Compare the Rajya Sabha’s and the Lok Sabha’s respective powers. (Answer in 200 words)
Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
Under the Constitution, the Parliament of India consists of three parts viz., the President, the Council of States (Rajya Sabha) and the House of the People (Lok Sabha). The Rajya Sabha is the Upper House and the Lok Sabha is the Lower House. The former represents the states of the Indian Union, while the latter represents the people of India as a whole. Both houses share similar powers and responsibilities with respect to passing of ordinary bills, constitution amendment, impeachment of the President, removal of Judges of the High Courts and the Supreme Court etc.
However, there are certain special powers accorded to the Lok Sabha:
Similarly, the Rajya Sabha also enjoys some special powers that are not given to the Lok Sabha.
The Rajya Sabha was envisaged as a revising chamber and a protection against majority government. Thus, both the houses play a critical role in the maintenance of the federal equilibrium in the country.
The Lok Sabha (House of the People) and the Rajya Sabha (Council of States) are the two houses of the Indian Parliament, with distinct powers and responsibilities.
Powers of the Lok Sabha:
1. The Lok Sabha is the primary legislative body, having the power to initiate and pass bills, including money bills.
2. The Lok Sabha has the exclusive power to elect the Prime Minister and hold the government accountable through mechanisms like no-confidence motions.
3. The Lok Sabha has the power to impeach the President and remove the Vice President.
4. Money bills can only be introduced in the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha has a limited role in their passage.
5. The Lok Sabha enjoys greater control over the executive branch, as the Prime Minister and their cabinet are responsible to it.
Powers of the Rajya Sabha:
1. The Rajya Sabha has the power to review and provide recommendations on bills passed by the Lok Sabha, except for money bills.
2. The Rajya Sabha has the power to initiate and pass regular bills, which are then sent to the Lok Sabha for consideration.
3. The Rajya Sabha has the power to investigate and recommend the removal of the President or the Vice President through impeachment.
4. The Rajya Sabha has the power to approve the declaration of emergency, the proclamation of President’s rule, and the ratification of constitutional amendments.
While the Lok Sabha is considered the more powerful house, the Rajya Sabha plays a crucial role in providing a platform for representation of the states and in the overall legislative process.
The lower house Lok Sabha, in turn is relatively more powerful especially with this being the case in financial matters. While the Rajya Sabha cannot amend Money Bills, it has 14 days to suggest changes after the Lok Sabha passes a money bill. The suggestions had to be approved or rejected by the truly representative body, Lok Sabha. The Lok Sabha also is the superior in confidence and no-confidence motions, which can yank down any government once passed.
Rajya Sabha, thus essential for ensuring that smaller states get their say and also act as a check on hasty legislation The assembly cannot be dissolved and is a perpetual body with members serving six-year terms, three Progresoakiende at the same period. It is granted to it before-hand that while an introduction of or any change in the non-financial bill can happen, but its passing is ultimately subject to approval by Lok Sabha only. Money Bills and the Budget can be delayed by a maximum of 14 days in the Rajya Sabha.
All things considered, the Rajya Sabha ensures state representation and provides a more thoughtful authoritative cycle, although the Lok Sabha has more notable control over monetary regulation and the chief. Collectively, they maintain harmony in India’s political system and vote-based governance framework by balancing the interests of the populace and the states.
Definition
The lower house or house of people. Bills are passed, and laws are made for better governance of India.
The upper house of the parliament or council of states. Provides protection to the rights of different states.
Constitutional Provision
Article 81 deals with the composition of the House of People.
Article 80 is associated with the composition of the Council of States.
Tenure Period
The tenure of the Lok Sabha is normally 5 years.
Rajya Sabha is a permanent house of parliament with no fixed tenure.
Election for Membership
The members of the Lok Sabha are elected through the voting process with the involvement of the common people.
The members of the Rajya Sabha are elected by the representatives of state legislative assemblies of states and union territories.
Election Principle
Universal Adult Franchise is applied for the Lok Sabha election.
Proportional Representation by means of single transferable votes is applied for the Rajya Sabha election.
Strength
The strength of the Lok Sabha ranges from 500 to 552. Presently, there are 543 seats.
The strength of the Rajya Sabha ranges from 200 to 250. Currently, there are 245 seats.
Minimum Age
To be an MP (Member of Parliament) of the Lok Sabha, one has to be at least 25 years of age.
To be an MP (Member of Parliament) of the Rajya Sabha, one has to be at least 30 years of age.
House Representative
The business of Lok Sabha is conducted by the speaker of Lok Sabha.
The business of Rajya Sabha is conducted by the Vice-President as the chairman of Rajya Sabha.
Role
Lok Sabha has a greater role in legislation and passing money bills as compared to the Rajya Sabha.
Rajya Sabha has exclusive rights and powers to make laws on state lists and create new all-India services.
The Lok Sabha (House of the People) and the Rajya Sabha (Council of States) are the two houses of India’s Parliament, each with distinct powers and functions.
#Lok Sabha
1. Legislative Powers: The Lok Sabha has greater legislative authority. Most bills, particularly money bills, must be introduced and approved first by the Lok Sabha. The Rajya Sabha can only suggest amendments or delay money bills for 14 days, but it cannot reject them.
