Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
One of the tests of integrity is complete refusal to be compromised. Explain with reference to a real life example. (150 words) [UPSC 2017]
Model Answer Introduction Integrity embodies honesty, ethics, and a steadfast commitment to one’s principles. A true test of integrity is the complete refusal to be compromised, meaning individuals will not sacrifice their values for personal gain, even when faced with adversity. Body A poignant exaRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Integrity embodies honesty, ethics, and a steadfast commitment to one’s principles. A true test of integrity is the complete refusal to be compromised, meaning individuals will not sacrifice their values for personal gain, even when faced with adversity.
Body
A poignant example of this principle is illustrated by Satyendra Dubey, an Indian engineer with the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI). In 2002, Dubey raised alarms about corruption and mismanagement in a highway construction project in Bihar. He courageously wrote letters to various high-ranking officials, including the Prime Minister’s Office, detailing the irregularities and urging an investigation.
Despite his bravery, Dubey faced severe retaliation from contractors and local politicians involved in the corrupt practices. Tragically, on November 27, 2003, he was shot dead by unidentified assailants, a direct consequence of his refusal to compromise his integrity. His commitment to exposing corruption ultimately cost him his life, yet it also shone a spotlight on the rampant corruption in India.
Dubey’s sacrifice led to the enactment of the Whistle-blowers Protection Act in 2004, aimed at safeguarding individuals who expose corruption and malpractice (Government of India, 2004). His case underscores the vital importance of integrity in public service and the necessity for protective legal frameworks for whistle-blowers.
Other notable figures exemplifying integrity include Rosa Parks, who defied segregation laws in the U.S. by refusing to give up her bus seat, and Edward Snowden, who leaked NSA documents to expose government surveillance practices. Similarly, Anna Hazare’s hunger strike in 2011 to combat corruption in India emphasizes the theme of standing firm against unethical practices.
Conclusion
These individuals, including Satyendra Dubey, demonstrate that true integrity means refusing to compromise on one’s principles, even under dire circumstances. Their actions not only highlight significant social issues but also inspire others to confront injustice and corruption.
See lessYoung people with ethical conduct are not willing to come forward to join active politics. Suggest steps to motivate them to come forward. (150 words) [UPSC 2017]
Model Answer Introduction The reluctance of young people in India to participate in active politics is a pressing issue. Many perceive politics as corrupt and unethical, which discourages those with strong ethical values from stepping forward. Addressing this concern requires strategic measures to iRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The reluctance of young people in India to participate in active politics is a pressing issue. Many perceive politics as corrupt and unethical, which discourages those with strong ethical values from stepping forward. Addressing this concern requires strategic measures to inspire and empower the youth.
Steps to Motivate Young People
1. Create a Supportive Environment
Political parties and civil society organizations must foster a welcoming atmosphere for youth engagement. Platforms for debate and policy contributions can encourage young voices. For example, initiatives like the Aam Aadmi Party’s youth wing provide avenues for young individuals to express their opinions in politics.
2. Increase Transparency and Accountability
Young people are more likely to engage if they see a transparent political system. Political parties should adopt clear decision-making processes and hold representatives accountable for their actions. Research indicates that transparency enhances trust, a crucial factor for youth involvement (Bleich & Norrander, 2020).
3. Enhance Representation
To ensure young people’s perspectives are heard, political parties should reserve seats for youth in legislative bodies. The Bharatiya Janata Party’s youth wing, ABVP, exemplifies efforts to integrate young leaders into political discourse.
4. Empower Youth-Led Initiatives
Encouraging youth-led organizations can galvanize young people to participate in politics. The Yuva Bharat program launched by the Indian government empowers youth initiatives, allowing them to contribute to national development.
5. Provide Civic Education
Civic education is vital for equipping young people with knowledge about their rights and responsibilities. Programs like the National Service Scheme (NSS) teach civic responsibility and encourage community service, fostering a sense of political engagement.
6. Address Barriers to Entry
Financial constraints and lack of networks can hinder youth participation. Initiatives like the Young Women’s Leadership Program by the All India Democratic Women’s Association aim to support marginalized youth in overcoming these challenges.
7. Increase Participation in Local Governance
Encouraging youth to engage in local governance can build interest in broader political participation. The Chief Minister’s Youth Advisory Council in Rajasthan serves as a model for involving young people in local decision-making.
