Roadmap for Answer Writing
1. Introduction (Brief Overview)
Begin by providing a concise introduction to the FRBM Act, 2003, mentioning its enactment and importance in ensuring fiscal discipline and stability in India.
- Fact: The FRBM Act was enacted in 2003 to bring transparency and fiscal discipline to India’s fiscal management, marking a turning point in fiscal reforms.
2. Objectives of the FRBM Act (Elaborate)
State the main objectives of the FRBM Act, explaining each goal clearly.
- Inter-generational equity: Ensure fiscal policies that don’t burden future generations with excessive debt.
- Macroeconomic stability: Achieve long-term stability by ensuring a revenue surplus and prudent fiscal policies.
- Remove fiscal obstacles to monetary policy: Prevent fiscal imbalances from interfering with monetary policy decisions by the RBI.
- Debt management: Keep borrowing and deficits within manageable limits.
- Inflation control: Allow flexibility for the RBI to manage inflation.
- Equitable debt distribution: Balance India’s debt over time to prevent future fiscal strain.
Source: The primary goals of the FRBM Act include maintaining fiscal discipline and ensuring macroeconomic stability, as stated in the Act’s purpose.
3. Key Features of the FRBM Act (Elaborate with Specific Features)
List and explain the key features of the FRBM Act in detail:
- Deficit reduction targets: The government must reduce fiscal and revenue deficits, aiming to eliminate the revenue deficit by 2009 and achieve a surplus thereafter.
- Fact: Initially, the Act set a target of eliminating the revenue deficit by 2009, and achieving adequate revenue surplus thereafter.
- Expenditure adjustments: If deficits are not reduced through tax revenue, the government must reduce its expenditures.
- Fact: Expenditure cuts are mandated if deficits can’t be bridged by higher revenue collections.
- Exceptions to deficit targets: The Act permits deviations from deficit targets in case of national security issues or natural calamities.
- Fact: The Act allows for exceptional circumstances like national emergencies to justify exceeding deficit targets.
- Government borrowing limits: The Act prohibits the central government from borrowing directly from the RBI, except in cases of temporary cash flow shortages.
- Fact: The Act restricts borrowing from the RBI, except for temporary advances.
- RBI’s role: Starting from 2006-07, the RBI is prohibited from subscribing to new government securities.
- Fact: The RBI is prohibited from subscribing to new government securities since 2006-07.
- Transparency measures: The government must lay down fiscal statements before Parliament, ensuring accountability.
- Fact: The government is required to submit the Medium-term Fiscal Policy Statement, Fiscal Policy Strategy Statement, and Macroeconomic Framework Statement to Parliament.
- Quarterly review of fiscal trends: The government must provide a quarterly review of receipts and expenditure trends to Parliament.
- Fact: Quarterly reviews of trends in receipts and expenditure are required to ensure fiscal transparency.
4. Review and Updates to the Act (Highlight Changes)
Mention that the FRBM Act was reviewed in 2016 by the NK Singh Committee, which suggested updates to some of the targets.
- Fact: The NK Singh Committee recommended targeting a debt-to-GDP ratio of 60% by 2023, with a target of reducing the fiscal deficit from 3.5% (2017) to 2.5% by 2023, along with introducing an escape clause for emergencies.
5. Conclusion (Summary)
Conclude by summarizing the importance of the FRBM Act in achieving fiscal discipline and ensuring economic stability in India.
Relevant Facts to Use in the Answer:
- The FRBM Act was enacted in 2003 to promote fiscal transparency and stability in India’s fiscal management.
- The NK Singh Committee in 2016 recommended revising the fiscal deficit targets and implementing a debt-to-GDP ratio target of 60% by 2023.
- The FRBM Act mandates that the central government reduce fiscal and revenue deficits, with strict guidelines for adjustments in case of exceptional circumstances like national emergencies.
- The Act promotes transparency through mandatory submission of various fiscal reports to Parliament.
The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA), enacted in 2003, aims to instill fiscal discipline in India.
Objectives of FRBMA
Key Features of FRBMA
Recent Developments
In light of economic challenges, the FRBMA has been amended to accommodate higher fiscal deficits. For instance, in the Union Budget 2021-22, the government targeted a fiscal deficit of 6.8% of GDP, up from the revised estimate of 9.5% in 2020-21, with plans to amend the FRBM Act accordingly.
These adjustments reflect the government’s commitment to balancing fiscal discipline with the need to support economic growth during challenging times.
The provided answer gives a concise overview of the goals and key features of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA), 2003. It is well-structured and effectively highlights the Act’s primary objectives, fiscal targets, and the inclusion of an escape clause. However, the answer could be improved in the following areas:
Incorrect Deadline:
The fiscal and revenue deficit targets were originally set for 2008-09, not 2018. This discrepancy needs correction for accuracy.
