Home/upsc: challenges of corruption
- Recent Questions
- Most Answered
- Answers
- No Answers
- Most Visited
- Most Voted
- Random
- Bump Question
- New Questions
- Sticky Questions
- Polls
- Followed Questions
- Favorite Questions
- Recent Questions With Time
- Most Answered With Time
- Answers With Time
- No Answers With Time
- Most Visited With Time
- Most Voted With Time
- Random With Time
- Bump Question With Time
- New Questions With Time
- Sticky Questions With Time
- Polls With Time
- Followed Questions With Time
- Favorite Questions With Time
Although bribery is illegal and detrimental, public officials still demand bribes, and private sector executives are often tempted to pay them. In this context, discuss how corporations can establish a framework to eliminate the practice of offering kickbacks. (150 words)
Model Answer 1. Anticipate Bribery Risk Management should conduct thorough assessments to understand the motivations behind public officials' demands for bribes. By identifying these motivations, companies can propose lawful alternatives that align with their operational mandates, thereby reducing tRead more
Model Answer
1. Anticipate Bribery Risk
Management should conduct thorough assessments to understand the motivations behind public officials’ demands for bribes. By identifying these motivations, companies can propose lawful alternatives that align with their operational mandates, thereby reducing the temptation to engage in corrupt practices.
2. Account for Costs
Corporations must factor in the potential costs of avoiding bribery in their financial projections. This includes recognizing that refusing to pay bribes may lead to delays or loss of contracts. By transparently communicating these costs to investors, companies can foster a culture of ethical decision-making that prioritizes long-term integrity over short-term gains.
3. Identify New Markets
Certain markets, often referred to as “moon markets,” are notorious for corruption. Companies should assess whether these markets align with their ethical standards and consider withdrawing from them if necessary. While this may result in short-term profit losses, it ultimately contributes to building a more resilient and principled organization.
4. Gather Intelligence
Investing in intelligence gathering is crucial for identifying high-risk areas for bribery. For example, Coca-Cola utilizes data from Transparency International to map out bribery risks and strategically focus its anti-corruption efforts.
5. Recalibrate Performance Targets
To discourage employees from accepting kickbacks, companies should revise performance-based targets. For instance, GlaxoSmithKline eliminated sales targets after facing significant fines for bribery, while Novartis shifted its compensation structure to prioritize values and behavior over sales quotas.
6. Reporting Mechanisms
Establishing transparent reporting channels for bribery incidents is essential. Corporations should commit to openly addressing and reporting any instances of bribery, reinforcing their zero-tolerance policy against corruption.
By implementing these strategies, corporations can create a robust framework that not only deters bribery but also fosters a culture of accountability and ethical business practices.
See lessDo you agree with the view that corruption thrives in Indian society due to its social acceptance and its perception as aspirational? Discuss with examples. (200 Words)
Model Answer Introduction Corruption continues to be a major issue in India, deeply rooted in various sectors like politics, business, and governance. I agree with the view that corruption thrives in Indian society due to its social acceptance and the perception that it is aspirational, although recRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Corruption continues to be a major issue in India, deeply rooted in various sectors like politics, business, and governance. I agree with the view that corruption thrives in Indian society due to its social acceptance and the perception that it is aspirational, although recent shifts in public attitudes indicate growing resistance.
Social Acceptance and Aspirational View of Corruption
Corruption often creates an image of success, with individuals who accumulate wealth and power through corrupt means being admired. In many cases, achieving success “by any means necessary” is seen as a shortcut to wealth, normalizing unethical practices. This normalization is further reflected in the widespread acceptance of “speed money,” where bribes are seen as a practical way to expedite services or get things done. For example, in sectors like bureaucracy and police, corruption is seen as the only effective way to bypass systemic inefficiencies, creating a cycle that is hard to break.
Shifting Attitudes and Anti-Corruption Movements
However, over time, there has been a growing intolerance towards corruption in India. The India Against Corruption Movement in 2011 became a significant turning point, mobilizing public opinion and pressuring the government for greater accountability. As a result, legislative measures like the Right to Information Act (2005) and the Lokpal Act (2013) were enacted to combat corruption more effectively.
