Home/Governance/Page 3
Governance
Governance refers to the processes, structures, and institutions through which a society or organization is directed, controlled, and held accountable.
Good governance principles include transparency, accountability, rule of law, efficiency, responsiveness, and inclusiveness. Effective governance at national, regional, and local levels is crucial for sustainable development, equitable service delivery, and protection of rights. It involves the interplay of the state, private sector, and civil society.
Share
How has Information and Communication Technology (ICT) reshaped governance at the grassroots level in India? What are the major challenges in fully harnessing its potential? (200 Words)
Model Answer Efficiency in Service Delivery: ICT has streamlined government services, enabling faster, more accurate service provision. A prime example is the Common Service Centres (CSCs), which provide rural communities with direct access to essential government services, utility payments, and welRead more
Model Answer
Major Challenges in Leveraging ICT’s Full Potential
Despite these advancements, several obstacles hinder the full utilization of ICT at the grassroots level.
In conclusion, while ICT has significantly reshaped governance at the grassroots level, overcoming these challenges is essential for maximizing its potential.
See lessHas the Right to Information (RTI) Act become redundant due to the challenges faced by the Office of the Central Information Commission? Analyze. (200 Words)
Model Answer The Right to Information (RTI) Act of 2005 was designed to enhance transparency and accountability in government operations. However, the effectiveness of the RTI Act has been compromised due to the challenges faced by the Central Information Commission (CIC). Challenges Affecting the RRead more
Model Answer
The Right to Information (RTI) Act of 2005 was designed to enhance transparency and accountability in government operations. However, the effectiveness of the RTI Act has been compromised due to the challenges faced by the Central Information Commission (CIC).
Challenges Affecting the RTI Act
One of the primary issues is the delay in the appointment of Information Commissioners (ICs), leading to understaffing. For instance, despite a Supreme Court directive in December 2019 to fill vacancies, only one new Commissioner was appointed by 2021. This delay has resulted in increased workloads and inefficiency in handling RTI requests.
Poor Enforcement of Penalties
The CIC has also shown reluctance to impose penalties on government officials who fail to provide information, as reported by Satark Nagrik Sangathan. This reluctance diminishes the deterrent effect of the RTI Act, further weakening its impact. Consequently, citizens are often denied access to crucial information.
Backlogs and Resource Constraints
Another significant problem is the backlog of cases. By 2023, the CIC had 20,078 pending cases, which highlights the inefficiency in processing appeals and complaints. Additionally, limited financial resources, inadequate digital infrastructure, and a lack of staff training in technology exacerbate these delays, undermining the Act’s potential.
Conclusion
In light of these issues—delays in appointments, poor enforcement, backlogs, and resource constraints—it is evident that the RTI Act has faced challenges in implementation. While it has not become entirely redundant, its transformative potential has been significantly hindered. Expediting appointments, addressing the backlog, and improving infrastructure are essential steps to restore the effectiveness of the RTI Act.
See lessHow effectively has the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) fulfilled its primary objectives?( 200 Words)
Model Answer Introduction The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), enacted in 2005, aims to provide 100 days of wage employment annually to rural households, foster inclusive development, and strengthen rural infrastructure. However, its effectiveness in achieving theseRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), enacted in 2005, aims to provide 100 days of wage employment annually to rural households, foster inclusive development, and strengthen rural infrastructure. However, its effectiveness in achieving these goals remains a subject of analysis.
Capacity Building of Rural Poor
In the financial year 2023-24, MGNREGA generated 3.1 billion person-days of employment, significantly aiding rural livelihoods. Additionally, initiatives like Project “UNNATI” have enhanced workers’ skills, equipping them for sustainable employment.
Creation of Productive Assets
As per the Economic Survey 2022-23, MGNREGA-funded projects, such as water body renovation and land reclamation, have improved agricultural productivity, increased household incomes, reduced migration, and alleviated rural indebtedness.
Social Inclusion
The scheme has effectively involved marginalized communities. In 2022-23, Scheduled Castes (SCs) constituted 19.75%, Scheduled Tribes (STs) 17.47%, and women 57.39% of total participants, promoting equitable development.
Strengthening Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs)
Panchayats play a critical role in planning and executing MGNREGA projects, while Gram Sabhas conduct regular social audits, fostering transparency and accountability.
Limitations of MGNREGA
Violation of Rights-Based Approach
A significant number of applicants are denied employment. For instance, only 9-14% of disabled persons and 5-9% of senior citizens in Bihar benefited from the scheme between 2014-2019.
Non-Uniform Wages and Payment Delays
Wage rates under MGNREGA vary across states, ranging from Rs. 193 to Rs. 318, with frequent delays in disbursal. Only 3% of job seekers received unemployment allowance in the past five years.
