Home/Governance/Page 2
Governance
Governance refers to the processes, structures, and institutions through which a society or organization is directed, controlled, and held accountable.
Good governance principles include transparency, accountability, rule of law, efficiency, responsiveness, and inclusiveness. Effective governance at national, regional, and local levels is crucial for sustainable development, equitable service delivery, and protection of rights. It involves the interplay of the state, private sector, and civil society.
Share
What make fundamental rights different for Armed forces of India?
Although the Indian Constitution provides fundamental rights to all citizens, it allows certain restrictions on the rights of the members of the Armed Forces. This is primarily because of the nature of their service and the need to maintain discipline and national security. Article 33: This ARead more
Although the Indian Constitution provides fundamental rights to all citizens, it allows certain restrictions on the rights of the members of the Armed Forces. This is primarily because of the nature of their service and the need to maintain discipline and national security.
Article 33: This Article gives the Parliament power to restrict or abolish, as regards members of the Armed Forces, police forces and such force as may hereafter be created, any right conferred by this Part. Such provisions can provide for restrictions, for instance, right to form union or strike which is essential to maintain discipline and operational efficiency in the forces.
Discipline and National Security: The Armed Forces operate on a strict code of discipline and hierarchy. Restraints upon certain rights are considered necessary for swift and effective command, maintenance of morale, and national security. For example, the right to freedom of speech may be restricted not to allow sensitive information to be disclosed, which could have a detrimental impact on national security.
-Specialized Nature of Service: Armed forces require manning on more occasions in challenging and demanding environments involving risks and sacrifices of significant proportions. Some rights may be limited as justification toward ensuring safety and well-being of personnel and operational effectiveness.
See less‘Once a Speaker, Always a Speaker’ ! Do you think this practice should be adopted to impart objectivity to the office of the Speaker of Lok Sabha ? What could be its implications for the robust functioning of parliamentary business in India?
The "Once a Speaker, Always a Speaker" principle might have been designed to promote impartiality but may also prove a boon and a bane to efficient parliamentary business management in India. Advantages: It would highly increase the impartiality of the Speaker because there would be no chance of eveRead more
The “Once a Speaker, Always a Speaker” principle might have been designed to promote impartiality but may also prove a boon and a bane to efficient parliamentary business management in India.
Advantages:
It would highly increase the impartiality of the Speaker because there would be no chance of ever returning to active party politics and, hence, any perceived or actual biases that may result from future political ambitions.
Strengthen Democratic Norms: This convention would strengthen the non-partisan character of the office of the Speaker, hence improving the democratic process and further instilling confidence in the institution among the people.
Reduced Impact of Political Pressure: Since there is no hope of political benefits in the future, the Speaker may not be under so much pressure to make political decisions but rather make impartial ones.
It may be considered a limitation of the political career of someone holding the office of Speaker, thereby discouraging men and women of good standing from holding such an office.
-Potential Not to Join Party After Term Has Been Completed: The potential not to join their party once their term has been served would reduce the incentive for highly qualified people to seek the position of Speaker.
Detachment from Political Realities: A Speaker permanently disconnected in active politics may become disoriented from the dynamic political scenario and thus would not be able to efficiently preside over the business of parliament and understand the nuances of contemporary political oratory.
Constitutional Issues: It may even attract constitutional questions because it can breach one’s right to associate oneself or oneself with political activity.
Alternative approaches to the “Once a Speaker, Always a Speaker” principle can be utilized to neutralize the office of the Speaker as follows:
-Strengthening the existing norms and conventions: It could be in focusing on strengthening existing norms and conventions governing the office of the Speaker to be directed toward non-partisanship and impartiality.
-Public awareness of the importance of the Speaker’s neutrality as well as to the need of maintaining the office dignity.
See less-Policies on periodical and clear review of conduct of the Speaker so that judgment is perceived not to be arbitrary and concerns will be addressed.
