Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
Case Study
(a) The Ethical Issues Involved in the Case It merits discussion of certain ethical issues, including the tension between showing compassion and maintaining institutional integrity. First of all, the Principal's giving of exam questions and answers to Asha is a clear violation of the rules of the exRead more
(a) The Ethical Issues Involved in the Case
It merits discussion of certain ethical issues, including the tension between showing compassion and maintaining institutional integrity. First of all, the Principal’s giving of exam questions and answers to Asha is a clear violation of the rules of the examination of the school. It is an act that sabotages the fairness and integrity of the assessment process as it places Asha at an unfair advantage over her peers. Secondarily, the Principal’s decision to place Asha’s personal circumstances above the school’s policies raises questions about the consistency, transparency and impartiality of the school’s administration. Although empathy and compassion should be provided to students who are going through tough times, such leniency runs the risk of being abused in the future. Thirdly, a huge concern is the potential demotivation of students working extremely hard to keep their grades up. When students see that rules can be circumvented, it can erode their faith in the school’s system, and their own work. Finally, there is pressure from Asha to improve her attendance, although a hopeful target; it could be understood as coercive and potentially further stress and burden on her wellbeing.
(b) Ethical Analysis of the Principal’s Conduct
From an ethical perspective, the Principal behaves with serious moral and professional deficiencies. This act of providing Asha with advance knowledge of the examination questions and answers undermines the fundamental principles of ethics. By letting Asha sit the exam at all, this clearly allows her to gain undue advantage over her peers, as well as a serious compromise to the integrity of the school’s examination system. Furthermore, the Principal’s decision to enter into a conditional arrangement with Asha—she would pass if he would give her the relaxed attendance—opens up a moral discussion on whether it is acceptable to use students’ academic performance as currency. But it is the method chosen that is very questionable rather than the intention of helping Asha, which is understandable. The Principal itself should have tried to help Asha in other genuine ways, like tutoring or counseling, or even allowing her to arrive late to class, but should not have played around with her exam system. This is also against the law if seen with academic fraud. Ethically, the Principal’s actions are disgusting and mind-numbing, as it puts the immediate need to quiet, and shut down a perceived threat versus thinking this through to its potentially very damaging outcomes to the educational environment of the school, and the well-being of other students.
(c) Pros and Cons of the Options Open to Priya
Priya has a tough ethics dilemma ahead of her, and there are a bunch of ways she could go. All of these have their pros and cons.
Report the Principal’s Actions:
Merits: Reporting the principal would help maintain the integrity of the school’s examination system and ensure that all students are treated fairly. Such messaging sends a clear signal that these attitudes are not okay and there may well be better systems of support for students in need that follow in the wake of such discussions.
Demerits: This may create an adversarial atmosphere and undermine the working relationship between Priya and the Principal. And, it may further lead to disciplinary measures, even suspension of the Principal, which would create a hostile environment in the school. Also, Asha could feel let down by this and undo all the progress she made with attendance and in her studies.
Confront the Principal:
Pros: Educating the Principal in a civil way might challenge the school’s policies and engender change. This would give Priya space to air her concerns and to explore a more ethical way to help students such as Asha.
CONS: This method may also be combative, and may not spur immediate action. As a result, the Principal may become defensive, and (thus) it may be hard to find a solution that both parties agree on.
Support Asha Privately:
This content is not restricted to a specific date, as it will be created in October 2023 and refer back to given input data. This would also help avert a combative one.
Demerits: This does not solve the underlying issue of exam malpractices and also sets a precedent to validate the actions of the Principal. Some other students may realize what happened, and the experience can leave them feeling demotivated or treated unjustly.
Ignore the Situation:
Benefits: They may get to keep the status quo (and avoid a fight for now). In the short term, this could be seen the least bad option.
Demerits: Neglecting the problem would undermine the school’s ethical level and could result in others being treated unequally. It would also challenge Priya’s duties as a Vice-Principal and her responsibility to uphold the integrity of the institution.
Plausible Alternative: Face the Principal
However, Priya should bring to the light his misconduct with the Principal in a healthy and professional way. This also addresses the ethics and gives her the opportunity to find a win-win solution. Through this dialogue, Priya can voice her worries on whether the examination system is fair and even, and suggest Asha, and other students that will come along, different ways to support them — the right way. As an example, the school can allow more flexibility with the attendance policy for students with special situations or offer extra tutoring and counseling services. This method balances a number of variables, proxies and various elements as we build a case for fairness while understanding supporting our most vulnerable students, making sure the school’s policies are both compassionate and fair.”
