Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
Pressure groups are organized collections of individuals or organizations that attempt to influence public policy without seeking elected office. Examples include trade unions, industry associations, environmental groups, and civil rights movements.
They employ various means like lobbying, mass mobilization, and media campaigns to advocate for their interests. Other non-governmental associations like professional bodies, research institutes, and non-profit organizations also shape public discourse and policy through expertise and engagement.
Analyze how religious groups like the Jamaat-e-Islami and the Vishva Hindu Parishad have shaped the conversation in India around religious and communal matters. Examine their impact on the nation’s secular fabric and political decision-making process.
Talk about the goals and strategies used by linguistic and cultural groups, like the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad, to further their individual ideological and cultural agendas, as well as how these groups’ efforts have affected ...
Cultural and linguistic organizations like the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) have distinct objectives and methods for promoting their cultural and ideological agendas in India. Their activities significantly impact the socio-political discourse iRead more
Cultural and linguistic organizations like the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) have distinct objectives and methods for promoting their cultural and ideological agendas in India. Their activities significantly impact the socio-political discourse in the country. Here’s an overview of each organization:
Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP)
Objectives
Promotion of Nationalism: ABVP aims to foster a sense of nationalism and patriotism among Indian students.
Educational Reforms: The organization advocates for reforms in the Indian educational system to align it more closely with traditional Indian values and culture.
Student Welfare: ABVP works to address issues faced by students, including academic, administrative, and social concerns.
Youth Engagement: It aims to involve youth in nation-building activities and create awareness about socio-political issues.
Methods
Student Mobilization: ABVP actively recruits and organizes students through educational institutions, using rallies, seminars, and workshops to disseminate its message.
Campus Activities: It conducts cultural programs, competitions, and lectures to promote Indian culture and values.
Advocacy and Protests: ABVP often engages in protests and agitations to voice student concerns and demand policy changes.
Publications and Media: The organization publishes literature and uses social media to spread its ideology and connect with the student community.
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS)
Objectives
Hindu Nationalism: RSS promotes the idea of Hindutva, seeking to establish Hindu cultural values as the foundation of Indian society.
Social Welfare: The organization aims to serve society through various social service activities.
Cultural Preservation: RSS focuses on preserving and promoting traditional Indian (Hindu) culture, practices, and languages.
National Unity: It strives to foster a sense of national unity and cohesion, emphasizing a unified Hindu identity.
Methods
Shakhas (Branches): Daily and weekly meetings (shakhas) are conducted to train members in physical activities, discipline, and ideological education.
Educational Programs: RSS runs numerous educational institutions to promote its values and ideas from a young age.
Social Service: Through its affiliated organizations, RSS is involved in various social welfare activities, including disaster relief, health services, and rural development.
Publications and Media: RSS publishes books, magazines, and online content to propagate its ideology and reach a wider audience.
Impact on Socio-Political Discourse
Political Influence: Both ABVP and RSS have strong links with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), influencing its policies and political strategies. Many BJP leaders have backgrounds in these organizations.
Cultural Shifts: These organizations have significantly contributed to the rise of Hindu nationalism and a shift towards more conservative social and cultural policies in India.
Educational Policies: Their advocacy has influenced changes in educational policies and curricula to emphasize Indian culture and values more prominently.
Social Mobilization: Through their extensive networks, they mobilize significant segments of society, particularly youth, to support their agendas.
Controversies and Criticism: Both organizations have faced criticism for promoting majoritarian views, marginalizing minority communities, and stoking communal tensions. Critics argue that their activities sometimes lead to polarization and societal division.
Overall, the ABVP and RSS play influential roles in shaping India’s socio-political landscape, promoting their vision of Indian culture and values while simultaneously sparking significant debate and controversy.
Although they have been attacked extensively, pressure organizations are thought to contribute positively to the advancement of democracy and our rights. Talk about.
Talk about the goals, plans, and tactics used by environmental pressure groups like the Save the Narmada and Chipko movements. Consider how much they have contributed to the preservation of the environment, the defense of native American communities, and the ...
