Roadmap for Answer Writing
1. Introduction
- Context Setting: Briefly introduce the Indian Constitution and its significance.
- Thesis Statement: State that while the Constitution borrows features from various countries, its unique characteristics set it apart.
2. Borrowed Features
- Parliamentary System: Derived from the United Kingdom.
- Fundamental Rights and Judiciary: Influenced by the United States.
- Ideals of Liberty, Equality, Fraternity: Borrowed from France.
- Federal Structure: Inspired by Canada.
- Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSPs): Taken from Ireland.
- Socio-economic Justice: Influenced by the erstwhile USSR.
Relevant Facts
- United Kingdom: Parliamentary form of government (Source: Indian Constitution, Article 79).
- United States: Fundamental Rights (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 12-35).
- France: Ideals in the Preamble (Source: Indian Constitution, Preamble).
- Canada: Federal structure (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 1-4).
- Ireland: DPSPs (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 36-51).
- USSR: Socio-economic justice principles.
3. Unique Characteristics
a. Length and Detail
- Lengthiest Constitution: Initially 395 articles, now 470 (Source: Indian Constitution).
b. Constitutional Sovereignty
- Sovereignty of the Constitution: Parliament cannot create a new Constitution; it can only amend it (Source: Constitution of India, Article 368).
c. Fundamental Rights
- Conditional Rights: Unlike the U.S., rights come with reasonable restrictions (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 12-35).
d. Federalism with Unitary Bias
- Central Authority: Stronger Centre during emergencies (Source: Constitution of India, Article 356).
e. Integrated Judiciary
- Single Judicial Framework: Both central and state laws enforced by a unified judiciary (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 124-147).
f. Directive Principles of State Policy
- Broad Scope: DPSPs include economic, social, and administrative justice (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 36-51).
4. Conclusion
- Summation: Reaffirm that the Indian Constitution, while drawing from various sources, is unique in its structure, principles, and adaptability.
- Final Thought: Highlight the foresight of the framers in creating a document tailored for India’s diverse needs.
Additional Relevant Facts
- Flexibility and Rigidity: The Indian Constitution is considered flexible but rigid in matters of federalism (Source: Constitution of India).
- Social Justice Focus: DPSPs aim for comprehensive welfare beyond mere economic rights (Source: Constitution of India).
By following this roadmap, you can effectively structure your answer to highlight both the borrowed elements and the distinctive features of the Indian Constitution.
The Indian Constitution adopted on November 26, 1949 is India’s supreme law outlining fundamental rights, directive principles and governance framework, ensuring democracy, equality and justice.India’s Constitution blends global inspirations with indigenous elements uniquely tailoring federalism, secularism and social justice to its diverse democratic fabric.
Borrowed Features –
Unique Characteristics –
India’s Constitution combines global ideas yet stands distinct by balancing diversity, flexibility and democratic values, tailored to its unique social landscape.India’s Constitution framers showed remarkable foresight by crafting a dynamic document suited to its diverse society.
India’s Constitution, adopted in 1950, is a unique blend of features from various countries’ constitutions, with distinct characteristics that reflect India’s diverse culture, history, and values.
*Influences from other constitutions:*
1. British Constitution (parliamentary system, rule of law)
2. US Constitution (fundamental rights, judicial review)
3. Irish Constitution (directive principles of state policy)
4. Australian Constitution (federal structure)
5. Canadian Constitution (emergency provisions)
*Distinct characteristics:*
1. *Social and Economic Rights*: India’s Constitution includes both individual rights (e.g., freedom of speech) and social and economic rights (e.g., right to education, right to work).
2. *Directive Principles of State Policy*: Unique to India, these principles guide the government’s policy-making, emphasizing social justice, equality, and welfare.
3. *Federal Structure with a Strong Center*: India’s federal system balances power between the center and states, with a strong central government.
4. *Emergency Provisions*: India’s Constitution allows for emergency declarations, enabling the central government to take control during crises.
5. *Amendment Process*: India’s Constitution has a flexible amendment process, allowing for changes through parliamentary procedures.
6. *Preamble*: The Constitution’s preamble outlines India’s commitment to democracy, socialism, secularism, and justice.
7. *Fundamental Duties*: Citizens have duties, such as respecting the Constitution and promoting harmony, in addition to fundamental rights.
