Roadmap for Answer Writing
1. Introduction
- Introduce the topic: Briefly mention the significance of India’s vast coastline (7,516.6 km) and how its geographical position makes it vulnerable to illegal activities that pose security threats.
- Context: Highlight the types of illegal activities—smuggling, terrorism, piracy, and human trafficking—that threaten national security.
2. Vulnerability of India’s Coasts to Illegal Activities
- Smuggling and Illegal Trade:
- Illegal trade via sea routes, particularly drugs, gold, and counterfeit goods.
- Example: 2,988 kg of heroin seized at Gujarat’s Mundra port in 2021.
- Terrorism:
- Coastal areas are easy entry points for terrorists.
- Example: Terrorists infiltrated Mumbai via sea routes during the 2008 attacks.
- Piracy:
- Piracy poses a threat to maritime trade.
- Example: INS Kolkata rescued the hijacked vessel MV Ruen and captured 35 pirates.
- Human Trafficking:
- Coastal routes are used for trafficking, especially from neighboring countries like Bangladesh and Myanmar.
3. Current Coastal Security System in Place
- Three-Tier Coastal Security Ring:
- Indian Navy: Patrols International Maritime Boundary Line.
- Indian Coast Guard: Conducts surveillance up to 200 nautical miles.
- State Coastal Police: Responsible for shallow coastal patrolling.
- Joint Coastal Security Exercises:
- Sagar Kavach: A bi-annual exercise involving Indian Navy, Coast Guard, Marine Police, and other agencies to test the security response to sea-borne threats.
- Coastal Surveillance Network:
- A network of static sensors, radars, cameras, and Automatic Identification Systems (AIS) across 46 locations along the coast.
- Community Interaction Programs:
- Engages local fishers and coastal communities to act as “Eyes and Ears” for detecting suspicious activity.
4. Challenges in Coastal Security
- Nighttime Patrolling: Lack of adequate patrols at night.
- Inadequate Training: Marine police often lack the necessary training.
- Under-Utilization of Funds: Insufficient investment in coastal infrastructure.
- Coordination Gaps: Challenges in coordination among multiple security agencies.
5. Conclusion
- Summarize key points: Restate the vulnerabilities of India’s coastline and the measures taken to mitigate threats.
- Call for improvement: Highlight the need for strengthening the existing system, addressing challenges, and ensuring a collaborative approach for better coastal security.
Relevant Facts and Examples
- Heroin Seizure at Mundra Port (2021): India seized 2,988 kg of heroin smuggled into the country through the Gujarat coastline.
- Mumbai Terror Attacks (2008): Terrorists entered Mumbai via sea routes, showcasing the vulnerability of coastal areas to infiltration.
- Piracy Incident (MV Ruen): The INS Kolkata successfully rescued the hijacked MV Ruen, capturing 35 pirates in the process, underlining the piracy threat in the Arabian Sea and Indian Ocean.
- Coastal Surveillance Network: The network of radars, cameras, and sensors deployed at 46 coastal locations enhances real-time monitoring of maritime activities.
- Sagar Kavach Exercises: Regular joint exercises involving multiple security agencies to ensure coordination and readiness for potential threats.
India, with a coast line of over 7,500 kilometers, is in an extremely favorable position to tap the potential of maritime trade and associated economic opportunities. But this broad expanse of coastline also makes the country susceptible to all manner of criminality that poses serious threats to its security. These include drug trafficking, arms smuggling, human trafficking, piracy, and terrorism. Knowing exactly what these threats are and how they are dealt with is closing the gap for the protection and safety of the nation.
The Legality and Risks of Criminal Actions
Risks of Drug Smuggling :
Indian coastal waters are frequently used as trans-shipment routes in respect of narcotics originating from the Golden Crescent (Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Iran) and the Golden Triangle (Myanmar, Thailand, and Laos). Others, including heroin and methamphetamine, enter the country and are then distributed throughout India and beyond. This fuels criminal and addictive behavior, as well as posing a threat to public health and social stability.
Solutions:
Less access to drugs may be needed if crime rates are to be reduced, healthcare expenditure is to be reduced and law enforcement agencies are not to struggle with drug abuse. And drug trafficking pays for the means to commit more crimes, from drug violence to terrorism.
Coastal Route (In-bits Arming):
The risk of arms transport through coastal routes presents an important threat, particularly concerning illegal transport of arms and ammunition. Insurgents, terrorists, and organized crime syndicates can use these weapons to increase their ability to commit acts of violence.
Impact:
The widespread spread of illegal weapons aggravates ongoing wars and violence in countries plagued by insurgencies and terrorism. This scenario equally hinders the government from enforcing rule of law and safeguarding the lives of its own people.
Human Trafficking:
Human trafficking is a horrible crime which involves the illegal transportation of people for the purpose of exploitation. With their many points of entry and exit, coastal places have been used for cross-border trafficking of victims. Not only is it a violation of fundamental human rights, it also promotes organized crime, ultimately leading to the destruction of the country. Some of these practices take the form of exploitation such as human trafficking or forced labor.
