Home/Biodiversity & Environment/Environmental Impact Assessment
Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
What role do environmental NGOs and activists play in influencing Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) outcomes for major projects in India? Cite four examples with all important details. (Answer in 150 words) [UPSC 2024]
Model Answer Introduction Environmental NGOs and activists play a crucial role in influencing Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) outcomes for major projects in India. Their involvement ensures that environmental considerations are integrated into decision-making processes, promoting sustainable dRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Environmental NGOs and activists play a crucial role in influencing Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) outcomes for major projects in India. Their involvement ensures that environmental considerations are integrated into decision-making processes, promoting sustainable development. Here are some key roles they play, along with four significant examples:
Roles of NGOs and Activists
Examples of Influence
Conclusion
Environmental NGOs and activists are vital in shaping EIA processes in India, ensuring that environmental sustainability is prioritized in major projects.
See lessEffective Strategies for Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)
Methods and strategies for conducting EIA for large-scale development projects: 1. Thorough Scoping: Define Project Limits: Clearly outline the spatial scope and time period of the project. Identify potential environmental and social economic impacts, direct, interactive, and cumulative ones. InvolvRead more
Methods and strategies for conducting EIA for large-scale development projects:
1. Thorough Scoping:
Define Project Limits: Clearly outline the spatial scope and time period of the project.
Identify potential environmental and social economic impacts, direct, interactive, and cumulative ones.
Involve key stakeholders in the scoping process to ensure their issues are accounted for.
2. Baseline data collection:
All baseline environmental, social, and financial situation data should be obtained through thorough data gathering.
This includes:
Biophysical features encompass soil properties, biodiversity (flora and fauna), air and water quality, hydrology, and temperature.
Socioeconomic factors encompass population, land use, cultural history, incomes, health, and social structure.
Data Quality: Employ appropriate techniques and quality control methods to ensure data integrity, reliability, and consistency.
3. Estimate of Influence and Evaluation:
Use Models and Techniques: Utilize applicable models and equipment-including GIS, spatial analysis, environmental impact prediction software-to predict and assess potential impacts.
Take into account Cumulative Impacts: Assess in conjunction with other existing and proposed developments within the region the cumulative impacts of the project.
Scenario analysis would allow you to analyze likely consequences across a range of possible development trajectories and in a variety of plausible future scenarios.
Mitigation measures and management strategies:
-Develop Effective Mitigation Plans: To avoid, minimize, or offset potential social and environmental impacts, develop and implement effective mitigation measures.
Formulate a detailed EMP outlining the actions to be taken, who is responsible for what, mechanisms for monitoring, and timeline of activities.
5. Public Participation and Consultation:
-Major interactions: Ensure effective public participation at every step of the EIA process, including:
-Early and continuous involvement: involve stakeholders at an early stage and continuously during.
-Accessible Information: Clearly, concisely, and accessibly present material to the public.
-Public Hearings and Discussion: Organize public hearings and discussions to let people express their opinion and so solve worries.
6. Control and Evaluation:
-Create Monitoring Projects: To compare the planned environmental and social effects of the project with reality, set up thorough monitoring plans.
Check that environmental laws and mitigation methods are followed.
Adaptive management is the process of continually assessing the effectiveness of mitigation measures and adjusting them as necessary based on monitoring data.
7. Follow-up and decision-making:
Transparent Decision-Making: Ensure a just and impartial decision based on EIA results.
-Follow-up and Enforcement: Ensure that the project is implemented in accordance with the approved EIA and that any necessary corrections are made.
Roles of stakeholders in ensuring adequate EIA:
Stakeholders are supposed to engage in the process of EIA actively through suggesting feedback, expounding their worry, and supervision of implementation processes of mitigation measure.
See less-Ensue Openness: Demand from the project proponent and regulation agency openness with liability.
-Assist Fierce Regulation: Strengthen strict regulation on the environmental issues and mean of enforcing this.
-Increase Capacity: Allow the local persons to understand how the EIA process is running and involve effectively.
