You work as a customs officer in one of India’s well-known port cities. Recently, a shipment containing more than 5000 kg of red sandalwood was intercepted by your crew. You detained a few people for allegedly trying to smuggle red sandalwood, also known as red sander, to another country. Red sandalwood is protected under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) list and is not allowed for export. But as time goes on, you find out that these individuals are employed by a powerful businessman who has strong connections to the state’s ruling party. You have received explicit instructions from your department’s seniors not to register any compliance at this time. You worry that the businessman and a few dishonest department officers would make a deal that will release the people who are in custody. Although you are prepared to file the complaint, you are also afraid that if you defy your superiors, the department will take action against you.
(A) In the aforementioned instance, what options are available to you? Consider the benefits and drawbacks of each of them.
(B) Moreover, state your plan of action and the rationale behind it, without necessarily limiting yourself to the choices listed above.
Answer: From the facts of the case, it is evident that Red Sandalwood is a prohibited item for export and is covered under the CITES list. Your team has intercepted a consignment having over 5000 kilograms of red sandalwood which is illegal and in violation of law. There is an unholy nexus between the influential businessman, ruling party of the state and your senior. The case pertains to concerns regarding your jurisdiction and professional obligation/duty to maintain law and order.
(a) Various options available with merits and demerits:
(b) The officer must go for the fourth option and should take the following course of action:
The official must fulfil his responsibility and uphold the principles of rule of law, and professional integrity.
(A) Options Available and their Considerations:
(B) Recommended Plan of Action:
Here’s a multi-pronged approach that attempts to balance risk with achieving a positive outcome:
The investigation into the intercepted shipment of over 5000 kg of red sandalwood is ongoing. Several individuals have been detained for their alleged involvement in this smuggling attempt. Red sandalwood is a protected species under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), and its trade is strictly regulated. This seizure highlights the ongoing issues of illegal wildlife trade and the need for stringent enforcement of regulations to protect endangered species. Further details will be shared as the investigation progresses.