Ineffective Social Audits
Despite being mandated, social audits are inconsistent. In 2020-21, only 29,611 Gram Panchayats conducted audits, leaving many projects unexamined.
Use of Labour-Displacing Machinery
The 2021 CAG Report highlighted the widespread use of machinery, such as tractors, in Bihar, undermining the scheme’s labour-intensive mandate.
Conclusion
MGNREGA has significantly contributed to rural development but faces critical challenges. Measures like indexing wages to rural inflation, appointing a district-level Ombudsperson, and increasing financial allocation can enhance its efficiency and better address rural distress.
See lessFrequent transfers are a widespread issue within the higher civil service in India. Analyze the negative impacts of such transfers on civil servants and propose reforms to address this challenge.( 200 Words)
Model Answer Introduction Frequent transfers of civil servants, especially within the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), are a longstanding issue. The average tenure of IAS officers in a posting is only 15-18 months, which significantly impacts the functioning of the administration. Negative ImpacRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Frequent transfers of civil servants, especially within the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), are a longstanding issue. The average tenure of IAS officers in a posting is only 15-18 months, which significantly impacts the functioning of the administration.
Negative Impacts of Frequent Transfers
Poor Governance:
Frequent transfers hinder the accumulation of knowledge and experience in a particular area. Officers are unable to effectively implement policies or see the results of their work, leading to a decline in governance quality. As the Hota Committee (2004) noted, the absence of a fixed tenure is a major reason behind the poor implementation of government policies.
Corruption:
Frequent transfers also foster corruption. As per the Hota Committee, these transfers create opportunities for officers to form a nexus with politicians to secure favorable postings, undermining accountability.
Erosion of Political Neutrality:
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC) observed that ministers focus more on administrative matters like transfers rather than on policymaking. This shift affects the political neutrality of the civil services, an essential characteristic for impartial governance.
Tool for Harassment:
Honest officers view frequent transfers as a form of harassment and coercion. This not only demotivates them but also affects the fairness of the bureaucratic system.
Suggested Reforms
Fixed Minimum Tenure:
A minimum tenure of 3-5 years for officers in a posting would ensure stability, continuity, and better policy implementation. This will also allow civil servants to demonstrate the results of their work over time.
Transparency in Transfers:
Transfer policies should be based on performance and experience, not on arbitrary or politically motivated reasons. This would reduce the potential for corruption and ensure fairness.
Establishment of an Independent Body:
The Supreme Court, in the TSR Subramanian case (2013), recommended the formation of a Civil Services Board (CSB) under Article 309 to oversee transfers. While the 2014 amendment to the IAS (Cadre) Rules, 1954 provided for a CSB, its implementation has been inconsistent, with several states failing to set it up.
Conclusion
Frequent transfers undermine the efficiency of civil servants. Implementing fixed tenures, ensuring transparency, and establishing an independent body for oversight can address these issues and lead to a more stable and effective bureaucracy.
See lessIs it possible E – voting system in India rather than conventional voting system since 1951?
India specifically has been at the forefront of the idea to adopt the system to eradicate the traditional system of elections known as E-voting. Although electronic voting machines have been in use from 1999, the transition to a completely online or distance E-voting system opens opportunities and tRead more
India specifically has been at the forefront of the idea to adopt the system to eradicate the traditional system of elections known as E-voting. Although electronic voting machines have been in use from 1999, the transition to a completely online or distance E-voting system opens opportunities and threats.
On the positive side E-voting would help the Non Resident Indians NRIs, the migrant workers and the senior citizens to vote since they are reluctant to vote through physically casting their votes. Besides, the option of casting votes from any location is convenient in the sense that it would cut down the time and challenges of organizing the polls in a very populous country such as this. Besides, it might prove to be efficient which reduces expenses on construction of physical infrastructure, the actual paper ballots and security measures at these booths.
The laying down of an online voting process is therefore not devoid of significant hurdles albeit starting with an empty plate. Indeed, one of the major impediments of such process in India is the digital divide as a large part of the population is deprived of Internet connection or adequate digital literacy. It may also cause disempowerment of already largely excluded sections of the society. Another threat involves cybersecurity for the organization’s database of customer information. The electronic systems in use for online voting face vulnerabilities such as hacking, malware attacks, and data breaching that derail the elections. The other issue of concern is the level of security and accuracy used to check fraud and impersonation by the fake voters.
The second focal area is trust and transparency. A voter or the political parties may even doubt the sanity of the online system if their checks and balances, or the verification measures are not well put in place. E-voting would also need major legal amendments regarding India’s electoral laws.
