India’s invitation as a Guest of Honour to the 46th session of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) Foreign Ministers’ Meet in 2019 marked a significant shift in geopolitical dynamics, particularly in terms of India’s relations with the Islamic world. This invitation was a pivotal moment in India’s diplomatic history, signaling growing recognition of its geopolitical importance and the evolving nature of its ties with the Gulf nations, especially the United Arab Emirates (UAE).

Key Points of the Invitation

• Historical Significance: The OIC, established in 1969, had historically excluded India due to pressure from Pakistan, especially on the Kashmir issue. India had been snubbed at an OIC summit in 1969, when Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, an Indian minister, was disinvited at Pakistan’s insistence​​.
• A Shift in UAE’s Stance: The UAE’s invitation in 2019 marked the first time India was invited to the OIC Foreign Ministers’ Meet, underscoring the UAE’s growing strategic relationship with India​. This move was seen as a correction of a “historic wrong” and was significant for enhancing India’s diplomatic stature in the Islamic world.

Geopolitical Dynamics and India’s Growing Influence

• India’s Increasing Clout: The invitation reflects India’s rising global influence, its robust economy, and its role as a strategic partner in the region. The UAE recognized India’s importance not only for its political and economic strength but also for its substantial Muslim population, which contributes to the pluralistic and diverse fabric of the country​.
• Strategic Relations with the Gulf: Over the past few years, India has cultivated strong economic, security, and cultural ties with the UAE and other Gulf countries. This has included significant cooperation in areas like trade, defense, and energy. The OIC invitation is a recognition of India’s central role in regional stability and development​.

Implications for India’s Foreign Policy

• Strengthening Bilateral Ties: The invitation was a diplomatic victory for India, which sought to deepen its ties with Gulf nations, moving beyond the historical baggage of Kashmir. It marked a shift towards focusing on areas of mutual interest, such as counterterrorism cooperation, economic growth, and energy security​.
• Broader Diplomatic Influence: This engagement opened new opportunities for India to present its views on regional and global issues at the OIC platform. It also allowed India to underline its policy of peaceful coexistence, its commitment to regional stability, and the importance of multilateral dialogue.

Conclusion

India’s inclusion in the OIC Foreign Ministers’ Meet as a Guest of Honour represents a new phase in its diplomatic efforts to strengthen relations with the Islamic world, particularly the Gulf states. It highlights a significant shift in regional geopolitics where strategic interests are increasingly outweighing historical conflicts. The UAE’s gesture marks the beginning of a new diplomatic era for India in the Middle East and the broader Islamic world, showcasing its growing global stature and commitment to multilateralism.

The United Nations Sustainable Development Solutions Network (SDSN) emphasizes a multidimensional approach to well-being, focusing on various social, economic, and environmental factors. The network’s framework for well-being highlights several key variables that contribute to a person’s and society’s overall health, prosperity, and sustainable development.

Key Variables Supporting Well-being

1. Good Health and Well-being (SDG 3)

• Universal Health Coverage (UHC):
  • Access to affordable healthcare is a critical pillar for well-being. The UN stresses the importance of ensuring that everyone, regardless of income or location, has access to essential health services.
  • For example, countries with comprehensive healthcare systems, such as Norway and Canada, show better health outcomes for their citizens.
• Mental Health:
  • Mental health is as important as physical health. The increasing recognition of mental health issues has led to global initiatives to reduce the stigma and provide adequate services.

Example: The World Health Organization (WHO) advocates for mental health services integrated into primary health systems, acknowledging that the mental well-being of individuals is crucial to overall happiness.

2. Education

• Access to Quality Education (SDG 4):
  • Education is directly linked to well-being as it empowers individuals to make informed choices, improving life satisfaction and economic mobility.
  • For instance, Finland’s education system is often cited for its focus on both academic knowledge and emotional well-being, which results in better life outcomes for students.
• Lifelong Learning:
  • Ensuring opportunities for lifelong learning and skills development promotes economic stability and personal growth, which are important components of well-being.