Public Debt Target Clarification:
The FRBMA does not explicitly specify a public debt target of 50% of GDP from 2011 onwards; this appears to be a misinterpretation or an unreferenced fact. Providing accurate data or removing this point would improve clarity.
Broader Impacts:
While the transparency and escape clause are mentioned, the answer does not discuss the broader impact of the Act, such as its role in improving fiscal discipline, creditworthiness, or long-term macroeconomic stability.
Mithila You can use these feedback also
Amendment History:
The answer refers to the 2021 amendments but misses earlier key amendments, such as the 2012 amendment, which introduced the concept of effective revenue deficit.
Lack of Examples for Escape Clause:
Including examples, such as its use during the COVID-19 pandemic, would make the explanation more relatable.
First however, some context, India introduced its first framework for effective fiscal management through the passing of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2003 (FRBMA). The FRBMA was enacted by the Parliament of India with the purpose of making fiscal operations transparent, reducing fiscal deficit, and achieving long-term macroeconomic stability. This paper explores the main objectives of FRBMA and outlines its key features.
Objectives of the FRBMA
Fiscal discipline and sustainable public finance:
FRBMA aims to lay a framework for fiscal discipline. This strategy will put public finance on a sustainable basis, with the goal of reducing the fiscal deficit and debt levels. This is key for macroeconomic stability and sustainable economic growth.
Dr. Buchan also added, “Transparency and Accountability:
The act highlights the importance of transparency in government fiscal activities. It requires the government to show clear and detailed fiscal information to the public, increasing accountability. Thus, this level of transparency encourages public trust and subject fiscal policies to scrutiny and debate.
Reduction of Revenue Deficit:
Overall, to eliminate the revenue deficit, i.e., the excess of revenue expenditure over revenue receipts. The act measures the effort of the states result by prescribing the revenue deficit targets to decrease over the years, with a balanced revenue budget.
Stability and Growth:
The FRBMA aims to ensure the fiscal discipline required for a stable economic environment conducive to investment, employment, and economic growth. Interest rates would fall, inflation would ease, and investors would show greater confidence if fiscal affairs were stable.
Debt Management:
It deals with controlling the debt levels of the government. It stipulates targets for bringing down the outstanding debt and the debt-to-GDP ratio, key indicators of fiscal health. Responsible debt management also lowers debt service costs and frees up resources for development and welfare work.
Main Features of the FRBMA
Fiscal Deficit Targets:
The FRBMA prescribes targets indicating the extent to which fiscal deficit (total expenditure minus total receipts (excluding borrowings)) should be reduced. The act prescribed that the fiscal deficit be reduced to 3% of the GDP by 2007-08 albeit, this target was subsequently revised owing to multiple economic developments.
Revenue Deficit Elimination:
The act requires the government to remove the revenue deficit (the gap between revenue expenditure and revenue receipts). The government is obliged to bring a plan on how to meet this target which is generally very loud through a step-by-step approach over the course of years.
Debt-to-GDP Ratio:
The FRBMA focuses more on lowering the ratio of government debt to GDP. This ratio is very important in terms of the government debt repayment capacity and fiscal sustainability. The law lays out certain targets for this ratio that the government has to meet.
Statement of Annual Fiscal Policy:
It mandates the government to place before Parliament an Annual Fiscal Policy Statement. This statement sets out the fiscal policy for the forthcoming financial year, along with the Government’s intention to achieve the fiscal deficit and revenue deficit targets. It also contains a summary of potential fiscal risks and the policies being implemented to manage them.
(Medium Term Fiscal Policy Statement)
The fiscal deficit is the difference between the government’s total revenue and its total expenditure. The Fiscal Statement is there to provide a long term setting for fiscal direction and ensure that government policy is in line with fiscal objectives.
Fiscal Transparency:
The law requires the government to prepare and publish the document Fiscal Transparency in Government Expenditure. This report includes information on various government off-budget transactions, contingent liabilities, and other commitments. Its purpose is to ensure the fiscal policies of the government are transparent and publicly comprehensible.
I. Budget Estimates and Revisions:
The FRBMA has mandated the government to provide accurate estimates of the revenues and expenditures for the budget. It also requires the government to reexamine and adjust these estimates if the original projections are substantially off. That keeps the budget in line with the government’s fiscal directives and economic conditions.
Fiscal Rules and Sanctions:
The Act embodies the fiscal rules which government must follow. These rules ensure that the government remains on track with its fiscal targets and does not over-borrow. The act introduces sanctions and corrective action if the government doesn’t meet these targets.
Autonomous Fiscal Council:
While not a requirement of the original act, an autonomous Fiscal Council has been a long-running topic of discussion. This council would review the government’s fiscal policies and offer independent counsel. Not implemented yet, but reflecting, sort of, the overall intent of the FRBMA to provide more fiscal oversight and accountability.
