Evaluate the significance of India’s ties with Iran, especially in light of the US sanctions’ effects and the Middle East’s shifting geopolitical landscape. Talk about possible areas of collaboration, like energy, connectivity, and regional security.
Answer: The altering war in Ukraine and the lackluster military performance of Russia throughout the year has increased its dependence on China. A bulk of Russian energy exports are going to China, and the Chinese Yuan has emerged as an alternative currency for the payments to Russia. Also, recentlyRead more
Answer:
The altering war in Ukraine and the lackluster military performance of Russia throughout the year has increased its dependence on China. A bulk of Russian energy exports are going to China, and the Chinese Yuan has emerged as an alternative currency for the payments to Russia. Also, recently both countries signed two key agreements, Joint Statement on Deepening the Comprehensive Strategic Cooperative Partnership for the New Era and the Pre-2030 Development Plan on Priorities in China- Russia Economic Cooperation.
This increasing proximity between China and Russia, which is described by some experts as the ‘most consequential undeclared alliance in the world’, can have significant impact on India’s national interests as mentioned below:
- India-China border dispute: Both countries are locked in a border standoff in Ladakh and Arunachal Pradesh. India’s military arsenal mainly consists of Russian weapons and China is also receiving advanced Russian weapons and technologies.
- The deepening Russia-China alliance may hamper India’s interests, as Russia will be unwilling to put pressure on China or even take a supportive stand towards India in the border confrontation.
- India’s geopolitical trajectory: China-Russia alliance will influence the geopolitics of Eurasia as well as the Indo-Pacific and present difficult dilemmas for India as it is member of Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) as well as the US-led Indo-Pacific initiatives like the Quad.
- India-Pakistan: If Russia and China become true strategic partners, the possibility that Russia will get closer to Pakistan under China’s influence and the possibility of transfer of Russian arms/military technology to Pakistan via China cannot be ruled out.
- India’s interest in Central Asia: India’s economic and strategic interests in Central Asia and Afghanistan require an understanding of Chinese and Russian positions and possible coordination with both.
- UNSC Seat: On the question of UN reforms and India’s candidature for a UNSC seat, if Russia and China oppose it together, there would be a deadlock and India’s chances of a permanent seat on the UNSC will be hampered.
The Russia-China alliance and their competitive relationship with the West are reshaping the world around India. India needs to draw up following strategies to protect its interests.
- Relations with Russia: India needs to broaden and strengthen its relations with Russia as it is an important balancer vis-à-vis China. This can be done by expanding cooperation at the political, strategic, and economic levels. There are several areas where the two countries can cooperate such as Afghanistan, Central Asia and West Asia.
- Use multiple groupings: India needs to follow a policy of multiple alignments and multiple partnerships, engaging Russia and China both bilaterally and multilaterally in groupings like BRICS. Also, it needs to engage with other countries from Southeast Asia, Central Asia, Global South in forums like ASEAN, SCO, G20, to balance Russia-China dominance.
- Diversification of defence supplies: India should diversify its military equipment sourcing from western countries like USA, France, etc. while also focusing on defence indigenization to increase self-reliance.
While some argue that India needs the USA to balance the rising Chinese power, yet by cooperating with China on specific issues and maintaining its military ties with Russia, it should be able to achieve its national interests.
See less
Iran has shared borders with India before the partition and independence in 1947. There has been trade and meaningful interaction since ancient times sharing common features in language culture and traditions. The strategic location of Iran provides a connection to central Asia for India bypassing tRead more
Iran has shared borders with India before the partition and independence in 1947. There has been trade and meaningful interaction since ancient times sharing common features in language culture and traditions. The strategic location of Iran provides a connection to central Asia for India bypassing the routes blocked due to Pakistan and China. The economic and commercial ties rely on the import of Iranian crude oil by India. The US sanctions did hurt India’s energy security by stopping oil imports in 2019 but India’s Ministry of External Affairs resumed importing oil from Iran, Leveraging the Rupee-Rial Trade to bypass US sanctions.
The significance of the ties can be understood by the following points:-
1-Iran offers access to central Asia and also counterbalances China and Pakistan’s influence in the region.
2-India imports from Iran were USD 1.02 billion during 2023 of which the major portions were organic chemicals and oils.
3-Multilateral engagement by cooperation in regional organizations like SCO and IORA while balancing ties with Israel and Arab states displaying diplomatic agility.
4-The ties with Iran also display resistance to US pressure and the Rupee-Rial trade bypasses the US sanctions and strengthens the rupee while de-dollarisation in the process.
Possible areas of collaboration between India – and Iran are:-
Energy:– The commercial ties have traditionally been based on imports of Iranian crude oil. While the us sanctions reduced the imports from a staggering USD14 billion in 2018 to USD1.02 billion in 2023. Expanding the oil and gas imports and Indian firms’ willingness to invest in Iran’s energy sector will help both countries.
Connectivity:– The Chabahar port project is a significant part of India’s interests as it further connects with the international north-south corridor providing the shortest multi-model transportation route linking India Russia Europe Iran and central Asia.
Regional security:- India and Iran both face threats of Terrorism and hence it’s required to strengthen counter-terrorism cooperation and intelligence sharing.
Conclusion
See lessIndia’s ties with Iran help counter China’s interest in the region, and trade boost through the INSTC by reducing the logistical cost and time. A source of cheap and clean energy and despite us sanctions and shifting regional geopolitical dynamics India has strengthened itself into a global power prioritizing national interests and regional stability. Good ties with India help Iran by giving it access to the fifth largest economy to improve its national development and get investment to boost the economy and a better prospect at the international level hence advancing mutual interest and promoting stability across the region.