Home/upsc: farm subsidies & food security
- Recent Questions
- Most Answered
- Answers
- No Answers
- Most Visited
- Most Voted
- Random
- Bump Question
- New Questions
- Sticky Questions
- Polls
- Followed Questions
- Favorite Questions
- Recent Questions With Time
- Most Answered With Time
- Answers With Time
- No Answers With Time
- Most Visited With Time
- Most Voted With Time
- Random With Time
- Bump Question With Time
- New Questions With Time
- Sticky Questions With Time
- Polls With Time
- Followed Questions With Time
- Favorite Questions With Time
Discuss the importance of the fisheries sector in contributing to food security, livelihoods, and economic development. Additionally, examine the concerns surrounding the fisheries subsidies agreement under negotiation at the World Trade Organization. (150 words)
Model Answer Introduction India is the world’s third-largest fish producer, and the fisheries sector plays a crucial role in the country’s food security, livelihoods, and economic development. Over 14 million people are employed in this sector, contributing significantly to India’s economy. However,Read more
Model Answer
Introduction
India is the world’s third-largest fish producer, and the fisheries sector plays a crucial role in the country’s food security, livelihoods, and economic development. Over 14 million people are employed in this sector, contributing significantly to India’s economy. However, there are growing concerns about the fisheries subsidies agreement currently being negotiated at the World Trade Organization (WTO), which could have implications for India’s fisheries sector.
Importance of the Fisheries Sector
1. Food Security
2. Livelihoods
3. Economic Growth
Concerns Regarding the WTO Fisheries Subsidies Pact
While the fisheries subsidies agreement seeks to address overfishing and sustainable fishing practices, it raises several concerns for India’s fisheries sector:
1. Prohibition on Research and Development (R&D) Subsidies
2. Potential Job Losses
3. Competitiveness Issues
4. Market Disruptions
5. Limited Access to Resources
6. Unequal Impact on India
- Critics argue that the agreement disproportionately affects countries like India, which have smaller fisheries subsidies compared to developed nations. It does not adequately address the overfishing and overcapacity problems caused by advanced fishing nations that have historically provided large subsidies.
See lessHow do subsidies influence farmers' decisions on cropping patterns and crop diversity? Provide examples to illustrate. (150 words)
Model Answer Introduction Agricultural subsidies are financial aids provided by governments to encourage specific agricultural practices, enhance production, and support the livelihoods of farmers. These subsidies can significantly influence the choices farmers make regarding which crops to grow andRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Agricultural subsidies are financial aids provided by governments to encourage specific agricultural practices, enhance production, and support the livelihoods of farmers. These subsidies can significantly influence the choices farmers make regarding which crops to grow and how diverse their cropping patterns are. While subsidies are designed to ensure food security and stabilize income, they also have complex effects on crop diversity.
How Subsidies Influence Cropping Patterns and Crop Diversity
Positive Impacts:
Subsidies for key crops like rice and wheat in India have contributed to higher production levels, which in turn improve food security. For example, the Minimum Support Price (MSP) for wheat and rice ensures that farmers are guaranteed a fixed price, encouraging them to grow these crops.
Subsidies provide financial stability to farmers, especially during periods of market price fluctuations. The MSP system, for instance, helps farmers by ensuring they receive a minimum price, which protects them against low market prices.
Some subsidies help reduce the risks associated with farming by offering financial support for risky ventures. For example, subsidies on crop insurance premiums enable farmers to protect their crops against unforeseen events like droughts or pest infestations, encouraging them to diversify into higher-risk, potentially higher-reward crops.
Certain subsidies encourage farmers to adopt crop rotation or mixed cropping practices. For example, subsidies for micro-irrigation promote the efficient use of water throughout the year, making it easier for farmers to rotate crops or grow a variety of crops, enhancing diversity in agricultural production.
Programs like PM-KISAN, which provide direct income support to farmers, allow them to experiment with different crops and adapt to changing market conditions. This financial cushion allows them to explore diverse cropping options without fearing financial ruin.
