Examine the events that resulted in the declaration of emergency in 1975 and talk about the ramifications.
Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
The promulgation of Emergency in India in 1975 was a pivotal event in the country’s history, marked by significant political, social, and constitutional implications. Here are the circumstances that led to its proclamation and its implications:
Circumstances Leading to the Emergency:
Implications of the Emergency:
In summary, while the Emergency was justified by the government as a response to internal instability and security threats, its implementation led to widespread suppression of democratic rights and a significant backlash. It remains a critical chapter in India’s democratic history, highlighting both vulnerabilities and resilience in the face of authoritarian challenges.
The President, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, announced a National Emergency in India on 25 June 1975 under Article 352 of the Indian Constitution due to internal disturbances in the country.
Circumstances Leading to the Emergency:
1. Allahabad High Court Judgment: On 12 June, Justice Jagmohan Lal Sinha of the Allahabad High Court declared Indira Gandhi’s election to the Lok Sabha as null and void.
2. Economic Crisis: The country faced a major economic crisis, marked by low industrial growth and high unemployment. The failure of the monsoon in 1972-73 led to a sharp decline in agricultural productivity.
3. Political Opposition: Opposition political parties, led by Jayaprakash Narayan, called for Indira Gandhi’s resignation and organized a massive demonstration in Delhi’s Ramlila ground on 25 June 1975. Narayan also urged the army not to obey “illegal and immoral orders.”
4. Railway Strike: In addition to the agitation led by Jayaprakash Narayan, railway employees called for a nationwide strike in 1974, posing a significant threat.
All of these factors contributed to the emergency.
Implications of the Emergency:
1. Suspension of Civil Liberties: The fundamental rights of citizens were curtailed, preventing them from challenging the emergency in court.
2. Misuse of Preventive Detention: The government misused preventive detention by making large-scale arrests during the emergency.
3. Press Censorship: The government imposed censorship on the press. Newspapers were asked to obtain permission for all materials to be published.
4. Authoritarian Rule: Indira Gandhi and her government wielded enormous authority, centralizing decision-making.
5. Constitutional Amendments:
a) During the emergency, amendments were made to the constitution to prevent challenges to the elections of the Prime Minister, Chief Minister, and President.
b) The 42nd Amendment was passed, extending the duration of the legislative assembly from 5 to 6 years.
Overall, the emergency period was seen as a blight on Indian democracy, emphasizing the importance of safeguarding democratic institutions and civil liberties.
In 1975 barely over two decades after it gained independence, India faced its biggest political crisis. On 26 June 1975, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi declared a national emergency under article 352, on the grounds of internal disturbance. The events leading up to the emergency were marked with rising poverty, economic inequality, and social unrest due to protests across Northern India, mainly due to the JP movement. Emergency was perhaps the darkest period and biggest crisis Indian democracy has faced in the post-Independence era.
Circumstances Leading To Promulgation Of Emergency
1. The height of popularity which Mrs. Gandhi achieved post-1971 war, began to decline by the beginning of 1973. She came to power with slogans of Garibi Hatao, but people’s expectations were unfulfilled and there was rising discontent. 2. Economic situation: It was the main reason for this discontent. A combination of recession, growing unemployment, rampant inflation, and scarcity of foodstuffs created a serious crisis.
3. Social conditions: The severe economic crisis, unemployment, scarcity of goods all led to largescale industrial unrest, with a wave of strikes all through 1972, and 1973 culminating in an all-India railway strike in 1974 for 22 days. Law and order deteriorated, particularly during 1974–75. Strikes, student protests, and popular demonstrations often turned violent. It was during this time, three major social classes, began detaching themselves from Congress. The middle class due to price rise and unemployment, the rich landed class due to social reforms, and the capitalist class due to talk of socialism, nationalization banks, etc. 4. Political situation: The situation of 1973 and 74 required strong leadership. But congress by this time had begun declining as an organization and proved incapable of dealing with the crisis at hand creating a political crisis. The economic and political crisis was turned into a crisis of the entire political system, due to popular movements in Gujarat and Bihar and the leadership provided to the Bihar movement by Jayaprakash Narayan. Gujarat in January 1974 saw popular anger over the rise in the prices of foodgrains, and other essential commodities explode in the cities and towns of the state in the form of a student movement which was soon joined by the Opposition parties. Forced by the strength of the agitations and fast unto death by Morarji Desai, Indira Gandhi dissolved the assembly and announced fresh elections.
