Sign Up

Have an account?

Sign In

Don't have account,

Forgot Password

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.


Have an account?

Sorry, you do not have permission to ask a question, You must login to ask a question.

Need An Account,

Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.

Search
Ask A Question
Home/Questions/Page 25

Mains Answer Writing Latest Questions

Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Roadmap for Answer Writing 1. Introduction Define the Doctrine of Democratic Governance: Explain its significance in the context of civil service. Thesis Statement: Assert that positive public perception of civil servants’ integrity and commitment is essential for effective governance. 2. Importance of Civil Servants ...

upsc: role of civil services in a democracy
  1. Team
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer Introduction The Doctrine of Democratic Governance underscores the essential role of civil servants in maintaining public trust, which is critical for effective administration. Article 311 of the Indian Constitution protects civil servants, highlighting their importance in fostering accRead more

    Model Answer

    Introduction

    The Doctrine of Democratic Governance underscores the essential role of civil servants in maintaining public trust, which is critical for effective administration. Article 311 of the Indian Constitution protects civil servants, highlighting their importance in fostering accountability and integrity within the government.

    Key Components of Democratic Governance

    1. Participation and Representation: Inclusive decision-making promotes legitimacy and reflects the will of the people.
    2. Responsiveness: Timely addressal of societal issues ensures that public services meet community needs.
    3. Openness and Transparency: Transparent governance fosters citizen scrutiny, enhancing trust and accountability.
    4. Ethical Conduct: Upholding public interest over personal gain creates a moral framework for governance.
    5. Accountability: Civil servants must be answerable to citizens, reinforcing the legitimacy of governance.

    Importance of Positive Perception of Civil Servants

    Trust and Governance

    Public trust in civil servants is vital for governance legitimacy. The Election Commission’s perceived neutrality during the 2024 General Elections exemplified this, as results were widely accepted without significant disputes.

    Compliance and Law Enforcement

    Public faith in civil servants enhances compliance with laws, especially during crises. For instance, trust in the Ministry of Health during the COVID-19 pandemic led to greater adherence to safety guidelines.

    Corruption Deterrence

    Integrity among civil servants is critical for deterring corruption. The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2nd ARC) highlighted the need for civil service integrity to combat corruption.

    International Standing

    The global perception of civil services impacts a country’s diplomatic and economic relations. India’s rise in the World Bank’s Doing Business Report, from 142nd in 2014 to 63rd in 2019, reflects the role of civil service integrity in enhancing the nation’s image.

    In conclusion, a positive public perception of civil servants is crucial for effective democratic governance. Promoting transparency, ethical conduct, and public trust will strengthen India’s democratic framework and ensure efficient civil service operations.

    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Roadmap for Answer Writing Introduction Define the relationship between poverty and malnutrition, emphasizing how they create a vicious cycle that adversely affects human capital formation. Mention the significance of addressing this issue for sustainable development. Understanding the Vicious Cycle Explain how poverty leads to malnutrition: Economic ...

upsc: human resource & human capital
  1. Team
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer Introduction Poverty and malnutrition are interconnected issues that create a vicious cycle adversely affecting human capital formation in India. Addressing these challenges requires a multifaceted approach that targets the root causes of malnutrition and poverty. How Poverty and MalnutRead more

    Model Answer

    Introduction

    Poverty and malnutrition are interconnected issues that create a vicious cycle adversely affecting human capital formation in India. Addressing these challenges requires a multifaceted approach that targets the root causes of malnutrition and poverty.

    How Poverty and Malnutrition Create a Vicious Cycle

    1. Economic Barriers to Nutrition: Economic limitations restrict access to nutritious food, particularly for vulnerable populations. For instance, the 2023 Global Hunger Index ranks India 111th out of 125 countries, highlighting significant nutritional deficiencies due to economic disparities.
    2. Developmental Impacts of Malnutrition: Malnutrition during early childhood impairs physical and cognitive development, leading to lifelong negative effects on productivity. Approximately 35% of children under six are stunted, according to the Poshan Tracker.
    3. Healthcare Costs of Malnutrition: Malnourished individuals face higher susceptibility to diseases, increasing healthcare costs and draining family resources. A study by the Public Health Foundation of India indicates that malnutrition raises the risk of diseases like tuberculosis, leading to economic strain.
    4. Educational Limitations: Cognitive delays caused by malnutrition reduce educational attainment, limiting future employment opportunities and perpetuating socio-economic disparities across generations.
    5. Productivity Loss: A malnourished workforce contributes less to national productivity, hindering overall economic growth. The World Bank estimates that India loses 2-3% of its GDP annually due to undernutrition in children under two.