Balance needed for economic growth with the necessity of preserving biodiversity, particularly in developing nations
Developing nations face a challenging dilemma to determine how they should balance their economic prosperity against biodiversity protection. A sustainable development plan with proper environmental protection policies helps reach this goal. 1. Policies for Sustainable Development Democratic leadersRead more
Developing nations face a challenging dilemma to determine how they should balance their economic prosperity against biodiversity protection. A sustainable development plan with proper environmental protection policies helps reach this goal.
1. Policies for Sustainable Development
Democratic leaders of government institutions need to incorporate environmental sustainability principles into their national economic plans. A combination of strengthening supportive policies focused on green infrastructure and eco-tourism and sustainable agriculture produces economic development alongside biodiversity protection.
2. Rewarding Conservation Efforts
Through PES the nations should offer financial compensation to local groups and industries to preserve their forests wetlands and animal habitations. Through carbon credit programs companies gain access to hard foreign currency by preserving their natural resources.
3. Promotion of green technology
An expedited economic development process will lead to less subsequent environment degradation. Every government in every nation must stand as support for their people and international organizations to supply needed funds and tools.
4. Legal Enforcement
Strict environmental regulations combined with elevated protected zones and active deforestation compliance frameworks provide long-term sustainability for preserving biodiversity. Strategic programs that include penalization systems against all unlawful forest extraction practices will prove essential.
5. Community Involvement and Local Knowledge. Local as well as indigenous communities involved in conservation efforts help ensure long-term sustainability. The knowledge of people in their local environment maintains ecological balance giving rise to locally managed conservation programs which create job opportunities for the community members.
6. International Cooperation and Financing
See lessDeveloped countries with support from the international community need to provide financial assistance as well as technological resources and expertise for developing countries to implement sustainable economic development plans. Financial shortfalls can be resolved thanks to the **UN Biodiversity Fund.
Environmental Science
The effects of climate change result in weather events that occur more frequently as well as reach more extreme levels of intensity. The rising worldwide temperature has caused heatwaves to repeat more often in addition to increasing in magnitude which increases heat-related mortalities and damagesRead more
The effects of climate change result in weather events that occur more frequently as well as reach more extreme levels of intensity.
The rising worldwide temperature has caused heatwaves to repeat more often in addition to increasing in magnitude which increases heat-related mortalities and damages to infrastructure.
Temperature rises lead to excessive moisture storage in air which results in larger precipitation quantities and flash floods and flooding hazards.
The consequences of more severe and repeated drought occurrences affecting agriculture, water resources and ecosystems will become noticeable in specific regions because of climate change.
More intense hurricanes. Hurricanes receive an excess of energy from warmer ocean temperatures that leads to stronger winds as well as increased rainfall amounts and bigger storm surge intensity.
Increased risk and severity of wildfires. Changes in temperature together with environmental conditions that lead to increased dryness and wind pattern modifications create favorable conditions for both greater frequency and higher intensity of wildfires.
Effects on Vulnerable Communities Mitigation
The implementation and enhancement of warning systems for severe weather should receive funding because such advances offer community members valuable notice time for evacuation arrangements.
-Disaster Preparedness and Response: Strengthen the plans for disaster preparedness and response, such as emergency shelters, evacuation routes, and community-based disaster response teams.
Public funds should be directed to build climate-resistant infrastructure which combines flood-proof construction with stronger protective sea barriers along with heat-resistant structural elements.
Social safety networks must receive stronger funding which enables them to help vulnerable groups affected by extreme weather events receive emergency and disaster relief with long-term recovery services.
Reducing environmental emissions and their sources for climate change mitigation requires transitioning from fossil fuels to renewable energy and raising energy performance levels and developing sustainable land management practices.
Community-Based Adaptation develops local people’s capabilities and gives them control to execute adaptation plans along with implementing local adaptation initiatives.
See lessForest Ecosystem
A drought of a severe nature in a forest ecosystem may cause a great effect on plant and animal species, causing significant changes to the food web. Effect on Plants Growth and Productivity: Drought stress slows down the growth rates of plants, results in smaller leaf sizes, and reduced photosyntheRead more
A drought of a severe nature in a forest ecosystem may cause a great effect on plant and animal species, causing significant changes to the food web.
