Examine the Inter-State Council’s contribution to the advancement of cooperative federalism in India critically. (125 Words) [UPPSC 2020]
Federal Structure in India: Accommodation of Diversity and Challenges Accommodation of Diversity: Division of Powers: The Indian federal structure, as defined by the Constitution, divides powers between the Central Government and State Governments. This allows states to have legislative and administRead more
Federal Structure in India: Accommodation of Diversity and Challenges
Accommodation of Diversity:
- Division of Powers: The Indian federal structure, as defined by the Constitution, divides powers between the Central Government and State Governments. This allows states to have legislative and administrative control over local issues and cultural matters, addressing their unique needs and aspirations.
- State Autonomy: States have the authority to formulate policies and enact laws on subjects listed in the State List of the Seventh Schedule. This enables regional governments to address local issues such as education, health, and transportation according to their specific requirements.
- Special Provisions: The Constitution includes special provisions for certain states and regions, such as Article 371 for North-Eastern states and Article 370 (now abrogated) for Jammu and Kashmir. These provisions grant additional autonomy and recognize regional uniqueness.
Challenges and Solutions:
- Regional Disparities: Differences in development levels and resources can create tensions. The Inter-State Council and the Finance Commission work to address these disparities by recommending equitable resource distribution and financial assistance.
- Center-State Relations: Conflicts arise over the division of powers. The Supreme Court plays a crucial role in resolving disputes and ensuring that federal principles are upheld.
- Demand for Greater Autonomy: Some states demand more autonomy, as seen in the Telangana agitation. The central government addresses these through negotiations, political agreements, and reorganization of states when necessary.
Conclusion: India’s federal structure accommodates diverse state needs through power distribution, special provisions, and mechanisms for addressing regional challenges. However, ongoing dialogue and judicial interventions are essential to manage conflicts and ensure harmonious federal relations.
See less
Role of the Inter-State Council in Promoting Co-operative Federalism 1. Purpose and Function: The Inter-State Council (ISC) was established under Article 263 of the Indian Constitution to promote co-operative federalism by facilitating dialogue between the Centre and states on issues of mutual conceRead more
Role of the Inter-State Council in Promoting Co-operative Federalism
1. Purpose and Function:
The Inter-State Council (ISC) was established under Article 263 of the Indian Constitution to promote co-operative federalism by facilitating dialogue between the Centre and states on issues of mutual concern. Its main role is to resolve disputes and coordinate policies.
2. Achievements:
The ISC has played a role in policy coordination, such as discussions on GST implementation and flood management. It serves as a platform for states and central government to address inter-state issues and ensure collaborative governance.
3. Criticisms:
However, its effectiveness has been questioned due to infrequent meetings and limited impact on major federal disputes. For instance, it had a limited role in the recent farm laws dispute, highlighting its ineffectiveness in resolving critical issues.
4. Recent Example:
In the context of COVID-19 management, while the ISC discussed various measures, state-central coordination often remained ad-hoc rather than systematically resolved through the council.
Conclusion:
See lessThe ISC aims to foster co-operative federalism, but its limited frequency and variable impact suggest the need for a more dynamic role in ensuring effective federal collaboration.