Conclusion
Motivating young people with ethical conduct to join active politics necessitates a comprehensive approach that includes creating supportive environments, enhancing transparency, and addressing barriers. By implementing these strategies, we can inspire the youth to take an active role in shaping the political landscape of India.
See lessGreat ambition is the passion of a great character. Those endowed with it may perform very good or very bad acts. All depends on the principles which direct them. – Napoleon Bonaparte. Stating examples mention the rulers (i) who have harmed society and country, and (ii) who worked for the development of society and country. (150 words) [UPSC 2017]
Model Answer Introduction Napoleon Bonaparte’s assertion about ambition underscores the pivotal role of leadership principles in shaping the trajectory of societies. While some leaders harness their ambition for constructive ends, others exploit it for destructive purposes. This essay examines exampRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Napoleon Bonaparte’s assertion about ambition underscores the pivotal role of leadership principles in shaping the trajectory of societies. While some leaders harness their ambition for constructive ends, others exploit it for destructive purposes. This essay examines examples of both types of rulers, emphasizing the principles that influenced their actions.
Body
Rulers Who Harmed Society and Country
Rulers Who Worked for Development
Conclusion
The principles guiding a leader decisively influence their impact on society. Leaders motivated by personal gain can inflict great harm, while those inspired by justice and progress can foster development and unity. Therefore, it is crucial to choose leaders who embody values that contribute positively to society.
See lessHow will you apply emotional intelligence in administrative practices? (150 words) [UPSC 2017]
Model Answer Introduction Emotional intelligence (EI) is the ability to recognize, understand, and manage one’s own emotions and those of others. In administrative practices, EI serves as a crucial tool for enhancing interpersonal relationships and making decisions that consider the emotional needsRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
Emotional intelligence (EI) is the ability to recognize, understand, and manage one’s own emotions and those of others. In administrative practices, EI serves as a crucial tool for enhancing interpersonal relationships and making decisions that consider the emotional needs of stakeholders. Here’s how emotional intelligence can be effectively applied in administrative roles.
Body
Building Positive Relationships
Developing strong relationships with employees is fundamental to effective administration. T.S.R. Subramanian, an esteemed IAS officer, exemplified this by being approachable and empathetic. He frequently interacted with his team, celebrating their achievements and addressing their concerns. Such practices foster trust and loyalty within the workforce, enhancing collaboration and productivity.
Managing Conflict
Kiran Bedi, former Lieutenant Governor of Puducherry, effectively managed conflicts by employing her emotional intelligence. She listened empathetically to all parties involved, understanding their emotions and motivations. This approach enabled her to mediate disputes and arrive at resolutions that satisfied everyone, ensuring a harmonious working environment.
Making Sensitive Decisions
S. Parasuraman, former Chief Secretary of Tamil Nadu, demonstrated how EI can guide decision-making. He initiated a financial assistance program for families of deceased government employees, addressing both emotional and practical needs. This decision not only fulfilled the government’s obligations but also acknowledged the emotional distress faced by the families, showcasing sensitivity in governance.
Managing Stress
H.C. Verma, a retired IAS officer, highlighted the importance of managing stress in the workplace. His calm demeanor and positive attitude created a supportive environment. He also promoted stress management techniques, such as yoga and meditation, which enhanced employee well-being and productivity.
Conclusion
By integrating emotional intelligence into administrative practices, civil servants can foster positive work environments, improve relationships, and make informed decisions that cater to the needs of all stakeholders. This ultimately leads to more effective governance and a healthier organizational culture.
See lessExamine the relevance of the following in the context of civil service: (150 words) [UPSC 2017] (a) Transparency (b) Accountability (c) Fairness and justice (d) Courage of conviction (e) Spirit of service
Model Answer Introduction In the context of civil service, values such as transparency, accountability, fairness and justice, courage of conviction, and the spirit of service are essential for the effective functioning of the administrative machinery. These values uphold the principles of good goverRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
In the context of civil service, values such as transparency, accountability, fairness and justice, courage of conviction, and the spirit of service are essential for the effective functioning of the administrative machinery. These values uphold the principles of good governance, foster public trust, and enhance the quality of service delivery.
Body
Transparency
Transparency is vital in civil service as it ensures that the actions and decisions of public officials are open to scrutiny. This openness helps prevent corruption and abuse of power. For example, India’s e-procurement portal allows citizens to monitor government procurement processes, promoting accountability.
Accountability
Accountability in civil service is crucial for maintaining integrity and public trust. Public officials must be responsible for their actions. The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) of India plays a key role in auditing government accounts, ensuring financial accountability.
