Senior citizen social security is still in its infancy. Analyze critically?
Elderly persons with disabilities face a complex array of challenges that are compounded by their intersecting identities and needs. Their situation requires a nuanced approach to ensure they have adequate access to healthcare, rehabilitation, and social welfare schemes. Here's an analysis of theirRead more
Elderly persons with disabilities face a complex array of challenges that are compounded by their intersecting identities and needs. Their situation requires a nuanced approach to ensure they have adequate access to healthcare, rehabilitation, and social welfare schemes. Here’s an analysis of their situation and an evaluation of the government’s efforts:
Situation of Elderly Persons with Disabilities
Healthcare Access:
Barrier to Services: Elderly individuals with disabilities often face barriers such as physical inaccessibility of healthcare facilities, inadequate transportation, and lack of tailored medical care.
Complex Health Needs: They may have multiple, chronic health conditions that require integrated and specialized care, which can be difficult to manage within existing healthcare systems.
Rehabilitation Services:
Limited Availability: Access to appropriate rehabilitation services can be limited, particularly in rural or underserved areas. There may be a lack of specialized professionals and facilities.
High Costs: Rehabilitation services can be expensive and not always covered by insurance or social welfare schemes, making them inaccessible for many elderly individuals with disabilities.
Social Welfare Schemes:
Inadequate Coverage: Social welfare schemes may not always adequately address the specific needs of elderly persons with disabilities, such as personalized care or adaptive equipment.
Complex Application Processes: The application processes for welfare schemes can be complex and difficult for elderly persons with disabilities to navigate, particularly if they have cognitive impairments or lack support.
Intersectional Challenges
Physical and Cognitive Limitations:
Accessibility Issues: Facilities and services may not be designed to accommodate physical disabilities, such as wheelchairs or mobility aids. Cognitive impairments can further complicate the ability to access and use services.
Communication Barriers: For those with sensory impairments (e.g., hearing or vision loss), communication with healthcare providers and social services can be challenging.
Economic Barriers:
Limited Financial Resources: Many elderly persons with disabilities may have limited financial resources, exacerbated by reduced earning capacity and higher healthcare costs.
Poverty and Social Exclusion: Disability and age-related factors can lead to increased risk of poverty and social exclusion, making it harder to afford necessary services and support.
Social and Psychological Factors:
Stigma and Isolation: Social stigma and isolation can negatively impact mental health and well-being, further complicating access to and utilization of healthcare and social services.
Lack of Support Networks: Limited family support and social networks can hinder access to services and reduce the effectiveness of available support systems.
Evaluation of Government Efforts
Strengths:
Policy Framework:
Legislative Measures: Governments have enacted various laws and policies aimed at improving the rights and welfare of elderly persons with disabilities, such as the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act.
Inclusion Initiatives: Policies promoting the inclusion of persons with disabilities in healthcare and social welfare systems have been established.
Programs and Schemes:
Subsidies and Financial Assistance: Financial assistance programs, pensions, and subsidies are available to support elderly persons with disabilities.
Specialized Services: Some governments have introduced specialized services and programs tailored to the needs of elderly persons with disabilities, such as adaptive devices and accessible facilities.
Challenges:
Implementation Gaps:
Inconsistent Application: There is often inconsistency in the implementation of policies and programs across regions, leading to disparities in access and quality of services.
Resource Constraints: Limited resources and funding can affect the availability and quality of specialized services and rehabilitation programs.
Accessibility Issues:
Infrastructure Limitations: Many healthcare facilities and social service centers are not fully accessible, and there may be insufficient focus on the needs of elderly persons with disabilities.
Awareness and Training: There may be a lack of awareness and training among healthcare providers and social workers about the specific needs of elderly persons with disabilities.
Bureaucratic Challenges:
Complex Processes: The application processes for social welfare and healthcare services can be complicated and difficult to navigate, particularly for those with cognitive or physical impairments.
Coordination Issues: Effective coordination between various government departments and agencies is often lacking, which can result in fragmented and inefficient service delivery.
Recommendations for Improvement
Enhance Accessibility:
Infrastructure Improvements: Ensure that healthcare facilities and social service centers are fully accessible to elderly persons with disabilities.
Adaptive Services: Develop and promote adaptive services and technologies to support the specific needs of elderly persons with disabilities.
Simplify Processes:
Streamline Applications: Simplify the application processes for social welfare and healthcare services to make them more accessible to elderly persons with disabilities.
Provide Assistance: Offer assistance with navigation and application processes for those who face difficulties.
Increase Funding and Resources:
Allocate Resources: Increase funding for specialized services and rehabilitation programs, and ensure equitable distribution of resources across regions.
Support Training: Invest in training programs for healthcare providers and social workers to better address the needs of elderly persons with disabilities.
Promote Awareness and Inclusion:
Public Awareness Campaigns: Conduct campaigns to raise awareness about the needs and rights of elderly persons with disabilities.
Foster Social Inclusion: Implement programs to reduce stigma and promote social inclusion, providing a supportive environment for elderly persons with disabilities.
By addressing these areas, the government can better support elderly persons with disabilities, improving their access to healthcare, rehabilitation, and social welfare schemes and ensuring they receive the care and support they need.
As per the report “Caring for Our Elders” by UNFPA India’s old age population( above 60) would grow from 8.6% in 2011 to 19% ( around 300 million) by 2050. This means India has to ensure healthy ageing with policy measures during this current beneficial period of demographic dividend. Social securitRead more
As per the report “Caring for Our Elders” by UNFPA India’s old age population( above 60) would grow from 8.6% in 2011 to 19% ( around 300 million) by 2050. This means India has to ensure healthy ageing with policy measures during this current beneficial period of demographic dividend. Social security could be said as the legislative or executive measure to support the vulnerable sections of society and is enshrined in Indian Directive Principles of State policy. Article 41 explicitly mentions the need to provide public assistance to the old age. Various initiatives have been taken to provide social security to the Indian senior citizens especially during this period of more Nuclear family and rural-Urban migration.
Major Schemes For Senior Citizens
Many of these schemes have improved the social perception about the need for senior citizen welfare. Also, schemes like IPOP have created an integrated chain of old-age care homes and NGO groupings across India. Creation of SCWF has allowed the utilization of unclaimed deposits of Public Provident Fund for senior citizens welfare. But despite these many schemes the social security of senior citizens in India is well below what’s needed and very much in the nascent stage.
Social Security Of Senior Citizens In Nascent Stage
A recent survey by Agewell Research and Advocacy Centre for the United Nations showed that around 51% of respondents were not satisfied with the overall status of social security schemes for the elderly in India. Around 53% of the elderly find it difficult in utilizing the social security schemes and 79% found these are not sufficient to meet their basic needs, which shows the amateur approach of addressing the old age population.
There needs to be a re-modelling of existing schemes and laws. Old age welfare by social security should not be accorded a peripheral position in the governance sphere and a Centre-state continuous discussion forum is needed. Recent amendments to Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens (Amendment) Bill, 2019 is a welcome initiative.
See less