters Treaty, which governs water sharing between the two countries. India has approached the World Bank-mediated arbitration process to resolve the dispute.
    2. **China-India border disputes:** India has raised concerns about China’s activities along their shared border, including construction of infrastructure and troop deployments. India has sought international support, including from the United Nations, to resolve these disputes peacefully.
    3. **Maritime boundary disputes:** India has disputes with countries like Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and Myanmar over maritime boundaries. India has sought to resolve these disputes through bilateral negotiations and international arbitration mechanisms.

    In conclusion, the ICJ plays a vital role in resolving India’s territorial and maritime disputes with its neighbors. The significance of international legal frameworks in India’s foreign policy lies in promoting compliance with international law, deterring aggressive actions, enhancing diplomatic leverage, and promoting regional stability. By engaging with international legal mechanisms, India can effectively address its disputes and protect its interests while upholding its commitments to international law and diplomacy.

    See less
Pranay Chopra
  • 0
Pranay ChopraBegginer
Asked: July 16, 2024In:
  • 0

Analyze how the World Trade Organization (WTO) affects India’s participation in the international economy and trade policies. Talk about India’s stances on important WTO framework issues like intellectual property rights, agricultural subsidies, and the dispute resolution process.

upsc: important international institutions
  1. Varun Nayak
    Varun Nayak Begginer

    The World Trade Organization (WTO) plays a significant role in shaping India’s trade policies and its engagement with the global economy. As a member of the WTO since 1995, India has been involved in various negotiations and disputes, influencing its trade strategies and international economic relatRead more

    The World Trade Organization (WTO) plays a significant role in shaping India’s trade policies and its engagement with the global economy. As a member of the WTO since 1995, India has been involved in various negotiations and disputes, influencing its trade strategies and international economic relations. Here’s an examination of the WTO’s influence on India, focusing on key issues such as agricultural subsidies, intellectual property rights, and the dispute settlement mechanism.

    Influence of WTO on India’s Trade Policies
    1. Trade Policy Framework:

    Regulatory Compliance: The WTO provides a structured framework for India’s trade policies, ensuring compliance with global trade rules and agreements. This includes adhering to tariff commitments, trade barriers, and transparency requirements.
    Market Access: The WTO’s rules on market access and non-discrimination impact India’s trade relations by promoting a level playing field and reducing trade barriers. India benefits from preferential access to international markets and is also required to offer similar access to other member countries.
    2. Trade Negotiations:

    Multilateral Negotiations: India actively participates in WTO negotiations, aiming to shape global trade policies and secure favorable terms for its economy. Negotiations cover various aspects, including trade liberalization, agricultural policies, and services.
    Bilateral and Regional Trade Agreements: WTO membership influences India’s approach to bilateral and regional trade agreements, often aligning them with broader multilateral commitments while seeking to address specific interests.
    Key Issues within the WTO Framework
    1. Agricultural Subsidies:

    India’s Position: India has been vocal about protecting its agricultural sector from international competition. Agricultural subsidies are crucial for supporting small farmers and ensuring food security. India argues that the WTO’s rules on subsidies disadvantage developing countries by limiting their ability to provide support to their farmers.
    Negotiations and Disputes: India has sought more flexibility in subsidy rules and has advocated for policies that consider the needs of developing countries. The WTO’s Agreement on Agriculture (AoA) and the Doha Development Round discussions have been platforms for India to push for reforms and better terms.
    2. Intellectual Property Rights (IPR):

    India’s Position: India has been cautious about the impacts of WTO’s Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement on its domestic industries and access to medicines. While recognizing the need for intellectual property protection, India advocates for a balance that does not undermine public health and access to affordable medicines.
    TRIPS Flexibilities: India has utilized TRIPS flexibilities, such as compulsory licensing, to ensure access to essential medicines. The country supports the continuation of these flexibilities to protect public health while complying with global IPR standards.
    3. Dispute Settlement Mechanism:

    India’s Experience: India has engaged with the WTO’s Dispute Settlement Mechanism (DSM) to address trade grievances and resolve disputes with other member countries. The DSM provides a formal process for resolving trade conflicts and enforcing WTO rules.
    Challenges and Criticisms: India has occasionally criticized the DSM’s effectiveness and transparency, particularly in cases where it perceives unfair rulings or bias. The effectiveness of the DSM in addressing complex trade issues and providing equitable solutions remains a point of contention.
    Influence on India’s Global Economic Engagement
    1. Economic Integration:

    Global Trade Relations: WTO membership has facilitated India’s integration into the global economy by providing a platform for engagement with international markets and trading partners. India benefits from the rules-based trading system and has access to a broader range of global markets.
    Investment and Trade Growth: The stability and predictability provided by WTO rules contribute to increased foreign direct investment (FDI) and trade growth. India’s economic reforms and liberalization have been aligned with WTO commitments, promoting economic development.
    2. Policy Alignment and Reform:

    Trade Policy Reforms: India’s trade policies have been influenced by WTO agreements and negotiations, leading to various reforms in tariff structures, trade facilitation measures, and regulatory practices. Compliance with WTO rules has necessitated policy adjustments and modernization efforts.
    Balancing Interests: India’s engagement with the WTO involves balancing its domestic interests with global commitments. The country strives to protect its economic priorities while adhering to international trade rules and promoting its trade and development objectives.
    Suggestions for Improving India’s WTO Engagement
    1. Strengthening Negotiation Strategies:

    Enhanced Representation: India should continue to strengthen its negotiation strategies and build alliances with other developing countries to advance its interests within the WTO framework.
    Strategic Prioritization: Focus on key issues, such as agricultural subsidies and IPR, and seek more flexible and equitable solutions that align with India’s development goals and domestic needs.
    2. Improving Dispute Resolution:

    Engagement with DSM: Actively engage with the WTO’s Dispute Settlement Mechanism to address grievances and ensure fair and transparent dispute resolution. Work towards improving the effectiveness and efficiency of the DSM.
    Capacity Building: Invest in capacity building for trade negotiation and dispute resolution to enhance India’s ability to effectively address trade issues and represent its interests.
    3. Leveraging WTO Membership:

    Utilizing Trade Opportunities: Fully leverage WTO membership to access global markets, attract investment, and promote trade growth. Align domestic policies with international trade standards to maximize benefits.
    Promoting Development Goals: Advocate for reforms and policies within the WTO that support development goals and address the specific needs of developing countries.
    Conclusion
    The World Trade Organization (WTO) has a profound influence on India’s trade policies and its engagement with the global economy. India’s positions on agricultural subsidies, intellectual property rights, and the dispute settlement mechanism reflect its efforts to balance domestic interests with international commitments.

    Opportunities for improving India’s engagement with the WTO include strengthening negotiation strategies, enhancing dispute resolution processes, and leveraging WTO membership to promote economic growth and development. Challenges involve addressing contentious issues, ensuring fair dispute resolution, and balancing global commitments with national priorities.

    A strategic and proactive approach will be essential for India to effectively navigate the complexities of the WTO framework and achieve its trade and development objectives.

    See less
Sujata Gautam
  • 0
Sujata GautamBegginer
Asked: July 16, 2024In:
  • 0

Examine India’s stances on major environmental issues as well as its involvement in international organizations that promote sustainable development, such as the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) and the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP).

upsc: important international institutions
  1. Suman Rajput
    Suman Rajput Begginer

    India has been an active participant in international organizations focused on sustainable development, particularly the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). Here's an analysis of India's participation and positions on global enviRead more

    India has been an active participant in international organizations focused on sustainable development, particularly the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). Here’s an analysis of India’s participation and positions on global environmental challenges:

    **United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP):**

    1. **Participation:** India has been a member of UNEP since 1973 and has actively participated in its meetings, conferences, and programs.
    2. **Climate change:** India has been a strong advocate for global action on climate change, emphasizing the need for sustainable development and equity.
    3. **Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs):** India has supported the SDGs, particularly SDG 12 (Responsible Consumption and Production) and SDG 13 (Climate Action).
    4. **Biodiversity conservation:** India has contributed to efforts to conserve biodiversity, including the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) and the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD).

    **International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN):**

    1. **Participation:** India is a member of IUCN and has participated in its World Conservation Congress, commissions, and regional offices.
    2. **Biodiversity conservation:** India has supported IUCN’s efforts to conserve biodiversity, including the development of national conservation plans and species recovery programs.
    3. **Protected areas:** India has established a network of protected areas, including national parks, wildlife sanctuaries, and biosphere reserves, which are recognized by IUCN.
    4. **Sustainable development:** India has emphasized the need for sustainable development that balances economic growth with environmental protection and social equity.