**Chipko Movement (1970s)** **Objectives:** 1. **Conservation of Forests:** The Chipko movement aimed to protect the forests and the rights of local communities to use them sustainably. 2. **Empowerment of Women:** The movement sought to empower women to take an active role in environmental conservaRead more
**Chipko Movement (1970s)**
**Objectives:**
1. **Conservation of Forests:** The Chipko movement aimed to protect the forests and the rights of local communities to use them sustainably.
2. **Empowerment of Women:** The movement sought to empower women to take an active role in environmental conservation and decision-making processes.
**Strategies:**
1. **Non-Violent Direct Action:** The movement employed non-violent direct action, including hugging trees (hugging the trees to prevent logging) and organizing sit-ins.
2. **Community-Based Conservation:** The movement focused on community-based conservation, involving local communities in the management and protection of forests.
3. **Education and Awareness:** The movement raised awareness about the importance of forests and the impact of deforestation on the environment and local communities.
**Contribution:**
1. **Protection of Forests:** The Chipko movement helped protect several hundred thousand hectares of forests in the Himalayas.
2. **Empowerment of Women:** The movement empowered women to take a leading role in environmental conservation and community decision-making processes.
3. **Sustainable Development:** The Chipko movement promoted sustainable development by highlighting the importance of conservation and community involvement in forest management.
**Save the Narmada Movement (1980s-1990s)**
**Objectives:**
1. **Protection of the Narmada River:** The movement aimed to protect the Narmada River from large-scale dam projects and promote sustainable development.
2. **Resettlement and Rehabilitation:** The movement sought to ensure fair compensation and rehabilitation for displaced communities affected by dam projects.
**Strategies:**
1. **Non-Violent Protests:** The movement employed non-violent protests, including sit-ins, hunger strikes, and marches.
2. **Mass Mobilization:** The movement mobilized large numbers of people, including farmers, tribals, and workers, to participate in protests and campaigns.
3. **International Support:** The movement gained international support from environmental organizations and human rights groups.
**Contribution:**
1. **Protection of the Narmada River:** The Save the Narmada Movement helped delay and modify large-scale dam projects, ensuring that the Narmada River remained relatively untouched.
2. **Resettlement and Rehabilitation:** The movement ensured fair compensation and rehabilitation for displaced communities, promoting just treatment for affected individuals.
3. **Promotion of Sustainable Development:** The Save the Narmada Movement highlighted the importance of sustainable development, emphasizing the need for environmentally friendly and socially responsible practices.
**Evaluation:**
Both the Chipko movement and the Save the Narmada movement demonstrate the effectiveness of environmental pressure groups in promoting conservation, protecting indigenous communities, and advocating for sustainable development. Their strategies, including non-violent direct action, community-based conservation, education, and mass mobilization, have contributed to significant positive outcomes:
1. **Environmental Conservation:** Both movements have protected significant areas of natural habitats, highlighting the importance of community-based conservation.
2. **Indigenous Community Protection:** Both movements have prioritized the rights and well-being of indigenous communities, ensuring fair treatment and compensation for affected individuals.
3. **Sustainable Development:** Both movements have promoted sustainable development by emphasizing the need for environmentally friendly and socially responsible practices.
However, both movements have also faced challenges, such as government resistance, lack of resources, and limited public awareness. Despite these challenges, their legacy continues to inspire future generations of environmental activists and advocates for social justice.
See lessRoadmap for Answer Writing 1. Introduction Define pressure groups and their role in public policy-making. Introduce business associations as key pressure groups in India. 2. Contributions of Business Associations to Public Policies Lobbying: Explain how business associations lobby policymakers to influence decisions. Example: CII and FICCI advocating ...
Model Answer Introduction Pressure groups, or interest groups, play a significant role in influencing public policy in India. Among these, business associations are prominent actors that actively shape public policies to align with their interests and objectives. Role of Business Associations in ShaRead more
Pressure groups, or interest groups, play a significant role in influencing public policy in India. Among these, business associations are prominent actors that actively shape public policies to align with their interests and objectives.
Business associations engage in extensive lobbying to influence policymakers. For example, the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) and the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce & Industry (FICCI) advocate for pro-business policies, tax reforms, and regulatory simplifications.
