Regulatory and Policy Frameworks Governing New Technologies in India

India’s regulatory and policy frameworks for emerging technologies like drones and genetic engineering are evolving rapidly to address their complex challenges and opportunities. Here’s a critical examination of these frameworks:

1. Drones:

Regulatory Framework:

DGCA Guidelines: The Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) governs the use of drones through the Civil Aviation Requirements (CAR) issued in 2018. These guidelines cover operational safety, pilot licensing, and operational restrictions.
Unmanned Aircraft System Rules (UAS), 2021: This rule introduces a more streamlined framework for the operation of drones, including provisions for different categories of drones, operational permissions, and the National Drone Policy, which aims to encourage innovation while ensuring safety.
Recent Developments:

Digital Sky Platform: Launched by DGCA, this platform facilitates drone registration and permissions, aiming to simplify regulatory processes and improve compliance.
Drone Policy 2.0: Announced in 2021, this policy includes provisions for easing regulations on drone usage, expanding their applications in agriculture, infrastructure, and surveillance.
Challenges:

Regulatory Rigor: Balancing innovation with security and privacy concerns remains challenging. For instance, the use of drones for surveillance and delivery services raises privacy and safety issues.
Implementation Gaps: There are concerns about inconsistent implementation and enforcement of regulations across states, which can lead to confusion and regulatory lapses.
2. Genetic Engineering:

Regulatory Framework:

Gene Technology Regulations: The Department of Biotechnology (DBT) oversees genetic engineering through the Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee (GEAC). The guidelines regulate the research, development, and commercialization of genetically modified (GM) organisms.
Rules for the Manufacture, Use, Import, Export, and Storage of Hazardous Microorganisms/Genetically Engineered Organisms or Cells, 1989: This set of rules regulates the handling and safety procedures for GMOs.
Recent Developments:

GM Crop Approval: The approval of Bt cotton in India marked a significant step in the commercialization of GM crops. The government has been cautious with other GM crops, such as Bt Brinjal, reflecting ongoing debates about their impact on health and environment.
Genome Editing: In 2021, the Union Minister for Science and Technology, Dr. Jitendra Singh, emphasized the need for a robust framework to regulate genome editing technologies like CRISPR. These technologies hold promise for agriculture and medicine but require careful oversight.
Challenges:

Public Concerns: There is significant public resistance to GMOs, driven by concerns about food safety, environmental impact, and ethical issues. This resistance often influences policy decisions and regulatory approaches.
Regulatory Complexity: The multi-ministerial and multi-agency involvement in genetic engineering regulation can lead to a fragmented and sometimes cumbersome approval process. Streamlining this process while ensuring rigorous safety standards is a key challenge.
Conclusion:

The regulatory and policy frameworks for drones and genetic engineering in India are designed to foster innovation while addressing safety, privacy, and ethical concerns. Recent developments like the updated Drone Policy and the cautious approach towards GMOs reflect the dynamic nature of these regulations. However, ongoing challenges such as regulatory consistency, public apprehension, and complex approval processes need continuous attention to ensure that India can effectively harness the benefits of these new technologies while mitigating potential risks.