    Steps to Break the Cycle

    1. National Nutrition Strategies: Strengthen initiatives like the Poshan Abhiyan to reduce stunting and undernutrition among children.
    2. Enhanced Public Distribution System: Improve the Public Distribution System (PDS) to ensure consistent access to food grains for economically vulnerable populations.
    3. Mid-Day Meal Program Enhancement: Expand the Mid-Day Meal Scheme to provide nutritious meals in schools, improving child nutrition and educational outcomes.
    4. Empowerment through Education and Employment: Focus on women’s education and employment to improve family nutrition and health outcomes.
    5. Public-Private Partnerships: Foster partnerships to enhance food storage, processing, and distribution, reducing food wastage and improving market access for farmers.
    6. Community Nutrition Education: Implement community-driven education programs on nutrition and sustainable agriculture to promote better dietary practices.

    By adopting these strategies, India can effectively address the intertwined issues of poverty and malnutrition, enhancing human capital and promoting sustainable development.

    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Roadmap for Answer Writing 1. Introduction Define public charitable trusts and their legal basis under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882. Introduce the concept of inclusivity in development and the significance of public charitable trusts in addressing vital public issues. 2. Role of Public Charitable ...

upsc: vulnerable sections
  1. Team
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer Introduction Public charitable trusts play a pivotal role in fostering inclusive development in India by addressing vital public issues through a range of philanthropic initiatives. Operating under legal frameworks such as the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, these trusts focus on education, heRead more

    Model Answer

    Introduction

    Public charitable trusts play a pivotal role in fostering inclusive development in India by addressing vital public issues through a range of philanthropic initiatives. Operating under legal frameworks such as the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, these trusts focus on education, healthcare, and social justice, significantly impacting underserved communities.

    Role in Inclusive Development

    Educational Enhancements

    Public charitable trusts are instrumental in improving educational access, especially in rural areas. For instance, the Azim Premji Foundation complements the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan by enhancing rural education, thereby contributing to universal elementary education.

    Healthcare Accessibility

    Trusts extend essential healthcare services to marginalized populations, aligning with India’s constitutional mandate under Article 47. The Tata Trusts, for example, support critical health initiatives, including cancer care hospitals and mobile medical units, improving healthcare access for underserved communities.

    Skill Development

    Trusts empower women through skill development and microfinance, promoting equality as per Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution. The SEWA Trust enhances women’s empowerment by providing skills training and financial assistance, particularly for rural youth.

    Legal Assistance and Advocacy

    Organizations like Bachpan Bachao Andolan provide legal aid to protect marginalized communities, supporting fundamental rights under the Constitution. This initiative aligns with the Integrated Child Protection Scheme (ICPS), addressing issues like child trafficking and labor.

    Environmental Conservation

    Trusts also lead efforts in environmental conservation, focusing on biodiversity in line with India’s commitments under the Paris Agreement. The Bombay Natural History Society (BNHS) actively contributes to the National Mission for Green India, promoting forest conservation.

    Limitations of Public Charitable Trusts

    Despite their potential, public charitable trusts face several limitations:

    • Funding Inconsistencies: Financial limitations hinder the sustainability of initiatives, as they often rely on fluctuating donor contributions.
    • Complex Regulatory Environment: Diverse regulations across states create operational inefficiencies, impeding effective functioning.
    • Transparency Issues: Some trusts lack robust governance structures, leading to accountability concerns and diminished public trust.
    • Impact Measurement Challenges: The absence of standardized evaluation tools complicates the assessment of project effectiveness.
    • Redundancy: Overlapping efforts by multiple trusts can lead to resource wastage and inefficiency.