Negative Impacts:
- Promotion of Monoculture:
- Neglect of Non-Subsidized Crops:
- Overuse of Inputs:
- Market Distortions:
- Environmental Concerns:
See lessWhile subsidies aim to ensure food security, they often target specific crops, which may lead to monoculture practices. In India, for example, rice and wheat, which receive heavy subsidies, occupy nearly 42% of the total cropped area. This over-reliance on a few crops can reduce biodiversity and make farmers vulnerable to market price changes.
The emphasis on subsidized crops often leads to a neglect of non-subsidized or traditional crops. This can result in a reduction in the variety of crops grown in a region, as farmers focus on growing the subsidized crops that offer guaranteed financial returns.
Input subsidies, such as those on fertilizers and pesticides, encourage excessive use of these chemicals, which can have negative environmental impacts. In Punjab, India, for example, the Green Revolution, which relied heavily on subsidized fertilizers and irrigation, resulted in ecological imbalances, such as water depletion and soil degradation.
Subsidies can distort domestic markets by making certain crops artificially more profitable than others. This can lead to inefficient cropping decisions and market imbalances. For example, the subsidy-driven focus on wheat and rice has sometimes reduced the incentive for farmers to grow other essential but non-subsidized crops, such as pulses or oilseeds.
Some subsidies promote practices that lead to environmental degradation. The MSP for rice, for instance, encourages excessive water use, especially in water-scarce regions like Punjab, leading to falling groundwater levels and environmental strain.
What role does the 'One Nation-One Ration Card' scheme play in ensuring food security for vulnerable populations in India, and what challenges need to be addressed for its successful implementation?
Model Answer The 'One Nation-One Ration Card' (ONORC) scheme plays a crucial role in ensuring food security for vulnerable populations in India by improving the portability and efficiency of the Public Distribution System (PDS). Role of ONORC in Ensuring Food Security Portability of PDS Benefits: ONRead more
Model Answer
The ‘One Nation-One Ration Card’ (ONORC) scheme plays a crucial role in ensuring food security for vulnerable populations in India by improving the portability and efficiency of the Public Distribution System (PDS).
Role of ONORC in Ensuring Food Security
Portability of PDS Benefits: ONORC allows over 67 million migrant households to access PDS benefits at any Fair Price Shop (FPS) across the country. This is especially beneficial for migrant workers and their families, who often face difficulty in accessing food entitlements due to migration.
Elimination of Fake & Duplicate Ration Cards: The scheme uses Aadhaar-based biometric authentication, which significantly reduces fraud, duplicate cards, and leakages in the system. This ensures that the rations reach the intended beneficiaries.
Choice and Convenience: Beneficiaries can choose any FPS that suits them, enabling them to avoid corrupt or inefficient dealers. This gives families flexibility and ensures that they can access their entitlements easily.
Mera Ration App: The mobile application allows beneficiaries to register online, check their entitlements, locate nearby FPSs, and verify their Aadhaar seeding status, improving accessibility and transparency.
Challenges to Successful Implementation
Lack of Awareness: Despite the benefits, 20% of eligible households did not know they could use the portability feature. This lack of awareness hampers the full potential of ONORC.
Technical Issues: The scheme relies heavily on technology, and problems like poor internet connectivity, device failure, and glitches in biometric authentication can cause inconvenience. 57% of dealers reported issues like poor connectivity, leading to refusal of service.
Supply Chain Challenges: 32% of PDS dealers reported stockouts, as the portability feature leads to an unpredictable demand at FPSs. This creates challenges in managing the supply of food grains.
Under-coverage and Aadhaar Seeding Issues: The 2011 census for NFSA eligibility excludes many low-income households, while problems with Aadhaar seeding (such as name mismatches) prevent some individuals, especially divorced women, from accessing their rations.
To achieve SDG 2 (Zero Hunger) by 2030, overcoming these challenges is crucial for ensuring the success of ONORC and securing food access for vulnerable populations.