*Reflecting Indian values and culture:*
1. Secularism and pluralism
2. Social justice and equality
3. Democratic principles
4. Protection of minority rights
5. Emphasis on social welfare
The Indian Constitution’s distinct characteristics demonstrate its ability to adapt international principles to India’s unique context, creating a robust framework for governance and social justice.
The provided answer effectively outlines the influences on the Indian Constitution and its distinct characteristics. However, there are areas for improvement.
Dear Sangeeta You Can Aslo Use This Feedback
1. Structure and Clarity: The answer is well-structured, clearly separating influences and distinct characteristics. This clarity aids comprehension.
2. Depth of Explanation: While the influences are listed, the answer could benefit from brief explanations of how each influence specifically manifests within the Indian Constitution. For instance, stating how the parliamentary system from the UK functions in India would provide deeper insight.
3. Missing Facts and Data:
Length: The answer does not mention that the Indian Constitution is the longest written constitution in the world, which is a significant distinction.
Sovereignty: It lacks discussion on the principle of constitutional sovereignty, particularly how Parliament can amend but not replace the Constitution (Article 368).
Integrated Judiciary: The unique aspect of having a unified judiciary that enforces both central and state laws could be highlighted.
Specific Examples: More specific examples of social and economic rights (like the right to education) and how they differ from other constitutions would strengthen the argument.
4. Conclusion: The conclusion could be more impactful by summarizing the significance of these characteristics in ensuring effective governance and social justice in India.
Overall, the answer provides a solid foundation but would benefit from additional details and clarity on certain points.
Constitution is to provide a set of basic rule that allows for for minimal coordination among member a society.
✔️ Indian constitution is the biggest constitution in the world.
*Constitution Adapted on : Nov 26,1949
The Constitution of India is copied some experts say. Dr Ambedkar said that even though people say that, there is a difference in the Indian Constitution.
What was taken from whom?
✔️USA – Fundamental Right, impeachment of President, removal of sc and hc high court, post of voice president .
✔️British Constitution – single citizenship , parliamentary government, prerogative writ. Cabinate system.
✔️Government of india Act 1935: emergency provision , service commission , federal scheme, judiciary system.
✔️Irish Constitution – DPSP, nominated member RS, election method of president.
✔️Canadian Constitution: federation with strong center, governor appointment by center, advisor judiciary supreme court.
✔️Australia Constitution: concurrent list , freedom trade, parliamentary joint sitting.
✔️Germany Constitution : suspended FR during emergency.
✔️Russia Constitution: Fundamental duties , (social , economical, political) in preamble.
✔️French Constitution: Liberty, equality, fraternity in preamble.
✔️South african Constitution: procedure of amendment in constitution, election of members RS.
✔️Japan Constitution: procedure Established by law.
👉Although the Constitution of India has adopted the above from other countries, it is different.
👉in USA Constitution Article is 7 , and India is 448 Article , indian constitution is quasi federal , USA constitution is strictly federal.
👉India has amended the Fundamental Rights through various constitutional amendments.
👉42 th constitutional amendment , in 1976 enshrined the fundamental duty.
👉 India is a country of various communities and for that the distinction is seen in the constitution. If there is a violation of human rights, the person can go to the High Court and not only to the Supreme Court.
The provided answer outlines the influences on the Indian Constitution and highlights its unique characteristics. However, it could be improved in several ways.
Dear Rahul You Can Also Use This Feedback
1. Structure and Clarity: The response lacks a clear structure, which can make it difficult for the reader to follow. It would benefit from headings or bullet points to separate influences and distinct characteristics.
2. Detail and Cohesion: While the answer lists various borrowed elements, it does not explain how these influences are integrated into the Indian context. Brief descriptions of each influence’s impact on the Constitution would enhance understanding.
3. Missing Facts and Data:
Length of the Constitution: The answer mentions that India has 448 articles but does not clarify that it is the longest written constitution in the world, which is a significant fact.
Constitutional Sovereignty: There is no mention of constitutional sovereignty, which is pivotal in understanding the limitations of parliamentary power in amending the Constitution.
Integrated Judiciary: The answer does not discuss the unique feature of India’s integrated judicial system, which enforces laws uniformly across the country.
Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSPs): More emphasis on the role and significance of DPSPs in promoting social justice would strengthen the argument.
4. Conclusion: The response lacks a concluding statement that ties together the discussion, emphasizing the synthesis of borrowed elements and unique characteristics.
Overall, while the answer provides valuable information, enhancing its coherence and depth would significantly improve its effectiveness.
The Indian Constitution: A Blend of Borrowed Features and Unique Characteristics:
Introduction
The Indian Constitution adopted on January 26, 1950, reflects the values and aspirations of India. It forms the basis of the world’s largest democracy, which lays down the framework for governance, justice, and the freedom of individuals. The Indian Constitution is adapted in a unique way to the specific socio-political needs of the country despite it borrowing from several other constitutions.
Borrowed Features
India’s Constitution, borrowing the concepts and amalgamating them as the Indian nation felt for such a society of heterogeneity:
2. Fundamental Rights and Judiciary: U.S. influenced the principles governing India’s Fundamental Rights articulated in Articles 12 through 35, coupled with judicial independence.
3. Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity: Principles from France are adopted in the Preamble, which is part of democratic values.
4. Federalism: The federalism of India was borrowed from Canada and is somewhat distinctive, which provides regional units with a fair degree of autonomy but a strong Centre (Articles 1-4).
5. Directive Principles of State Policy: The concept of DPSPs was adopted from Ireland, where it directs the state to make welfare for the people its ultimate objective (Articles 36-51).
6. Social and Economic Justice: This concept was borrowed from the USSR, where social and economic development is considered necessary to provide equality in all walks of life.
Distinctive Features
While incorporating all these, the Indian Constitution also stands out for quite a few distinctive features:
1. Length and Detail: With 395 articles in the beginning (now 470), it is the world’s lengthiest constitution, reflecting India’s complexity of needs and diversity.
2. Constitutional Sovereignty: The Constitution holds absolute authority; Parliament can amend it but cannot replace it (Article 368), constituting constitutional supremacy.
3. In a nutshell, Conditional Fundamental Rights: Unlike the United States, rights in India have reasonable restrictions (Articles 12-35). These maintain freedom along with social order.
4. Federalism with Unitary Bias: There is a bias towards strong center in India’s federalism, especially in matters related to emergencies (Article 356). This gives it the opportunity to unite itself on a particular issue when facing a crisis.
5. Judicial Unity: The judiciary is completely integrated. Central laws are enforced uniformly throughout the state, and state laws across the country (Articles 124-147).
It covers economic, social, and administrative objectives of DPSPs in India from Articles 36-51 for the purpose of promotion of welfare beyond mere economic rights.
Conclusion
It is a mixture of borrowed principles and original adaptations that make the document uniquely suitable for India’s needs. The balance reflects the wisdom of its draftsmen in drafting a constitution which is flexible and stable to form a framework for the varied and constantly changing Indian society. The structure and principles ensure its continued applicability, making it the epitome of the ideal just and inclusive India.
The provided answer effectively outlines the borrowed features of the Indian Constitution and its distinctive characteristics. However, there are several areas for improvement:
Dear Anita You Can Also Use This Feedback
1. Clarity and Structure: The answer is generally well structured, but the use of headings for each section (borrowed features and distinctive features) would enhance clarity. Bullet points for key features could also improve readability.
2. Specificity and Detail While the answer identifies several borrowed features, it could benefit from brief explanations of how these features are uniquely adapted to fit the Indian context. Providing examples or implications of these adaptations would strengthen the argument.
3. Missing Facts and Data:
Constitutional Sovereignty: The answer mentions Article 368 but does not clarify that this article allows for constitutional amendments while preserving the Constitution’s basic structure.
Emergency Provisions: While Article 356 is referenced, a brief mention of the implications of such provisions on federalism would add depth.
Fundamental Duties: The answer does not mention that Fundamental Duties were incorporated by the 42nd Amendment in 1976, which is a unique feature compared to many other constitutions.
Judicial Review: Mentioning the concept of judicial review, which is crucial in maintaining the supremacy of the Constitution, would enhance the discussion on the judiciary.
4. Conclusion: The conclusion reiterates the main points well but could more explicitly connect the features back to how they reflect India’s unique socio-political landscape.
Overall, while the answer is informative and covers many essential aspects, adding more detail and context would improve its comprehensiveness and impact.
