Home/upsc: moral thinkers & philosophers/Page 3
- Recent Questions
- Most Answered
- Answers
- No Answers
- Most Visited
- Most Voted
- Random
- Bump Question
- New Questions
- Sticky Questions
- Polls
- Followed Questions
- Favorite Questions
- Recent Questions With Time
- Most Answered With Time
- Answers With Time
- No Answers With Time
- Most Visited With Time
- Most Voted With Time
- Random With Time
- Bump Question With Time
- New Questions With Time
- Sticky Questions With Time
- Polls With Time
- Followed Questions With Time
- Favorite Questions With Time
Human beings should always be treated as 'ends' in themselves and never as merely 'means'. Explain the meaning and significance of this statement, giving its implications in the modern techno-economic society. (150 words)[UPSC 2014]
Meaning and Significance of Treating Human Beings as 'Ends' The statement "Human beings should always be treated as 'ends' in themselves and never as merely 'means'" emphasizes the intrinsic value of individuals. This ethical principle, rooted in Kantian philosophy, asserts that every person possessRead more
Meaning and Significance of Treating Human Beings as ‘Ends’
The statement “Human beings should always be treated as ‘ends’ in themselves and never as merely ‘means'” emphasizes the intrinsic value of individuals. This ethical principle, rooted in Kantian philosophy, asserts that every person possesses inherent worth and should be respected as an end in their own right, not merely as a tool for achieving other goals.
Implications in Modern Techno-Economic Society
In today’s techno-economic society, the application of this principle is crucial for ethical decision-making. For example, the rise of data-driven technology has led to significant privacy concerns. Companies like Facebook and Google use personal data to maximize profit, sometimes treating users as mere commodities. Here, the principle mandates that individuals’ privacy and autonomy must be upheld, emphasizing their value beyond mere data sources.
Moreover, the gig economy presents challenges where workers are often seen as flexible resources rather than valued contributors. Ensuring fair wages, job security, and proper working conditions reflects treating these workers as ends in themselves.
In summary, respecting individuals as ends involves prioritizing their dignity and rights over mere utilitarian gains, fostering a more ethical and humane society.
See lessIntegrity without knowledge is weak and useless, but knowledge without integrity is dangerous and dreadful. What do you understand by this statement? Explain your stand with illustrations from the modern context. (150 words)[UPSC 2014]
Understanding the Statement The statement highlights the interdependence of integrity and knowledge. Integrity without knowledge lacks effectiveness as it cannot be applied constructively. Conversely, knowledge without integrity can be perilous, as it may be used for harmful purposes. Integrity WithRead more
Understanding the Statement
The statement highlights the interdependence of integrity and knowledge. Integrity without knowledge lacks effectiveness as it cannot be applied constructively. Conversely, knowledge without integrity can be perilous, as it may be used for harmful purposes.
Integrity Without Knowledge
When integrity is not supported by knowledge, actions may be well-intentioned but ineffective. For example, nonprofit organizations run by individuals with strong ethical values but limited expertise may fail to address societal issues effectively.
Knowledge Without Integrity
Conversely, knowledge devoid of integrity can be dangerous. The misuse of advanced technologies such as AI and genetic engineering exemplifies this. If tech experts develop powerful tools without ethical considerations, it can lead to privacy invasions or biological risks. For instance, the Cambridge Analytica scandal showed how data knowledge was misused to manipulate public opinion, demonstrating the potential dangers of knowledge without ethical constraints.
Illustrations and Stand
The COVID-19 pandemic provides another example. Vaccine development required scientific knowledge but also demanded integrity to ensure transparent research and equitable distribution. Misuse or misinformation in this context could have led to severe public health consequences.
Thus, a balance between integrity and knowledge is essential to harness the positive potential of both while mitigating risks.