2. Financial Powers: The Lok Sabha holds significant financial control. It alone can introduce and pass money bills and the annual budget. The Rajya Sabha’s role is advisory oinancial matters.
3. Control Over Executive: The Lok Sabha exercises substantial control over the executive. The Prime Minister and the Council of Ministers are accountable to the Lok Sabha, and they must maintain its confidence. The Lok Sabha can pass a vote of no confidence to dismiss the government.
# Rajya Sabha
1. Legislative Powers: The Rajya Sabha has the power to review, suggest amendments, and delay legislation, except for money bills. It can introduce and pass ordinary bills, which must then be approved by the Lok Sabha.
2. State Representation: The Rajya Sabha represents the states of India, providing a federal balance. It safeguards the interests of states against the potential dominance of the central government.
3. Permanent Body: Unlike the Lok Sabha, which is subject to dissolution every five years, the Rajya Sabha is a permanent body with staggered biennial elections, ensuring continuity in the legislative process.
In summary, while the Lok Sabha wields more decisive legislative and financial powers and has control over the executive, the Rajya Sabha plays a crucial role in federal representation and provides stability and continuity to the parliamentary system.
Lok Sabha vs. Rajya Sabha: Pillars of Indian Democracy
The Indian Parliament is bicameral, consisting of the Lok Sabha (House of the People) and the Rajya Sabha (Council of States). Both houses play vital roles, but with distinct characteristics:
Origin:
Members:
Powers:
Selection Procedure:
Speaker Selection:
Bills Passed by Members:
Eligibility Criteria:
In essence, Lok Sabha represents the immediate voice of the people, while Rajya Sabha provides a platform for states’ concerns and ensures long-term, considered legislation. This bicameral system fosters a healthy balance in India’s vibrant democracy.
Lok Sabha vs Rajya Sabha: A Power Comparison
India’s bicameral parliament consists of two houses: the Lok Sabha (House of the People) and the Rajya Sabha (Council of States). While both play crucial roles in India’s democracy, their powers differ significantly.
Key Differences in Powers
Rajya Sabha’s Unique Powers
The Rajya Sabha has some special powers, including:
Recent Power Dynamics
The recent passage of controversial farm bills highlighted the power struggle between the houses. The government’s decision to classify these as money bills limited the Rajya Sabha’s ability to block or significantly amend them.
In conclusion, while the Lok Sabha generally holds more power, the Rajya Sabha plays a crucial role in India’s federal structure and legislative process.
Legislative Powers
Lok Sabha:
Primary Role: The principal legislative body, responsible for passing most laws.
Money Bills: Only the Lok Sabha can introduce and pass Money Bills related to taxation and public expenditure. The Rajya Sabha can only suggest amendments.
Government Confidence: The government must maintain the confidence of the Lok Sabha to stay in power. A vote of no confidence requires a majority in the Lok Sabha.
Rajya Sabha:
Review Role: Reviews and suggests amendments to bills passed by the Lok Sabha. It cannot reject Money Bills.
Legislative Process: Can introduce non-Money Bills and participate in discussions but has a consultative role.
Government Formation
Lok Sabha:
Formation: The majority party or coalition in the Lok Sabha forms the government, and the Prime Minister is always a member of the Lok Sabha.
Rajya Sabha:
No Direct Role: Does not directly influence government formation or confidence motions.
Representation and Membership
Lok Sabha:
Direct Elections: Members are elected by the public from constituencies. Maximum of 552 members.
Rajya Sabha:
Indirect Elections: Members are elected by state assemblies and nominated by the President. Up to 250 members.
Financial Powers
Lok Sabha:
Control: Has authority over financial matters, including the annual budget.
Rajya Sabha:
Limited Role: Can discuss and suggest changes but cannot initiate Money Bills.
Duration
Lok Sabha:
Term: Five years, can be dissolved earlier.
Rajya Sabha:
Continuous: Permanent body with staggered retirements.
Oversight
Lok Sabha:
Central Role: Key in scrutinizing and holding the government accountable.
Rajya Sabha:
Supportive Role: Provides expertise and reviews legislation.
Both Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha have different powers and roles, making up the Indian Parliament.
Lok Sabha: Having more authority in legislative issues, the Lok Sabha is the primary house. It is elected by the public, thus being more reflective of the people’s views. The Lok Sabha alone has the authority to introduce money bills, and its consent is necessary for the approval of the budget and taxation. In case of a conflict on a bill between the two houses, the decision of the Lok Sabha takes precedence. Furthermore, the government is comprised of the party or coalition that has a majority in the Lok Sabha.
Rajya Sabha, serving as the upper house, represents the states and union territories to ensure their interests are represented at the national level. Although it is able to examine and propose changes to bills, it lacks the authority to introduce financial bills. The Rajya Sabha can postpone laws but cannot completely stop them if the Lok Sabha is resolute. It also plays a vital role in showcasing the federal structure of India.
In summary, the Lok Sabha holds more power in legislative processes, while the Rajya Sabha serves as a stabilizing force representing regional interests.