Roadmap for Answer Writing Introduction Define the purpose and function of parliamentary committees. Briefly mention their importance in enhancing the legislative process. Usefulness of Committees for Parliamentary Work Discuss specific reasons why committees are considered beneficial: Expertise Development: How committees enable MPs to gain specialized knowledge. Detailed ...
Model Answer Introduction Simultaneous elections, or "One Nation, One Election," propose conducting Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections at the same time in India. This concept aims to streamline the electoral process, reduce costs, and minimize disruptions caused by frequent elections. AdvantagesRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Simultaneous elections, or “One Nation, One Election,” propose conducting Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections at the same time in India. This concept aims to streamline the electoral process, reduce costs, and minimize disruptions caused by frequent elections.
Advantages of Simultaneous Elections
- Saving Resources: Conducting elections concurrently can significantly reduce financial and administrative expenditures. The Election Commission of India estimates that simultaneous elections could save over ₹4,500 crores per election cycle, which can be redirected to development projects .
- Policy Continuity: With fewer elections, governments can focus on long-term policy implementation rather than being driven by election cycles. This can lead to more stable governance and better execution of developmental programs .
- Reduced Election Fatigue: Frequent elections can lead to voter fatigue, resulting in lower turnout. Simultaneous elections can alleviate this issue by consolidating the electoral process, encouraging higher voter participation .
- Mitigating the Impact of the Model Code of Conduct: The Model Code of Conduct restricts government activities during elections, which can hinder developmental projects. Conducting elections simultaneously can limit these interruptions, allowing for continuous governance .
Disadvantages of Simultaneous Elections
- Reduced Government Accountability: Fewer elections mean fewer opportunities for citizens to express dissatisfaction with government performance. This could lead to a disconnect between the electorate and elected officials, reducing accountability .
- Dilution of Local Issues: Combining national and state elections may shift focus to national issues, overshadowing local concerns that are equally important to voters. This can diminish the representation of local interests .
- Impact on Coalition Governments: In a scenario where a hung Parliament or Assembly arises, forming coalition governments could become more complicated with simultaneous elections, potentially leading to political instability .
- Constitutional Challenges: Implementing simultaneous elections would require significant amendments to the Constitution, which poses logistical and political challenges, potentially disrupting the federal structure of the country .
Conclusion
While simultaneous elections offer clear benefits in terms of saving time and resources, they may also compromise government accountability and dilute local representation. A careful evaluation of these pros and cons, along with public consultations, is essential to ensure that such a system strengthens, rather than undermines, India’s democratic processes.
See less
Model Answer Introduction Committees are vital components of the legislative process in parliamentary systems, providing platforms for detailed scrutiny of legislative proposals, policies, and budgets. Comprising Members of Parliament (MPs) from various political parties, these committees function iRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Committees are vital components of the legislative process in parliamentary systems, providing platforms for detailed scrutiny of legislative proposals, policies, and budgets. Comprising Members of Parliament (MPs) from various political parties, these committees function in a non-partisan manner, enhancing the overall efficiency of the parliamentary process.
Why Committees are Useful for Parliamentary Work
Role of the Estimates Committee
The Estimates Committee, a key standing committee, performs several critical functions:
Conclusion
Parliamentary committees, particularly the Estimates Committee, significantly enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of the legislative process. By facilitating comprehensive scrutiny, developing MP expertise, and promoting a cooperative atmosphere, these committees play a crucial role in ensuring transparent and accountable governance.
See less