Do we truly possess free will, or is it merely an illusion of choice?
Model Answer Introduction Environmental ethics is a branch of ethics that examines the moral relationship between humans and the natural environment. It involves exploring the ethical questions arising from human interactions with nature, including our responsibilities and obligations toward the natRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Environmental ethics is a branch of ethics that examines the moral relationship between humans and the natural environment. It involves exploring the ethical questions arising from human interactions with nature, including our responsibilities and obligations toward the natural world.
Importance of Studying Environmental Ethics
- Moral Obligations:
- Environmental ethics clarifies the moral duties humans have toward the environment, such as the duty to protect biodiversity and preserve natural habitats (Ehrlich & Pringle, 2008).
- Sustainable Development:
- It assists in balancing development with conservation, ensuring that present needs do not compromise the ability of future generations to meet their own (Brundtland Commission, 1987).
- Decision Making:
- Environmental ethics provides a framework for making informed decisions that impact the environment, guiding land use planning, resource management, and environmental policy (Norton, 1991).
Environmental Issue: Deforestation
Deforestation refers to the large-scale clearing of forests for agriculture, logging, and urbanization. India has experienced significant forest loss, ranking second globally in deforestation over a short period (FAO, 2020). From an environmental ethics perspective, deforestation raises critical ethical concerns:
- Loss of Biodiversity:
- Forests host diverse species, and their destruction leads to habitat loss. The Western Ghats in India, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, is under threat from deforestation, endangering numerous endemic species (IUCN, 2014).
- Climate Change:
- Forests act as carbon sinks, absorbing CO2. Deforestation releases stored carbon, exacerbating global warming. The Himalayan region’s deforestation contributes to glacier melting and increases the risk of landslides (IPCC, 2021).
- Impact on Indigenous Communities:
- Many indigenous groups rely on forests for their livelihoods and cultural identity. Deforestation displaces these communities, violating their rights. For instance, the Dongria Kondh tribe in Odisha faces threats from mining activities in their ancestral lands (Survival International, 2017).
Conclusion
Studying environmental ethics is essential for understanding our moral responsibilities toward the environment. Deforestation exemplifies the pressing ethical issues we face, including biodiversity loss, climate change, and the displacement of indigenous communities. Addressing these concerns is vital for achieving a sustainable future.
See less
The question of whether we actually have free will or whether it is, inversely, only an illusion of choice has been part of the philosophers' debate for years. One way, it is assumed that free will is an illusion driven by neurological and psychological, that our choices are sculpted by a combinatioRead more
The question of whether we actually have free will or whether it is, inversely, only an illusion of choice has been part of the philosophers’ debate for years. One way, it is assumed that free will is an illusion driven by neurological and psychological, that our choices are sculpted by a combination of genetics, environment, and prior experiences—leaving very little room for autonomous decision-making.
Although free-will theorists agree that all these factors have an influence, a person still has the capacity to make choices and exercise personal agency. They propose that even though manifold factors have an influence on our decisions, reflection, deliberation, and the act in accordance with values are characteristics pointing to the reality of free will.
It has been shown neuroscientifically that brain activity can set choices before we consciously become aware of them; some have used this as a case against free will. Others, however, argue that consciousness performs the role of shaping and justifying choices, even if it does not initiate them.
Ultimately, the argument is still very far from resolution.
See less