Fairness and Justice
Fairness and justice ensure that all citizens are treated equally and that decisions are made impartially. This principle is enshrined in the Indian Constitution through institutions like the National Human Rights Commission, which protects citizens’ rights.
Courage of Conviction
Courage of conviction enables civil servants to uphold ethical standards and resist unethical pressures. For instance, IAS officer Durga Shakti Nagpal opposed illegal sand mining despite political opposition, illustrating the importance of standing firm in one’s beliefs.
Spirit of Service
The spirit of service emphasizes the commitment of civil servants to serve the public interest. Training programs for Indian Administrative Service (IAS) recruits focus on ethical standards and public service dedication, fostering a culture of service.
Conclusion
The relevance of these values in civil service cannot be overstated. They form the foundation of effective governance, ensuring that civil servants operate with integrity, fairness, and a commitment to the public good. By embodying these principles, civil servants can significantly contribute to a just and equitable society.
See lessThe crisis of ethical values in modern times is traced to a narrow perception of the good life. Discuss. (150 words) [UPSC 2017]
Model Answer Introduction The crisis of ethical values in modern times stems from a narrow perception of the good life, which often prioritizes materialism and individualism. This limited view leads to a diminished concern for others and the broader community, ultimately undermining ethical principlRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The crisis of ethical values in modern times stems from a narrow perception of the good life, which often prioritizes materialism and individualism. This limited view leads to a diminished concern for others and the broader community, ultimately undermining ethical principles.
Body
Firstly, the pervasive emphasis on materialism and consumerism has significantly eroded ethical values. Many individuals focus on accumulating wealth and possessions, neglecting personal development and contributions to the common good. For instance, the fashion industry exemplifies this issue; it is a major contributor to environmental degradation and labor exploitation. Consumers frequently prioritize trendy brands without considering the ethical implications of their purchases, fostering a culture where personal satisfaction outweighs environmental and social justice concerns.
Secondly, individualism plays a crucial role in this ethical decline. Many people prioritize self-interest over the welfare of others, leading to disregard for social justice and equality. Income inequality is a glaring example, as individuals often pursue their financial success while ignoring systemic injustices. This focus on personal gain detracts from advocacy for policies that promote equity and the common good.
Moreover, the opioid epidemic in the U.S. illustrates the ethical crisis within the healthcare industry. Pharmaceutical companies prioritized profits over patient welfare, contributing to widespread addiction. Similarly, child labor persists in developing countries due to the demand for cheap goods, reflecting a disregard for ethical labor practices.
Discrimination and corruption further highlight the impact of a narrow perception of the good life, where self-interest leads to unethical behavior in politics and society.
Conclusion
To address the crisis of ethical values, a broader perception of the good life is essential—one that emphasizes social justice, environmental sustainability, and the common good. Through education, ethical consumerism, and community engagement, society can cultivate a more ethical and just framework for future generations.
See lessEthics Case Study
Model Answer Introduction The case of Edward Snowden, a former CIA administrator who leaked classified government documents exposing surveillance programs, raises complex ethical questions. While Snowden's actions violated the Espionage Act, he argued that his moral obligation to inform the public jRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The case of Edward Snowden, a former CIA administrator who leaked classified government documents exposing surveillance programs, raises complex ethical questions. While Snowden’s actions violated the Espionage Act, he argued that his moral obligation to inform the public justified his whistleblowing. This analysis will weigh competing values: privacy, national security, government transparency, and individual conscience.
Body
a. Arguments in Favor of Ethical Justification
b. Arguments Against Ethical Justification
Conclusion
In weighing these competing values, one must consider the context and consequences of Snowden’s actions. While his intentions to protect privacy and promote transparency resonate with many, the legality of his actions and the potential risks to national security cannot be overlooked. Ultimately, the ethical justification hinges on the balance one places on individual conscience versus the rule of law and national security.
See lessEthics Case Study
Model Answer Introduction The case involves Dr. X, a prominent medical practitioner planning to establish a super-speciality hospital through a charitable trust to serve a neglected region. However, an inspection by the tax investigation agency reveals both substantial tax irregularities and minor tRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The case involves Dr. X, a prominent medical practitioner planning to establish a super-speciality hospital through a charitable trust to serve a neglected region. However, an inspection by the tax investigation agency reveals both substantial tax irregularities and minor technical defaults. The decision now is whether to prioritize substantial compliance and overlook minor defaults or to pursue strict action on all fronts.
