Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
These two legal doctrines fall under civil procedure but, they do not have the same roles nor do they occur in similar contexts.
RES JUDICATA SECTION 11 of CPC.
Meaning: What can be translated to English as “A matter already judged”.
Purpose: This ensures that new trials are not occasioned that had already been determined by a competent court.
Application: Used where there is a previous decision of the superior court on the same issueThe same parties or their representativesA competent court of law.
Effect: Stops future legal actions on an issue between two parties until the initial proceeding has been resolved.
*RES SUBJUDICE SECTION 10 OF CPC*
Meaning: It means a case under the consideration of the court of law or a matter that is before the court.
Purpose: It serves as protection against the initiation of similar actions in different courts concerning the same matter
Application: Used when a case is under consideration in another chamberWhich is still pending in a competent court having jurisdiction
Effect: Demands a stay of the proceedings in the subsequent suit until the first suit has been resolved.
Timing: While Res Judicata takes place after the last judgment, Res Subjudice occurs during the conduct of a case.
Outcome: Res Judicata prevents subsequent actions all together while Res Subjudice only freezes them for the time being.
Finality: Res Judicata entails a finality while Res Subjudice on the other hand pertains to cases still in progress. Both are meant to avoid the risk of different outcomes, save time and resources, and yet they work at different steps in the legal system.
Code of Civil Procedure 1908 deals with two important doctrine “Res Judicata” and “Res Sub Judice”. The key differences between the two are:
Meaning:
Sec 11 CPC deals with the doctrine of Res Judicata and states that a matter that has already been decided by a competent court it can’t be re-opened in subsequent litigation.
Sec 10 CPC deals with Res Sub judice and it prevents the courts from taking up any matter which is still pending before subsequent court.
Purpose
The main purpose of Res Judicata is to protect individuals from being harassed by multiplicity of suits.
The purpose behind doctrine of Res sub Judice is to ensure there is conflicting or multiple judgements and matter to be decided by only one competent court.
Stage Of Litigation
Res Judicata is applicable after the final Judgement has been pronounced whereas Res Sub judice is applicable when the suit is pending.
Effect
Res Judicate bars further litigation on the decided issue on the other hand Res Sub judice stays the trial of the pending suit.