Examine India’s worries about energy security and its collaboration with its neighbors, especially about hydropower, oil, and gas. Talk about how India’s energy diplomacy in the area affects geopolitics.
Former PM A.B. Vajpayee once famously said ‘You can change your friends but not neighbours’. For India to play a vital role in the emerging multipolar world politics, it is important to develop enduring linkages between its domestic priorities and its foreign policy objectives. India’s policy towardRead more
Former PM A.B. Vajpayee once famously said ‘You can change your friends but not neighbours’. For India to play a vital role in the emerging multipolar world politics, it is important to develop enduring linkages between its domestic priorities and its foreign policy objectives. India’s policy towards its immediate neighbourhood is based on efforts to build peace and cooperation in South Asia. Its neighbourhood first policy accords primacy to nations in the periphery with a focus on encouraging trade, connectivity and people-to-people contact.
India’s Neighbourhood First Policy
- Immediate priority to neighbours: Priority is to improve the relations with immediate neighbours as peace and tranquillity in South Asia is essential for realizing the development agenda.
- Dialogue: It focuses on vigorous regional diplomacy by engaging with neighbouring nations and building political connectivity through dialogue. The first initiative in this direction was extending an invitation to all heads of government of SAARC countries for the oath-taking ceremony of the Prime minister in 2014.
- Resolving bilateral issues: The focus is on resolving bilateral issues through mutual agreement. For instance, India and Bangladesh have signed a pact to operationalise the historic Land Boundary Agreement (LBA).
- Economic Cooperation: It focuses on enhancing trade ties with neighbours. India has participated and invested in SAARC as a vehicle for development in the region. One such example is the Bangladesh-Bhutan-India-Nepal (BBIN) grouping for energy development i.e. motor vehicles, waterpower management and inter-grid connectivity.
- Technical Cooperation: The policy put emphasis on technical cooperation. Recently a dedicated SAARC satellite was developed to share the fruits of technology like telemedicine, elearning etc. with people across South Asia.
- Disaster management: India’s offer cooperation on disaster response, resource management, weather forecasting and communication and also capabilities and expertise in disaster management for all South Asian citizens. For example, India provided immense assistance to its neighbour Nepal in the aftermath of the 2016 earthquake.
The Growing Influence Of China
- Afghanistan: Beijing was a part of the trilateral China-Pakistan-Afghanistan foreign ministers dialogue which focuses on facilitating Afghan domestic political reconciliation, enhancing regional connectivity, and improving regional common development. The trilateral discussions also agreed to push “forward under the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)” and “to enhance connectivity by extending the CPEC to Afghanistan”.
- Bangladesh: China and Bangladesh pledged to deepen defence cooperation, especially in the areas of “defence industry and trade, training, equipment and technology. China is also the largest arms supplier of the Bangladeshi military, providing 71.8% of weapons from 2008 to 2018.
- Maldives: China’s relationship with the Maldives is near-exclusively focused on leveraging BRI to develop the Maldives as well as to raise Chinese influence there to counter India.
- Nepal: Chinese President went to Nepal in 2019. This was the first visit by a Chinese head of state in 23 years. The countries have signed agreements to accelerate Infrastructure building in Nepal and improve connectivity between them. Both the countries have also announced the launch of a feasibility study of the China-Nepal cross-border railway.
- Sri Lanka: Sri Lanka handed over Hambantota port on a 99-year lease to China to repay its loan back to china. Hambantota is geostrategically located on the Indian Ocean, potentially bolstering Beijing’s String of Pearls.
India Response
1.India’s response to the challenges has been to assert its Neighbourhood First and SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region) strategies as foreign policy priorities. 2.India has also upped its game on infrastructure delivery, particularly for regional connectivity in the past year. This includes :
- Completing railway lines to Bangladesh and Nepal.
- Riverine projects, ferry service to the Maldives.
- Identifying other services to Sri Lanka and IOR islands.
- Also considering debt waiver requests from its neighbours.
Way Forward
- India does not have the economic capacity as that of China yet. Thus it should cooperate with China (with the exception of CPEC) for the development of these countries such that fruits of development collectively reach South Asia.
- Further India should invest in these countries where China falls short and maintain its goodwill in South Asia and prevent these nations from slipping off from India’s Influence.