5. Spark for emergency: At the time when the JP movement was declining, judgment in the Raj Narain case by Justice Sinha of Allahabad High Court convicted Mrs.Gandhi for campaign corruption and declared her election as void. This decision means that she cannot contest in the 1976 election or hold office for six years. While the appeal of Mrs. Gandhi was pending in Apex court, in the Gujarat election Congress suffered a severe blow with the Janata party forming the government. The Allahabad HC judgment and Gujarat election results revived the opposition movement, who now not willing to wait for 1976 general elections decided on a countrywide, one-week campaign to force Mrs. Gandhi to resign. The response of Mrs. Gandhi to this planned campaign and agitations was to impose an emergency on 26th June, on grounds of an internal emergency.
Implications Of Emergency
A. Political Implications
1.Negatives
2. Positives:
There was also an immediate and general improvement in administration, with government servants coming to office on time and being more considerate to the public. Quick, dramatic, and well-publicized action was taken against smugglers, hoarders, black marketeers, illegal traders in foreign currency, and tax evaders, with several thousand of them put behind bars under MISA. Serious efforts were made to implement the Twenty -Point Programme; and some quick results were produced in terms of reduction of prices, free availability of essential commodities, and check on hoarding, smuggling, and tax evasion. Congress lost the 1977 elections and the Janata government which came to power brought into force the 44th constitutional amendment act, which changes aspects related grounds on which emergency can be imposed, better protection for fundamental rights, etc.
B. Social Implication:
1. Positives:
Negatives:
The bureaucracy and the police now had increased power that was unchecked by criticism and exposure from the Press, courts, MLAs and MP s, political parties, and popular movements and they abused this power.
In January 1977, Mrs.Gandhi announced elections to Loksabha, released political prisoners, lifted press censorship. The subsequent elections saw congress losing. It was a time many Indians and people abroad had doubts about the future of democracy in India. However India has not only survived the dark period of emergency and the social unrest of the JP movement, it even thrived. The democratic system has taken firm roots not just because of the constitution or courts but because the people of India have internalized it.
The government of India,under the leadership of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi , declare a national emergency in 1975. The government uses Article 352 of Indian constitution, declaring a threat of internal security.
The following were the reasons given by the government:
1) Economic Crisis: Indo-Pak war of 1971 put a heavy strain on India’s economy. US government also stopped all aid to India Post war. Also the rise in prices of oil and other commodities caused hardship for economy.
2) Student’s protest in Gujarat and Bihar: Due to rise in prices and unemployment, the students started an agitation against them. These protests were joined by opposition leaders.
3) JP Movement and Railway strike: JP Narayan gave a call for total revolution in the social economic and political spheres, in order to establish, what he considered, true democracy. Alongside this, the workers of Railways started a nationwide strike under the leadership of George Fernandes.
4) Judicial conflicts: Along with the ‘basic structure doctrine’ in Keshavananda Bharti Case, the tussle between judiciary and parliament began. Further, the tensions were ignited with the politically controversial appointment of Justice A.N. Ray as the chief Justice of India.
5) The verdict of Allahabad High Court: The order came on an election petition filed by Raj Narain, who contested against Indira Gandhi in 1971. The judgement declared that she is no more an MP.
The above mentioned reasons led to the promulgation of National Emergency in 1975.
The impacts of this was:
1. the strikes and Hartals were banned.
2. the opposition leaders were put in jails.
3. the government suspended Freedom of Press.
4. the various Fundamental rights (including Article 14, 19, 21 & 22 ) were suspended.
5. The government made extensive use of preventive detention.
6. the government bought in many amendments to the constitution through 42nd and 43rd constitutional amendments.
The 42nd CAA affected the constitution to the extent that it is called as ‘mini constitution’. During emergency, the election of 1976 were postponed to 1978 and as a result of emergency, Indira Gandhi lost the elections. The new government was formed by Janta Dal and various controversial amendments of 42nd and 43rd CAA were abrogated by 44th CAA.