Corruption in Elections and Public Sentiment
Corruption has also become a key issue in Indian elections, influencing the political landscape. Public outrage over high-profile scandals, such as the 2G spectrum case, coal allocation scam, and allegations of “40% commission” governments, has led to electoral shifts, showing that the public is increasingly intolerant of corrupt practices.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while corruption thrives due to its social acceptance and perceived aspirational nature, there has been a marked shift in public sentiment toward greater accountability and the need for institutional reforms. Strengthening anti-corruption laws, promoting ethical leadership, and integrating ethics into education are essential for a long-term solution.
See lessEvaluate the effectiveness of these measures with justifications.
To evaluate the effectiveness of measures, it's crucial to understand which specific measures are being referred to. However, I'll provide a general framework that can be adapted to various contexts, with recent examples to illustrate the points. 1. Introduction: Evaluating the effectiveness of measRead more
To evaluate the effectiveness of measures, it’s crucial to understand which specific measures are being referred to. However, I’ll provide a general framework that can be adapted to various contexts, with recent examples to illustrate the points.
1. Introduction: Evaluating the effectiveness of measures involves assessing their impact, efficiency, and outcomes relative to their objectives. This framework can be applied to different types of measures, such as economic policies, environmental regulations, or public health interventions.
2. Economic Measures:
a. Economic Stimulus Packages: Recent Example: The Indian government’s Atmanirbhar Bharat Abhiyan (2020) aimed to boost economic growth post-COVID-19. Effectiveness: This measure provided liquidity support, enhanced credit facilities, and stimulus to MSMEs. Justification: The initiative helped stabilize the economy and supported small businesses, though the pace of recovery was uneven.
b. GST Implementation: Recent Example: Goods and Services Tax (GST) was implemented to streamline tax collection and reduce tax evasion. Effectiveness: GST has simplified tax structure and broadened the tax base. Justification: The introduction of GST led to increased compliance and revenue, though issues like compliance burden and IT glitches initially posed challenges.
3. Environmental Measures:
a. Plastic Waste Management Rules: Recent Example: Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2021, aimed to reduce single-use plastics. Effectiveness: The rules have led to improved waste segregation and recycling. Justification: Implementation has faced hurdles, such as lack of infrastructure and enforcement challenges, but public awareness and local initiatives have shown positive trends.
b. Carbon Pricing Mechanisms: Recent Example: India’s carbon market initiatives, like the National Clean Energy Fund, are designed to mitigate carbon emissions. Effectiveness: These mechanisms have incentivized renewable energy projects. Justification: While progress has been made, there is a need for more comprehensive and aggressive policies to meet long-term emission reduction targets.
4. Public Health Measures:
a. COVID-19 Vaccination Drive: Recent Example: India’s COVID-19 vaccination campaign aimed to achieve mass immunization. Effectiveness: Rapid vaccination rollout has significantly reduced COVID-19 cases and deaths. Justification: The drive’s success was marked by the administration of over 2 billion doses, though vaccine hesitancy and logistical challenges affected initial phases.
b. National Health Mission: Recent Example: National Health Mission (NHM) focuses on improving healthcare infrastructure and access. Effectiveness: NHM has expanded healthcare facilities and services in rural areas. Justification: Despite improvements, challenges remain in terms of quality and accessibility, especially in remote regions.
5. Conclusion: The effectiveness of measures should be continuously monitored and adjusted based on their outcomes and changing circumstances. Recent examples demonstrate both successes and areas needing improvement, highlighting the need for adaptive and evidence-based policy-making.
See lessSuggest more effective strategies to tackle this menace. (150 words) [UPSC 2015]
Effective Strategies to Tackle Modern Menaces Cybersecurity Threats: To address the growing threat of cyber-attacks, advanced encryption technologies and artificial intelligence-based threat detection systems are crucial. For instance, India's National Cyber Security Policy 2020 outlines measures toRead more
Effective Strategies to Tackle Modern Menaces
Cybersecurity Threats: To address the growing threat of cyber-attacks, advanced encryption technologies and artificial intelligence-based threat detection systems are crucial. For instance, India’s National Cyber Security Policy 2020 outlines measures to protect critical infrastructure and data. Strengthening public-private partnerships can also enhance cybersecurity resilience.
