Home/upsc: india & neighbourhood/Page 3
- Recent Questions
- Most Answered
- Answers
- No Answers
- Most Visited
- Most Voted
- Random
- Bump Question
- New Questions
- Sticky Questions
- Polls
- Followed Questions
- Favorite Questions
- Recent Questions With Time
- Most Answered With Time
- Answers With Time
- No Answers With Time
- Most Visited With Time
- Most Voted With Time
- Random With Time
- Bump Question With Time
- New Questions With Time
- Sticky Questions With Time
- Polls With Time
- Followed Questions With Time
- Favorite Questions With Time
Examine India's water-sharing agreements and disputes with its neighbours, particularly Bangladesh and Nepal. Discuss the environmental, economic, and political implications of these water-related issues and India's efforts to find equitable solutions.
Water-sharing agreements and disputes between India and its neighboring countries, specifically Bangladesh and Nepal, are complex issues that have far-reaching environmental, economic, and political implications. As water resources become increasingly scarce, understanding and addressing these challRead more
Water-sharing agreements and disputes between India and its neighboring countries, specifically Bangladesh and Nepal, are complex issues that have far-reaching environmental, economic, and political implications. As water resources become increasingly scarce, understanding and addressing these challenges is crucial for sustainable development and regional cooperation. In this article, we will delve into the dynamics of India’s water-related issues with Bangladesh and Nepal, exploring their environmental impact, economic consequences, political dimensions, and India’s efforts to find equitable solutions.
Water Sharing with Bangladesh:
Environmental Implications: The shared rivers, such as the Ganges and Brahmaputra, are lifelines for both India and Bangladesh. However, factors like pollution, deforestation, and climate change pose environmental threats. Disruptions in water flow and water quality impact ecosystems, biodiversity, and the overall health of the rivers.
Economic Implications: Bangladesh heavily relies on river resources for agriculture, fisheries, and transportation. Unilateral activities upstream, such as dam construction or water diversion, can lead to reduced water availability and hamper economic activities, affecting livelihoods and food security.
Political Implications: Water-sharing disputes have been a longstanding challenge in India-Bangladesh relations. Balancing the water needs of both countries while addressing the concerns of riparian communities requires delicate diplomacy and mutual trust. These issues have the potential to strain bilateral ties and hinder broader regional cooperation.
India’s Efforts: India has undertaken initiatives to address water-related challenges with Bangladesh. Agreements like the Ganges Water Sharing Treaty and the Joint River Commission facilitate regular dialogue, data sharing, and cooperative river basin management. These efforts aim to ensure equitable utilization of water resources, environmental sustainability, and mutual benefits.
Water Sharing with Nepal:
Environmental Implications: Nepal’s mountainous terrain makes it the source of several major rivers flowing into India. Dams, hydropower projects, and river diversion activities in Nepal can alter water flow patterns and affect downstream ecosystems, causing ecological disruptions and potential loss of biodiversity.
Economic Implications: Nepal’s rivers contribute significantly to India’s water supply, irrigation, and hydropower generation. Disputes or delays in water-sharing agreements can impact agricultural productivity, energy availability, and economic development in both countries, hampering regional progress.
Political Implications: Water-sharing disputes have occasionally strained India-Nepal relations. Historical agreements like the Kosi and Gandak treaties require ongoing cooperation and periodic reviews. Ensuring equitable distribution and the fair utilization of water resources necessitates diplomatic negotiations and mutual understanding.
India’s Efforts: India has fostered dialogue and cooperation with Nepal to address water-related concerns. Mechanisms like the Joint Committee on Water Resources and bilateral projects promote information sharing, joint development, and mutual benefits. These initiatives aim to enhance trust, minimize water conflicts, and foster regional stability.
Efforts to find equitable solutions:
India recognizes the importance of equitable water-sharing and sustainable development. It has focused on integrated water resource management, investing in technology, infrastructure, and monitoring mechanisms. Collaborative platforms such as the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) provide avenues for multilateral discussions and consensus-building.