Model Answer
Unique Characteristics of the Indian Constitution
The Indian Constitution, while incorporating elements from various countries, stands out due to its distinctive features and the context in which it was crafted.
Length and Structure
One of the most notable aspects of the Indian Constitution is its length. Initially consisting of 395 articles and currently expanded to 470, it is the lengthiest written constitution in the world. In contrast, the U.S. Constitution has only seven articles, and the Australian Constitution contains 128 articles. This comprehensive nature reflects India’s diverse socio-political landscape (Source: Indian Constitution).
Constitutional Sovereignty
India’s Constitution embodies the principle of constitutional sovereignty, asserting that the Constitution itself, not Parliament, holds ultimate authority. Unlike the UK, where Parliament is sovereign, the Indian Parliament can amend the Constitution but cannot create a new one, especially without upholding its basic structure (Source: Constitution of India, Article 368).
Fundamental Rights
The Fundamental Rights enshrined in the Indian Constitution are not absolute; they come with restrictions aimed at balancing individual liberties with social interests. This contrasts with the U.S. Constitution, where rights are typically guaranteed without limitations (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 12-35).
Federalism with Unitary Bias
India’s federal system is influenced by Canada but has a unique unitary bias. While states have defined powers, the Centre can assume greater authority during emergencies, illustrating a balance of power that is distinct from other federal systems (Source: Constitution of India, Article 356).
Integrated Judiciary
The Indian judiciary is characterized by its integrated nature, where both central and state laws are enforced under a single judicial framework, headed by the Supreme Court. This differs from the U.S. system, which separates federal and state jurisdictions (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 124-147).
Directive Principles of State Policy
The Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSPs) in India encompass a broader scope than in many other countries, addressing economic, social, and administrative rights, thereby reflecting a commitment to socio-economic justice (Source: Constitution of India, Articles 36-51).
In conclusion, the Indian Constitution is not merely a compilation of borrowed elements; it is a unique document crafted with foresight to meet the needs of a diverse nation. Its distinctive features highlight the innovative spirit of its framers, tailored specifically for India’s socio-political context.
The constitution of the India adopted in 1950, is an integral document that decides the principles and frames for governance in India. In fact, though it has taken inspiration from the features of a number of other nations’ constitutions, it has been uniquely adapted to fit the diverse socio-political landscape of India itself.
India simply borrowed the parliamentary system from Britain, Fundamental Rights and judicial review from America, liberty, equality, and fraternity from France, a quasi-federal structure from Canada, DPSPs from Ireland, and socio-economic justice principles from the USSR. All these reflect a global approach to filling the governance vacuum in India.
But what makes the Indian Constitution distinct is its peculiar characteristic. It is one of the longest constitutions with a detailed structure of now 470 articles. The sovereignty of the Constitution lies totally in itself; Parliament can amend it but cannot replace it. Rights under the Constitution are conditioned by reasonable restrictions, which does not apply under the U.S. Constitution and thereby reflects India’s balance between liberty and social order. It has a federalism with unitary bias, allowing a strong central authority in emergencies and an integrated judicial system that is applicable to both central and state laws.
This flexibility has demonstrated that the draftsmen intended a living, inclusive Constitution that was specially designed for India’s varied and changing needs.
The answer provides a clear overview of the Indian Constitution’s borrowed features and its unique characteristics. However, there are several areas for improvement:
Dear Shivamx You Can Also Use This Feedback
1. Clarity and Structure: The answer would benefit from clearer organization. Using headings or bullet points for the borrowed features and distinctive characteristics would enhance readability.
2. Detail and Depth: While the answer lists various influences, it could expand on how these features are uniquely adapted to the Indian context. For example, explaining the implications of the “unitary bias” in federalism would provide more depth.
3. Missing Facts and Data:
Constitutional Sovereignty: The mention of sovereignty is good, but it should clarify that Parliament can amend the Constitution only within the framework of its basic structure (Article 368).
Judicial Review: The answer could include details about judicial review, which is vital for maintaining constitutional supremacy.
Fundamental Duties: Mentioning that Fundamental Duties were included through the 42nd Amendment would highlight another unique aspect of the Constitution.
Emergency Provisions: A brief explanation of the implications of emergency provisions (Article 356) would clarify the central authority during crises.