See lessMax Weber said that it is not wise to apply to public administration the sort of moral and ethical norms we apply to matters of personal conscience. It is important to realise that the State bureaucracy might possess its own independent bureaucratic morality. Critically analyse this statement.(150 words) [UPSC 2016]
Analysis of Max Weber’s Statement on Bureaucratic Morality 1. Distinction Between Personal and Bureaucratic Morality Personal Conscience vs. Bureaucratic Norms: Max Weber argued that applying personal moral and ethical standards to public administration is impractical. Bureaucratic morality, focusedRead more
Analysis of Max Weber’s Statement on Bureaucratic Morality
1. Distinction Between Personal and Bureaucratic Morality
Personal Conscience vs. Bureaucratic Norms: Max Weber argued that applying personal moral and ethical standards to public administration is impractical. Bureaucratic morality, focused on efficiency and adherence to rules, can sometimes conflict with personal ethics. For example, public officials might follow legal procedures strictly even if they conflict with their personal beliefs about justice or fairness.
2. Bureaucratic Independence and Its Implications
Efficiency Over Morality: Bureaucracies often prioritize procedural efficiency over personal moral considerations. This is evident in how government agencies operate under strict regulations to ensure consistency and predictability. For instance, the implementation of controversial policies like the National Register of Citizens (NRC) in India illustrates how bureaucratic efficiency can sometimes overshadow individual ethical concerns.
3. Practical Examples
Corruption and Accountability Issues: In some cases, bureaucratic systems may fail to address corruption due to adherence to established norms rather than ethical considerations. Recent examples include allegations of bureaucratic corruption and inefficiency in various countries, where adherence to procedural norms has sometimes hindered effective accountability.
4. Balancing Bureaucratic and Personal Morality
Integrating Ethics in Public Administration: While Weber’s argument emphasizes bureaucratic efficiency, integrating ethical considerations into public administration is crucial. Modern public administration increasingly seeks to balance efficiency with ethical standards, as seen in reforms aimed at increasing transparency and accountability in governance.
Conclusion
Weber’s assertion highlights the complexity of applying personal ethical norms in bureaucratic settings, where efficiency and adherence to procedures often take precedence. However, maintaining a balance between bureaucratic efficiency and ethical standards remains essential to ensure that public administration serves the broader societal good.
See lessEthics Case Study
a. “Ethics is knowing the difference between what you have the right to do and what is right to do.” - Potter Stewart This quotation emphasizes the fundamental distinction between legality and morality. Ethics often goes beyond mere compliance with laws and regulations; it involves making choices thRead more
a. “Ethics is knowing the difference between what you have the right to do and what is right to do.” – Potter Stewart
This quotation emphasizes the fundamental distinction between legality and morality. Ethics often goes beyond mere compliance with laws and regulations; it involves making choices that uphold moral principles. Potter Stewart suggests that having the legal right to perform an action does not necessarily make it ethical. For instance, a corporation might legally exploit tax loopholes to minimize its tax burden, but ethically, it may be seen as shirking its social responsibilities. Ethical decisions require individuals to consider the broader impact of their actions on others and society. Recent example: In the context of the Adani Group controversies, while some actions were legally permissible, there was significant debate over their ethical implications concerning environmental and social responsibilities.
b. “If a country is to be corruption free and become a nation of beautiful minds, I strongly feel that there are three key societal members who can make a difference. They are father, mother and teacher.” – A. P. J. Abdul Kalam
A. P. J. Abdul Kalam underscores the crucial role of family and educators in shaping an individual’s values and character. Fathers, mothers, and teachers are pivotal in instilling ethical values and a sense of integrity from a young age. Parents provide the foundational values and moral compass, while teachers reinforce these principles through education. For instance, the “Moral Science” curriculum in Indian schools is designed to instill ethical values among students. If these key societal members emphasize honesty and transparency, it can significantly contribute to a corruption-free society. Recent example: The emphasis on values-based education in schools, such as the introduction of “Value Education” programs, aims to build character and prevent future corruption.
c. “Judge your success by what you had to give up in order to get it.” – Dalai Lama
Dalai Lama encourages evaluating success not just by the achievements but by the sacrifices made to attain them. This perspective highlights that true success often involves personal cost and compromises. Success that is achieved by compromising values or harming others is less commendable. For example, whistleblowers often face significant personal and professional sacrifices, yet their actions are considered noble because they uphold ethical standards. Recent example: The Edward Snowden case, where Snowden sacrificed his career and personal freedom to expose governmental surveillance practices, illustrates this notion of success being measured by the sacrifices made in the pursuit of a higher ethical standard.