See lessWhat are the direct and indirect subsidies provided to farm sector in India? Discuss the issues raised by the World Trade Organization (WTO) in relation to agricultural subsidies. (250 words) [UPSC 2023]
Direct and Indirect Subsidies Provided to the Farm Sector in India Direct Subsidies: Minimum Support Price (MSP): The MSP is a significant direct subsidy where the government guarantees a minimum price for certain crops to ensure farmers' income stability. For instance, in 2023, the MSP for wheat waRead more
Direct and Indirect Subsidies Provided to the Farm Sector in India
Direct Subsidies:
Indirect Subsidies:
Issues Raised by the World Trade Organization (WTO):
In summary, while subsidies play a crucial role in supporting the agricultural sector in India, they also raise significant concerns under WTO regulations, particularly regarding trade distortions and sustainability.
See lessWhat are the salient features of the National Food Security Act, of 2013? How has the Food Security Bill helped in eliminating hunger and malnutrition in India? (250 words) [UPSC 2021]
The National Food Security Act, 2013 aims to provide subsidized food grains to approximately two-third of the country’s population. The enactment of this landmark legislation, brought a paradigm shift in approach to food security, from welfare to rights-based approach. The salient features of the acRead more
The National Food Security Act, 2013 aims to provide subsidized food grains to approximately two-third of the country’s population. The enactment of this landmark legislation, brought a paradigm shift in approach to food security, from welfare to rights-based approach. The salient features of the act are as:
Role of NFSA in eliminating hunger and malnutrition:
However, there is still a long way for India to reach nutritional sufficiency as:
The food bill has revolutionized the access to food grains; however, the need is to move towards nutritional security and not just food security. Further the structural bottlenecks in the implementation food bill should be corrected by leverage of technology.
See lessDiscuss the role of farm subsidies in the context of the ongoing farmer protests and the demands for a comprehensive agricultural policy framework that addresses the concerns of various stakeholders, including farmers, consumers, and the environment.
Role of Farm Subsidies in the Context of Farmer Protests and Demands for Agricultural Policy Framework Introduction Farm subsidies are a crucial component of agricultural policy, designed to support farmers and stabilize agricultural markets. However, recent farmer protests in India have highlightedRead more
Role of Farm Subsidies in the Context of Farmer Protests and Demands for Agricultural Policy Framework
Introduction
Farm subsidies are a crucial component of agricultural policy, designed to support farmers and stabilize agricultural markets. However, recent farmer protests in India have highlighted significant concerns about the current subsidy regime and the need for a comprehensive agricultural policy framework. This discussion explores the role of farm subsidies within this context and examines how they intersect with the demands of various stakeholders, including farmers, consumers, and environmental advocates.
Role of Farm Subsidies in Agricultural Policy
Farmer Protests and Concerns
Demands for a Comprehensive Agricultural Policy Framework
Government Initiatives and Responses
Conclusion
Farm subsidies play a vital role in supporting agricultural production and farmer incomes but have also been a focal point in the recent farmer protests. Addressing the demands for a comprehensive agricultural policy framework requires balancing the interests of farmers, consumers, and the environment. This involves ensuring equitable subsidy distribution, legal guarantees for MSP, and promoting sustainable practices. Government initiatives are moving towards these goals, but ongoing engagement and policy adjustments will be crucial in achieving a fair and effective agricultural policy.
See lessAnalyze the distributional impacts of farm subsidies, and discuss the measures taken by the government to ensure the equitable access and distribution of these benefits, particularly among small and marginal farmers, and the landless agricultural workers.
Distributional Impacts of Farm Subsidies and Government Measures for Equitable Access Introduction Farm subsidies play a crucial role in supporting agricultural production and stabilizing incomes for farmers. However, the distributional impacts of these subsidies can vary significantly, affecting diRead more
Distributional Impacts of Farm Subsidies and Government Measures for Equitable Access
Introduction
Farm subsidies play a crucial role in supporting agricultural production and stabilizing incomes for farmers. However, the distributional impacts of these subsidies can vary significantly, affecting different segments of the farming community in diverse ways. This analysis explores how farm subsidies impact various groups, particularly small and marginal farmers and landless agricultural workers, and examines the measures taken by the Indian government to ensure equitable access to these benefits.