See lessWhat are the benefits and challenges of implementing precision medicine in India? (200 Words)
The evolution of precision medicine in treatment allows healthcare professionals to tailor medical care based on the individual characteristics of each patient. This powerful system has the potential to revolutionise the way that diseases are diagnosed and treated in India. Using advanced genomic, mRead more
The evolution of precision medicine in treatment allows healthcare professionals to tailor medical care based on the individual characteristics of each patient. This powerful system has the potential to revolutionise the way that diseases are diagnosed and treated in India. Using advanced genomic, molecular, and clinical information, this personalized approach intends to promote a wider range of accurate and relevant therapies. However, implementation of precision medicine in India faces challenges that should be handled carefully in order to seamlessly incorporate it into the healthcare system.
Benefits of Precision Medicine in India
Improved Treatment Outcomes: Precision medicine has the potential to significantly enhance treatment outcomes by providing therapies specifically designed for each patient that tend to be more effective and have fewer side effects. For example, in the field of cancer treatment, precision medicine enables the target of specific genetic changes that drive tumor formation. This enables healthcare providers to utilize drugs that directly attack such genetic abnormalities, which can ultimately lead to increased remission rates and improved quality of life for patients.
While initial costs for genomic sequencing and data analysis can be high, precision medicine may lead to long-term healthcare cost savings. And by quickly matching patients with the best treatments early, we can avoid ineffective (and costly) interventions. Such a proactive methodology can reduce hospitalization and associated costs of care, while making the entire healthcare system work better.
Reduced Research and Innovation: India’s diverse population provides a significant source of genetic and clinical data. Implementing precision medicine has the potential to accelerate the R&D process throughout the health-field and lead to novel medication and treatment avenues. Such a project will bring India to the forefront of world medical integration, will stimulate investments in health technologies and create advances in patient care.
Enhancing Patient Involvement: Precision medicine often includes patients in decision-making, using their genetic and health data to tailor their treatments. This can lead to better patient participation and improvement in treatment compliance, which is a crucial factor for the success of any medical device. They are more likely to trust and follow a treatment plan tailored to their unique needs.
Wider Public Health Effects: Precision medicine also has major implications for public health writ large. This allows collective efforts with the societal goal of containing the spread of infectious diseases while making public health strategies more targeted and efficient by revealing genetic vulnerabilities to certain diseases. This can take the form of early identification of at-risk individuals, which can contribute to prevention of disease, reduced load on the healthcare system, and improved health of the population.
Challenges for Putting Precision Medicine Into Practice in India
Infrastructure and Technology
One of the biggest barriers to adoption of precision medicine in India is the lack of infrastructure and technology. Genomic sequencing, data management, and analysis require significant investment in state-of-the-art hardware and software. Several hospitals throughout India, especially in the villages, are not equipped to use these technologies proficiently.
Also Read: Data Privacy and Ethical Considerations
This is because precision medicine requires the collection and analysis of a huge amount of personal and genomic data. Protecting the privacy and security of this data is a major challenge. What India needs are strong data protection laws and the ethical framework needed to prevent misuse and build patient trust. The Personal Data Protection Bill (PDP-Bill) is a step in the right direction, but more needs to be done to address the unique challenges presented by genomic information.
Agnostic Approach to Affordability and Accessibility
The high cost of genomic sequencing and data analysis have the potential to make precision medicine inaccessible to a large portion of the population, especially lower-income individuals. And there is a growing need for public sector subsidies and public-private partnerships to ensure these technologies are affordable and available to a broad swath of people.
Regulatory Challenges
The regulation in India is complex and hinders adoption of precision medicine. One area of urgent need is the development of standards and regulatory frameworks for the processes of collection, analysis, and use of genetic data. Setting these standards could also help administrators approve and pay for precision medicine treatments.
Most of them must meet only a set of requirements.
Health care providers and patients alike need to be well informed about the strengths and limitations of precision medicine. This means comprehensive training for medical practitioners and initiatives to raise public awareness. The full potential of precision medicine may go unrealized without a knowledgeable healthcare team and an informed patient base.
Cultural & Social Factors
Indian society is rich in cultural and social diversity, which may play a crucial role in determining the receptivity and application of precision medicine. There could be cultural barriers to genetic testing, and social dynamics such as caste and religious groups may also influence patients’ attitudes and responsivity. These cultural and social barriers must be addressed if precision medicine is to be successfully integrated into the healthcare system.
Conclusion
Precision medicine in India opens up exciting paths expanding healthcare, reducing costs, and driving medical innovation. However, those benefits can only be realized if the challenges of infrastructure, data privacy, cost issues, regulatory concerns, education, and cultural shortcomings are effectively addressed. There needs to be a concerted effort by the Indian government, healthcare organizations and the private sector to build a conducive environment to accelerate acceptance of precision medicine. India can take a giant leap towards personalized, efficient, equitable health care by doing this.
See less