Body
As the head of the tax investigation agency, I would opt for the first course of action: taking a broader view by ensuring substantial tax compliance and ignoring merely technical defaults. Here are my reasons:
1. Public Interest
The proposed hospital would significantly benefit the community by improving access to healthcare for all sections of society. Supporting this initiative aligns with the agency’s commitment to public welfare.
2. Resource Allocation
Focusing on technical defaults that do not affect overall tax collection would waste valuable resources. Instead, we should direct our efforts towards addressing substantial compliance issues that have a meaningful impact.
3. Compliance Cooperation
Dr. X’s willingness to pay the substantial tax demonstrates a positive attitude towards compliance. Recognizing this cooperation can foster a better relationship between the agency and taxpayers.
4. Proportional Response
The agency’s response should match the severity of non-compliance. Addressing significant irregularities should take precedence over minor technicalities, which can be rectified through guidance rather than punishment.
5. Promoting Social Welfare and Economic Growth
Supporting the hospital not only enhances healthcare but also stimulates local economic growth by creating jobs and attracting investment.
6. Mitigating Negative Consequences
Pursuing technical defaults may delay the hospital project, causing unnecessary burdens. By focusing on substantial compliance, we can facilitate timely completion and community benefits.
7. Promoting Voluntary Compliance
Acknowledging Dr. X’s cooperation encourages a culture of voluntary compliance, motivating others to fulfill their tax obligations willingly.
Conclusion
In conclusion, prioritizing substantial tax compliance and supporting the establishment of the super-speciality hospital aligns with public interest and promotes community welfare. This balanced approach ensures that the agency’s efforts contribute positively to society while maintaining effective tax administration.
See lessEthics Case Study
Model Answer Introduction The closure of a chemical manufacturing plant due to severe environmental and health impacts has created significant challenges. Initially approved by the State government, the factory's operations led to pollution affecting land, water, and public health, prompting widesprRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
The closure of a chemical manufacturing plant due to severe environmental and health impacts has created significant challenges. Initially approved by the State government, the factory’s operations led to pollution affecting land, water, and public health, prompting widespread public outcry and subsequent closure. The economic fallout includes unemployment for factory workers and adverse effects on dependent industries.
Body
1. Assess the Environmental Damage
Conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the pollution caused by the factory:
2. Engage with Stakeholders
Initiate dialogue with all affected parties:
3. Mitigate Immediate Impact
Support affected workers and their families:
4. Environmental Remediation
Develop a plan for restoring the environment:
5. Support Alternative Industries
Promote sustainable economic alternatives:
6. Strengthen Environmental Regulations
Advocate for improved regulatory measures:
7. Community Development
Implement initiatives to uplift the community:
8. Public Awareness and Engagement
Conduct educational campaigns:
Conclusion
By adopting a holistic approach that addresses both immediate and long-term consequences of the factory’s closure, we can foster environmental restoration, support the affected workforce, and promote sustainable economic growth in the region. This balanced strategy will help rebuild community trust and lay the foundation for a healthier, more sustainable future.
See lessEthics Case Study
Model Answer Introduction As the newly appointed Superintendent of Police in a district plagued by illicit distillation of liquor, the challenge is to implement effective strategies that move beyond traditional law enforcement. The persistent issue of illicit liquor is deeply rooted in the socio-ecoRead more
Model Answer
Introduction
As the newly appointed Superintendent of Police in a district plagued by illicit distillation of liquor, the challenge is to implement effective strategies that move beyond traditional law enforcement. The persistent issue of illicit liquor is deeply rooted in the socio-economic backwardness of the area, requiring a comprehensive, multi-faceted approach that addresses the underlying causes.
Body
1. Comprehensive Assessment
Conduct a detailed analysis of the factors contributing to illicit distillation, including:
2. Collaborative Efforts
Engage with key stakeholders:
3. Socio-Economic Development
Initiate programs focusing on:
4. Infrastructure Development
Advocate for improvements in:
5. Community Policing
Implement community-oriented policing strategies to:
6. Awareness and Education
Launch campaigns to:
7. Rehabilitation and Support
Provide support for individuals involved in illicit distillation through:
8. Strengthen Law Enforcement
Enhance the capability of law enforcement by:
Conclusion
By adopting this holistic approach, focusing on socio-economic development, community engagement, and effective law enforcement, I aim to create a sustainable solution to the problem of illicit distillation. This strategy not only addresses the immediate issues but also fosters long-term community resilience and prosperity.
See less