4. Conclusion: The final sentence effectively summarizes the Constitution’s adaptability, but it could more explicitly connect back to how these adaptations reflect India’s unique socio-political landscape.
Overall, while the answer is informative and covers several essential aspects, adding more detail and structure would improve its comprehensiveness and clarity.
Introduction
The Indian Constitution adopted on January 26, 1950, is one of those basic documents describing the structural structure, powers, and functions of the different establishments of India. It had absorbed principles from many constitutional bodies around the world. Still, its outstanding characteristics made it stand unique among many other constitutions needed to serve a diversified country. It differs from several others, yet it remains similar at times.
Accepted Traits
Most of the features of the Indian Constitution borrowed from other constitutions. It adopted parliamentary system from UK under Article 79, fundamental rights from the US from Articles 12-35, ideals of liberty, equality, and fraternity from France in the Preamble, federal structure from Canada from Articles 1 to 4, Directive Principles of State Policy from Ireland from Articles 36 to 51, and socio-economic justice principles from USSR.
Unique Features:
1. Length and detail: The world’s longest written constitution, comprising 470 articles, covers many issues in detail.
2. Constitutional Sovereignty: As opposed to other countries, Parliament cannot abrogate the Constitution but only modify it (Article 368).
3. Fundamental Rights Conditioned: They are available with reasonable restrictions, an adaptation suited to India’s complex social landscape (Articles 12-35).
4. Federalism with Unitary Bias: Though federal in character, it permits central authority to become stronger in times of emergency (Article 356).
5. Integrated Judiciary: Under this, the integrated judiciary contains both central and state laws (Articles 124-147).
6. Vast DPSPs: With an emphasis on socio-economic justice, DPSPs frame state policies on welfare, social, and economic matters. Conclusion: In conclusion, the Indian Constitution, though inspired from many sources, is outstanding in its adaptability, depth, and vision tailored especially for India’s diversified requirements. The insight of the framers has made the constitution, though rooted in universal principles, distinctly Indian in spirit and application.
Introduction
The Indian Constitution adopted on January 26, 1950, is one of those basic documents describing the structural structure, powers, and functions of the different establishments of India. It had absorbed principles from many constitutional bodies around the world. Still, its outstanding characteristics made it stand unique among many other constitutions needed to serve a diversified country. It differs from several others, yet it remains similar at times.
Accepted Traits
Most of the features of the Indian Constitution borrowed from other constitutions. It adopted parliamentary system from UK under Article 79, fundamental rights from the US from Articles 12-35, ideals of liberty, equality, and fraternity from France in the Preamble, federal structure from Canada from Articles 1 to 4, Directive Principles of State Policy from Ireland from Articles 36 to 51, and socio-economic justice principles from USSR.
Unique Features:
1. Length and detail: The world’s longest written constitution, comprising 470 articles, covers many issues in detail.
2. Constitutional Sovereignty: As opposed to other countries, Parliament cannot abrogate the Constitution but only modify it (Article 368).
3. Fundamental Rights Conditioned: They are available with reasonable restrictions, an adaptation suited to India’s complex social landscape (Articles 12-35).
4. Federalism with Unitary Bias: Though federal in character, it permits central authority to become stronger in times of emergency (Article 356).
5. Integrated Judiciary: Under this, the integrated judiciary contains both central and state laws (Articles 124-147).
6. Vast DPSPs: With an emphasis on socio-economic justice, DPSPs frame state policies on welfare, social, and economic matters. Conclusion: In conclusion, the Indian Constitution, though inspired from many sources, is outstanding in its adaptability, depth, and vision tailored especially for India’s diversified requirements. The insight of the framers has made the constitution, though rooted in universal principles, distinctly Indian in spirit and application.
Distinct Characteristics of the Indian Constitution
The Indian Constitution is unique despite borrowing elements from various global constitutions. Here are some key features that set it apart:
1. Lengthy and Detailed Framework
2. Blend of Rigidity and Flexibility
3. Federal Structure with Unitary Bias
4. Fundamental Rights and Duties
Conclusion
In summary, while the Indian Constitution draws inspiration from various sources, its unique blend of length, flexibility, federal structure, and emphasis on rights and duties makes it distinct. This adaptability is vital for a diverse nation like India.