India’s approach emphasizes inclusivity, transparency, and the principle of “water for all.” It seeks to balance the needs of riparian communities, foster environmental protection, and encourage regional cooperation. By engaging in constructive dialogue, data sharing, and joint projects, India strives to find equitable solutions that benefit all stakeholders.
In conclusion, India’s water-sharing agreements and disputes with Bangladesh and Nepal have profound implications for the environment, economy, and politics of the region. Through diplomatic efforts, bilateral agreements, and regional cooperation, India aims to navigate these challenges, ensuring sustainable water management, fostering economic growth, and strengthening relationships with its neighbors. It is through collaborative endeavors that the shared vision of equitable and harmonious water-sharing can be achieved, paving the way for a prosperous and interconnected South Asia.
See lessSecurity and Growth for All in the Region (SAGAR) seeks to differentiate India’s leadership from the methods of other regional powers; it reassures littoral states as India’s maritime influence grows. Analyse.
The Security and Growth for All in the Region (SAGAR) initiative reflects India’s strategic vision for enhancing its maritime influence in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR) while promoting cooperation and development. Here’s an analysis of its significance and implications: 1. Promoting Regional StabiliRead more
There are similarities and interactions between the affirmative action adopted by India and USA owing to similar historical injustices faced by their respective vulnerable groups. Discuss.
India and the United States have implemented affirmative action policies in response to historical injustices faced by their vulnerable populations, reflecting similar goals and interactions : India and the United States have implemented affirmative action policies in response to historical injusticRead more
India and the United States have implemented affirmative action policies in response to historical injustices faced by their vulnerable populations, reflecting similar goals and interactions : India and the United States have implemented affirmative action policies in response to historical injustices faced by their vulnerable populations, reflecting similar goals and interactions:
Similarities:
Historical Context: Again, both countries underwent systematic prejudice or ‘discrimination’ of certain sections of the population on the grounds of caste in India and race in USA. Affirmative action seeks to remedy these injustices through enhancing equality as well as making provisions for the disadvantaged persons.
Policy Objectives: It is for these reasons that affirmative action policies in both countries aim at the promotion of diversity, inclusion and ultimately socio economic equity. These programs try to eliminate the long-standing systematic discrimination which excluded women of color from education, employment, and leadership.
Legal Framework: Reservations in educational institutions and public employment that India has in its constitution like Article 15(4) and Article 16(4) are similar to civil rights act of America of 1964 and other related laws that sought to ban reverse discrimination.
Interactions:
Global Influence: Amid the movement of affirmative actions, both countries have aided each other by providing models and references as southern India’s caste based reservations have helped the country while America’s race based policies have acted as a model for other countries to refer to and follow when it comes to affirmative action.
Challenges and Debates: Each nation encounters controversies and discussions on issues of the suitability, extent, and legal compliance of their affirmative action solutions. As such, key issues of discussion may include issues to do with the extent of meritocracy, issues of reverse discrimination, and the long term social ramifications of such policies.
In conclusion, India and the USA are different in choosing the target groups of affirmative actions and in terms of the legal regime regulating affirmative action policies; however, both states have similarities in historical conditions, goals of affirmative actions, and world positions. This way, their engagement in the practices of dealing with past injustices using affirmative action policies is presented as an ongoing struggle to achieve development which is inclusive in nature as well as striving for more social justice on the global level.
See lessAs security threats increase in form and frequency in the South-West Indian Ocean, discuss the role played by India in relation to small island developing states (SIDS) in the region.
The South-West Indian Ocean (SWIO) region can be defined as the nautical area where the African sovereign island states of Mauritius, Seychelles, Comoros, and Madagascar are strategically located- southwest of the Indian Ocean Region (IOR), adjoining the eastern/south-eastern coastline of the AfricaRead more
The South-West Indian Ocean (SWIO) region can be defined as the nautical area where the African sovereign island states of Mauritius, Seychelles, Comoros, and Madagascar are strategically located- southwest of the Indian Ocean Region (IOR), adjoining the eastern/south-eastern coastline of the African continent. In the post-Cold War era, the Indian Ocean Region (IOR) experienced instability exacerbated by weak government structures and the littorals’ limited capacity to control the maritime domain.