Frequent transfers are a widespread issue within the higher civil service in India. Analyze the negative impacts of such transfers on civil servants and propose reforms to address this challenge.( 200 Words)
How Frequent Transfers Affects the Higher Civil Service in India and Proposed Changes Introduction Needless to say, frequent transfers have been a matter of perennial concern in the higher echelons of the civil service in India, with implications for efficiency, morale and continuity of governance.Read more
How Frequent Transfers Affects the Higher Civil Service in India and Proposed Changes
Introduction
Needless to say, frequent transfers have been a matter of perennial concern in the higher echelons of the civil service in India, with implications for efficiency, morale and continuity of governance. Although transfers are designed to facilitate accountability and to reduce opportunities for entrenchment, frequent transfers are detrimental to the civil officials as well as the public services they deliver. Here we analyze the pernicious effects of such transfers and offer reform suggestions to tackle this challenge to foster a more robust and effective civil service.
Frequent Transfer: The Costly Change of the Negative Impact
Disruption of Institutional Continuity: Regular transfers disrupt the continuity of institutional memory and expertise. Civil servants who are constantly rotated from one job to another cannot formulate long-term strategies or implement ongoing projects effectively. Such divergences in approach serve to foster a fragmented system of governance in which every new transfer is met with a new set of directives and objectives, resulting in a cookie-cutting approach to governance where prior initiatives and measures are abandoned.
Reduced Morale and Job Satisfaction: The eternal uncertainty of transfers can cast a long shadow on the morale and job satisfaction of civil servants. At the same time, this lack of job stability, along with the disruption in one’s personal life that comes from moving often, can make workers less inclined to perform well and stay motivated, leading to broad workplace stress and burnout. Civil servants too may be reluctant to give it their best, given that their time in one position is limited.
Greater Bureaucratic Inefficiency: Each transfer creates a time of adjustment and familiarization for the incoming officer. There is often a dip in productivity during this transition period while the new officer assimilates into the role, and the existing staff adjust to the new leadership. Such differences can slow down decision-making and implementation of policies, reducing the efficiency of the bureaucracy.
Stress on Family and Personal Life: For many civil servants, frequent transfers require uprooting their families and relocating repeatedly. This may lead to a serious burden on personal relationships and the physical and emotional well-being of family members, especially children who may have to change schools due to frequent relocation. This effect on family life can only add to the existing dissatisfaction of civil servants and lead to increased turnover and greater loss of experience.
Erosion of Public Trust: Frequent changes in leadership can erode public trust in the civil service itself. Citizens could come to view the state as unstable and incapable, which would likewise undermine public institutions’ credibility. As a result, it’s harder for civil servants to secure the cooperation of the public that is critical to effective governance.
Proposed Reforms
Reform One: Stabilization of Tenure The first, and most basic reform to deal with the problem of frequent transfers is to stabilize the tenure of civil servants. The other solution could be that the government could bring a policy so that the officers at each level can be guaranteed a minimum time in these positions so that they can understand their job and make relations and implement strategies. It could include a minimum tenure of three to five years in key positions, with the option to extend based on performance and the needs of the service, for example.
Performance-Driven Transfer Process Transfers should be driven by performance and the needs of the service and not by arbitrary or political considerations. This ensures that qualified and willing officers are retained in those positions. These reasons can be intensified by the inclusion of regular performance appraisals and rewarding the officers who deliver stellar results with longer tenures or promotions and moving underperforming officers into roles where they can be more effective.
More Robust Support for Transferees To help alleviate some of the personal and family disruption inherent to transfers, the government could offer transferees more robust support. This can range from financial assistance to relocating them, supporting children’s education, and counseling services that help their family to adjust to new surroundings. Furthermore, encampments of housing and infrastructure should be put in place at new postings to ease the transition.
Such as Training and Development Programs Civil servant must have training and development programs to strengthen their skills and knowledge. Such programs can be beneficial in at least making officers ready for their new roles and responsibilities, this way the adjustment period can be shortened and efficacy can be improved. Training should aim towards Technical skills but beyond that it should engage on Leadership, Communication and Conflict resolution.
Creation of Specialized Roles To address frequent transfer needs, the government could instead create specialized roles that would require deep expertise and long-term commitment. Examples include relatively stable roles in policy formulation, project management, and strategic planning that could be designed with longer tenures in mind and a focus on building a committee of experts that can lead and direct consistently.
There should be more transparency and accountability in the transfer process. Establishment and public availability of a transparent framework to transfer players, including criteria for transfers and publication of timelines for transfers to take place, would aid in reducing the perception of bias and favoritism amongst players who move between registers. You could set up an independent body or committee of good people — non-partisan, apolitical if you will — to oversee that transfer and make sure it happens in a way that is fair, equitable and is consistent with effective governance.
