Amendments in Indian Constitution Provisions
The Constitution of India has provisions for amending its various provisions, ensuring its relevance and adaptability to changing times. The amendment process involves a rigorous procedure, requiring either a two-thirds majority in both houses of Parliament or a simple majority plus ratification by at least half of the state legislatures.
Since its adoption in 1950, the Constitution has been amended over 100 times, addressing evolving needs and challenges faced by the country.
Share
What are the criticisms of the amendment procedure under the Indian Constitution?
The amendment procedure under the Indian Constitution has been criticized on several grounds. Some of the main criticisms are: Complexity: The amendment procedure is cumbersome and time-consuming, requiring a two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament and ratification by at least half of the SRead more
The amendment procedure under the Indian Constitution has been criticized on several grounds. Some of the main criticisms are:
- Complexity: The amendment procedure is cumbersome and time-consuming, requiring a two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament and ratification by at least half of the State Legislatures. This makes it difficult to make timely changes to the Constitution.
- Difficulty in making major changes: The Constitution requires a special majority of two-thirds in both Houses of Parliament and ratification by half of the State Legislatures for major changes to the Constitution. This makes it challenging to make significant changes to the fundamental structure and principles of the Constitution.
- Lack of flexibility: The amendment procedure does not provide sufficient flexibility to adapt to changing circumstances. For example, it is difficult to make changes to the Constitution to address new issues or problems that have arisen since the Constitution was drafted.
- No provision for judicial review: The Constitution does not provide for judicial review of amendments, which means that there is no mechanism to ensure that amendments are consistent with the spirit and principles of the Constitution.
- Vulnerability to abuse: The amendment procedure can be vulnerable to abuse by governments, as they can use their majority in Parliament to push through changes that may not be in the best interests of the country or its people.
- Lack of representation: The amendment procedure does not provide adequate representation for all sections of society, particularly marginalized groups such as women, Dalits, and minorities.
- No provision for urgent changes: The amendment procedure does not provide for urgent changes, which can lead to delays in addressing pressing issues or crises.
- No mechanism for popular referendum: There is no provision for a popular referendum or a plebiscite, which can lead to a lack of public participation and ownership in the amendment process.
See lessEvaluate the nature of the Bhakti Movement and its contribution to Indian culture.
Bhakti Literature is a significant part of Indian culture that emerged during the medieval period. It refers to a collection of devotional texts written in various Indian languages by poets and saints who advocated the path of devotion to attain the divine. The nature of Bhakti Literature is charactRead more
Bhakti Literature is a significant part of Indian culture that emerged during the medieval period. It refers to a collection of devotional texts written in various Indian languages by poets and saints who advocated the path of devotion to attain the divine. The nature of Bhakti Literature is characterized by its intense emotional appeal, simplicity, and accessibility to the masses.
The nature of Bhakti literature to the reference of the context of Indian culture: Bhakti literature holds significant importance in the context of Indian culture. Here are some key aspects of the nature of Bhakti literature in the reference of Indian culture:
Linguistic Diversity: Bhakti literature embraces the rich linguistic diversity of India. It is composed in various regional languages, allowing people from different linguistic backgrounds to engage with and express their devotion in their native tongues.
Inclusivity and Equality: Bhakti literature transcends social barriers and promotes inclusivity. It emphasises that devotion is accessible to all,that devotion is accessible to all, regardless of caste, creed, or social status. It fosters a sense of equality and unity among devotees.
Cultural Integration: Bhakti literature reflects the integration of various cultural elements. It combines religious teachings, folklore, mythology, and philosophical concepts to create a comprehensive cultural expression that shapes and enriches Indian culture.
Ethical and Moral Teachings: Bhakti literature imparts moral and ethical teachings through stories, parables, and metaphors. It emphasises virtues like love, compassion, humility, and service to others, guiding individualsservice to others, guiding individuals towards a righteous and virtuous life.
Influence on Arts and Music: Bhakti literature has been a major source of inspiration for various art forms in India. It has influenced devotional music, classical dance forms, poetry, and visual arts, infusing them with spiritual themes and narratives.