Distributional Impacts of Farm Subsidies
Government Measures for Equitable Access and Distribution
Conclusion
Farm subsidies have a significant impact on various segments of the farming community, with large farmers often benefiting more than their smaller counterparts. To address these disparities and ensure equitable distribution of benefits, the Indian government has implemented a range of targeted programs, infrastructure investments, and support systems. By focusing on direct income support, inclusive support mechanisms, and improved outreach and monitoring, these measures aim to better serve small and marginal farmers and landless agricultural workers, promoting a more equitable agricultural sector.
See lessEvaluate the implications of India's international trade obligations and commitments, such as the World Trade Organization (WTO) agreements, on the design and implementation of farm subsidy programs, and discuss the strategies adopted by the government to balance the interests of domestic producers and consumers with the requirements of the global trading system.
Implications of International Trade Obligations on India's Farm Subsidy Programs Introduction India's farm subsidy programs are significantly influenced by its international trade obligations, particularly those under the World Trade Organization (WTO) agreements. These obligations impact how IndiaRead more
Implications of International Trade Obligations on India’s Farm Subsidy Programs
Introduction
India’s farm subsidy programs are significantly influenced by its international trade obligations, particularly those under the World Trade Organization (WTO) agreements. These obligations impact how India designs and implements subsidies, aiming to balance domestic interests with global trade commitments. Understanding these implications requires examining WTO agreements, recent examples, and the strategies employed by the Indian government.
International Trade Obligations and Farm Subsidies
Implications for Farm Subsidy Design and Implementation
Strategies to Balance Domestic and Global Interests
Conclusion
India’s farm subsidy programs are intricately linked to its international trade obligations under the WTO agreements. The need to comply with these obligations necessitates careful design and implementation of subsidy policies to avoid trade distortions while supporting domestic producers and consumers. The Indian government has employed a range of strategies, including policy adjustments, negotiations for flexibility, and targeted support measures, to balance these competing interests effectively. Moving forward, continued adaptation and negotiation will be crucial in navigating the complexities of global trade and domestic agricultural needs.
See lessAssess the potential of alternative support mechanisms, such as direct income transfers, investment in agricultural infrastructure, and market-based risk management tools, in addressing the shortcomings of the current farm subsidy system and enhancing the overall welfare of farmers and consumers.
Potential of Alternative Support Mechanisms in Enhancing Farmer and Consumer Welfare As farm subsidy systems face criticism for inefficiencies and unintended consequences, alternative support mechanisms such as direct income transfers, investment in agricultural infrastructure, and market-based riskRead more
Potential of Alternative Support Mechanisms in Enhancing Farmer and Consumer Welfare
As farm subsidy systems face criticism for inefficiencies and unintended consequences, alternative support mechanisms such as direct income transfers, investment in agricultural infrastructure, and market-based risk management tools are being explored. These alternatives offer potential solutions to address the shortcomings of traditional subsidies and enhance the overall welfare of farmers and consumers.
1. Direct Income Transfers
Enhanced Targeting and Efficiency:
Direct income transfers offer a more targeted and efficient way of providing financial support to farmers. By providing cash transfers directly to eligible farmers, governments can reduce administrative overheads and target support more precisely. For example, India’s Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi (PM-KISAN) provides direct cash transfers to small and marginal farmers, which helps reduce dependency on subsidies and ensures that financial support reaches those in need.
Increased Financial Autonomy:
Direct income transfers provide farmers with the flexibility to use funds according to their needs, whether for purchasing inputs, investing in technology, or managing household expenses. This approach can enhance financial autonomy and reduce the reliance on specific input subsidies. For instance, Kenya’s Digital Farmers’ Payment System provides direct financial support to farmers, enabling them to make more informed decisions and invest in their agricultural operations.