    Conclusion

    Public charitable trusts are uniquely positioned to address critical issues like education, healthcare, and environmental sustainability, contributing to more equitable development in India. By tackling vital public concerns, these trusts can enhance inclusivity and promote sustainable progress. However, addressing their limitations through improved regulatory frameworks, standardized impact assessments, and community-driven initiatives is essential for maximizing their potential.

    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Roadmap for Answer Writing 1. Introduction Define local bodies and their significance in decentralized governance. Mention the constitutional framework that empowers local bodies (73rd and 74th Amendments). Briefly introduce the topic of pros and cons of merging rural and urban local bodies. 2. Role of ...

upsc: local governance
  1. Team
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer Introduction Local bodies are fundamental to decentralized governance in India, empowered by the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments. These amendments have transformed local bodies into key drivers of development and governance, ensuring that local needs are addressed effectively. RRead more

    Model Answer

    Introduction

    Local bodies are fundamental to decentralized governance in India, empowered by the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments. These amendments have transformed local bodies into key drivers of development and governance, ensuring that local needs are addressed effectively.

    Role of Local Bodies in Good Governance

    1. Decentralized Decision-Making: Local bodies enable autonomous decision-making tailored to community needs. For example, Gram Panchayats in Maharashtra successfully managed the Jalyukt Shivar Abhiyan, enhancing water availability in drought-prone areas.
    2. Enhanced Community Engagement: Articles 243A and 243G promote citizen participation in governance. Initiatives like Ward Committees in Bengaluru empower citizens to engage in local budgeting, fostering transparency.
    3. Accountability and Transparency: The Right to Information Act (2005) encourages regular monitoring of government programs. Social audits in MGNREGA have exposed fund mismanagement, enhancing accountability.
    4. Local Economic Initiatives: Local bodies promote economic development under Article 243W. For instance, municipalities in Gujarat have supported micro-enterprises through the National Urban Livelihoods Mission (NULM).
    5. Inclusion of Marginalized Sections: Reservations for women and SC/STs ensure political participation from marginalized groups, with women constituting 6% of total Panchayati Raj Institution representatives in 2024.
    6. Resource Management: Local bodies manage natural resources effectively, as seen in Rajasthan’s Alwar district, where community-led efforts improved groundwater levels.
    7. Service Delivery: Municipalities are responsible for essential services like health and education. Kerala’s local self-government departments significantly contribute to the state’s exemplary health outcomes.

    Pros of Merging Rural and Urban Local Bodies

    • Integrated Development: Merging promotes unified planning, balancing infrastructure development across regions.
    • Cost Reduction: Consolidation eliminates redundant administrative functions, improving efficiency.
    • Equitable Resource Allocation: Ensures fair distribution of resources, preventing urban-centric development.
    • Disparity Reduction: Extends essential urban services to rural areas, improving quality of life.
    • Simplified Governance: Reduces bureaucratic hurdles, facilitating easier access to services.
    • Enhanced Service Efficiency: Merged bodies can pool resources for better service delivery.

    Cons of Merging Rural and Urban Local Bodies

    • Overlooked Local Needs: Urban-centric policies may neglect rural-specific issues, particularly in agriculture.
    • Increased Management Complexity: Larger jurisdictions may struggle to address diverse socio-economic challenges.
    • Political Representation Issues: Rural representation may diminish, with urban areas receiving more focus.
    • Skewed Resource Distribution: Urban areas might attract more development funds, leaving rural regions underfunded.
    • Erosion of Identity: Cultural identities of rural areas may be threatened by urbanization pressures.
    • Implementation Difficulties: Aligning regulatory frameworks can be legally complex and slow down governance.

    In conclusion, while merging rural and urban local bodies could streamline governance and foster uniform development, it is crucial to consider local needs, cultural nuances, and equitable resource allocation to ensure sustainable development.