3. Economic Stability

• Income Equality and Poverty Reduction (SDG 1):
  • Economic stability, with reduced income inequality, plays a significant role in enhancing well-being. The SDSN emphasizes the importance of achieving decent work and fair wages, which contribute to reducing poverty and increasing social mobility.
• Employment Opportunities:
  • Access to secure employment allows individuals to achieve financial independence and improve quality of life.

Example: Countries like Denmark and Sweden focus on reducing inequality through progressive tax systems, strong social safety nets, and universal access to healthcare and education.

4. Environmental Sustainability

• Climate Action (SDG 13):
  • A healthy environment is fundamental for sustaining human well-being. The UN promotes reducing environmental degradation, improving air quality, and addressing climate change to protect human health.
• Access to Clean Water and Sanitation (SDG 6):
  • Clean water, sanitation, and pollution control are essential to preventing diseases and enhancing quality of life.

Example: Iceland, with its focus on clean energy and environmental protection, leads by example in creating a sustainable environment that supports public health and well-being.

5. Social Inclusion and Equality

• Gender Equality (SDG 5):
  • Ensuring gender equality by addressing discrimination and empowering women contributes significantly to well-being. Equal access to resources and opportunities is crucial for building a fair and prosperous society.
• Social Protection:
  • Access to social protection systems (such as pensions, unemployment benefits, and disability support) promotes well-being by reducing vulnerabilities and enhancing economic security.

Example: In countries with strong social protection systems, like Germany, citizens experience a higher sense of security and well-being.

Analysis Beyond Income, Averages, and Present Conditions

The SDSN’s approach to well-being goes beyond income and material wealth, acknowledging the complexity of human flourishing:

1. Holistic Well-being:
   • Beyond GDP: The SDSN emphasizes that well-being is more than just economic output, as it includes factors such as health, education, social inclusion, and environmental sustainability. For instance, Bhutan’s Gross National Happiness (GNH) Index evaluates well-being through happiness rather than just financial success.
2. Intergenerational Perspective:
   • The SDSN stresses the importance of considering the long-term impact of present actions on future generations. For example, the effects of climate change and environmental degradation today will affect future generations’ health and opportunities.
3. Cultural and Social Factors:
   • Well-being is also shaped by social networks, cultural values, and community involvement. Countries with strong social cohesion, such as Japan, demonstrate that a sense of belonging and social participation contribute significantly to overall life satisfaction.

Conclusion

The UN Sustainable Development Solutions Network (SDSN) highlights a broad and multidimensional approach to well-being, focusing on health, education, economic stability, environmental sustainability, and social inclusion. By integrating these diverse variables, the SDSN provides a more comprehensive understanding of well-being, moving beyond simple economic indicators like income or GDP.

The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Human Development Report 2019, titled “Beyond Income, Beyond Averages, Beyond Today: Inequalities in Human Development in the 21st Century,” focuses on addressing inequalities in human development. It emphasizes how disparities in opportunities, rather than just outcomes, are reshaping societies and hindering progress.

Key Highlights of the Report

1. Beyond Income:
   • Traditional income-based metrics, like GDP, are insufficient to capture the complexities of inequality.
   • The report introduces a broader understanding of disparities, such as access to quality education, healthcare, and technological advancement.
2. Beyond Averages:
   • Averages often mask inequalities within populations.
   • For instance, while global life expectancy has improved, differences in access to healthcare lead to significant disparities across regions and demographics.
3. Beyond Today:
   • The report highlights new-generation inequalities that go beyond basic survival, such as access to technology, higher education, and climate resilience.
   • It emphasizes intergenerational inequality and its implications for future development.

How the Analysis Goes Beyond Income, Averages, and Present Conditions

1. Multidimensional Approach:

• The report introduces measures like the Inequality-Adjusted Human Development Index (IHDI) and the Gender Inequality Index (GII) to assess disparities beyond income.
• These indices consider factors such as education, health, and gender-based barriers.

2. Focus on Capabilities:

• Inspired by Amartya Sen’s capability approach, the report examines how inequalities restrict individuals’ ability to lead fulfilling lives.
• For example, two individuals with similar incomes may have vastly different opportunities based on their access to education or healthcare.