Rise of security threats in the South-West Indian Ocean:
India’s engagement with the SIDS in the SWIO: As part of its commitment to South-South Cooperation (SSC) and its growing profile as a regional power, India has demonstrated its capabilities and willingness to assist them in dealing with common maritime and developmental challenges. These include:
While most of India’s engagements with these island states so far have been bilateral, multilateral engagement is gaining traction. This presents India with an excellent opportunity to distinguish itself from China and play a more constructive role in the SWIO region.
See lessAs India re-imagines its neighborhood, cross-border connectivity through sub-regions is becoming increasingly vital. Analyse.
Answer: The idea of re-integrating India's neighborhood through a sub-regional approach began to emerge in the late 1990s, but it was only in the mid-2000s that a sustained push for sub-regional connectivity started to take concrete shape. Recently, marking 50 years of Bangladesh's independence, IndRead more
Answer: The idea of re-integrating India’s neighborhood through a sub-regional approach began to emerge in the late 1990s, but it was only in the mid-2000s that a sustained push for sub-regional connectivity started to take concrete shape. Recently, marking 50 years of Bangladesh’s independence, India and Bangladesh made a joint decision to explore sub-regional connectivity initiatives with additional road and railway connectivity links to Nepal as well as rail links to Bhutan via Indian Territory. Various steps taken in sub-regional connectivity
Importance of sub-regional connectivity for India in its neighbourhood
However, India’s sub-regional approach towards its neighborhood faces several challenges such as political instability as well as economic imbalances between countries in the region. Further, border disputes between India and some of its neighboring countries can also pose a challenge to sub-regional initiatives, as they can create tensions and disrupt trade and investment flows. Thus, an Indian connectivity strategy will have to consider the political, economic, and cultural sensitivities of the neighboring countries. At the same time, re-integrating the subcontinent by re-discovering the old as well as building new land, sea, and riverine corridors should be a key focus. Moreover, India should invest relatively more in the soft dimensions of connectivity, including capacity building.
See lessIndia needs to be a sensitive and generous partner to Nepal for the "Neighbourhood First" policy to take root. In this context, mention the recent roadblocks in the Indo-Nepal relationship and suggest a way forward.
Answer: India, through its Neighbourhood First policy, strives to build cordial and synergetic relations with its South Asian neighbors in various areas such as economy, science and technology, research, and education, among others. Though India has used this policy for cordial relations with NepalRead more
Answer: India, through its Neighbourhood First policy, strives to build cordial and synergetic relations with its South Asian neighbors in various areas such as economy, science and technology, research, and education, among others. Though India has used this policy for cordial relations with Nepal (like the India-Nepal treaty of trade in 2009, Vaccine Maitri, etc.), there remain certain roadblocks in the Indo-Nepal relationship, highlighted below:
In this context, India needs to be a sensitive and generous partner to Nepal and improve the ties by incorporating the following measures:
The need today is to avoid rhetoric on territorial nationalism and lay the groundwork for quiet dialogue where both sides display sensitivity as they explore what is feasible.
See lessIndia is no longer wedded to 'bilateralism only' in its approach to its South Asian neighbors. Discuss. Also, highlight the challenges pertaining to effective cooperation in the region.
Answer: India had a bilateral approach to its relations with South Asian neighbors in the past, as it preferred to engage in direct negotiations with each country on specific issues and bilateral high-level visits, rather than relying on regional coordination. India also provided development assistaRead more
Answer: India had a bilateral approach to its relations with South Asian neighbors in the past, as it preferred to engage in direct negotiations with each country on specific issues and bilateral high-level visits, rather than relying on regional coordination. India also provided development assistance to individual countries and focused on negotiating trade agreements with individual countries rather than pursuing a regional development and trade mechanism. However, India is no longer wedded to ‘bilateralism only’ in its approach and is adopting a multilateral approach with its immediate neighbors in the following ways:
Challenges pertaining to effective cooperation in the region are as follows:
Although over the last decade, India has made significant progress in connecting with its neighbors, India’s neighborhood policy is still a work in progress as the region adapts to new security challenges.