    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Roadmap for Answer Writing 1. Introduction Define the role of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) in India. Introduce the statement highlighting the dual responsibility of ensuring legality and propriety in expenditure. 2. Legality of Expenditure Explain the CAG’s primary function of auditing government accounts ...

upsc: constitutional bodies
  1. Team
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer Introduction The statement that "the duty of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) is not merely to ensure the legality of expenditure but also its propriety" underscores the comprehensive responsibilities of this constitutional authority in India. The CAG plays a crucial role in maRead more

    Model Answer

    Introduction

    The statement that “the duty of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) is not merely to ensure the legality of expenditure but also its propriety” underscores the comprehensive responsibilities of this constitutional authority in India. The CAG plays a crucial role in maintaining financial accountability and transparency in government spending.

    Legality of Expenditure

    The CAG’s primary function, as outlined in Article 149 of the Indian Constitution, is to audit government accounts to ensure that expenditures are legal. This involves verifying that public funds are utilized in accordance with the laws and regulations established by Parliament. For instance, the CAG’s report on the 2019-20 Union Government Accounts highlighted instances of misallocation of funds, emphasizing the necessity for strict adherence to legal frameworks.

    Propriety of Expenditure

    Beyond legality, the CAG is tasked with assessing the propriety of expenditures. This means evaluating whether the funds were used efficiently, economically, and for their intended purposes. Propriety ensures that expenditures not only comply with legal standards but also align with the principles of good governance. For example, the CAG’s Performance Audit of the National Rural Health Mission revealed significant inefficiencies and mismanagement, indicating that the intended objectives were not being achieved effectively.

    Importance of Propriety

    Focusing on propriety is essential for fostering accountability and public trust in government institutions. It ensures that taxpayers’ money is spent judiciously and that government programs deliver the intended benefits. If expenditures are legal but not proper, it can lead to wastage of resources and undermine public welfare.

    Conclusion

    In conclusion, the CAG’s duty extends beyond ensuring legal compliance to encompass the broader aspect of propriety in expenditure. By ensuring both legality and propriety, the CAG plays a vital role in safeguarding public funds and promoting good governance in India. This dual focus is critical for enhancing the effectiveness of government programs and ensuring accountability to the citizens.

    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Roadmap for Answer Writing 1. Introduction Define Lok Adalats and Arbitration Tribunals as alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms. Briefly state their purpose and significance in the legal system. 2. Distinction between Lok Adalats and Arbitration Tribunals Nature of Disputes Explain the types of cases each mechanism ...

upsc: judiciary
  1. Team
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer Lok Adalats vs. Arbitration Tribunals Both Lok Adalats and Arbitration Tribunals serve as alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms aimed at resolving disputes outside the conventional court system. However, they differ in terms of nature, jurisdiction, and procedures. DistinctionRead more

    Model Answer

    Lok Adalats vs. Arbitration Tribunals

    Both Lok Adalats and Arbitration Tribunals serve as alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms aimed at resolving disputes outside the conventional court system. However, they differ in terms of nature, jurisdiction, and procedures.

    Distinction between Lok Adalats and Arbitration Tribunals

    Nature of Disputes

    • Lok Adalats primarily address minor civil, family, and petty criminal cases. For instance, they often resolve land disputes, matrimonial issues, and cases like cheque bounces (Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987).
    • Arbitration Tribunals focus on commercial, contractual, and corporate disputes. A notable example is the Vodafone tax case, which was settled through arbitration (Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996).

    Legal Basis

    • Lok Adalats operate under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, aimed at delivering quick and accessible justice, particularly for underprivileged citizens.
    • Arbitration Tribunals function under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which provides a structured framework for resolving disputes.

    Voluntary Nature

    • Participation in Lok Adalats is voluntary, requiring mutual agreement from both parties to resolve disputes.
    • In contrast, Arbitration Tribunals are based on agreements or contracts between disputing parties.

    Appointment of Judges/Arbitrators

    • Lok Adalats are chaired by a judicial officer, typically a retired judge or sitting magistrate.
    • Arbitrators in Arbitration Tribunals are selected by the parties involved and may include legal or non-legal professionals, as seen in international cases like Cairn Energy vs. the Indian Government.

    Cost Efficiency

    • Lok Adalats generally do not require court fees, making them more cost-effective.
    • Arbitration Tribunals involve fees for arbitrators and legal representation, which can increase costs significantly.