In conclusion, optimistically, the new system has the potential to provide more people’s involvement and effectiveness on this regard, but contemporary complete substitution of the existing traditional system is not possible. In my opinion a better approach could be a combined model of the remote E-voting model in conjunction with in-person voting.
See lessHow should governments assess the cost versus the benefit of e-Governance initiatives? What metrics should be used to evaluate their success?
Comparing Cost and Benefits of e-Governance Programs The later means, that the governments should analyze e-Governance not in terms of cost-benefit, tangible and intangible, with time. That is to say fixed costs in addition to other operating expenses in relation to the impact on citizens and, in thRead more
Comparing Cost and Benefits of e-Governance Programs
The later means, that the governments should analyze e-Governance not in terms of cost-benefit, tangible and intangible, with time. That is to say fixed costs in addition to other operating expenses in relation to the impact on citizens and, in the long run, on public administration. ”
Steps to Assess Cost vs. Benefit:
1. Cost Identification: Hardware, software and communication networks installation
– Maintenance and operational costs Maintenance and operational costs include all the expenses that are incurred during the operations of an organisation or company.
– Programs that related to staff training and digital literacy .
– Cybersecurity measures .
2. Evaluate Benefits:
– Reducing the time, and therefore the cost incurred by citizens and businesses
– Efficient service delivery
– Reduced corruption and manual mistakes
– Enhanced bureaucracy
– Better citizen satisfaction
3. Think About Intangibles:
More interaction between the government and the people
Digital inclusion and empowerments of the most vulnerable group
Long-term socio economic impacts
Metrics for Assessing e-Governance Programs’ Success:
1. Operational Efficiency:
– The time required to process government services has gone down
– Most services can be accessed from the net
2. Adoption and Satisfaction of Users:
– CMO/ A2 Number of citizens availing e-Governance services
: citizen feedback scores and satisfaction scores
3. Cost Savings:
Reducing its allergy rating, or Degree to which it is allergy-friendly or appropriate all together to accommodate all patients needs or lack of or Increase or improving patients Experience –patients satisfaction level by Decrease administrative cost
– Preshrunk to minimal paperwork hence minimizing manual encumbrance.
4. Transparency and Accountability:
Total grievances resolved through the online mode .
Of cases of corruption reported to decrease.
5. Inclusivity and Accessibility:
See lessProportion of rural and other unserved population accessing the services .
Services being available in regional languages.
Citizen Charter's Aim and challenges
Citizen’s Charter refers to a document that defines the services that a given government organization or agency provides citizens as well as the quality, availability, customer courtesy, choice, equality, and reciprocity, responsibility, and reporting that will accompany the service. How Citizen ChaRead more
Citizen’s Charter refers to a document that defines the services that a given government organization or agency provides citizens as well as the quality, availability, customer courtesy, choice, equality, and reciprocity, responsibility, and reporting that will accompany the service.
How Citizen Charters enhance public service delivery:
-Improved Service Quality: Policies also play vital roles in increasing service delivery as it strengthens providers’ charters to standardize their offer to citizens.
More Responsibility By proactively defining some of the standards and outlining where to report a complaint, charters make people capable of demanding service provision accountability as well as promote people’s problem-solving action.
Citizen Empowerment Charters make citizens powerful based on information and tools which enhance citizens’ agency to push for improved service delivery and responsiveness from service delivery institutions.
-Reduced Corruption: Mmm..by so doing, they enhance the degree of accountability, that will in turn minimize incidences of corruption and overall enhance the degree efficiency and effectiveness in delivering people’s services.
Challenges to effective implementation of Citizen Charters:
-Lack of Political Will: Unfortunately for the success of the Citizen’s Charter, there is much needed political will and commitment from every tiers of government officials.
-Resistance to Change: Employees within the government organizations do not embrace change of the existing systems and practices and embrace new culture of operation.
-Lack of Awareness and Understanding: This implies that majority of the citizens do not even have an idea to do with the rights and provisions of the Citizen’s Charter.
-Inadequate Monitoring and Evaluation: It is important to then ensure the provider of the services is in compliance with the charter by the use of the proper monitoring and evaluation tools.
-Lack of Resources: Both financial and human resources are very important especially when it comes to the implementation of the Citizen’s Charters.
-Cultural Barriers: They may also limit the degree of interaction between citizens and service providers since different cultures imply different ways of perceiving things and behaving.
See lessIn what ways can traditional customs be adapted to coexist with modern values without leading to obscurantism?
It is the challenge between keeping up with conservativeness and embracing the new thinking without being obscure. Critical Scrutiny Identify Strong Values: Negotiate view on values and principles contained in practices by breaking them down. To what extent are they motivated by respect, community oRead more
It is the challenge between keeping up with conservativeness and embracing the new thinking without being obscure.