Reduction of Market Distortions:
Unlike traditional subsidies that can distort market signals, direct income transfers do not interfere with market prices. This approach helps maintain market equilibrium and encourages farmers to respond to market demands. For example, Brazil’s Bolsa Família program, while not exclusively for farmers, demonstrates how direct income transfers can improve welfare without distorting agricultural markets.
2. Investment in Agricultural Infrastructure
Improved Productivity and Efficiency:
Investing in agricultural infrastructure, such as irrigation systems, rural roads, and storage facilities, can significantly enhance productivity and efficiency. Improved infrastructure reduces post-harvest losses, facilitates access to markets, and supports better crop management. For example, the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS) in India includes provisions for rural infrastructure development, which benefits farmers by improving access to resources and markets.
Support for Technological Advancements:
Infrastructure investment can also support technological advancements and innovation in agriculture. For instance, Israel’s investments in drip irrigation technology and water management systems have transformed its arid agricultural sector, leading to increased crop yields and water efficiency.
Facilitation of Market Access:
Better infrastructure helps farmers access larger and more diverse markets, improving their bargaining power and reducing transaction costs. For example, Ethiopia’s Agricultural Growth Program has focused on building rural roads and market infrastructure, which has improved farmers’ access to markets and increased their income.
3. Market-Based Risk Management Tools
Hedging Against Price Volatility:
Market-based risk management tools, such as futures contracts and crop insurance, help farmers hedge against price volatility and adverse weather conditions. India’s Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY) provides crop insurance to protect farmers from crop loss due to natural disasters, helping stabilize incomes and reduce financial risk.
Enhanced Risk Management:
These tools allow farmers to manage risks more effectively and make informed decisions based on market conditions. For example, US Commodity Futures Trading Commission offers futures contracts for agricultural commodities, enabling farmers to lock in prices and manage price risks.
Encouragement of Private Sector Involvement:
Market-based tools encourage private sector participation and innovation in risk management. For example, China’s Agricultural Reinsurance Program involves both public and private sectors in providing insurance coverage, increasing the availability and affordability of risk management products for farmers.
4. Comparative Analysis and Integration
Comparative Advantages:
Each alternative support mechanism has its strengths. Direct income transfers offer precise targeting and flexibility, infrastructure investments enhance productivity and market access, and market-based tools provide risk management. Combining these approaches can address the shortcomings of traditional subsidies and create a more comprehensive support system.
Integrated Approach:
Integrating direct income transfers with investments in infrastructure and market-based risk management tools can provide a balanced and effective support system. For example, India’s new agricultural reforms aim to integrate direct income support with infrastructure development and market reforms, addressing multiple aspects of agricultural support.
Conclusion
Alternative support mechanisms, such as direct income transfers, investment in agricultural infrastructure, and market-based risk management tools, offer potential solutions to the shortcomings of traditional farm subsidies. These approaches can enhance the overall welfare of farmers and consumers by improving financial efficiency, productivity, and risk management. Adopting an integrated approach that combines these mechanisms with traditional support systems can create a more robust and effective agricultural support framework, addressing the diverse needs of the agricultural sector and fostering sustainable development.
See lessDiscuss the role of farm subsidies in ensuring food security and price stability, and evaluate the alignment of these programs with the government's objectives of achieving self-sufficiency in food production and improving the affordability of essential commodities for consumers.
Role of Farm Subsidies in Ensuring Food Security and Price Stability Farm subsidies are a critical tool used by governments to support agricultural sectors, ensure food security, and stabilize prices. These subsidies impact food production, consumer prices, and overall economic stability in the agriRead more
Role of Farm Subsidies in Ensuring Food Security and Price Stability
Farm subsidies are a critical tool used by governments to support agricultural sectors, ensure food security, and stabilize prices. These subsidies impact food production, consumer prices, and overall economic stability in the agricultural sector. This discussion evaluates their role in achieving food security and price stability, and assesses how well these programs align with the government’s objectives of self-sufficiency and affordability.