    Appeal Process

    • Once a settlement is reached in Lok Adalats, no appeal can be made, although parties retain the right to litigate.
    • In Arbitration, awards can be challenged under certain conditions, often due to bias or procedural issues, as demonstrated in the Antrix-Devas arbitration case.

    Role of Lawyers

    • Lok Adalats do not require legal representation, though parties may seek advice. Many parties represent themselves.
    • Arbitration Tribunals typically involve lawyers, especially in complex cases like Reliance vs. ONGC.

    Speed of Resolution

    • Lok Adalats resolve disputes quickly, often in a single sitting. For example, over 1.14 crore cases were settled at the 3rd National Lok Adalat (2024) organized by NALSA.
    • Arbitration can take longer, depending on the case’s complexity.

    Civil and Criminal Case Jurisdiction

    • Lok Adalats handle civil matters and minor criminal cases (compoundable offences), such as cheque bounce cases and motor accident claims.
    • Arbitration Tribunals strictly deal with civil matters, particularly commercial disputes, as seen in the Ambani family asset dispute.
    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Roadmap for Answer Writing 1. Introduction Define electoral reforms and their importance in democratic governance. Introduce the “One Nation, One Election” principle as a key reform suggested by various committees. 2. Need for Electoral Reforms Strengthening Electoral Participation Discuss the need for higher voter turnout and ...

upsc: elections & representation of people’s act
  1. Team
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer Introduction Electoral reforms are essential for enhancing the integrity and efficiency of India’s democratic process. The principle of "One Nation, One Election," recently advocated by the Kovind Committee, promotes the idea of conducting simultaneous elections for the Lok Sabha and stRead more

    Model Answer

    Introduction

    Electoral reforms are essential for enhancing the integrity and efficiency of India’s democratic process. The principle of “One Nation, One Election,” recently advocated by the Kovind Committee, promotes the idea of conducting simultaneous elections for the Lok Sabha and state assemblies. This reform seeks to minimize election-related expenditures, simplify governance, and increase political stability by synchronizing electoral cycles.

    Need for Electoral Reforms

    Strengthening Electoral Participation

    Encouraging higher voter turnout and simplifying the voter registration process is vital for a more inclusive democracy. The Goswami Committee suggested measures to enhance voter participation, emphasizing streamlined registration processes (Goswami Committee Report, 1990).

    Addressing Political Corruption

    Combating the nexus between criminals and politicians is crucial for restoring voter trust and accountability. The Vohra Committee Report highlighted these connections and called for comprehensive electoral reforms to address them (Vohra Committee Report, 1993).

    Curbing Electoral Expenditure

    Limiting escalating election costs is necessary to maintain a level playing field. The 2nd Administrative Reforms Commission (ARC) emphasized the need to control electoral expenses to ensure fair elections (2nd ARC Report, 2007).

    Improving Election Integrity

    Strengthening transparency measures is vital for a credible electoral process. The Election Commission of India has advocated for reforms in electoral funding to enhance integrity, particularly concerning electoral bonds (Election Commission Reports).

    Ensuring Inclusivity in Voting

    It is imperative to guarantee that marginalized communities have equal access to voting. The National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC) recommended inclusive practices to accommodate diverse needs (NCRWC Report, 2002).

    Significance of One Nation-One Election Principle

    Economic Growth

    Simultaneous elections can boost GDP by enhancing economic stability. The Kovind Committee projected a potential 5 percentage point increase in national GDP growth in the following year (Kovind Committee Report, 2020).

    Increased Government Expenditure

    Simultaneous elections could lead to a 67% increase in public expenditure, focusing on capital investments that promote long-term growth (Economic Survey, 2021).

    Investment Climate

    Frequent elections create uncertainty for investors. Simultaneous elections can foster a more stable investment environment, with the Gross Fixed Capital Formation to GDP ratio estimated to be 5 percentage points higher during such periods (Economic Studies).

    Cost Efficiency

    The Election Commission reportedly spends over ₹4,500 crore on conducting elections. Consolidating these elections could significantly reduce governmental expenditures (Parliamentary Panel Reports).

    Enhanced Governance

    Frequent enforcement of the Model Code of Conduct disrupts governance. Simultaneous elections could mitigate these interruptions, ensuring smoother government functioning (Political Analysis, 2023).