These associations provide technical expertise and industry insights, helping policymakers make informed decisions. Notably, NASSCOM’s recommendations on IT policies and the ease of doing business have been instrumental in shaping governmental strategies.
Business associations often fund research initiatives to generate data that supports their policy recommendations. For instance, the Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India (ASSOCHAM) publishes reports on various economic issues, influencing policy debates.
They organize conferences and seminars to discuss pressing policy issues, facilitating dialogue between industry and government. The annual “India Economic Summit,” co-organized by the World Economic Forum and CII, exemplifies this engagement.
Business associations run public campaigns to garner support for their policy positions. FICCI’s campaigns promoting the “Make in India” initiative have notably shaped public opinion and influenced policy direction towards domestic manufacturing.
Business associations regularly participate in governmental policy forums, with representatives from CII and FICCI serving on various committees and task forces involved in policy-making.
Through lobbying, expert advice, research funding, event organization, public campaigns, and representation in policy forums, business associations significantly influence public policy-making in India, ensuring that the interests of the business community are reflected in governmental decisions.
See lessTalk about the formation and development of regional parties, such the Trinamool Congress and the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK), and their function in advancing the interests of particular states or language groups. Examine their effects on coalition politics and India’s ...
**Emergence and Evolution of Regional Parties:** Regional parties in India have emerged as a significant force in Indian politics, particularly in the post-1990s era. These parties have been instrumental in representing the interests of specific states or linguistic communities. Two notable examplesRead more
**Emergence and Evolution of Regional Parties:**
Regional parties in India have emerged as a significant force in Indian politics, particularly in the post-1990s era. These parties have been instrumental in representing the interests of specific states or linguistic communities. Two notable examples are the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) and the Trinamool Congress.
**DMK (Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam):**
1. **Emergence:** The DMK was founded in 1949 by C.N. Annadurai, a former member of the Indian National Congress, to represent the interests of the Tamil people.
2. **Regional Focus:** The DMK focused on issues specific to the Tamil Nadu region, such as language, culture, and self-respect.
3. **Success:** The DMK has had a significant impact on Tamil Nadu’s politics, winning several elections and playing a crucial role in shaping the state’s politics.
4. **National Role:** Although primarily a regional party, the DMK has also participated in national politics, supporting various non-Congress governments at the center.
**Trinamool Congress (TMC):**
1. **Emergence:** The TMC was founded in 1998 by Mamata Banerjee, a former Congress leader, to challenge the dominance of the Left Front in West Bengal.
2. **Regional Focus:** The TMC focused on issues specific to West Bengal, such as industrialization, infrastructure development, and governance.
3. **Success:** The TMC has had significant success in West Bengal, winning multiple elections and forming the government in 2011.
4. **National Role:** Like the DMK, the TMC has also participated in national politics, supporting various non-Congress governments at the center.
**Impact on India’s Federal Structure:**
1. **Regional Autonomy:** Regional parties like the DMK and TMC have played a crucial role in advocating for greater autonomy for their respective states.
2. **Competitive Federalism:** The emergence of regional parties has led to competitive federalism, where different states compete for resources and attention from the center.
3. **Blurring of Party Lines:** Regional parties have blurred the lines between national and regional politics, making it difficult to distinguish between national and local issues.
**Impact on Coalition Politics:**
1. **Unpredictable Alliances:** Regional parties have created unpredictable alliances and coalitions, making it challenging for national parties to form stable governments.
2. **Brokerage Politics:** Regional parties have become key players in brokerage politics, using their influence to negotiate concessions and benefits for their respective regions.
3. **Challenges to National Parties:** Regional parties have challenged the dominance of national parties like the Congress and BJP, forcing them to adapt to changing political landscapes.
**Conclusion:**
Regional parties like the DMK and TMC have emerged as significant forces in Indian politics, representing the interests of specific states or linguistic communities. Their impact on India’s federal structure has been profound, leading to competitive federalism and unpredictable alliances. While they have challenged national parties’ dominance, they have also brought greater attention to regional issues and concerns.