Effect on Plants
Growth and Productivity: Drought stress slows down the growth rates of plants, results in smaller leaf sizes, and reduced photosynthesis. This affects their ability to produce biomass- the base of the food web that is made up of leaves, stems, fruits.
-Increased Death: Severe drought can cause a significant increase in tree deaths, especially the drought-sensitive tree species. The loss of vegetation decreases the overall plant biomass as well as shifts the forest’s structure.
Change in Species Population: Drought-resistant species would thrive while susceptible species decline in population, thus changing the plant community composition with time. Eventually, this change will alter the structure and the function of the ecosystem.
Nevertheless, seed production can be significantly reduced in many plant species due to drought, affecting recruitment of new individuals and long-term population dynamics.
Effects to Animals:
food scarcity: Herbivores are also directly affected by reduced growth and productivity of plants, thus leading to food shortages and greater competition for available resources.
Habitat Loss : Tree death, in turn, results in habitat loss for many species of animals that might be dependent on the death tree for food, shelter or as a nesting area.
Changes in Animal Behavior: Drought-stressed food is likely to change foraging patterns for animals that will respond to scarcity by changing breeding habits, some by moving to other locations.
Increased Susceptibility to Predation: Drought-stressed animals may become susceptible to predators.
Changes in the Food Web:
Decreases in Herbivorous Populations: Decreases in herbivorous populations may indicate reduced plant biomass and have direct implications for their predators, which feed on herbivores.
Changes in Predator-Prey Interactions: Changes in herbivorous populations may indicate changes in predator-prey relationships that may translate to population declines for some species of predators while increasing for others.
Cascading Effects: Such changes at the lower trophic levels, like plants and herbivores, may cascade into effects throughout the food web to higher-level predators, scavengers, and decomposers.
Increased Competition: Reduced resources can increase competition between species at all trophic levels.
See less5. Examine the impact of renewable energy adoption on national energy security and economic stability.
The introduction of renewable sources of energy, namely, solar, wind, and hydroelectric power, can enhance national energy security and, in turn, national economic stability as follows: While expanding energy independence allows nations to reduce their dependence on foreign oil, such diversificationRead more
The introduction of renewable sources of energy, namely, solar, wind, and hydroelectric power, can enhance national energy security and, in turn, national economic stability as follows:
While expanding energy independence allows nations to reduce their dependence on foreign oil, such diversification would make them less vulnerable to geopolitical instability, price shocks, and supply disruptions from international energy markets. For this reason, strengthening energy independence supports national security and reduces the country’s reliance upon such external energy shocks to trigger the overall vulnerability of its economy.
-Increased Energy Security: Renewable energy sources are more likely to be locally available. This makes their supply more dependable and secure compared to imported fossil fuels. Therefore, the risks of energy shortages resulting from geopolitical disturbances or supply disruptions are less likely.
Economic Stability
Lower energy costs: The electricity produced from solar and wind sources can be offered at lower long-term rates than from fossil fuel sources, and the cost is continuing to decline with technological improvements. This will save consumers and businesses money on energy bills, furthering economic competitiveness.
One of the reasons renewable energy supports job generation is through a job creation angle in manufacturing and installation, its maintenance, research, and development. This directly supports the economy through job stimulation.
– Savings from Reduced Environmental and Social Costs: Countries can save on environmental and social costs stemming from pollution, climate change, and fossil fuel extraction and transportation costs by reducing dependence on fossil fuels. It leads to enormous long-term economic benefits such as improvement in public health and curbed healthcare expenditure, agricultural productivity, etc.
– Sure, technological innovation: The investment in renewable energy technology creates innovation and technological advancement by opening new industries and economic opportunities that make a country even more competitive globally and boost its economy.