    Conclusion

    The “One Nation, One Election” principle has the potential to strengthen India’s democratic framework by promoting efficient governance, reducing costs, and enhancing voter engagement.

    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Dr. Srinivasan is a senior scientist working for a reputed biotechnology company known for its cutting-edge research in pharmaceuticals. Dr. Srinivasan is heading a research team working on a new drug aimed at treating a rapidly spreading variant of a ...

upsc: ethics case studies
  1. Team
    Best Answer
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer (a) What Would You Do in Such a Situation? As Dr. Srinivasan, I would prioritize ethical integrity over commercial pressure. This includes: Uphold Ethical Standards: Reject any suggestions to manipulate data, bypass informed consent, or infringe on patents. Communicate Concerns: DiscussRead more

    Model Answer

    (a) What Would You Do in Such a Situation?

    As Dr. Srinivasan, I would prioritize ethical integrity over commercial pressure. This includes:

    1. Uphold Ethical Standards: Reject any suggestions to manipulate data, bypass informed consent, or infringe on patents.
    2. Communicate Concerns: Discuss the risks of unethical practices with senior management, emphasizing the importance of maintaining research integrity.
    3. Promote a Culture of Ethics: As a leader, I would encourage my team to adhere to ethical standards and resist shortcuts, thereby setting a precedent for future research.

    (b) Examine Your Options and Consequences in Light of Ethical Questions

    Option 1: Follow Suggested Shortcuts

    • Consequences:
      • Ethical Violation: Manipulating data violates principles of honesty and respect for patient rights.
      • Legal Repercussions: Using patented compounds without permission could lead to lawsuits.
      • Loss of Trust: Unethical practices could erode public trust, damaging the company’s reputation.
      • Short-term Gain: A first-mover advantage could quickly be overshadowed by negative consequences.

    Option 2: Uphold Ethical Standards

    • Consequences:
      • Ethical Integrity: Aligns with the responsibility to provide safe scientific outcomes.
      • Potential Delays: This approach may delay drug approval, frustrating company aspirations.
      • Maintaining Standards: Compliance with laws ensures protection from legal disputes.
      • Building Long-term Trust: Upholding ethics enhances credibility in the pharmaceutical industry.

    Option 3: Seek Ethical Compromise

    • Consequences:
      • Ethical Accountability: Proposing alternatives maintains integrity while demonstrating leadership.
      • Transparency: Encourages open dialogue about the importance of ethics.
      • Risk of Pushback: There may be pressure from management to compromise, but it allows exploration of ethical paths.

    (c) How Can Data Ethics and Drug Ethics Save Humanity?

    Data Ethics

    1. Transparency in Data Reporting: Ensures trust in research findings, leading to better patient outcomes.
      • Fact: The principle of veracity demands honest reporting (National Institutes of Health).
    2. Protection of Participant Privacy: Upholds dignity and privacy, adhering to standards like GDPR.
      • Example: GDPR protects trial participants’ data, fostering ethical research practices.
    3. Ensuring Data Integrity: Maintains reliability of research outcomes, benefiting society.
      • Example: Validating data aligns with teleological ethics focused on societal benefits.

    Drug Ethics

    1. Informed Consent: Respect for autonomy ensures participants understand risks and benefits.
      • Fact: Ethical trials require informed consent as a fundamental principle (Declaration of Helsinki).
    2. Prioritizing Patient Safety: Ensures trials minimize harm while maximizing benefits.
      • Fact: The principle of non-maleficence is central to ethical medical research (Beauchamp & Childress).
    3. Equitable Access to Medicines: Distributive justice ensures fair distribution of treatments.
      • Example: Ethical pricing models for drugs like insulin support equitable access.

    In navigating these challenges, Dr. Srinivasan’s commitment to integrity underscores the principle of “Satyameva Jayate” (Truth alone triumphs). Upholding ethical standards not only ensures safe treatments but strengthens public trust in scientific endeavors, which is crucial for societal well-being.