    **Positions on global environmental challenges:**

    1. **Climate change:** India has called for urgent action to address climate change, emphasizing the need for developed countries to reduce their emissions and provide climate finance to developing countries.
    2. **Biodiversity loss:** India has highlighted the importance of conserving biodiversity, recognizing that it is essential for human well-being and sustainable development.
    3. **Environmental degradation:** India has expressed concern about environmental degradation, particularly air and water pollution, and has called for increased international cooperation to address these issues.
    4. **Disaster risk reduction:** India has emphasized the need for disaster risk reduction and management, recognizing that disasters can have severe environmental, social, and economic impacts.

    **Challenges and opportunities:**

    1. **Implementation gaps:** India faces implementation gaps in translating its commitments into concrete actions, particularly in terms of reducing emissions and conserving biodiversity.
    2. **Capacity building:** India needs to build capacity in areas like climate resilience, sustainable infrastructure development, and environmental governance.
    3. **International cooperation:** India recognizes the importance of international cooperation to address global environmental challenges but needs to strengthen its partnerships with other countries to achieve shared goals.

    In conclusion, India has been an active participant in international organizations focused on sustainable development, particularly UNEP and IUCN. Its positions on global environmental challenges reflect its commitment to sustainable development, biodiversity conservation, and climate action. However, implementation gaps and capacity-building needs remain significant challenges that require attention from both the government and civil society stakeholders.

    See less
Mamta Rani
  • 0
Mamta RaniLearner
Asked: June 18, 2024In:
  • 0

Since SAARC projects aren’t progressing as planned, BIMSTEC could be a dynamic substitute venue for South and South-East Asian regional organization. Talk about it.(250 words)

upsc: important international institutions
  1. Bhavesh singh
    Bhavesh singh Begginer

    Answer: In this dynamic world, India has focussed on a foreign policy, which incorporates a smooth conduct of regional relationships through multilateral partnerships enabling mutual cooperation and growth. South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC), as an organisation, reflects the SoRead more

    Answer: In this dynamic world, India has focussed on a foreign policy, which incorporates a smooth conduct of regional relationships through multilateral partnerships enabling mutual cooperation and growth. South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC), as an organisation, reflects the South Asian geographical identity of the countries. However, since its inception in 1985, various initiatives within the SAARC are not moving forward in the desired direction due to various reasons, including:

    • Pakistan’s non-cooperation: This has stalled some major initiatives under SAARC such as the SAARC-Motor Vehicles Agreement (MVA) and SAARC satellite project (replaced with BBIN-MVA and South Asia satellite respectively).
    • Asymmetry between India and other member countries: The other South Asian countries perceive India as the “big brother” and have been reluctant to implement various agreements under SAARC.
    • Lack of trade: Despite South Asia Free Trade Agreement coming into effect, intra-regional trade is around 5%, compared to the ASEAN region where intra-regional trade makes up around 25% as per the World Bank.
    • Shortage of resources: SAARC faces a shortage of resources as member countries have been reluctant to increase their contributions.
    • Security cooperation: SAARC does not have any arrangement for resolving disputes or mediating conflicts. There is also a lack of consensus on threat perceptions. For instance, while cross-border terrorism emanating from Pakistan is a major concern for India, Pakistan has failed to address these concerns.
    • Postponement/cancellation of annual summits: Annual SAARC summits have been postponed more than 10 times for political reasons, either bilateral or internal. In 2021, a meeting of foreign ministers from the SAARC countries was cancelled after most member states refused to entertain Pakistan’s request to allow the Taliban regime to represent Afghanistan in the meeting.

    In view of this, it is argued that Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation (BIMSTEC) can be a better alternative forum for regional cooperation due to following reasons:

    • Geo-economic significance: The Bay of Bengal region covered by BIMSTEC is home to around 23% of the world population and its collective economy accounts for 4% of the global GDP.
    • Devoid of Pakistan: Negotiations at the SAARC are ineffective due to strains in India’s relations with Pakistan, thus, India is looking for a parallel platform which would be devoid of Pakistan.
    • Convergence of Neighbourhood First and Act East Policy: BIMSTEC acts as a bridge between South Asia and South-East Asia. It has also emerged as a platform to realize India’s Neighbourhood First Policy and Act East Policy.
    • Realising India’s blue economy potential: BIMSTEC is significant due to its regional integration and maritime security where India can also realize its ‘blue economy’ ambitions.
    • Countering China: With China’s aggressive stance in various areas, BIMSTEC helps India counter China multilaterally. This requires economic, political, security and maritime cooperation that is enabled through this organization.
    • Shared regional influence: It includes two influential regional powers i.e. Thailand and India, which reduces the fear of dominance by one power.