See lessInternational Relations
Public discourse continues to explore the possibility of an Arctic "scramble," as if it were some kind of a 19th-century scramble for Africa. Anti-Scramble for the Arctic: There are high reserves of oil, gas, minerals, and fisheries in the Arctic, giving the region a big resource potential and makinRead more
Public discourse continues to explore the possibility of an Arctic “scramble,” as if it were some kind of a 19th-century scramble for Africa.
Anti-Scramble for the Arctic:
There are high reserves of oil, gas, minerals, and fisheries in the Arctic, giving the region a big resource potential and making it one of the more interesting regions in which to extract resources.
In some sense, they are strategic avenues because they account for the meltage of the ice with sea and now one can take easier routes between Asia and Europe within less time while at the same time saving many costs. Very high international power competition is prevalent once again today, and many countries will battle to prove some relevance in such a region today.
-Climate Change: Climatic changes have altered the Arctics conditions so fast. This means vast opportunities exist there for extracting its resources and traversing its ocean routes, also spurring an element of contest for controlling this region.
Points Against a “Scramble for the Arctic”:
-International Cooperation: Through the inter-governmental Arctic Council, it is highly successful for building cooperation within the Arctic countries in terms of environmental protection, sustainable development etc.
Environmental Concerns: The Arctic is an extremely fragile system that easily falls victim to environmental destruction. International concern about the preservation of the Arctic environment and responsible development is rapidly on the rise.
Indigenous Peoples’ Rights: The rights and interests of indigenous peoples in the Arctic region are increasingly acknowledged and respected.
-Economic and Technological Challenges: Developing in the Arctic environment presents serious economic and technological challenges that could limit the speed of development.
Conclusion
Although the site and potential for conflict and competition over the Arctic region do exist, it is unlikely to be a direct replica of the 19th-century scramble for Africa. The factors that are likely to influence the future of the Arctic region include international cooperation, environmental concerns, and the rights of indigenous peoples.
See lessWhat are the ethical implications of the art market's role in the looting and illicit trafficking of cultural artifacts?
The ethical implication of looting and illicit traffic in the culture artifacts of art market is actually very huge because: The cultural loss is entangled with art market. To feed its gullible need for antiquated and priceless monuments, the art market incites looting as well as illegal traffickingRead more
The ethical implication of looting and illicit traffic in the culture artifacts of art market is actually very huge because:
The cultural loss is entangled with art market. To feed its gullible need for antiquated and priceless monuments, the art market incites looting as well as illegal trafficking that rob source countries from their own artifacts and disarrays historical and archeological scenarios.
-Profit from Plunder: The illegal trade in cultural heritage sometimes generates revenue for criminals who use such money for terrorism and organized crime, which fuels violence and instability in the source countries.
-Erosion of Trust: It erodes public confidence in the art market when respected auction houses and galleries are found selling looted antiquities, this will destroy the reputation of honest collectors and dealers.
-Ethical Concerns for Collectors: The acquisition of this artifact for collectors raises questions about ethical sourcing. How can one be certain that the artifact being purchased was acquired lawfully and ethically?
-Repatriation Challenges: Illegal trade is the major hindrance to the repatriation of looted cultural artifacts to their original owners, which in turn has resulted in a wave of lawsuits and ethical deliberations over ownership and rights to cultures.
Multi-dimensional strategy is required to tackle these ethical problems:
Transparency and Due Diligence: The art market should be demanding with due diligence in the authentication of provenance, so the artifacts are legally acquired.
International Cooperation: International cooperation must strengthen to avoid illicit trafficking. Better information sharing, improved law enforcement, and stronger export controls would help achieve that.
-Education and Awareness: Education among collectors, dealers, and the public is needed to educate them on ethical implications that the illegal trade of art creates.
-Backing Source Countries, through capacity building, training, and providing resources, help source countries preserve cultural heritage through archaeological researches and building museums.
See lessGarbage Maintenance in India
India has covered lots of ground with regard to managing wastes, yet a lot needs to be dealt with. In short, it is as follows: Challenges: There lacks proper infrastructures for collecting and transporting waste; many cities face such problems with disposal. Waste segregation is poor at the source,Read more
India has covered lots of ground with regard to managing wastes, yet a lot needs to be dealt with. In short, it is as follows:
Challenges:
There lacks proper infrastructures for collecting and transporting waste; many cities face such problems with disposal.