Climate Change: Combating climate change requires a multi-faceted approach, including a shift towards renewable energy sources and sustainable practices. The Paris Agreement emphasizes global cooperation to limit global warming. Countries should invest in climate adaptation technologies and enforce stricter emission regulations. For example, Denmark’s wind energy initiatives and India’s Solar Power Mission exemplify successful strategies in renewable energy adoption.
Global Health Crises: To manage global health threats, robust vaccination programs and international collaboration are essential. The response to the COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the need for rapid vaccine development and equitable distribution. Strengthening healthcare infrastructure and improving global health surveillance systems are vital for early detection and response. GAVI’s COVAX initiative demonstrates effective international cooperation for equitable vaccine access.
By implementing these strategies, we can more effectively address these contemporary challenges and enhance global resilience.
See lessIt is often said that poverty leads to corruption. However, there is no dearth of instances where affluent and powerful people indulge in corruption in a big way. What are the basic causes of corruption among people? Support your answer with examples. (150 words)[UPSC 2014]
Causes of Corruption among People Corruption is a complex issue that is not confined to poverty; it also pervades among the affluent and powerful. The basic causes of corruption are deeply rooted in human behavior, societal structures, and governance systems. 1. Greed and Desire for Power Greed andRead more
Causes of Corruption among People
Corruption is a complex issue that is not confined to poverty; it also pervades among the affluent and powerful. The basic causes of corruption are deeply rooted in human behavior, societal structures, and governance systems.
1. Greed and Desire for Power
Greed and the insatiable desire for more wealth and power often drive individuals to engage in corrupt practices. For example, the Vijay Mallya case is a significant instance where a wealthy businessman engaged in fraudulent financial activities, despite his already substantial wealth.
2. Weak Governance and Lack of Accountability
Inadequate governance structures and lack of accountability create an environment where corruption can thrive. The 2022 Chhattisgarh coal scam highlighted how loopholes in governance allowed powerful individuals to exploit resources unlawfully.
3. Social Acceptance and Cultural Factors
In some societies, corruption is socially accepted or seen as a necessary evil. This cultural acceptance perpetuates corrupt behavior across different social strata. The Telangana liquor scam of 2023 is an example where corruption was normalized in certain business circles.
4. Absence of Strong Legal Frameworks
Corruption often flourishes where there is an absence of strong legal frameworks or ineffective enforcement of existing laws. The Punjab sand mining scam in 2021 revealed how the lack of stringent regulations enabled powerful individuals to bypass the law.
5. Opportunities and Lack of Transparency
The presence of unchecked opportunities and lack of transparency in decision-making processes can lead to corruption. The Commonwealth Games scam in 2010, involving high-profile officials, underscored the role of opaque processes in fostering corruption.
In conclusion, while poverty may contribute to corruption, it is not the sole cause. Greed, weak governance, social acceptance, and the lack of strong legal frameworks are significant factors that lead even the affluent to indulge in corrupt practices.
See lessToday we find that in spite of various measures like prescribing codes of conduct, setting up vigilence cells/commissions, RTI, active media and strengthening of legal mechanisms, corrupt practices are not coming under control.
Evaluation of Existing Anti-Corruption Measures 1. Vigilance Commissions and Cells Effectiveness: Increased oversight on corrupt practices within organizations. Enhanced accountability and investigation capabilities. Justifications: Recent examples such as the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) haveRead more
Evaluation of Existing Anti-Corruption Measures
1. Vigilance Commissions and Cells
Effectiveness:
Justifications:
Challenges:
2. Right to Information (RTI)
Effectiveness:
Justifications:
3. Active Media
Effectiveness:
Justifications:
4. Codes of Conduct and Legal Mechanisms
Effectiveness:
Justifications:
Challenges:
Suggested Strategies to Tackle Corruption
1. Strengthening Whistleblower Protection
Strategy:
Justification:
2. Enhancing Digital Transparency
Strategy:
Justification:
3. Judicial Reforms
Strategy:
Justification:
4. Public Engagement and Education
Strategy:
Justification:
Conclusion: While existing measures have made some impact, enhancing whistleblower protection, adopting digital transparency tools, and implementing judicial reforms can provide a more comprehensive approach to combatting corruption effectively.