3. Intergenerational Inequalities:

• The report addresses how inequalities today impact future generations, particularly in the context of:
  • Climate change: Vulnerable populations are disproportionately affected.
  • Technology gaps: Limited access to digital tools creates long-term divides in skills and opportunities.

4. Spotlight on Gender:

• A significant part of the analysis focuses on gender inequalities, highlighting gaps in political representation, economic participation, and violence against women.

Critical Examination of the Report

Strengths:

1. Holistic Perspective:
   • The report goes beyond economic growth to assess human well-being comprehensively, reflecting real-life disparities more accurately.
2. Timeliness:
   • By addressing emerging inequalities like digital access and climate impact, the report is forward-looking.
3. Policy Relevance:
   • Its recommendations on reducing inequalities, such as progressive taxation and investments in education, offer actionable insights for governments.

Limitations:

1. Implementation Challenges:
   • While the report provides valuable data and insights, addressing deep-rooted inequalities requires significant political will and global coordination.
2. Over-reliance on Global Indicators:
   • The report’s use of universal metrics may not fully capture localized disparities or cultural nuances.
3. Limited Focus on Accountability:
   • While it identifies issues, the report does not emphasize mechanisms to hold governments and institutions accountable for addressing inequalities.

Illustrative Examples

1. Technology Gap:
   • In Sub-Saharan Africa, fewer than 25% of people have internet access, creating educational and economic disadvantages compared to developed countries.
2. Gender Inequality:
   • In India, despite economic growth, the Gender Inequality Index highlights persistent disparities in female labor force participation and political representation.
3. Climate Resilience:
   • Island nations like the Maldives face existential threats due to rising sea levels, exacerbating inequalities linked to geography.

Conclusion

The UNDP Human Development Report 2019 is a comprehensive analysis that sheds light on the complex and interconnected nature of inequalities. While it provides a robust framework for understanding and addressing disparities, its success depends on the commitment of global and local policymakers to translate its insights into concrete action​.

Tribal Protests in the 19th Century:

The 19th-century tribal protests in India were significant episodes of resistance against British colonial policies and exploitative practices. These movements highlighted the tribals’ struggle to preserve their culture, autonomy, and resources. Here is an analysis of their features, examples, and the reasons for their failure:

Characteristics of Tribal Protests

1. Localized Nature:
   • Tribal uprisings were often restricted to specific regions and lacked a pan-Indian framework.
   • For example, the Santhal Rebellion (1855-56) was confined to present-day Jharkhand and parts of Bengal and Bihar.
2. Resistance to Land Alienation:
   • Tribals opposed the colonial policies that allowed outsiders (dikus) to acquire their lands.
   • The Munda Rebellion (1899-1900), led by Birsa Munda, sought to end the practice of forced labor and reclaim ancestral land.
3. Cultural and Religious Elements:
   • Many protests were driven by attempts to protect tribal culture and religion from external influences.
   • The Koya Rebellion (1879-80) in Andhra Pradesh combined traditional beliefs with armed resistance.
4. Leadership by Tribal Chiefs or Spiritual Leaders:
   • Tribal protests often revolved around charismatic leaders who combined social, political, and religious authority.
   • Birsa Munda and Sidhu-Kanhu (Santhal leaders) are prominent examples.
5. Violent Resistance:
   • Many uprisings were marked by violent clashes against British forces, landlords, and moneylenders.
   • The Kol Rebellion (1831-32) in Jharkhand witnessed widespread attacks on British officials and properties.

Major Tribal Protests in the 19th Century

1. Santhal Rebellion (1855-56):
   • Led by Sidhu and Kanhu, the Santhals revolted against oppressive landlords and moneylenders in the Rajmahal Hills.
   • Though the rebellion was suppressed, it led to the creation of the Santhal Parganas district for tribal administration.
2. Munda Rebellion (1899-1900):
   • Under Birsa Munda’s leadership, the movement aimed to establish a Munda Raj and remove dikus from tribal lands.
   • It was a combination of religious reform and resistance against exploitation.
3. Kol Rebellion (1831-32):
   • The Kols revolted against the transfer of their lands to outsiders and the exploitative practices of moneylenders and British officials.
4. Koya Rebellion (1879-80):
   • Led by tribal leader Tomma Dora in the Godavari district, it protested against colonial exploitation and land revenue policies.