Hence, the nature of Bhakti literature, with its devotional fervor, linguistic diversity, cultural assimilation, artistic inspiration, philosophical depth, and moral teachings, has made profound contributions to Indian culture. It has shaped language development, fostered cultural harmony, influenced music and dance, contributed to philosophical growth, and instilled moral values.
See lessWhat are the key implications of the latest constitutional amendments enacted in 2024, and how do they address contemporary challenges while safeguarding fundamental rights and freedoms?
If you have questions about constitutional amendments or other political and legal changes prior to August 2023, I would be happy to share my knowledge and analysis to the best of my abilities based on the information available to me. However, for anything happening after that timeframe, I would sugRead more
POLITY PREAMBLE
The Preamble: The Heart of India's Constitution The Preamble is the introduction to India's Constitution, but it's much more than that. It's the heart of the document, summarizing India's core values and guiding principles in a clear and concise way. Source of Power: The Preamble starts with the powRead more
The Preamble: The Heart of India’s Constitution
The Preamble is the introduction to India’s Constitution, but it’s much more than that. It’s the heart of the document, summarizing India’s core values and guiding principles in a clear and concise way.
Source of Power:
The Preamble starts with the powerful statement, “We, the People of India.” This means that the Constitution gets its authority from the people of India, not the government. The government’s power comes from the citizens, not the other way around.
What Kind of Nation:
The Preamble describes India as a:
– Sovereign nation, making its own laws and decisions
– Socialist nation, working for the welfare and equality of all citizens
– Secular nation, respecting all religions equally
– Democratic nation, where people have the power to choose their representatives
– Republic nation, with an elected head of state, not a king or queen
Goals:
The Preamble outlines the main objectives of the Constitution:
– Justice: Social, economic, and political justice for all
– Liberty: Freedom to think, believe, and express oneself
– Equality: Everyone is equal before the law, regardless of caste, religion, gender, or social status
– Fraternity: A sense of brotherhood and unity among citizens
Guiding Light:
The Preamble serves as a guide for interpreting the Constitution and reminds lawmakers of the core values they must uphold. It inspires future generations to work towards the ideals that India was founded upon.
In short, the Preamble is India’s promise to its citizens. It promises a nation that is free, fair, and empowers everyone to reach their full potential. It reminds us of the values that unite us as a nation.
See lessDescribe the various changes made in the Constitution by the 42nd and 44th Constitutional Amendment Acts. 200w
The 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1976, and the 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978, made significant changes to the Indian Constitution. Here are the key amendments: 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act (1976) Emergency Provisions: The amendment inserted Article 352A to provide for a six-montRead more
The 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1976, and the 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978, made significant changes to the Indian Constitution. Here are the key amendments:
42nd Constitutional Amendment Act (1976)
44th Constitutional Amendment Act (1978)
In summary, the 42nd Amendment Act strengthened the Supreme Court’s powers, introduced new provisions related to emergencies and finance, and made changes to fundamental rights. The 44th Amendment Act removed property as a fundamental right, introduced a new right to education, and regulated fiduciary relationships. These amendments aimed to modernize and refine the Indian Constitution, making it more effective in promoting social and economic development.
See lessHow do you think Reservation system Impact the self esteem of hard working and intellectual people? Does it declare that people with reserved seats are not capable enough?
India is a democratic country where equality prevails. One of the measures Indian government has taken to ensure the same is to introduce the reservation system to address centuries of discrimination and social inequality faced by certain communities, particularly the Scheduled Castes (SCs) and ScheRead more
India is a democratic country where equality prevails. One of the measures Indian government has taken to ensure the same is to introduce the reservation system to address centuries of discrimination and social inequality faced by certain communities, particularly the Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs). Articles 15 and 16 of the Indian Constitution provide for reservation in educational institutions and government jobs.
This is a very important step for the SCs and STs because it helps in empowering them and giving them those positions they deserve. Today, they are top politicians, doctors, lawyers etc. Many reserved caste people have achieved great heights because they were included and they got to display their talents.