Conclusion
Frequent transfers at the higher civil service in India is a complex problem that needs a multifaceted solution through reforms. The government can mitigate the adverse effect of transfers, by ensuring stability of tenure, introducing a performance-based transfer system, eliminating disincentives through better support, continuous training and development, creating specialized roles, giving proper reasons for transfer and finally a more transparent policy in terms of transfers. These reforms will help to not only the civil servants but at the same time improve the effective public services as well as governance of the country.
See lessDiscuss the important provisions of the Forest Rights Act, 2006, and the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA) in promoting environmental conservation and safeguarding the rights of forest-dwelling communities (200 words)
Model Answer Introduction The Forest Rights Act (FRA) of 2006 and the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act (PESA) of 1996 are pivotal in recognizing the rights of forest-dwelling communities and promoting environmental conservation. These laws empower local communities in managing their resRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The Forest Rights Act (FRA) of 2006 and the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act (PESA) of 1996 are pivotal in recognizing the rights of forest-dwelling communities and promoting environmental conservation. These laws empower local communities in managing their resources sustainably, ensuring their participation in decision-making and conservation practices.
Key Aspects of the Forest Rights Act, 2006, and PESA 1996
Promoting Environmental Conservation
Protecting Forest-Dwelling Communities’ Rights
Limitations of the FRA and PESA
Way Forward
Conclusion
The Forest Rights Act and PESA are essential for balancing the empowerment of forest communities with environmental conservation. Their continuous refinement will foster a sustainable and equitable relationship between people and nature.
See lessIn 2011, India ratified the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC), but the existing legal framework to fulfill this commitment remains insufficient. Discuss. (200 words)
Model Answer Introduction India ratified the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) in 2011, committing to implement a comprehensive framework to combat corruption. While India has made some progress in enacting anti-corruption laws, the current legal structure remains insufficient inRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
India ratified the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) in 2011, committing to implement a comprehensive framework to combat corruption. While India has made some progress in enacting anti-corruption laws, the current legal structure remains insufficient in addressing all aspects of corruption as required by UNCAC.
Legal Framework and Reforms
Inadequacies in Fulfilling UNCAC Commitments
Conclusion
While India has made progress in fulfilling its UNCAC commitments, its legal and institutional framework remains inadequate. Addressing gaps such as improved whistleblower protection, faster trials, broader coverage of corruption offenses, and strengthening political will are essential to meet the goals set by UNCAC and curb corruption effectively.
See lessDespite the competitive political environment following the 73rd Constitutional Amendment, Panchayats have struggled to become effective bodies for planning and service delivery. (200 words)
Model Answer Introduction The 73rd Constitutional Amendment of 1992 aimed to empower Panchayats and promote decentralization by ensuring greater autonomy for local governance. However, despite the competitive political environment fostered by the amendment, Panchayats have not yet evolved into effecRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The 73rd Constitutional Amendment of 1992 aimed to empower Panchayats and promote decentralization by ensuring greater autonomy for local governance. However, despite the competitive political environment fostered by the amendment, Panchayats have not yet evolved into effective bodies for planning and service delivery in rural India.
Challenges in Panchayat Effectiveness
Suggested Measures for Improvement
Conclusion
The Venugopal Committee (2018) emphasized the need for reforms to strengthen Panchayats. By addressing challenges like financial constraints, lack of transparency, and limited community participation, Panchayats can fulfill their potential in driving rural development and ensuring effective service delivery.
See lessHow can India become such a society where religion is a personal choice rather than a political weapon , making India democratically more developed?
India serves as a live example showing that diverse belief systems produce a light of religious tolerance and effective democracy. People across India must decide between religion as an instrument of politics and religious affiliation as their private preference to make this idea work. Here are theRead more
India serves as a live example showing that diverse belief systems produce a light of religious tolerance and effective democracy. People across India must decide between religion as an instrument of politics and religious affiliation as their private preference to make this idea work. Here are the key steps toward that goal:
1. Secular Education:
-Reforms to Curricula : Our educational strategy teaches students to think critically about religious differences throughout history based on belief and identity.
-Teacher Training: Help teachers understand student diversity so they build classrooms that accept everyone equally.
