Roadmap for Answer Writing
1. Introduction (50-75 words)
- Briefly define illegal trans-border migration and its relevance to India.
- Mention the estimated number of illegal immigrants in India.
Relevant Facts:
- Over 2 million illegal immigrants reside in India, as per the Ministry of Home Affairs 2020 report.
2. Security Threats Posed by Illegal Trans-Border Migration (100-150 words)
- Terrorism and Infiltration:
- Explain how illegal migration facilitates terrorist activities.
Relevant Facts:
- The 2008 Mumbai attacks exemplified risks from infiltration (Ministry of Home Affairs).
- Crime and Insurgency:
- Discuss the relationship between illegal migration and increased criminal activities, including smuggling and human trafficking, particularly along the India-Bangladesh border.
- Social Unrest:
- Highlight historical instances of social tensions due to demographic changes, such as the Assam Agitation and violence against Sri Lankan refugees.
3. Strategies to Curb Illegal Trans-Border Migration (100-150 words)
- Enhanced Surveillance:
- Describe initiatives like the Comprehensive Integrated Border Management System (CIBMS) for improved border security.
- Legal Measures:
- Discuss the National Register of Citizens (NRC) and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), noting their potential humanitarian implications.
- Bilateral Cooperation:
- Emphasize the importance of cooperation with neighboring countries, citing the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement with Bangladesh.
4. Factors Driving Illegal Trans-Border Migration (100-150 words)
- Economic Opportunity:
- Explain how better economic prospects in India attract migrants from Bangladesh and Sri Lanka.
- Political Unrest and Conflict:
- Discuss the impact of political instability, such as the Sri Lankan Civil War, on migration trends.
- Environmental Factors:
- Highlight how climate change and disasters in low-lying regions of Bangladesh drive migration.
- Socio-Cultural Ties:
- Mention shared linguistic and cultural connections that facilitate integration, particularly among Sri Lankan Tamils in Tamil Nadu.
5. Conclusion (50-75 words)
- Summarize the security threats posed by illegal migration and the necessity of effective strategies.
- Emphasize the importance of addressing the underlying factors driving migration for sustainable solutions.
Threats of Illegal Transborder Migration to India’s Security:
1. National Security Risks:
2. Social and Economic Strain:
3. Border Management Challenges:
Strategies to Curb Illegal Transborder Migration:
1. Strengthening Border Security:
2. Legal and Policy Measures:
3. Socio-Economic Development:
Recent Examples:
Conclusion: Illegal transborder migration poses severe threats to India’s security, impacting national security, social stability, and resource allocation. Strengthening border security, implementing effective legal measures, and addressing socio-economic factors are essential strategies to curb illegal migration and mitigate its impacts.
Model Answer
Introduction
Illegal trans-border migration into India, particularly in states like Assam and Tamil Nadu, poses significant security threats. India’s diverse geography and economic opportunities attract illicit migration. A report by the Ministry of Home Affairs in 2020 estimated over 2 million illegal immigrants in India, with a substantial number residing in Assam and Tamil Nadu.
Security Threats Posed by Illegal Trans-Border Migration
Terrorism and Infiltration
Illegal migration can facilitate terrorist infiltration. The 2008 Mumbai attacks highlighted how militants exploited vulnerabilities in border security. Concerns have also been raised regarding connections between illegal Sri Lankan immigrants and militant groups like the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE).
Crime and Insurgency
There is a notable correlation between illegal migration and a rise in criminal activities. The India-Bangladesh border has become a hotspot for smuggling and human trafficking. In the North-Eastern states, unchecked migration has exacerbated insurgency issues.
Social Unrest
Rapid demographic changes due to illegal immigration have led to social tensions. Historical incidents, such as the Assam Agitation in the 1980s and recent violence against Sri Lankan refugees in Tamil Nadu, underscore the potential for unrest.
Strategies to Curb Illegal Trans-Border Migration
Enhanced Surveillance
India has improved border security through initiatives like the Comprehensive Integrated Border Management System (CIBMS), which employs technology for better monitoring. Coastal security in Tamil Nadu has also been strengthened to prevent illegal maritime migration.
Legal Measures
The government has implemented legal frameworks, such as the National Register of Citizens (NRC) in Assam and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA). However, these measures have sparked debate regarding their humanitarian implications.
Bilateral Cooperation
Strengthening cooperation with neighboring countries is crucial. The 2015 Land Boundary Agreement with Bangladesh represents a significant step towards addressing migration issues collaboratively.
Factors Driving Illegal Trans-Border Migration
Economic Opportunity
India’s relatively better economic prospects serve as a significant pull factor for migrants from Bangladesh and Sri Lanka.
Political Unrest and Conflict
Political instability, exemplified by the Sri Lankan Civil War, has driven many to seek refuge in India.
Environmental Factors
Climate change and associated disasters, particularly in Bangladesh’s low-lying regions, are increasingly influencing migration patterns.
Socio-Cultural Ties
Shared linguistic and cultural connections facilitate the integration of migrants, as seen with Sri Lankan Tamils in Tamil Nadu.
Conclusion
Addressing illegal trans-border migration requires a nuanced approach that balances security needs, socio-economic dynamics, and humanitarian concerns. The complexity of this issue highlights the necessity for comprehensive and sustainable solutions.