See lessCorruption causes misuse of government treasury, administrative inefficiency and obstruction in the path of national development. Discuss Kautilya's views.(150 words) [UPSC 2016]
Kautilya's Views on Corruption 1. Corruption and Government Treasury Misuse: Explanation: Kautilya, in his treatise Arthashastra, viewed corruption as a severe threat to the proper functioning of the state, leading to misuse of the government treasury. He warned that corrupt officials could depleteRead more
Kautilya’s Views on Corruption
1. Corruption and Government Treasury Misuse:
2. Administrative Inefficiency:
3. Obstruction in National Development:
Conclusion: Kautilya’s views on corruption highlight its detrimental impact on the government treasury, administrative efficiency, and national development. Addressing corruption is crucial for improving governance and advancing national progress.
See lessAnalyse John Rawls's concept of social justice in the Indian context.(150 words) [UPSC 2016]
John Rawls's Concept of Social Justice in the Indian Context 1. Theory of Justice: Explanation: John Rawls’s theory emphasizes "justice as fairness". It is founded on two principles: equal basic liberties for all and fair equality of opportunity, coupled with the difference principle, which allows fRead more
John Rawls’s Concept of Social Justice in the Indian Context
1. Theory of Justice:
2. Equal Basic Liberties:
3. Fair Equality of Opportunity:
4. Difference Principle:
Conclusion: John Rawls’s concept of social justice is relevant in the Indian context as it aligns with constitutional provisions and policies aimed at ensuring fairness, equality, and improving the conditions of the disadvantaged.
See lessDiscuss Mahatma Gandhi's concept of seven sins.(150 words) [UPSC 2016]
Mahatma Gandhi's Concept of Seven Sins 1. Wealth Without Work: Explanation: Gandhi criticized acquiring wealth without contributing to labor or service, which he saw as exploitative and unjust. Example: Modern-day corporate scandals, where executives receive exorbitant bonuses while exploiting workeRead more
Mahatma Gandhi’s Concept of Seven Sins
1. Wealth Without Work:
2. Pleasure Without Conscience:
3. Knowledge Without Character:
4. Commerce Without Morality:
5. Science Without Humanity:
6. Worship Without Sacrifice:
7. Politics Without Principle:
Conclusion: Gandhi’s concept of the seven sins emphasizes the need for ethical and principled behavior across various aspects of life, advocating for a harmonious balance between personal actions and societal impact.
See lessWhere there is righteousness in the heart, there is beauty in the character. When there is beauty in the character, there is harmony in the home. When there is harmony in the home, there is order in the nation. When there is order in the nation, there is peace in the world. – A. P. J. Abdul Kalam(150 words) [UPSC 2019]
Righteousness and Its Ripple Effect Righteousness in the Heart: When individuals uphold righteousness, their character reflects integrity and moral strength. For instance, Malala Yousafzai's commitment to education and gender equality exemplifies righteousness, inspiring global support for these cauRead more
Righteousness and Its Ripple Effect
Righteousness in the Heart:
When individuals uphold righteousness, their character reflects integrity and moral strength. For instance, Malala Yousafzai‘s commitment to education and gender equality exemplifies righteousness, inspiring global support for these causes.
Beauty in the Character:
A character shaped by righteousness fosters positive relationships and ethical behavior. Jacinda Ardern, New Zealand’s Prime Minister, is admired for her compassionate leadership and transparency, demonstrating how moral character enhances public trust and respect.
Harmony in the Home:
When families embrace values of respect and understanding, it leads to a peaceful and supportive environment. For example, the Nordic countries, known for their strong social values and family support systems, showcase how harmonious family dynamics contribute to overall societal well-being.
Order in the Nation:
Countries with internal harmony often exhibit stability and good governance. Bhutan’s Gross National Happiness approach emphasizes well-being and social harmony, contributing to its stable and ordered society.
Peace in the World:
Orderly nations contribute to global peace and cooperation. The Paris Agreement on climate change is a testament to how nations committed to righteousness and order can collaborate towards a common global goal, ensuring environmental sustainability and international peace.