Reasons for the Failure of Tribal Protests

1. Lack of Unity and Coordination:
   • Tribal protests were often localized and lacked a unified leadership to challenge the British effectively.
2. Inferior Weaponry:
   • Tribals relied on traditional weapons like bows and arrows, which were no match for the British army’s modern firearms.
3. Limited Political Awareness:
   • The movements were primarily driven by immediate grievances and lacked a broader vision for political change.
4. Repressive Colonial Policies:
   • The British used a combination of military force and administrative measures to suppress rebellions.
   • For instance, the Criminal Tribes Act (1871) categorized some tribes as “criminal,” leading to further marginalization.
5. Absence of Support from Other Communities:
   • Tribal movements often remained isolated and failed to gain support from non-tribal groups or the larger nationalist movement.

.

Conclusion

The tribal protests of the 19th century were valiant efforts to resist exploitation and preserve indigenous rights. While they failed to achieve their immediate goals due to several structural and strategic limitations, they played a critical role in laying the groundwork for later struggles for justice. Leaders like Birsa Munda remain celebrated as symbols of resistance and tribal pride​.

Champaran Satyagraha:

The Champaran Satyagraha of 1917 marked a turning point in India’s struggle for independence. It was the first significant civil disobedience movement led by Mahatma Gandhi and highlighted the oppressive policies of British rule. Here’s a detailed examination of its causes, outcomes, and broader significance:

Causes of the Champaran Satyagraha

1. Tinkathia System:
   • Under this system, farmers in Champaran (Bihar) were forced by British planters to grow indigo on 3/20th of their land.
   • Farmers faced economic ruin due to declining indigo prices and the shift to synthetic dyes in Europe.
   • The British planters often levied unfair taxes and extracted illegal payments from the farmers.
2. Peasant Suffering:
   • Exploitation by planters caused severe economic distress.
   • Many farmers were unable to cultivate food crops due to the forced cultivation of indigo, leading to hunger and poverty.
3. Invitation to Gandhi:
   • Local leaders like Rajkumar Shukla invited Gandhi to Champaran to investigate and support the farmers’ cause.

Gandhi’s Role and Actions

• Fact-Finding Mission:
  • Gandhi arrived in Champaran and collected testimonies from thousands of peasants about their exploitation.
  • Despite attempts by British authorities to intimidate him, Gandhi continued his inquiry.
• Civil Disobedience:
  • Gandhi defied a British court order to leave the district, emphasizing his commitment to truth and justice.
  • His non-violent resistance garnered widespread support among locals.
• Formation of a Committee:
  • The British government formed a committee to address the issue, with Gandhi as a member.
  • He successfully argued for the abolition of the Tinkathia system and partial compensation for farmers.

Results of the Champaran Satyagraha

1. Abolition of Tinkathia:
   • The exploitative system was officially ended, providing much-needed relief to the peasants.
2. Empowering Peasants:
   • The movement instilled confidence in the rural masses and demonstrated that collective non-violent resistance could bring change.
3. Rise of Gandhi:
   • Champaran established Gandhi as a leader of the national movement, marking the beginning of his journey as a mass mobilizer.

Significance in India’s Freedom Struggle

• Shift in Strategy:
  • The Satyagraha introduced non-violence and civil disobedience as effective tools against British oppression.
  • It set the tone for future mass movements, including the Non-Cooperation Movement and the Salt March.
• Focus on Rural India:
  • Champaran highlighted the plight of rural India and brought the masses into the fold of the freedom struggle.
• Moral Victory:
  • The movement showed that Indians could challenge British authority without resorting to violence.

Broader Perspective: Why Champaran is a Watershed Moment

The Champaran Satyagraha was not just a local revolt but a symbolic victory for Indian nationalism. It bridged the gap between urban and rural struggles and demonstrated the power of truth and non-violence. This success laid the foundation for future movements and gave peasants a voice in the national narrative​.