    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

With the summer heat being exceptionally severe this year, the district has been facing severe water shortage. The District Collector has been mobilizing his subordinate officials to conserve the remaining water reserves for preventing the district from plunging into acute ...

upsc: ethics case studies
  1. Team
    Best Answer
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer (a) Options Available to the District Collector Implement Stricter Penalties for Industrial Violations Introduce fines for industries over-extracting water to address farmers' concerns. Fact: Regulatory frameworks can enhance compliance (World Bank). Investigate Allegations of CorruptioRead more

    Model Answer

    (a) Options Available to the District Collector

    1. Implement Stricter Penalties for Industrial Violations
      • Introduce fines for industries over-extracting water to address farmers’ concerns.
      • Fact: Regulatory frameworks can enhance compliance (World Bank).
    2. Investigate Allegations of Corruption
      • Conduct an independent inquiry to restore trust among farmers.
      • Fact: Transparency in governance builds public confidence (Transparency International).
    3. Prioritize Irrigation for Farmers
      • Allow farmers limited access to water for irrigation while regulating industrial usage.
      • Fact: Distributive justice ensures fair resource allocation (Rawls, 1971).
    4. Emergency Relief Measures
      • Provide temporary water supplies via tankers to affected farmers during the crisis.
      • Fact: Immediate relief can mitigate protest risks and support livelihoods (UN OCHA).
    5. Organize Stakeholder Dialogues
      • Facilitate discussions between farmers, industry representatives, and officials to address concerns collaboratively.
      • Fact: Deliberative democracy enhances trust and legitimacy in decision-making (Habermas).

    (b) Suitable Actions for Mutually Compatible Interests

    1. Equitable Water Allocation Framework
      • Develop a transparent system prioritizing essential needs, like drinking water and irrigation.
      • Fact: Fair allocation frameworks can prevent conflicts (OECD).
    2. Infrastructure Upgrades
      • Improve water infrastructure to reduce losses and ensure balanced distribution.
      • Fact: Efficient infrastructure is key to sustainable water management (Global Water Partnership).
    3. Incentivize Water Conservation
      • Offer subsidies for water-efficient practices, promoting sustainable usage.
      • Example: KUSUM scheme supports solar-powered pumps for farmers.
    4. Monitoring and Evaluation Systems
      • Implement real-time monitoring of water usage to adapt policies effectively.
      • Fact: IoT solutions can provide data-driven insights for resource management.
    5. Conflict Resolution Mechanisms
      • Establish local committees to address disputes over water usage proactively.
      • Fact: Conflict management frameworks can preemptively address issues (Fisher et al.).

    (c) Potential Administrative and Ethical Dilemmas

    1. Resource Allocation Dilemma
      • Balancing the needs of vulnerable populations against industrial demands poses ethical challenges.
      • Fact: The ethics of care prioritizes basic human rights (Nussbaum).
    2. Corruption Allegations
      • Maintaining transparency is crucial to uphold public trust and prevent perceptions of favoritism.
      • Fact: Open governance practices mitigate corruption risks (World Bank).
    3. Legal vs. Ethical Obligations
      • Legal frameworks may not always ensure ethical fairness, especially in resource-scarce contexts.
      • Example: Restricting water for irrigation may disproportionately affect small farmers.
    4. Public vs. Private Interests
      • Balancing the economic needs of industries with the public’s right to water creates ethical conflicts.
      • Fact: Utilitarianism and Kantian ethics can clash in resource management decisions.
    5. Equity vs. Efficiency
      • Ensuring efficient water use for industries may compromise equitable access for marginalized communities.
      • Example: Prioritizing industrial needs could lead to insufficient irrigation for farmers.

    Conclusion

    The District Collector must navigate a complex landscape of interests and ethical dilemmas while addressing the water crisis. By fostering cooperation and implementing fair resource management practices, the administration can promote a balanced and sustainable future for all stakeholders. As the shloka states, “Sarve Bhavantu Sukhinah” (May all be happy), emphasizing the need for equitable resource management.