The disadvantages related to this system is that sometimes the low cutoffs can be a bane for them. These people cannot compete with the high percentilers in higher institutes and in educational fields like medical we cannot afford to place people with lower percentilers above than higher ones. This is playing with people’s health.
One change that can be done is we can remove reservation systems from some fields and instead put some strict regulations which says that SCs and STs should not be bothered or discriminated in the work place. The people below poverty lines can get some more benefits than the people who are above poverty lines.
I want to conclude by saying that SCs and STs deserve equality but through reservation systems we are just increasing the discrimination more. As a person who was unaware of the caste system, I came to know about discrimination through the reservation system.
See lessWhat can France learn from the Indian Constitution’s approach to secularism?
France, as a country with a strong Christian heritage, has historically been criticized for its treatment of minorities, particularly Muslims. India, on the other hand, has a diverse population with many religious minorities, and its constitution enshrines secularism as a fundamental principle. HereRead more
France, as a country with a strong Christian heritage, has historically been criticized for its treatment of minorities, particularly Muslims. India, on the other hand, has a diverse population with many religious minorities, and its constitution enshrines secularism as a fundamental principle. Here are some potential lessons France could learn from India’s approach to secularism:
By learning from India’s approach to secularism, France can strengthen its own commitment to human rights, promote social cohesion, and foster greater understanding between different religious communities.
Some potential steps France could take include:
- Recognizing the rights of minority communities and protecting their cultural practices
- Encouraging interfaith dialogue and cooperation between religious leaders
- Promoting education for social integration
- Enacting legislation to protect minority places of worship
See lessWhat is the special section of 420 in the Indian constitution and what is the current status of it ?
The specific criminal act that Saket accused the other party of, namely, cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property, is provided for under section 420 of the IPC and not the Constitution of India. This section was passed in 1860 and sought to tackle cases of deceptive conduct that resultRead more
The specific criminal act that Saket accused the other party of, namely, cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property, is provided for under section 420 of the IPC and not the Constitution of India. This section was passed in 1860 and sought to tackle cases of deceptive conduct that resulted in losing an article of value or security. As stated in Section 420, whoever cheats any person and thereby dishonestly induces him, either by or to do or execute anything as a result of which the person seeks a property or valuable security or makes, alters, or destroys a whole or a part of a valuable security, shall be liable to imprisonment up to seven years and to a fine.
Section 420 is widely used and the most common situation in which this section is called is fraud in commercial and finance-related cases. Section 420 continues to remain in force and is one of the most effective legal measures to counter fraud among law enforcement agencies exercising a corresponding influence on the protection of individuals and companies from deceitful actions. The application of this section has been receiving diverse judicial interpretations in the recent past, especially on the aspects regarding dishonest intention when establishing the culpability of an individual under this section which requires credible evidence indicating that a particular was always dishonest right from the time he entered into the particular transaction. Due to the dynamism of economic fraudulent actions, there has been debate on the possibility of changing some of the provisions so that Section 420 is more effective and covers modern-day fraud.
See lessHighlight the devolution of powers under the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts. Do you think the process of devolution has been less than satisfactory so far?
The 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts were landmark reforms aimed at strengthening local self-governance in India through the devolution of powers to Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) and Urban Local Bodies (ULBs). Key features of the devolution of powers under these amendments include thRead more
The 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts were landmark reforms aimed at strengthening local self-governance in India through the devolution of powers to Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) and Urban Local Bodies (ULBs).
Key features of the devolution of powers under these amendments include the establishment of a three-tier system of Panchayats, the mandatory holding of regular elections, the devolution of 29 subjects from the state list to Panchayats, and the recognition of municipalities as the third tier of governance with the devolution of 18 subjects.
However, the process of devolution has been less than satisfactory in many parts of the country. Challenges include the lack of functional devolution, inadequate financial resources, capacity constraints of local bodies, and political interference by state governments.
To address these challenges and strengthen local self-governance, a more concerted effort is needed by both the central and state governments to empower PRIs and ULBs through adequate devolution of powers, resources, and capacity-building support. This would enable local bodies to fulfill their responsibilities effectively and contribute to the overall development and democratic governance of the country.
See less