2. Political Discourse:
-Responsible Leadership: Public officials should state both religious neutrality and welcome all people toward shared values during their public actions.
-Focus on Development: People should talk about development issues in public life rather than religious identification.
3. Community Engagement:
-Interfaith Dialogue: You should set up conversations between different faiths to let people understand one another better.
– Grassroots Initiatives: Give local groups funding to help different faiths work better together and create stronger communities.
4. Media Responsibility:
-Balanced Reporting: Support news media that share true facts while building audience understanding and stopping harmful speech.
-Fact-Checking: Support efforts to verify information and analyze data as a method to stop religious false information circulation.
5. Legal Framework:
-Effective Enforcement: Maintain existing rules that protect religious minority rights including everyone in their use.
See less-Anti Hate Crimes: Punishment for during religious communities becomes particularly stringent when people carry out violent attacks.
Analyze and assess the effectiveness of the implementation of the Smart Cities Mission in India. (200 Words)
Model Answer Introduction The Smart Cities Mission (SCM), launched in 2015, aims to transform urban India by creating sustainable, inclusive cities through smart solutions. The initiative focuses on improving core infrastructure, quality of life, and environmental sustainability. While the program hRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The Smart Cities Mission (SCM), launched in 2015, aims to transform urban India by creating sustainable, inclusive cities through smart solutions. The initiative focuses on improving core infrastructure, quality of life, and environmental sustainability. While the program has made notable progress, its effectiveness has been mixed, with both successes and challenges.
Key Achievements
By December 2023, 86% of the planned funding (₹49,000 crore) was released by the central government, demonstrating strong financial commitment. As of now, 57 cities have achieved 80-100% progress, and 6419 of the 7970 projects have been completed. Integrated Command and Control Centres (ICCCs) have been successfully operationalized in all 100 cities, enhancing monitoring and management of urban infrastructure. These developments showcase the potential of SCM in fostering urban modernization.
Implementation Challenges
Despite these achievements, the SCM faces several hurdles that hinder its full potential. One of the significant issues is the ineffective governance model, particularly the frequent transfers of CEOs in Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs), which affect continuity and accountability. Additionally, many cities struggle to meet their funding obligations, with only 28 cities receiving their full share from state or local governments. The Private-Public Partnership (PPP) model, which was expected to provide about 21% of funding, has seen limited success, with half of the cities failing to launch any projects under PPP.
Another concern is the intercity disparity in progress. While cities like Surat, Ahmedabad, and Pune are performing well, progress in Northeastern cities and other regions has been slow despite substantial central funding. Furthermore, the convergence of SCM with other government schemes, such as AMRUT and Swachh Bharat, has created difficulties due to multiple stakeholders, affecting the smooth implementation of projects.
Conclusion
The Smart Cities Mission has made important strides in urban development, but its effectiveness has been impeded by governance issues, funding challenges, and disparities in execution across regions. Addressing these challenges and ensuring better coordination and stakeholder engagement will be crucial for the long-term success of the initiative.
See lessWhat are the financial challenges encountered by Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) in India, and what steps can be implemented to enhance their revenue generation? (200 Words)
Model Answer 1. Over-reliance on Grants A major issue faced by PRIs is their heavy dependence on grants from the central and state governments. As per an RBI report, approximately 95% of their revenue is derived from these grants. This makes PRIs financially vulnerable and limits their autonomy in dRead more
Model Answer
1. Over-reliance on Grants
A major issue faced by PRIs is their heavy dependence on grants from the central and state governments. As per an RBI report, approximately 95% of their revenue is derived from these grants. This makes PRIs financially vulnerable and limits their autonomy in decision-making and local development.
2. Weak State Finance Commissions (SFCs)
Article 243-I of the Indian Constitution mandates the creation of State Finance Commissions (SFCs) to recommend the devolution of funds to local governments. However, only 9 states have constituted their 6th SFC, and of these, only two are operational. The lack of effective and functional SFCs exacerbates the financial difficulties faced by PRIs by delaying and limiting the funds allocated to them.
3. Insufficient Tax Revenue
PRIs generate very little revenue through local taxes and fees. In 2021-22, their own revenue from taxes and fees accounted for just 1.1% of total revenue. This is due to a narrow tax base, low compliance rates, and weak enforcement mechanisms. Additionally, lack of awareness and clarity regarding tax rules contributes to the underperformance in tax collection.