    SAARC and BIMSTEC focus on geographically overlapping regions. However, this does not make them equal alternatives. SAARC is a purely regional organisation, whereas BIMSTEC is an inter- regional organization. They complement each other in terms of functions and goals. BIMSTEC provides SAARC countries a unique opportunity to connect with ASEAN. Further, the success of BIMSTEC does not render SAARC redundant, it adds a new chapter in regional cooperation in South Asia.

    See less
Umesh Singh
  • 0
Umesh SinghBegginer
Asked: June 13, 2024In:
  • 0

List the duties performed by the UN Human Rights Council. Talk about the challenges the Council faces in advancing and defending human rights worldwide.(150 words)

upsc: important international institutions
  1. Tina Singh
    Tina Singh Begginer

    Answer: The Human Rights Council is an inter-governmental body within the United Nations system and is made up of 47 United Nations Member States, which are elected by the UN General Assembly. It meets at the UN Office at Geneva. Functions of the United Nations Human Rights Council: It is responsiblRead more

    Answer: The Human Rights Council is an inter-governmental body within the United Nations system and is made up of 47 United Nations Member States, which are elected by the UN General Assembly. It meets at the UN Office at Geneva. Functions of the United Nations Human Rights Council:

    • It is responsible for promoting universal respect for the protection of all human rights and fundamental freedoms for all. It has the ability to discuss all thematic human rights issues and situations that require its attention throughout the year.
    • It aims to prevent and combat human rights violations, including gross and systematic violations, and to make recommendations thereon.
    • It also works to promote and coordinate the mainstreaming of human rights within the UN system.
    • The Council serves as a forum for dialogue among States, with input from other stakeholders like NGOs etc. Through dialogue and cooperation, it contributes towards the prevention of human rights violations and responds promptly to human rights emergencies.

    However, while performing these functions, following are the hurdles faced by the Council in promotion and protection of human rights around the globe:

    • Vague membership criteria: It requires candidates to commit to the highest standards of human rights, and states should take into account a nominee’s human rights record when voting. Both of these rules are basically unenforceable. Also, the “measurement” and respective ranking of human rights records across states is contentious.
    • Issues in Council elections: In some elections, there is lack of competitiveness. Countries have run unopposed after regional groups nominated the exact number of countries required to fill Council vacancies.
      • Also, the Council’s closed ballot elections make it easier for countries with questionable human rights records to be elected to the Council.
    • Prone to politicization: States generally vote in favour of their national interests rather than human rights interests if the two should clash. Thus, the Council remains prone to politicization, as evidenced by decisions that privilege political interests over human rights protection.
    • Reprisals against human rights defenders: NGO representatives invited to speak at the Council are too often interrupted with harassing points of order from repressive delegations.
    • Others:
      • The submissions and statements of governments perceived to be human rights abusers are taken at face value rather than being challenged.
      • Many experts have also expressed concern regarding some member states’ rejection of Universal Periodic Review (UPR) recommendations and nonparticipation in the UPR process.

    Thus, there is need to undertake various measures such as open ballots in Council elections, lowering the two-thirds vote threshold to make it easier to remove a Council member, strengthening UPR mechanism of the UNHRC. Moreover, any state found to be responsible for reprisals against human rights defenders, and which fails to rectify them, should be disqualified from sitting on the Council.

    See less
Kalpna Mehara
  • 1
Kalpna MeharaLearner
Asked: June 8, 2024In:
  • 1

For UN Peacekeeping to continue serving its intended purpose, adjustments are necessary. Talk about the difficulties the UN Peacekeeping is facing in this situation. Additionally, recommend changes to enhance how it operates. (Answer in 150 words)

upsc: important international institutions
  1. Mansi Gautam
    Mansi Gautam Learner

    Answer: North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) is the largest military alliance on the planet. It was established in 1949 as a bulwark against the Soviet armies after the Second World War. It guarantees the freedom and security of its members through political as well as military means. Born fromRead more