Waste segregation is poor at the source, thereby causing contamination. It hinders recycling.
Overburdening waste management structures by rampant urbanization.
Most people have no idea what to do with waste and also do not see the importance of segregation.
-Limited Enforcement: Inadequate implementation of waste management policies is also a reason.
Responsibility:
-Municipal Corporations: Waste collection, transportation, and disposal are the main responsibilities.
-State and Central Governments: The responsibility includes the formulation of policy, resource development, and supervision.
-Citizens: The citizens are also responsible for waste segregation, proper disposal, and waste management programmes.
-Business houses: It deals with proper handling of waste in their unit and maximizing generation at source.
Swachh Bharat Mission: It is a program for a better sanitation and cleanliness campaign encompassing waste management.
Solid Waste Management Rules: Government rules which give a platform to manage the waste.
However, despite all these, much is yet to be achieved. Many cities are still facing landfills overflowing and littering.
Key Factors:
-Lack of Political Will: Assured continuity in implementing policies and sufficiency of funds remain problems.
-Corruption: Corruption interferes with effective waste management because it diverts the funds and slows down providing effective services.
-Fast Population Growth: The population growth rates grow exponentially, resulting in increasing amounts of trash.
Way Forward:
-Improvement of Infrastructure: The provision of modern facilities in collection, transportation, and processing of wastes.
-Public Awareness: Increased public awareness on waste segregation, recycling, and proper disposal.
-Enforcement: Enforcing the implementation of rigorous waste management regulations and stricter punishments for violations.
-Community Involvement: Encouraging active community participation in waste management initiatives.
-Technological Solutions: Innovative technologies such as waste-to-energy and waste-to-compost facilities.
See lessEnvironment and Sustainability
The most important challenge for the 21st century is balancing economic growth with environmental sustainability. Some of the key strategies include: Shifting to a Green Economy: -Investing in Renewable Energy: Transitioning from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources like solar, wind, and geotherRead more
The most important challenge for the 21st century is balancing economic growth with environmental sustainability. Some of the key strategies include:
Shifting to a Green Economy:
-Investing in Renewable Energy: Transitioning from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources like solar, wind, and geothermal power.
-Promoting Energy Efficiency: Improving energy efficiency in buildings, transportation, and industrial processes.
Develop green technologies, such as electric vehicles, battery storage, and carbon capture and storage, through research and development.
Circular Economy Principles:
-Reduce, Reuse, Recycle: Reduce waste generation through reduced consumption, reuse of products, and effective recycling programs.
-Sustainable Consumption and Production: This involves the promotion of sustainable consumption patterns and the production of durable and recyclable and repairable products.
Sustainable Agriculture and Forestry:
-Sustainable Agriculture: Encouraging sustainable agricultural practices such as organic farming, precision agriculture, and agroforestry, which reduce environmental impacts.
-Forest Protection and Restoration: Protecting forests that exist today and restoring more forests to conserve biodiversity and counteract climate change.
Effective Environmental Laws and Policies:
Carbon Pricing: Carbon pricing mechanisms, either in the form of carbon taxes or emissions trading systems, encourage the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions.
-Environmental Impact Assessments: Conducting thorough environmental impact assessments for all major projects to ensure their environmental sustainability.
-Protecting Biodiversity: Implementing policies to protect biodiversity and conserve natural habitats.
Social Equity and Inclusion:
-Just Transition: Ensure that the transition to a sustainable economy is just and equitable for all, with a focus on supporting workers and communities that may be affected by economic shifts.
Environmental Justice: Address the disproportionate environmental impacts on marginalized communities.
International Cooperation:
See less-International Accords: The strengthening of international cooperation on mitigation of climate change and environmental protection through accords such as the Paris Agreement.
-Best Practices Sharing: Facilitating sharing of best practices and technologies between countries to expedite the transition to a sustainable future.