This interconnected process illustrates how individual values impact broader societal and global harmony, leading to a more peaceful world.
See lessGreat ambition is the passion of a great character. Those endowed with it may perform very good or very bad acts. All depends on the principles which direct them. – Napoleon Bonaparte. Stating examples mention the rulers (i) who have harmed society and country, and (ii) who worked for the development of society and country. (150 words) [UPSC 2017]
Ambition and Its Impact on Society Great ambition can drive both positive and negative outcomes depending on the principles guiding it. Napoleon Bonaparte’s observation highlights that while ambition is a powerful trait, its impact is shaped by the ethical framework within which it operates. RulersRead more
Ambition and Its Impact on Society
Great ambition can drive both positive and negative outcomes depending on the principles guiding it. Napoleon Bonaparte’s observation highlights that while ambition is a powerful trait, its impact is shaped by the ethical framework within which it operates.
Rulers Who Harmed Society and Country:
Adolf Hitler’s ambition for an expansionist Aryan state led to the devastation of World War II and the Holocaust, causing immense suffering and loss of life. His extreme nationalist ideology and brutal policies resulted in one of history’s darkest periods.
Pol Pot, the leader of the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia, pursued radical ambitions of creating a classless agrarian society. His policies led to the Cambodian Genocide, where nearly 2 million people died due to forced labor, starvation, and execution.
Rulers Who Worked for Development:
Mahatma Gandhi‘s vision of a free and inclusive India was driven by his principles of non-violence and social justice. His leadership in the Indian independence movement promoted social reforms and economic self-sufficiency, leading to the empowerment of millions.
Nelson Mandela’s ambition for a post-apartheid South Africa guided his efforts towards reconciliation and nation-building. His leadership helped dismantle the apartheid system and foster a new era of democracy and social equality in South Africa.
These examples illustrate that while ambition can drive significant change, its outcomes depend greatly on the ethical principles and values guiding the ambitions of leaders.
See lessEthics Case Study
a. Abraham Lincoln’s Quote “The true rule, in determining to embrace, or reject any thing, is not whether it has any evil in it; but whether it has more evil than good. There are few things wholly evil or wholly good. Almost every thing, especially of governmental policy, is an inseparable compoundRead more
a. Abraham Lincoln’s Quote
“The true rule, in determining to embrace, or reject any thing, is not whether it has any evil in it; but whether it has more evil than good. There are few things wholly evil or wholly good. Almost every thing, especially of governmental policy, is an inseparable compound of the two; so that our best judgment of the preponderance between them is continually demanded.”
In the current context, Lincoln’s quote is relevant in evaluating complex policies. For example, COVID-19 lockdowns had significant economic drawbacks but were crucial for controlling the spread of the virus. The key is to weigh the overall benefits against the negatives. Environmental regulations may limit industrial freedom but protect natural resources, showcasing a balance where the greater good is prioritized despite inherent trade-offs. This approach emphasizes that effective governance often requires nuanced decisions, balancing the mixed nature of most policies.
b. Mahatma Gandhi’s Quote
“Anger and intolerance are the enemies of correct understanding.”
Gandhi’s quote highlights the importance of maintaining calm and open dialogue. In today’s highly polarized political climate, anger and intolerance often cloud discussions on sensitive issues like citizenship laws or farmers’ protests. Constructive dialogue and understanding require setting aside anger to engage in meaningful debate and find common ground. For instance, recent debates on social media often escalate into heated arguments, impeding rational discourse. Managing emotions and fostering tolerance is essential for effective problem-solving and societal harmony.
c. Tirukkural’s Quote
“Falsehood takes the place of truth when it results in unblemished common good.”
Tirukkural’s quote can be seen in practices where strategic simplifications are used for public benefit. For instance, during emergency situations like the Ukrainian war or COVID-19 pandemic, governments sometimes present a controlled narrative to avoid panic, even if it involves withholding some information. This approach aims to maintain public order and safety, reflecting the idea that minor distortions may be acceptable if they ensure the greater good. However, it is crucial that such practices are transparent and do not lead to long-term mistrust or harm.
See less