See lessWhistle-blower, who reports corruption and illegal activities, wrongdoing and misconduct to the concerned authorities, runs the risk of being exposed to grave danger, physical harm and victimization by the vested interests, accused persons and his team. What policy measures would you suggest to strengthen protection mechanism to safeguard the whistle-blower? (150 words) [UPSC 2022]
Policy Measures to Strengthen Protection for Whistle-Blowers 1. Legal Protections: Enact robust laws ensuring whistle-blower protection, such as the Whistle Blower Protection Act, 2014 in India. Amendments should include mandatory safeguards against retaliation and comprehensive legal recourse for wRead more
Policy Measures to Strengthen Protection for Whistle-Blowers
1. Legal Protections: Enact robust laws ensuring whistle-blower protection, such as the Whistle Blower Protection Act, 2014 in India. Amendments should include mandatory safeguards against retaliation and comprehensive legal recourse for whistle-blowers facing threats or harm.
2. Anonymous Reporting Channels: Establish secure, anonymous reporting mechanisms to protect the identity of whistle-blowers. Digital platforms should use advanced encryption to ensure confidentiality, as seen in the UK’s Public Interest Disclosure Act provisions.
3. Effective Enforcement: Implement stringent monitoring and enforcement measures to ensure the protection laws are adhered to. Regular audits and reviews should be conducted to verify the effectiveness of the protection measures.
4. Awareness and Training: Conduct widespread awareness campaigns and training programs for whistle-blowers and authorities to understand their rights and responsibilities, as demonstrated by successful initiatives in the European Union.
5. Support Systems: Provide psychological support and financial assistance to whistle-blowers facing retaliation. Examples like the Whistleblower Protection Program in the United States offer support services to safeguard and assist whistle-blowers.
6. Legal Aid: Ensure access to free legal aid for whistle-blowers to defend against retaliatory actions and pursue justice effectively, reinforcing the protective measures established by recent reforms in countries like Canada.
These measures, supported by strong institutional frameworks, can significantly mitigate risks and encourage more individuals to report corruption and misconduct.
See lessWith the help of appropriate examples, discuss the ethical challenges involved in policing in India. Also, highlight the reasons behind corruption in the police force.
Answer: Policing is essential for maintaining law and order and smooth functioning of the society. However, police officers in day to day life often face various ethical challenges as follows: Conflict between means and ends: Police officers often face the dilemma of whether to use wrong means to acRead more
Answer: Policing is essential for maintaining law and order and smooth functioning of the society. However, police officers in day to day life often face various ethical challenges as follows:
Reasons behind police corruption.
Thus, there is a need to ensure greater police accountability, better service conditions etc. to abate police corruption in India. Further, implementation of the Supreme Court directions on police reforms under the Prakash Singh case, 2006 enforcing transparent postings and appointments, political neutrality etc. can go a long way in ensuring ethics in police functioning.
See lessAlthough bribery is illegal and counterproductive, public officials still demand bribes, and executives in the private sector remain tempted to pay up. In this context, discuss ways in which corporations can build a framework to eliminate the practice of offering kickbacks.
Answer: Bribery refers to the offering, giving, soliciting, or receiving of any item of value as a means of influencing the actions of an individual holding a public office. A kickback is a form of bribery wherein an illegal commission is paid to someone typically in exchange for preferential treatmRead more
Answer: Bribery refers to the offering, giving, soliciting, or receiving of any item of value as a means of influencing the actions of an individual holding a public office. A kickback is a form of bribery wherein an illegal commission is paid to someone typically in exchange for preferential treatment. For example, a buyer receives kickbacks from a supplier in exchange for being issued a purchase order in preference over other suppliers whose goods or services may be of lower price or higher quality. Bribery may lead to lower profit margins, and returns, and lead to a decline in employee morale. Despite this, the World Bank reports that roughly one-third of firms around the world use kickbacks. Therefore, corporations must have a resistance plan in place to address this practice. Such a plan should be informed by the following:
An enlightened management must rely upon its products and services rather than bribery and kickbacks. Companies that create state-of-the-art products and strategies to sell them without bribes will help dismantle this age-old system that perpetuates poverty abroad and stifles creativity within.
See less