See lessRoadmap for Answer Writing 1. Introduction Definition of Khap Panchayats: Briefly describe what Khap Panchayats are and their traditional role in society. Context of Human Rights Violations: Introduce the issue of Khap Panchayats acting as extra-constitutional authorities and the types of human rights ...
Model Answer Introduction Khap Panchayats are traditional caste-based councils primarily found in northern India, particularly in states like Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, and Rajasthan. These councils have been criticized for operating as extra-constitutional authorities, often making pronouncements thatRead more
Khap Panchayats are traditional caste-based councils primarily found in northern India, particularly in states like Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, and Rajasthan. These councils have been criticized for operating as extra-constitutional authorities, often making pronouncements that lead to human rights violations, including honor killings and gender discrimination.
The Indian Parliament has enacted several laws aimed at protecting individual rights and prohibiting honor killings. Key legislations include:
Despite these laws, their effectiveness is limited due to the entrenched influence of Khap Panchayats, which often operate outside the formal legal framework .
The executive branch, including police and local administration, has taken steps to address human rights violations linked to Khap Panchayats. Actions include:
However, these measures have often been reactive rather than proactive, with inadequate enforcement of existing laws .
The judiciary has played a crucial role in countering the influence of Khap Panchayats. Notable actions include:
Despite legislative, executive, and judicial efforts, the influence of Khap Panchayats continues, largely due to deep-rooted patriarchal norms and socio-political power dynamics in rural areas. To effectively combat these issues, it is essential to raise awareness about the unconstitutionality of Khap actions, empower local law enforcement, and promote social change to challenge regressive customs.
See lessAnalyze the contribution and impact of think tanks, including the Centre for Policy Research and the Observer Research Foundation, to formulating public policy, research, and discourse on various matters of national significance.
Think tanks play a crucial role in shaping public policy and national discourse by providing research-based recommendations, engaging in policy analysis, and influencing public opinion. In India, organizations like the Observer Research Foundation (ORF) and the Centre for Policy Research (CPR) are pRead more
Think tanks play a crucial role in shaping public policy and national discourse by providing research-based recommendations, engaging in policy analysis, and influencing public opinion. In India, organizations like the Observer Research Foundation (ORF) and the Centre for Policy Research (CPR) are prominent examples of such think tanks. Here’s an evaluation of their roles and influences:
Observer Research Foundation (ORF)
Role and Objectives:
Policy Research: ORF conducts extensive research on a range of topics, including foreign policy, national security, economic development, and technology. Its objective is to offer data-driven insights and policy recommendations.
Public Engagement: The foundation organizes conferences, seminars, and workshops to discuss pressing issues, engaging policymakers, academics, and the public in dialogues that influence policy discussions.
Publications and Media: ORF produces reports, policy briefs, and articles that contribute to public discourse and provide evidence-based recommendations to stakeholders.
Influence:
Policy Recommendations: ORF’s research has informed policy decisions on various fronts, including international relations and economic strategies. Its expertise is often sought by government officials and policymakers.
Shaping Discourse: By organizing high-profile events and publishing research, ORF influences public debate and helps shape the narrative around key national and international issues.
Networking and Collaboration: ORF collaborates with international think tanks and research organizations, enhancing its impact on global policy discussions and fostering cross-border exchanges of ideas.
Challenges:
Resource Dependency: Like many think tanks, ORF’s ability to influence policy can be limited by its funding sources and the need to balance independence with financial sustainability.
Political Neutrality: Ensuring political neutrality while engaging with various stakeholders can be challenging, as think tanks are often perceived to have particular ideological leanings.
Centre for Policy Research (CPR)
Role and Objectives:
Research and Analysis: CPR focuses on in-depth research and analysis on issues such as governance, urban development, and social policy. It aims to provide evidence-based recommendations to improve public policy and governance.
Policy Advocacy: CPR engages in advocacy efforts by highlighting research findings and working with government bodies, civil society, and other stakeholders to drive policy changes.
Educational Contributions: The centre contributes to academic discourse by publishing research papers, books, and policy briefs, and organizing seminars and lectures.