Critical Scrutiny
Identify Strong Values: Negotiate view on values and principles contained in practices by breaking them down. To what extent are they motivated by respect, community or a feel of identity?
Challenge Destructive Practices: Challenge the existence of oppressive and discriminative or otherwise, negative practices toward individuals or groups.
reinterpretation and Rethinking:
Update practices:
Transform the primarily conservative structures of old ways into a modern form while keeping them old. As an example, traditional festivals could be presented with mixture of the modern arts, music or technology in presenting the traditional festival to the community.
Inclusive Practices
Always make the previous customs to be flexible so that they may meet all the people despite their sex or their religion or even status.
Education and Dialogue
Promote Understanding:
Make the young people learn from experience about the roots of traditions and make them value it to the maximum.
Promote Dialogue: Promoteraisinglethumb discussions about which values and practices should be preserved, and how the African values can be adapted to suits the advances 21st century world call for.
Technology and Innovation:
Use Technology:
Support documentation of traditional knowledge systems through replicating them in the virtual space through, websites, and other online and digital databases.
-Avoid Literalistic Interpretation: The person must struggle against adolescent literal-dogmatic nepotism with respect to steralized and pathological elements of tradition.
See less-Allow Individual Choice: Allow the subjects to choose in what manner and to what extent to engage and what meaning to attribute to the traditional practices.
-Embrace Diversity: Appreciation of the multiculturalism and diversity of a society.
Thus, by adopting these practices, we are healthy-bound to msear popular traditions appropriate for the contemporary age orientation of culture wealth as well as the principles of equality, justice and human rights.
What role does the government of a country have in organising the Games?
Government Role in Olympic Organisation: Although the host state government is not a party to the official agreements between the International Olympic Committee (IOC), the National Olympic Committees (NOCs), and the International Sports Federations (IFs), it plays a very central role of propitiousRead more
Government Role in Olympic Organisation:
Although the host state government is not a party to the official agreements between the International Olympic Committee (IOC), the National Olympic Committees (NOCs), and the International Sports Federations (IFs), it plays a very central role of propitious force and financial contribution with media, particularly on the organization of the Games.
Infrastructure Development:
Governments must, from time to time, invest hugely in constructing new sports venues, the rehabilitation of transport services are the remodeling of athlete occupation and recreational residential rooms.
Public Security and Services:
Government also takes responsibility for the physical defense of players, officials, and the spectators so they provide the force of security, health services, and emergency systems.
Financial help:
The government funds the organizing committee through fund allocations, subsidies, and tax exemptions operationalizing the expenditures of the Games.
Legal and Policy Framework:
Where a host country wants to organize the Games, the government liberalizes its policy, makes visa quick procedures and employs specific laws for organizing the Games.
Advertising and Tourism:
A strategically important tool used by governments is the increase importance given to the Games, promoting tourism, boosting the international image of the country, and spurring economic growth.
Although the IOC is the instrument of invitation to the NOCs and the overall direction for the games, the host-country government has the burden of providing the essential support for logistics, finance, and administration to ensure the success of the event.
See lessWhat role does the government of a country have in organising the Games?
Government Role in Olympic Organisation: Although the host state government is not a party to the official agreements between the International Olympic Committee (IOC), the National Olympic Committees (NOCs), and the International Sports Federations (IFs), it plays a very central role of propitiousRead more
Government Role in Olympic Organisation:
Although the host state government is not a party to the official agreements between the International Olympic Committee (IOC), the National Olympic Committees (NOCs), and the International Sports Federations (IFs), it plays a very central role of propitious force and financial contribution with media, particularly on the organization of the Games.
Infrastructure Development:
Governments must, from time to time, invest hugely in constructing new sports venues, the rehabilitation of transport services are the remodeling of athlete occupation and recreational residential rooms.
Public Security and Services:
Government also takes responsibility for the physical defense of players, officials, and the spectators so they provide the force of security, health services, and emergency systems.
Financial help:
The government funds the organizing committee through fund allocations, subsidies, and tax exemptions operationalizing the expenditures of the Games.
Legal and Policy Framework:
Where a host country wants to organize the Games, the government liberalizes its policy, makes visa quick procedures and employs specific laws for organizing the Games.
Advertising and Tourism:
A strategically important tool used by governments is the increase importance given to the Games, promoting tourism, boosting the international image of the country, and spurring economic growth.
Although the IOC is the instrument of invitation to the NOCs and the overall direction for the games, the host-country government has the burden of providing the essential support for logistics, finance, and administration to ensure the success of the event.
See less