Answer the question in maximum 200 words. This question carries 11 marks. [MPPSC 2023] Talk about the financial side of state-federal ties while referencing the “One Nation, One Tax” policy.
Gross domestic product (GDP) is the total monetary or market value of all the finished goods and services produced within a country's borders in a specific time period, typically a year. GDP, by expenditure method, is calculated as: GDP = Private consumption (C) + Government spending (G) + InvestmenRead more
Gross domestic product (GDP) is the total monetary or market value of all the finished goods and services produced within a country’s borders in a specific time period, typically a year. GDP, by expenditure method, is calculated as: GDP = Private consumption (C) + Government spending (G) + Investment (1) + Exports (X) Imports (M).
- Payment of pensions to retired government employees: It is included in the GDP as it is a deferred wage. It is part of payment for factor services rendered by the recipients prior to their retirement. However, old age pension is not included in the GDP accounting as it constitutes transfer payments.
- Income from the sale of an old car: It is not included in the GDP since its value has already been included in the GDP of the year in which it was produced. Including it in the GDP will be equivalent to double counting. However, commission earned on the sale of the old car by agents will be included in GDP accounting of the current year.
- Interest on national debt: It is not included in the GDP as interest is paid upon the borrowing/loans taken by the government to fund its consumption expenditure and no productive activity is linked with such loans.
- Foodgrains produced by farmers for their own consumption: Foodgrains used for own consumption form a part of the private consumption. Producing foodgrains has an opportunity cost in terms of factors used for production. Equivalently, it would have generated income, had the same foodgrains been sold in the market. So, an imputed value of foodgrains used for own consumption is included in the GDP.
- Services provided by housewives: These are not included in the GDP because they constitute personal services rendered within the household or family. These services are not marketed and it is hard to assess monetary value of such personal services.
Thus, GDP is limited in the sense that it only measures the market value of final goods and services produced in an economy in a given period of time.
See less
The financial aspect of Centre-State relations in India has undergone significant changes with the implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST), also known as the "One Nation One Tax" regime. *Pre-GST Scenario:* 1. Multiple taxes: Central sales tax, state VAT, excise duty, etc. 2. Complex taxRead more
The financial aspect of Centre-State relations in India has undergone significant changes with the implementation of the Goods and Services Tax (GST), also known as the “One Nation One Tax” regime.
*Pre-GST Scenario:*
1. Multiple taxes: Central sales tax, state VAT, excise duty, etc.
2. Complex tax structure: Different tax rates, exemptions, and compliance requirements.
3. Revenue sharing: Centre and states shared taxes, with states receiving a significant portion.
*GST Regime (Post-2017):*
1. Unified tax: Single tax rate for goods and services across India.
2. Dual GST: Central GST (CGST) and State GST (SGST) components.
3. GST Council: Centre and states jointly decide tax rates, exemptions, and policies.
*Financial Implications:*
*Centre:*
1. Reduced revenue: GST rates lower than pre-GST taxes.
2. Compensation: Centre compensates states for revenue loss (5-year period).
*States:*
1. Increased autonomy: States have more control over taxation.
2. Revenue growth: GST revenue growth benefits states.
3. Dependence on Centre: States rely on Centre for compensation and GST Council decisions.
*Challenges:*
1. Revenue distribution: Disparities in revenue sharing between Centre and states.
2. Tax rate disputes: Differences in GST rates between Centre and states.
3. Compliance issues: Difficulty in implementing and enforcing GST.
*Benefits:*
1. Simplified tax structure
2. Reduced tax evasion
3. Increased transparency
4. Boost to economic growth
*Centre-State Relations:*
1. Cooperative federalism: GST Council promotes collaboration.
2. Increased dependence: States rely on Centre for revenue and policy decisions.
3. Potential conflicts: Disagreements over revenue sharing, tax rates, and exemptions.
*Reforms:*
1. Improve GST compensation mechanism
2. Enhance states’ autonomy in taxation
3. Streamline compliance procedures
4. Address revenue disparities
*Conclusion:*
The “One Nation One Tax” regime has transformed Centre-State financial relations in India. While challenges persist, the GST regime has simplified taxation, increased transparency, and boosted economic growth. Ongoing reforms aim to address revenue disparities, enhance state autonomy, and strengthen cooperative federalism.