1. Role of Farm Subsidies in Ensuring Food Security
Support for Agricultural Production:
Farm subsidies help stabilize agricultural production by providing financial support to farmers. This support can be crucial during adverse weather conditions or economic downturns, ensuring a steady supply of food. For instance, the United States has utilized subsidies through programs like the Farm Bill to support farmers growing essential crops like corn and soybeans, ensuring consistent food production and availability.
Boost to Crop Yields and Productivity:
Subsidies often promote the use of modern farming techniques and technology, which can enhance crop yields and productivity. In India, subsidies for fertilizers and seeds have contributed to increased agricultural productivity and higher crop yields, playing a significant role in meeting the country’s food needs.
Safety Nets for Farmers:
By providing income support and crop insurance, subsidies act as safety nets for farmers facing financial difficulties. For example, the India’s Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY) provides insurance coverage to farmers against crop losses due to natural calamities, ensuring financial stability and encouraging continued food production.
2. Role of Farm Subsidies in Price Stability
Mitigating Price Volatility:
Farm subsidies can help mitigate price volatility by stabilizing farmers’ incomes and production levels. By supporting farm incomes, subsidies reduce the impact of price fluctuations in global markets. For instance, the European Union’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) includes subsidies that stabilize farm incomes and support market prices for key agricultural products.
Control Over Market Prices:
Subsidies can be used to control market prices by influencing supply levels. For example, China has implemented subsidies to regulate the production of staples like rice and wheat, thereby maintaining stable prices and avoiding sudden price hikes that could affect consumer affordability.
3. Alignment with Government Objectives
Achieving Self-Sufficiency in Food Production:
Farm subsidies align with the goal of achieving self-sufficiency by promoting domestic production and reducing reliance on imports. India’s Green Revolution in the 1960s, supported by subsidies for fertilizers and irrigation, was instrumental in achieving self-sufficiency in staple grains like wheat and rice. Similarly, the US has used subsidies to maintain high levels of domestic production in key crops.
Improving Affordability of Essential Commodities:
While subsidies can lower production costs and stabilize prices, their impact on consumer affordability can vary. In India, subsidies on essential commodities like rice and wheat under the Public Distribution System (PDS) help keep prices affordable for low-income households. However, there have been concerns about the efficiency of the distribution system and potential leakages.
Balancing Subsidy Costs and Efficiency:
The alignment of subsidies with government objectives must also consider cost-effectiveness and efficiency. For instance, in Brazil, subsidies for biofuels aimed at reducing oil dependency have faced criticism for contributing to higher food prices and deforestation. Ensuring that subsidy programs are well-targeted and efficiently managed is crucial for balancing their benefits with potential trade-offs.
4. Recent Developments and Challenges
Focus on Sustainable Practices:
Recent policy shifts have aimed at making subsidies more aligned with sustainability goals. The EU’s CAP reform has increasingly emphasized environmental sustainability and rural development, integrating subsidies with practices that promote soil health, biodiversity, and climate resilience.
Addressing Over-reliance on Subsidies:
There is a growing recognition of the need to reduce over-reliance on subsidies and promote market-based solutions. For instance, India’s new agricultural reforms aim to create more market-friendly conditions and reduce dependency on subsidies, while still supporting farmers through targeted measures and infrastructure development.
Conclusion
Farm subsidies play a vital role in ensuring food security and price stability by supporting agricultural production, stabilizing farmers’ incomes, and controlling market prices. They align with government objectives of achieving self-sufficiency in food production and improving the affordability of essential commodities. However, the effectiveness of these programs depends on their design, implementation, and alignment with broader goals of sustainability and efficiency. Recent policy developments reflect a shift towards more sustainable and market-oriented approaches, balancing the benefits of subsidies with the need for efficient resource use and environmental stewardship.
See less