Influence:
Policy Impact: CPR’s research has influenced a range of policy areas, including urban planning, social welfare, and public administration. Its recommendations are often incorporated into policy frameworks and government strategies.
Public Discourse: CPR helps shape public discourse through its publications and public engagement activities, providing a platform for informed debate on critical issues.
Academic Contributions: By contributing to the academic field, CPR influences the broader intellectual and policy-making community, fostering a deeper understanding of complex issues.
Challenges:
Visibility and Reach: While CPR’s research is highly regarded, its impact can be limited by challenges in reaching broader audiences and translating research findings into actionable policy.
Political Dynamics: Navigating the political landscape and maintaining credibility in the face of political pressures can be a challenge, particularly when dealing with contentious or sensitive issues.
Conclusion
Both ORF and CPR play significant roles in providing policy recommendations, conducting research, and shaping public discourse:
ORF is known for its wide-ranging research and public engagement efforts, influencing both national and international policy discussions.
CPR excels in in-depth research and advocacy, contributing to academic and policy debates on governance and social issues.
Their effectiveness in shaping policy and discourse is closely tied to their ability to produce high-quality research, engage with diverse stakeholders, and maintain credibility in a complex political environment. Challenges related to resource dependency, political neutrality, and visibility are ongoing, but both organizations continue to make meaningful contributions to the public policy landscape in India.
Relieving stress effectively involves incorporating physical, mental, and emotional strategies into your daily routine. Regular exercise is key, as it releases endorphins that improve mood and reduce stress. Practice deep breathing techniques and mindfulness meditation to calm the nervous system andRead more
Relieving stress effectively involves incorporating physical, mental, and emotional strategies into your daily routine. Regular exercise is key, as it releases endorphins that improve mood and reduce stress. Practice deep breathing techniques and mindfulness meditation to calm the nervous system and focus on the present moment. Ensure you get adequate sleep and maintain a healthy diet, as both significantly impact stress levels.
Emotionally, talking to someone you trust can help process stress. Journaling is another effective method to express and release built-up tension. Engage in hobbies and activities you enjoy to provide a mental break from stressors. Implementing good time management skills, setting boundaries, and learning to say no can prevent feeling overwhelmed.
Quick stress-relief tips include taking short breaks during stressful situations, listening to calming music, and finding humor in daily life. Progressive muscle relaxation and visualization techniques can also reduce physical and mental tension. Limiting caffeine and alcohol, which can heighten anxiety, is advisable.
Experiment with different strategies to find what works best for you. Integrating a combination of these methods into your lifestyle can help manage stress effectively, leading to a healthier and more balanced life.
See lessAlthough pressure organizations have a significant impact on governance, there have been questions raised about the groups’ funding, representativeness, and ties to the government. Talk about it.
Pressure groups are also known as interest or lobbying groups. They play an important part in the democratic society because they hold different portfolios of the communities and affect the policy outcomes. However, few criticisms have been made with regard to their openness, sample selection, and aRead more
Pressure groups are also known as interest or lobbying groups. They play an important part in the democratic society because they hold different portfolios of the communities and affect the policy outcomes. However, few criticisms have been made with regard to their openness, sample selection, and affiliation to the government.
Online? Publicity of Higher Education Institutions Transparency and Accountability
Another problem is that most pressure groups are not very clear on how they fund or operate. The origins of funding, techniques of exercising influence, and the extent of such influence over public policy are frequently not well defined or easily discernible. This can lead to an apprehension of assertion and corruption within the altogether faulty system.
Representativeness
Another problem is the question of whose interest a pressure group represents. Some organizational interests may be vested within a restring section of society while others maybe given an over arching mandate. It may cause some groups to have a blunt power or financial authority more than the others, for instance, the executive has more power than the legislative.
Relation with government
The relationship between pressure groups and the government can also be got complicated at times This relationship may also be problematic. There is a possibility where some of these pressure groups have some relationship with government in that they are affiliated to some of the government official thus compromise the proficiency of these groups. More over, such theories post that the government might fast benefit those pressure groups that have power, while ignoring those minoritarians.