4. Misuse of Funds
Instances of corruption and fund mismanagement are also prevalent. The absence of strong oversight mechanisms allows for the misuse of funds, as demonstrated by the diversion of Rs 1.58 crore from the Gannavaram Gram Panchayat (Andhra Pradesh) without proper approval. This undermines the financial stability and credibility of PRIs.
Steps to Enhance Revenue Generation for PRIs
To address these challenges, several measures can be implemented:
1. Strengthening Tax Collection
PRIs should adopt innovative approaches like partnering with Self-Help Groups (SHGs) for tax and fee collection. For example, Surquja Gram Panchayat in Chhattisgarh witnessed an increase in revenue by collaborating with SHGs.
2. Improving Transparency and Resource Efficiency
Enhanced budgeting, fiscal discipline, and transparent resource management can help reduce misuse of funds. Regular audits and monitoring mechanisms should be put in place to ensure proper utilization.
3. Revenue Diversification
PRIs can adopt best practices from other successful models. Bademarenga Gram Panchayat in Chhattisgarh, for example, implemented various initiatives to increase both tax and non-tax revenue, such as leveraging local resources for income generation.
4. Land Monetization
PRIs should identify unused land for development purposes, such as commercial projects, community centers, or markets. This can generate significant revenue and contribute to local infrastructure.
5. Strengthening SFCs
Regular constitution and empowerment of SFCs are crucial for ensuring fair and timely devolution of funds from the state to the local level.
By embracing these strategies, PRIs can enhance their financial independence and play a more effective role in rural development.
See lessHow does the politicization of the civil services undermine the 'steel frame' of governance in India? What steps can be taken to mitigate this impact? (200 Words)
Model Answer The concept of the "steel frame" of governance in India, envisioned by the framers of the Constitution, underscores the need for an impartial, efficient, and non-partisan bureaucracy. However, the politicization of civil services erodes this foundation and disrupts the essential role ofRead more
Model Answer
The concept of the “steel frame” of governance in India, envisioned by the framers of the Constitution, underscores the need for an impartial, efficient, and non-partisan bureaucracy. However, the politicization of civil services erodes this foundation and disrupts the essential role of the civil services in ensuring stable and transparent governance.
Loss of Neutrality and Integrity: Politicization often compels civil servants to make decisions that align with political goals rather than the public interest. For instance, in the 2G spectrum case, bureaucrats from the Telecom Ministry compromised their neutrality, leading to significant governance failures. This undermines the very essence of civil services, which is to serve the nation impartially.
Widespread Corruption: Political interference increases the likelihood of corrupt practices within the bureaucracy. According to the Global Corruption Barometer-Asia (2020), India has one of the highest bribery rates in Asia, with 39% of respondents indicating that bribery is widespread, and 46% citing the prevalence of personal connections for bureaucratic deals. Such corruption erodes trust in the administration and hampers development.
Impact on Morale and Policy Continuity: Political interference in transfers and appointments demoralizes civil servants. The frequent transfer of IAS officer Ashok Khemka, who has been moved 56 times in a 30-year career, exemplifies how political pressures disrupt bureaucratic stability. Additionally, mass bureaucratic reshuffles after new government formations lead to discontinuity in policy implementation, further impeding long-term governance objectives.
Steps to Mitigate the Impact of Politicization
Transparent Appointments: Ensuring that civil service appointments and promotions are based on merit, with transparent criteria, can help mitigate political influence. The Prakash Singh judgment (2006) recommended setting up independent bodies like State Security Commissions to oversee appointments in the police, and similar mechanisms can be applied to other services.
Post-Retirement Neutral Period: To prevent the revolving door between politics and bureaucracy, the Hota Committee recommended a two-year cooling-off period before civil servants take up post-retirement political positions, such as becoming Governors.
Strengthening Accountability and Training: The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (ARC) emphasized the importance of defining public service values by law, holding bureaucrats accountable for ethical lapses. Moreover, regular training can reinforce neutrality and ethical conduct among civil servants, enabling them to withstand political pressures effectively.
In conclusion, reinforcing a non-partisan, neutral, and efficient bureaucracy through reforms in appointments, accountability, and training can help restore the integrity of the “steel frame” of governance in India.
See less