See lessDespite certain hiccups, recent developments suggest that continuity still looms large in the Indo-Bhutan relationship. Discuss.
Answer: Bhutan has maintained a special relationship with India since the signing of the Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation in 1949. Though the two neighbours have a close civilizational, cultural and economic relationship, there are some challenges in the relationship, as given below: Chinese infRead more
Answer:
Bhutan has maintained a special relationship with India since the signing of the Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation in 1949. Though the two neighbours have a close civilizational, cultural and economic relationship, there are some challenges in the relationship, as given below:
Despite these challenges, recent developments suggest that continuity still looms large in the Indo-Bhutan relationship:
The relationship between India and Bhutan is based on the pillars of trust, goodwill and mutual understanding. It is necessary to address the concerns of Bhutan, specifically related to fulfilling the aspirations of Bhutanese youth in order to fully realise the potential of the longstanding development partnership between the two countries.
See lessThere is a need to address the underlying challenges, both internal and external, in the North- Eastern region of India before it can serve as a pivotal connecting space between India and its neighbours. Comment.
Answer: India's foreign policy priorities, reflected in its "Act East' and 'Neighbourhood First policies, recognize the significance of the North-East region as a vibrant link to the country's eastern neighbours. Geo-strategic advantages of the North-Eastern region of India: It shares 5,812 km of inRead more
Answer: India’s foreign policy priorities, reflected in its “Act East’ and ‘Neighbourhood First policies, recognize the significance of the North-East region as a vibrant link to the country’s eastern neighbours. Geo-strategic advantages of the North-Eastern region of India:
However, various challenges need to be addressed before the potential of the region as a pivotal connecting space can be utilised, such as:
However, the cooperation from BIMSTEC and SASEC countries and Japan can help tackle the above challenges and take advantage of the strategic location of the North-Eastern region and boost economic growth in the region.
See lessThe Indo-China war of 1962 was a result of various factors leading upto the war. Elaborate. Additionally, discuss the significance of the war for India.
Answer: The foreign policy of a nation reflects the interplay of domestic and external factors. Indian foreign policy has been influenced by ideals that inspired India's freedom struggle. The three major objectives of India's foreign policy were to preserve its sovereignty, protect territorial integRead more
Answer: The foreign policy of a nation reflects the interplay of domestic and external factors. Indian foreign policy has been influenced by ideals that inspired India’s freedom struggle. The three major objectives of India’s foreign policy were to preserve its sovereignty, protect territorial integrity, and promote rapid economic development. India sought to achieve these objectives through the strategy of non-alignment. But India’s independence coincided with the beginning of the Cold War era. India’s leadership had to pursue its national interests within the prevailing rivalry between two superpowers, the US and the USSR. These circumstances, as underlying currents, influencing India’s foreign policy are evident from following factors: Peace and Conflict with China India was one of the first countries to recognise the communist government in China. The joint enunciation of Panchsheel on 29 April 1954 was a step in the direction of stronger relationship between the two countries. However, this relationship soured owing to two instances.
Conflict with Pakistan Pakistan emerged as a critical factor in India’s relations with USA and subsequently with China. While India was trying to convince the other developing countries about the policy of non- alignment, Pakistan joined the US-led military alliances.
Indo-US relations: The Indo-US Education Foundation was formulated in 1966 during Indira Gandhi’s first visit to the US as the PM, but could not materialize due to strong opposition in India. This was because America had suspended aid to India in 1965 at the time of the Indo-Pak war. The visit helped India secure more food and development aid from the US. However, India resented the US policy of food aid as a tool in forcing India to adopt policies favored by the US and India resolutely refused to sign the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons. This was done despite India’s heavy dependence on US food aid in the 1960’s. Thus the conduct of foreign relations involves a careful balancing act between both domestic compulsions and prevailing international situations.
See less