Evolution of Civil Services

The Lee Commission officially known as the Royal Commission on the Superior Civil Services in India was established in 1923 to examine the composition and organization of the civil services in India. The commission’s report submitted in 1924 had significant implications for the reform of civil services in India.

Key Recommendations and significance –

1. The commission recommended increasing Indian representation in the civil services which led to more opportunities for Indians to join the services.
2. The commission emphasized the importance of merit based recruitment which helped to reduce patronage and nepotism in the civil services.
3. The commission recommended the reorganization of the civil services into three categories the All India Services, Central Services and Provincial Services.
4. The commission emphasized the need for training and development programs for civil servants to improve their efficiency and effectiveness.

Impact –

1. The commission’s recommendations led to an increase in Indian representation in the civil services which helped to reduce the dominance of British officials.
2. The commission’s emphasis on merit based recruitment and training and development programs helped to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the civil services.
3. The commission’s recommendations on the reorganization of services helped to clarify the roles and responsibilities of different categories of civil servants.

Overall the Lee Commission played a significant role in reforming the civil services in India by increasing Indian representation, improving efficiency and reorganizing the services. Its recommendations had a lasting impact on the development of the civil services in India.

The British education policies in India aimed to create a subservient bureaucracy. They introduced Western style education emphasizing English language and literature while neglecting traditional Indian education systems, promoting a colonial mindset and cultural assimilation.The British educational policies had a significant impact on the development of civil services in India i.e. both positive and negative.

Positive impacts –

1. The British introduced Western style education, which emphasized rational thinking, scientific inquiry and modern administrative practices.
2. The British established a merit-based system for recruitment to the civil services which helped to create a more efficient and effective bureaucracy.
3. The British expanded educational opportunities in India, establishing universities, colleges and schools that helped to increase the pool of educated Indians.

Negative impacts –

1. British educational policies were biased towards the elite classes , limiting access to education for the masses.
2. The British educational system promoted a colonial mindset emphasizing the superiority of Western culture and values over Indian ones.
3. The British neglected traditional Indian education systems such as the gurukul system which had provided education and training in Indian languages, literature and culture.
4. The British educational policies helped to create a subservient bureaucracy that was loyal to the British colonial government rather than to the Indian people.

The British educational policies had a lasting impact on the development of civil services in India. While they introduced modern Western education and established a merit based system, they also promoted a colonial mindset and neglected traditional Indian education systems. The legacy of these policies can still be seen in the Indian civil services today.