Regular Fiscal Reporting:
It mandates periodic disclosures about the government’s fiscal performance. Audit reports to be presented to parliament and contain disclosures on the state of government finances, including the actual fiscal deficit, revenue deficit and debt levels. This process of regular reporting and measuring enables accountability and corrective actions if needed in a timely manner.
Conclusion
FRBMA (The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2003) Despite its statutory nature, FRBM remains an important legislative achievement that has sought to bring fiscal discipline, transparency, and accountability in government finances. The FRBMA lays down a framework for fiscal deficits, revenue deficits, and debt levels with clear targets and mandates. Although the act has undergone challenges and revisions through the years, it continues to be a pillar of India’s fiscal policy, furthering the country’s economic stability and growth.
Model Answer
The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act, 2003 was established to enforce fiscal discipline and ensure long-term macroeconomic stability in India. The main objectives of the FRBM Act are as follows:
Key Features of the FRBM Act
The key features of the FRBM Act include:
The NK Singh Committee, in 2016, reviewed the Act and suggested updating targets, including reducing the debt-to-GDP ratio to 60% by 2023, with 40% for the Centre and 20% for the states. It also recommended adjusting the fiscal deficit target to 2.5% by 2023, introducing a range of fiscal targets with escape clauses for emergencies.
The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA), enacted in 2003, was designed to institutionalize financial discipline in India. Its primary goals were to reduce the fiscal deficit, eliminate the revenue deficit, and promote prudent management of public finances. By setting specific targets, the Act aimed to ensure long-term macroeconomic stability and foster transparency in the government’s fiscal operations.
Key features of the FRBMA include:
Over time, the Act has undergone amendments to accommodate evolving economic conditions. For instance, in the Union Budget 2021, the government announced plans to amend the FRBM Act to accommodate a higher fiscal deficit, targeting a reduction to 4.5% of GDP by 2025-26.
In summary, the FRBMA was a significant legislative measure aimed at promoting fiscal discipline, enhancing transparency, and ensuring sustainable economic growth in India.
The provided answer is well-structured and comprehensive, highlighting the objectives and key features of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA), 2003. However, there are a few missing details and opportunities for enhancement:
Missing Specific Deadlines:
While the answer mentions targets for fiscal deficit and revenue deficit reduction, it does not specify the original deadlines under the Act. For instance, the fiscal deficit target of 3% of GDP was to be achieved by 2008-09 (later extended).
Coverage of Amendments:
Although the 2021 amendment is briefly mentioned, earlier amendments, such as those in 2012 (which replaced the revenue deficit target with an “effective revenue deficit” target), are missing.
Impact of FRBMA:
The answer could discuss the broader impacts of the Act, such as its role in curbing fiscal profligacy and promoting creditworthiness.
Escape Clause Examples:
Specific instances of when the escape clause has been invoked, such as during the COVID-19 pandemic, would strengthen the analysis.
Lekha You can use this Feedback Also
Overall, the answer captures the essence of the FRBMA but could benefit from additional data to improve its precision and depth.
The Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA), enacted in 2003, aims to institutionalize fiscal discipline in India.
Objectives of FRBMA
Key Features of FRBMA
In light of economic challenges, the FRBMA has been amended to accommodate higher fiscal deficits. For instance, in the Union Budget 2021-22, the government targeted a fiscal deficit of 6.8% of GDP, up from the revised estimate of 9.5% in 2020-21, with plans to amend the FRBM Act accordingly.
These adjustments reflect the government’s commitment to balancing fiscal discipline with the need to support economic growth during challenging times.
The answer provides a good overview of the objectives and features of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA), 2003. However, it has notable inaccuracies and omissions that need to be addressed to enhance its quality and reliability.
Incorrect Deadlines:
The fiscal and revenue deficit targets in the FRBMA were initially set to be achieved by 2008-09, not 2018. This is a significant factual error that undermines the credibility of the answer.
Public Debt Target Misrepresentation:
The claim that the FRBMA sets a target for public debt not exceeding 50% of GDP from 2011 onwards is incorrect. The Act does not explicitly mention such a threshold.
Amendment History:
The answer mentions the 2021-22 amendments but omits earlier changes, such as the 2012 amendment, which replaced the revenue deficit target with the concept of effective revenue deficit. Including this would provide a more complete historical perspective.
Sowmya You can use this feedback also
Escape Clause Examples:
While the escape clause is mentioned, real-world examples, such as its invocation during the COVID-19 pandemic, would make the answer more impactful and relevant.
Broader Impact:
The discussion could benefit from explaining how the FRBMA contributed to macroeconomic stability, improved creditworthiness, and curbed fiscal profligacy.
Suggestions for Improvement
Correct the deadlines and remove the inaccurate public debt target.
Add information on the 2012 amendment and earlier deviations from targets.
Include examples of the escape clause in action (e.g., during the pandemic).
Expand on how the FRBMA promotes transparency and fiscal discipline in the long term.
These additions would create a more balanced and comprehensive response.