Risks of piracy:
While piracy is mostly prevalent in areas like the gulfs of Aden and Malta strait across the world, the risk of piracy and sea theft is also evolving near the shores of India. These disruptive moves undermine maritime commerce, jeopardize sailors’ safety, and can result in heavy financial losses. Effects Piracy could discourage foreign investment in maritime-based industries and raise shipping firms’ insurance premiums, with ripple effects on the larger economy.
Terrorism Risks:
Terrorism is a major risk because coastal areas are easy to infiltrate and can be attacked. The 2008 attacks in Mumbai, in which the attackers arrived by sea, underscored an urgent need to introduce robust coastal security. Impact: Terrorist attacks may lead to mass slaughter of the citizens and destruction of properties and affect national economy as well as the image of the nation. In addition, they also demand significant resources for response and recovery efforts.
Existing Strategies for Coastal Defense
India has devised an elaborate (it involves many organizations and technologies) security system to counter threats potentially emanating from illegal elements operating along its coasts. Role of Coast Guard: The ICG (Indian Coast Guard) acts as the main agency for securing the coastline. It conducts constant patrols, assesses maritime traffic and provides real-time emergency response. The ICG also works with other authorities to deter, detect and mitigate illegal acts. Avenues of Most Improvement: Considering the ICG where a varying patrol class ship ships and aircraft increasing as well as the drone and systems like the high-altitude high resolution co-ordinate reporting systems; the ability to maintain the operationalization capacity has improved.
Indian Navy :
One of the Key Pillars of Coastal Defense Indian Navy plays a crucial role in coastal defense especially in high strategic importance area. It shares vigilance and secures the maritime domain in continued partnership with the Coast Guard and other forces.
Navy Innovations:
The navy has heavily invested in monitored satellite and underwater drone technologies to boost these.
Function of the Maritime Security Coordination Centre (MSCC):
The MSCC is essentially coordination roundabout of diverse maritime security organizations. It also enables intelligence sharing and ensures a coordinated response to threats directly and indirectly (through proxies).
They are data provisioners:
The MSCC integrates information from multiple organizations — like the Coast Guard and Navy — as well as multiple intelligence agencies, creating an accurate picture of the maritime operating environment.
State Maritime Police:
There is an establishment of state police maritime units by each coastal state, which coordinate closely with the Coast Guard and Navy. They have the duty to enforce the law and ensure the safety in their national territorial waters. Local Know-How: State maritime police draw on their local knowledge, and visibility in the region, to help efficiently patrol and address security issues within their areas of jurisdiction.
Importance:
Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM) ICZM project is important as it aims to establish an integrated approach to the management of coastal zones, with an emphasis on environmental protection, economic activity and securityωσης α μεταχ∞; This will need the cooperation of all government departments and organisations.
It focuses on the safety of coastal communities but also on a long term sustainable vision for how to manage the environment around them.
A Coastal Security Principles Framework for Discussion Community Engagement:
Coastal security cannot be a top-down process; coastal governance must involve local fishing communities and other coastal stakeholders. They usually have critical information and are on the front lines of fighting illicit activity.
Prevention principles :
The government aims to build a trust and collaboration through trust management programs and coastal crime awareness programs with coastal communities.
Next Steps, Questions, and Things to Work On
But there is much work to be done despite the strategies in place. These include:
– Resource Constraints: The vast stretch of coast compared to the finite resources available present an obstacle to routine monitoring and enforcement
-Technical Barriers: Although significant advances have been achieved, there is an urgent need for more sophisticated technologies to prevent and apprehend malicious behaviors
– Coordination Problems : A well-functioning security regime requires coordination among various agencies and actors.
Cross-border cooperation:
Many illicit activities do not stop at a border, therefore, sharing information and cooperating globally is essential.
In response to these challenges, the government is aiming to:
It will free up resources for new technologies, including AI and machine learning, that help identify and remediate threats
Improved Coordination – Enabling coordinated C2 for greater effectiveness
Cooperate facilitation : Alliances with countries, Local ground realizers
Conclusion
India, being a gateway to many illegal activities, the coastal vulnerability is a major national security concern. In 2019, writing for the DAP, they noted that while these set-backs were promising, more detailed reporting would be needed in the face of emerging threats and resulting technological abilities. With all its coastal habitats, and a growing population that deserves to do better, India should look at how strengthening (often called, upgrading) infrastructure, new technology and pooling efforts between the states and communities can push its coastal defence efforts far ahead.
Model Answer
Vulnerability of India’s Coasts to Unlawful Activities
India’s vast coastline of over 7,516 km, spanning nine states and four union territories, makes it highly vulnerable to unlawful activities that threaten national security. These activities include:
Current Coastal Security System
To address these security threats, India has implemented a robust security framework:
Challenges
Despite these measures, challenges persist. A CAG report highlighted issues such as:
These gaps point to the need for continuous improvements to strengthen India’s coastal security system.