    Answer: North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) is the largest military alliance on the planet. It was established in 1949 as a bulwark against the Soviet armies after the Second World War. It guarantees the freedom and security of its members through political as well as military means. Born from a desire for collective defence and containment of the USSR, its mandate post Cold War morphed to include nation-building, peace-keeping, military-civil relations and the never-ending fight against terrorism and organised crime, with varying degrees of success. Since then, NATO has been struggling to remain relevant and faces challenges in redefining its role:

    • Failures of NATO: The notion of collective security has receded in the background post USSR era. However, it needs to be re-invigorated. For instance, the 2014 bloodless assimilation of Crimea into Russia and recent invasion of Ukraine by Russia have sent shockwaves, especially amongst Russia’s neighbours.
    • Shift in focus of collective security from within Europe towards east: The old East-West partitions have become a thing of the past and new fault lines dividing the increasingly worried Baltic States and Poland from a resurgent Russia, have emerged.
    • NATO has always been a fractious alliance: The attempts to consider the national wants and needs of all its member states at times seem to be an impossible task. For instance, France left NATO in 1966, only to return, under certain conditions, decades later in 2009.
    • Differences within NATO: Turkey, a vital member of the Alliance, has recently involved itself in conflicts on its doorstep in Syria and as far away as Libya. In these civil wars, NATO members have at times found themselves on opposing sides.
    • Issue of economic burden sharing: Failure to share the costs of NATO operations more equitably pose risks of unravelling of the alliance as the issue of “burden sharing” has been revived.

    Throughout history, military alliances have formed to balance the countervailing power. They have collapsed when the need for a balance disappeared as a result of either power crumbling or changing threat perceptions. However, the collapse of Soviet imperial rule in the late 1980s did not lead to NATO’s demise rather it has evolved, Le.:

    • Maintain strategic balance: Post Cold War, NATO identified the need to “preserve the strategic balance in Europe” and adopted it as one of its fundamental security tasks. Under this, it would provide security to democratizing countries, solidifying their transitions from communism and opening new economic prosperity through greater connections with the European Union.
    • Reconceived as a “cooperative-security” organization: Under this, NATO has two main objectives, Le., to foster dialogue and cooperation with former adversaries in the Warsaw Pact and to “manage” conflicts in areas on the European periphery, such as the Balkans.
    • Pluralistic security community: NATO grew from being a military alliance principally dedicated to protecting its members into institutional expression of the transatlantic community of states and the western values that both defined and united them. Further, the NATO grew into a pluralistic security community where use of force for settling disputes among its members has been ruled out.
    • Redefined its missions: Politically, NATO has sought new missions to retain its relevance from peacekeeping to countering the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction (WMD) to counter-terrorism etc. While on the military side, it has streamlined and created a more flexible command structure capable of deploying military forces rapidly and over greater distances than was the case during the cold war.

    Thus, post Cold War, the NATO has not only survived but been transformed into a politico-military entity. NATO of today is a confluence of like-minded democratic ideals and of shared values. The world order has changed and it is in this climate that NATO now has to operate. Unlike the Cold War era, with one clearly defined adversary, today there is a need to fight a patchwork of local conflicts while maintaining an ever-growing alliance between countries.

    See less
Load More Questions

Resources & Suggestions

Mains Answer Writing Latest Articles

On: February 24, 2025

Daily Answer Writing Practice Questions (24 February 2025)

The rise of the work-from-home culture has brought about several ethical issues in private organizations. In this context, do you believe it is ethical for an employee to engage in moonlighting? Discuss. (Answer in 150 words) घर से काम करने ...

On: February 22, 2025 Comments: 0

Indo-US Relation: Areas of Cooperation & Conflicts

Key Areas: Defense, technology, trade, energy, and regional cooperation. Key Areas of Cooperation 1. Defense and Security Transition from buyer-seller to co-production and technology sharing. India as a Major Defense Partner (MDP) and inclusion in STA-1. Access to advanced technologies, ...

On: February 22, 2025 Comments: 0

भारत-अमेरिका संबंध: सहयोग और संघर्ष के क्षेत्र

मुख्य विषय: भारत-अमेरिका संबंधों की मजबूती, विशेषकर रक्षा, प्रौद्योगिकी और क्षेत्रीय सहयोग में प्रगति। सहयोग के प्रमुख क्षेत्र 1. रक्षा एवं सुरक्षा सहयोग भारत और अमेरिका के बीच रक्षा संबंधों का विस्तार। प्रमुख रक्षा साझेदार (MDP) का दर्जा और STA-1 ...

Explore Our Blog