    See less
Ajay Sundar
  • 0
Ajay SundarLearner
Asked: February 18, 2025In:
  • 0

Sneha is a Senior Manager working for a big reputed hospital chain in a mid-sized city. She has been made in-charge of the new super speciality center that the hospital is building with state-of-the art equipment and world class medical ...

upsc: ethics case studies
  1. Team
    Best Answer
    Team Supreme

    Model Answer (a) Course of Action for Sneha Sneha should recuse herself from the procurement decision-making process. By stepping aside, she can prevent any potential bias or appearance of favoritism that may arise from her brother's involvement as a vendor. Justification: Adherence to Ethical PrincRead more

    Model Answer

    (a) Course of Action for Sneha

    Sneha should recuse herself from the procurement decision-making process. By stepping aside, she can prevent any potential bias or appearance of favoritism that may arise from her brother’s involvement as a vendor.

    Justification:

    1. Adherence to Ethical Principles: Following the Doctrine of Conflict of Interest ensures impartiality.
    2. Transparency: Disclosing her relationship with the vendor promotes trust and accountability.
    3. Compliance with Hospital Policies: Aligning with the hospital’s ethical guidelines reinforces her commitment to fairness.

    (b) Justification for Her Decision

    1. Protecting Hospital Reputation: By recusing herself, Sneha protects both her and the hospital’s reputation from accusations of nepotism.
    2. Prioritizing Patient Care: Ensuring that procurement decisions are made based on merit guarantees high-quality medical equipment, ultimately benefiting patient welfare.
    3. Long-term Sustainability: Acting ethically sets a standard for future decisions, reinforcing the hospital’s integrity and stakeholder trust.

    (c) Compromise of Medical Ethics with Vested Personal Interest

    1. Conflict of Interest: Sneha’s personal ties introduce bias, undermining her professional responsibility. Ethical egoism suggests her decision could prioritize personal gain over the hospital’s needs.
      • Example: Favoring her brother’s company might lead to substandard equipment, violating the principle of non-maleficence (avoiding harm to patients).
    2. Loss of Trust: Stakeholders may question the integrity of procurement decisions, leading to a loss of confidence in the hospital’s operational ethics.
      • Example: If stakeholders perceive decisions as influenced by nepotism, they may withdraw support or trust in the hospital’s governance.
    3. Unfair Business Practices: Favoring her brother’s firm violates the principle of distributive justice, denying other vendors a fair chance to compete.
      • Example: Other suppliers might feel unfairly treated, leading to fewer competitive bids and potentially higher costs for the hospital.
    4. Impact on Staff Morale: Witnessing nepotism can demotivate employees, negatively affecting productivity and morale.
      • Example: Staff may feel disillusioned, leading to a decline in overall job satisfaction and engagement.

    In navigating this ethical dilemma, Sneha’s commitment to integrity and transparency will reinforce the hospital’s reputation and set a precedent for ethical decision-making. As Albert Einstein noted, “Whoever is careless with the truth in small matters cannot be trusted with important matters,” emphasizing the importance of ethical conduct in all areas.

    See less
Load More Questions

Resources & Suggestions

Mains Answer Writing Latest Articles

On: April 18, 2025

Daily Answer Writing Practice Questions (18 April 2025)

Do you agree with the claim that indecision and risk aversion are prevalent issues in Indian bureaucracy? Support your answer with logical reasoning. (150 words) ऐसा कहा जाता है कि भारतीय नौकरशाही में अनिर्णय और जोखिम से बचने की प्रवृत्ति ...

On: April 18, 2025 Comments: 0

Strengthening India’s Cyber Defence

Rising Threats Digital Era Challenges: 2024 marks a significant rise in digital threats, particularly from AI and cyberattacks. Key Issues: Disinformation campaigns. Cyber fraud affecting daily life. Current Major Cyber Threats Ransomware Rampage: Over 48,000 instances of WannaCry ransomware detected ...

On: April 18, 2025 Comments: 0

भारत की साइबर सुरक्षा

बढ़ते खतरे कृत्रिम बुद्धिमत्ता (AI) और साइबर हमले: 2024 में AI और साइबर हमलों के खतरे में वृद्धि। महत्वपूर्ण अवसंरचना पर हमले: डिजिटल हमलों और दुष्प्रचार अभियानों की संभावना बढ़ी है। प्रमुख साइबर खतरें रैनसमवेयर का प्रकोप: 48,000 से अधिक ...

Explore Our Blog