- India should work with its neighbour in strengthening its markets and its own infrastructure to its neighbours.
- India must ensure its neighbour continuous support for their development. Efforts must be made to strengthen Indian exports in the region.
- Soft power: India’s soft power and common culture provide an opportunity for India to strengthen its cultural roots further in the region.
- Improving Regional Connectivity: Regional connectivity must be pursued with greater vigour while security concerns are addressed through cost-effective, efficient and reliable technological measures which are in use in other parts of the world.
Although there are complex challenges and situations, neighbourhood first policy must be anchored in the sustained engagement at all levels of the political and people to people levels, building upon the deep cultural affinities which are unique to India’s relations with its neighbours. India’s immediate neighbourhood directly impacts it geopolitically, geo-strategically and geo-economically because of its vicinity. Thus, working with them is important for India to rise as a superpower. Emphasis must be on sustainable and inclusive development.
See less
India's energy security concerns and cooperation with its neighbors, particularly in hydropower, oil, and gas, are crucial aspects of its foreign policy and regional dynamics. Here’s an analysis of these issues and their geopolitical implications: Energy Security Concerns Dependency on Imports: OilRead more
India’s energy security concerns and cooperation with its neighbors, particularly in hydropower, oil, and gas, are crucial aspects of its foreign policy and regional dynamics. Here’s an analysis of these issues and their geopolitical implications:
Energy Security Concerns
Dependency on Imports:
Oil and Gas: India is heavily dependent on imported oil and gas to meet its energy demands. Most of these imports come from the Middle East, making India vulnerable to geopolitical tensions in that region.
Hydropower: India’s northeastern states rely significantly on hydropower, with potential for development in neighboring countries like Bhutan and Nepal.
Diversification of Energy Sources:
India aims to diversify its energy sources to enhance energy security. This includes expanding renewable energy capacity, nuclear energy, and exploring regional cooperation for hydropower development.
Infrastructure and Connectivity:
Improved infrastructure and connectivity are essential for efficient energy transmission and trade. Projects like the India-Myanmar-Thailand Trilateral Highway and the TAPI (Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India) pipeline are examples of initiatives to enhance regional energy cooperation.
Cooperation with Neighbors
Hydropower Cooperation:
Bhutan: India has a long-standing cooperation with Bhutan in hydropower generation. Projects like the Chukha, Tala, and Punatsangchhu dams supply electricity to India, contributing to Bhutan’s economy.
Nepal: India is exploring opportunities for hydropower projects in Nepal, aiming to enhance mutual benefits through energy trade and infrastructure development.
Oil and Gas Cooperation:
Iran: India has historical and strategic energy ties with Iran, including the development of the Chabahar Port and energy projects. Sanctions on Iran have impacted bilateral energy cooperation.
Central Asia: India is involved in projects like the TAPI pipeline and partnerships with countries like Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan for energy cooperation.
Geopolitical Implications of India’s Energy Diplomacy
Regional Influence:
Energy diplomacy enhances India’s influence in neighboring countries by fostering economic ties and mutual dependency. Projects like hydropower in Bhutan and potential gas pipelines with Central Asia strengthen India’s regional presence.
Mitigating Chinese Influence:
India’s energy engagements in the region also serve as a counterbalance to China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), which includes significant energy infrastructure projects. For instance, India’s involvement in Chabahar counters China’s investments in Gwadar.
Geopolitical Stability:
Energy cooperation promotes stability by addressing energy deficits and fostering economic development in neighboring countries. Stable energy supply reduces potential for conflicts over resources and enhances regional security.
Challenges and Risks:
Political instability, cross-border tensions, and regulatory challenges in neighboring countries pose risks to energy projects. Delays in project implementation and geopolitical tensions can impact India’s energy security plans.
See lessConclusion
India’s energy security concerns and cooperation with its neighbors in hydropower, oil, and gas are integral to its foreign policy objectives. By diversifying energy sources, enhancing regional infrastructure, and fostering cooperation with neighboring countries, India aims to strengthen its energy security and regional influence. Geopolitically, these efforts help mitigate vulnerabilities, counterbalance rival influences, and contribute to stability and economic development in South Asia and beyond. However, managing geopolitical complexities and addressing challenges in project implementation remain critical for India’s energy diplomacy to effectively serve its strategic interests in the region.