Such issues raise the importance of more openness and accountability in the functions of pressure groups. Such might be made to be through legal compulsory declarations on their funding, sever legislation against pressure groups on lobbyings, as well as publicity concerning pressure groups on the political operations. Lastly, an effort must be made so that it constitutes voices that can stand against some types of discrimination during policy formulation.
See less
Religious organizations like the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) and Jamaat-e-Islami play significant roles in shaping the discourse on religious and communal issues in India. Their influence on political decision-making and the country's secular fabric is multifaceted and impactful. Here’s an in-depthRead more
Religious organizations like the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) and Jamaat-e-Islami play significant roles in shaping the discourse on religious and communal issues in India. Their influence on political decision-making and the country’s secular fabric is multifaceted and impactful. Here’s an in-depth examination:
Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP)
See lessRole and Impact
Promotion of Hindu Nationalism: The VHP, an affiliate of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), promotes Hindutva, a form of Hindu nationalism. It emphasizes the cultural and religious identity of Hindus and often positions itself against perceived threats to this identity from other religious communities, especially Muslims and Christians.
Campaigns and Movements: The VHP has been involved in various campaigns, such as the Ram Janmabhoomi movement, which led to the demolition of the Babri Masjid in 1992. This event significantly heightened communal tensions between Hindus and Muslims.
Educational and Social Services: The VHP runs schools, healthcare services, and social programs that promote its ideological perspective. These initiatives often aim to foster a sense of Hindu unity and cultural pride.
Influence on Political Decision-Making
Political Alliances: The VHP is closely aligned with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), India’s ruling party. This relationship allows the VHP to influence policy decisions, especially those related to cultural and religious issues.
Policy Advocacy: The VHP actively lobbies for policies that reflect its Hindu nationalist agenda, such as the implementation of the Uniform Civil Code and anti-conversion laws.
Mobilization of Voters: By mobilizing its extensive grassroots network, the VHP plays a crucial role in election campaigns, helping to consolidate the Hindu vote bank for the BJP.
Jamaat-e-Islami
Role and Impact
Islamic Education and Awareness: Jamaat-e-Islami focuses on promoting Islamic education and values. It runs numerous schools and religious institutions aimed at fostering a deeper understanding of Islam among Indian Muslims.
Social and Political Activism: The organization engages in social welfare activities, including disaster relief, healthcare, and education. It also addresses issues like poverty and unemployment among Muslims.
Communal Harmony and Justice: While advocating for the rights of Muslims, Jamaat-e-Islami also participates in initiatives promoting communal harmony and justice, though it often positions itself against policies and actions it perceives as discriminatory towards Muslims.
Influence on Political Decision-Making
Political Engagement: Though Jamaat-e-Islami does not have a direct political wing like the VHP, it influences political discourse through alliances with secular and Muslim political parties. It has been involved in various political coalitions and campaigns, advocating for Muslim interests.
Policy Advocacy: The organization lobbies for policies that protect the rights of Muslims, such as minority rights, reservations, and protection against communal violence.
Community Mobilization: Through its extensive network, Jamaat-e-Islami mobilizes the Muslim community on key issues, influencing voter behavior and public opinion.
Impact on India’s Secular Fabric
Communal Tensions: Both organizations contribute to communal tensions through their rhetoric and activities. The VHP’s Hindutva agenda and Jamaat-e-Islami’s focus on Muslim identity can sometimes exacerbate Hindu-Muslim relations.
Secularism vs. Religious Identity: The active involvement of religious organizations in politics challenges India’s secular framework. While they argue for the protection of their respective communities’ rights, their actions can lead to the marginalization of other communities and increase religious polarization.
Policy Implications: The influence of these organizations on political decision-making can lead to policies that favor specific religious communities, potentially undermining the secular principles enshrined in the Indian Constitution.
Conclusion
Religious organizations like the VHP and Jamaat-e-Islami play crucial roles in shaping the discourse on religious and communal issues in India. Their influence extends to the political sphere, where they impact policy decisions and electoral outcomes. While they provide valuable services to their communities and advocate for their rights, their activities often contribute to communal tensions and challenge the secular fabric of the nation. Balancing religious identity with secular principles remains a complex and ongoing challenge for India.